Poly!Hamilsquad x Reader - Valentine’s Day Headcanons:
You and the boys don't go out very much. You all become very concerned over the judgemental stares you all get when you're all out and being all lovey-dovey.
But you want to enjoy yourselves no matter what people think.
So, Lafayette books a private table that is secluded in the choice of restaurant. Thankfully, he knows one of the waitresses that work there so she'll be able to wait on you and keep people away from your special night.
On Valentine's, Laf surprises you and the boys with the date.
“Dress yourselves up to the nines, cheries. We're going out.”
You, Alex and John are really exciting, dancing around and kissing Lafayette in thanks before hurrying off to get washed, ready and dressed. Herc, however, is not so sure. But Laf confirms to him that it's just the five of them. So he's easily swayed.
Soon, Herc drives you all up to the restaurant. There, you find Peggy and Eliza to be your waitresses for the night. Peggy takes you to a corner of the restaurant and keeps other guests out.
The five of you divulge yourselves with a three course meal with glasses of champagne.
By the time you get to dessert, you all decide to share it, choosing two large chocolate sundaes and finding each other, whilst settling down with one last drink before heading home.
You leave the car to Eliza to drop off when she finishes as you've all had a drink or two.
Once the night it over with, you all settle in your pyjamas and watch several romantic films.