Forgive me if this is/sounds slightly wanky, but apparently I have a lot of feelings about Dean and how he is being treated by his parents and how this treatment caused and causes so many of Dean’s issues this morning and I just needed to put them somewhere otherwise I would explode lol. *hides* So this is not a coherent character analysis or whatever, it will likely have its flaws in argumentation but really this is just a spur of emotions bubbling out and not meant as truly anything “meta”.
If these past seasons showed something, then it is that Dean indeed did/does not matter as a person in his own right to any of his parents.
John who shaped Dean’s extreme feelings of needing to protect Sam at all cost and completely ignoring and disregarding Dean and his childhood and what he would have needed and what he from the tender age of 4 onwards basically sacrificed his whole life: Himself.
And then Mary who couldn’t be bothered to give a damn about her older son in S12 either and only as much as started to listen to him when he was trying to save her when he started to talk about Sam. Not himself, not about his scars or traumas. Because he has learnt they don’t matter, they don’t measure up, they are not of interest.
They both, John and Mary, made it perfectly clear that they not only failed as parents, but as simple decent human beings. Because the plain takeaway for Dean all his life must have been: You only matter because of Sam, not because you have value as yourself. We only see and care about you as long as you can make sure Sam is okay.
They never treated Dean as a person really with that, but only a tool. And like I said in my gifset of Dean in conversation with AU!Michael this dehumanization and objectification of Dean goes back a long way and of course falls completely together with Dean’s lack of self worth (and really how should he have gotten any when he only ever was shown the opposite, that he himself indeed is not of worth but only ever in extension to someone else) which really makes Dean’s decision to offer himself up as a vessel - to become a sword in his own words even - and with that turning himself into an object (though he had tried to reject that in seasons prior as talked about in the mentioned gifset as well, but at some point anything’s gut to give...) - not difficult to understand.
Whether it was in S2 when Dean sold his soul to bring Sam back from the dead or in S8/9 when Dean made a deal with an angel to save his brother from certain death which spurred his fall and set up taking on the mark of Cain or now in S13 when he said yes to an archangel because he needed to try and save Sam and Jack from Lucifer: It all foots in this one small but important thing that Dean lacks while his capability to love is so huge: self love and self worth.
But as the series has shown, how could Dean have learnt both of these things when he was taught/shown the opposite from childhood on which is the most formative of time for any kid? Sure, Dean knows people care about him. That Sam does, or Jack and Cas, but I doubt Dean can truly understand that or even believe it, because he went through all his life taking the backseat even though he was sitting behind the wheel, taking care of everyone except himself, because he never knew or experienced or learned that he is of value.
His recklessness and carelessness towards himself can not only be seen when he throws himself head first into fights, but also shows in Dean’s way of coping through drinking and also in smaller things that are played for laughs like the bit about “the cholesterol” for example.
All of these things and aspects paint a very complete, though complex and saddening picture of a man who loves with his heart in his hands but has no love for himself due to how he was raised. And now that man is possessed by an archangel, who again is using Dean as an object, a vehicle, a tool to be able to do what he wants to achieve: destruction. And sadly with that he has found “his perfect vessel”, because if Dean Winchester is well skilled in one department it’s that: not destruction as such but self destruction. And nothing screams that - the disappearance of Dean Winchester - more than an archangel parading around in his body. A body that now is a cage for Dean. And I can just hope and pray that this storyline will be handled with care (lol who am I kidding it won’t be under Dabb) and that this storyline, which will bring about so much more guilt for Dean due to everything Michael may do while Dean is his “sword” - a weapon of mass destruction - will end with not Sam or Cas or Jack or anybody else saving Dean, but Dean being the vital player to take back his agency. Because to me it entails so much more than just Dean being freed from possession, to me it would mean that Dean for once would fight for himself, fight for his own life, because he matters.
Sadly however, I think whatever will come around on screen, there will likely be happening some sort of reversal of all the incidents where Dean was able to get through to his loved ones when they were possessed and came close to killing him, but this time with Dean possessed and possibly seeing Michael strangling his brother, Jack or Cas with his own hands will make him be able to take back control and cast the archangel out. And while the turnaround would work on a narrative level in a weird way to me it would still fall into the same old gap that causes so many of Dean’s issues. Because ultimately Dean snapping out of it would then again not be about a recognition of self worth but an act to save his loved ones, it would again be about someone else and not him. Don’t get me wrong, I wouldn’t want such a scene to play out any other way than Dean pulling through but to me it would negate the entire importance this set up should explore. Therefore I hope we won’t be getting such a scene to “bring Dean back”, but another one that makes it clear that in this moment Dean is fighting simply for himself by recognizing his own worth and in extension also saving the world from AU!Michael.
A girl can dream, right?!