thoughts on asoue s3! talk to me about it
good things
best moment was sunny and violet on mount fraught when sunny ties her hair with a ribbon!! my children!!!!
LOVE QUIGLEY QUAGMIRE
i’m living for the opera scenes. lemony watching beatrice perform! olaf and kit! esme and kit talking about how bitter tea should be! and of course the tragic poison dart incident
it really highlighted the parallel between the man with a beard and no hair and woman with hair and no beard indoctrinating olaf into the fire-setting side of the schism with kit indoctrinating the baudelaires into the fire-fighting side. this is still one of my favorite parts of the series, how the adults always take advantage of vulnerable young people for their own agendas
related, fernald and fiona were amazing. they are so important to the theme of how there is no wicked side and good side and how everyone is a mix of good and bad. doing bad things for a noble reason - whether that makes you a bad person and whether those things should be forgiven. the big questions of this series!!
another bullet point on fernald and fiona. i love their relationship so much and how protective they are of each other - they are great foils to the baudelaires. there are so many sibling relationships in this series i dont know how to analyze them all without going overboard so i’ll just leave it here
and, fernald and sunny! an amazing friendship! so many cute interactions uwu
lemony meeting the baudelaires...an interesting change. i guess they wanted to develop lemony’s character more. i still don’t know how i feel about it.
EXCELLENT casting for the denouement brothers! the scenes where they don’t know who’s frank and who’s ernest were SO GOOD and chilling. and dewey’s death...that hurt.
the penultimate peril episodes in general were just amazing. can’t believe they confirmed who JS was though?
love the reference to all the wrong questions - L. Snicket wrote an account of the great unknown
the olaf/esme/carmelita shenanigans were so funny omg
i really liked the villain decay that olaf went through. it felt much more pronounced in the show than in the books. in the books it felt more like you only start seeing olaf as more of a human in the end, whereas you start seeing him become a weaker threat in comparison to the man/woman with hair and beard much earlier. by the time the baudelaires get into the boat with him he’s basically lost his power over them and is no longer scary but merely despicable and pathetic
also love the scenes where the baudelaires debate doing bad things for noble reasons like holding esme hostage and pushing olaf off the boat
so glad we got to see kit and lemony interaction
i really liked the beatrice II and lemony scene at the end. i felt like it was the closure i didn’t know i needed
things i didn’t like
they explained everything
seriously after YEARS of agonizing over what’s in the sugar bowl and they tell us it was sugar???
sugar that makes you immune to the mycelium just seemed like a weak narrative choice. there’s already a cure so this doesn’t seem that important. it was better when you never find out what’s in it, because it becomes something everyone is fighting over without knowing why - more about how the schism escalated than something real and important
speaking of sugar, they sugarcoated everything. it makes no sense in this story for the incredibly deadly viper to save all the island people by following them with the apple. ishmael was an evil dude who let them all die and saved himself!!
also, didn’t like that they answered what happened to the quagmires and fiona and fernald with perfect happy endings. again, better when we didn’t know what happened and we could make theories!
then again, we could assume that the endings they showed us weren’t confirmations but just imagining what might have been a happy ending for them.
people who only watched the show and didn’t read the books will never know the pain and brilliance of leaving so many questions unanswered!!!!
overall, love the show. it was an amazing adaptation, perfect dark/absurd/comedic tone, great acting, and mostly stayed true to the books. again, talk to me about it!














