Hi, did you watch Smallville back in the day? I've been thinking about how the fandom hated asian!Lana with a passion, and preferred Clark to be with either the white Chloe or the white Lois. Usually they cited bad writing, but I feel like if the series aired now, I would back Lana like a motherfucker, and probably stop watching once she was written out. Do you think the fandom was like super racist or what?
No I didn’t. Apart from one or two episodes and all I can recall of those two are Clark and Bald Guy and even that is extremely vague. So I can’t really comment in the specific.
I can’t say I’m in any way surprised at how Lana was treated though. And the tired old “bad writing” argument. Funny how fandom can overlook and fix bad writing when it comes to white male characters, isn’t it? Even white female characters can get this treatment if it helps sideline a woman of color. But any character of color? Nah.
I don’t think the Smallville fandom was any more racist than any other fandom though. There is that post I’m too tired to go find right now that points out that a fandom with a diverse cast isn’t more racist than any other fandom, it’s just that the racists that are always present now have more target. And I would add more prominent targets, so it becomes that much more noticeable.
So with the caveats for not knowing the specific fandom in any way I don’t think it was any more racist than your average fandom. Lana’s presence just made the racists noticeable.
Hope this makes sense, I’m quite a bit of a scatter brain today.