“Osaka Koi No Uta”
Release date: April 27, 2005
Oricon Weekly placement: 2nd
B-side: “Nature Is Good!”
Members: Ai Takahashi, Asami Konno, Eri Kamei, Hitomi Yoshizawa, Mokoto Ogawa, Mari Yaguchi, Miki Fujimoto, Reina Tanaka, Rika Ishikawa, Risa Niigaki, Sayumi Michishige
Morning Musume’s experiments have included different approaches to voice and delivery in addition to tackling other styles of pop music. The jazz-influenced yelps of “Mr. Moonlight ~Ai No Big Band~” or the dramatic sigh of “As for One Day” immediately come to mind as examples of the singers toying with their voices. "Osaka Koi No Uta” takes it another level by incorporating the Kansai dialect to its lyric writing -- the American equivalent of writing lyrics with, say, a New Yorker accent in mind.
Tsunku is from the Osaka prefecture, the area of Japan that serves as the representative home to the hypothetical person from the Kansai region, or Western Japan. And the producer talks and acts the part with a demeanor that’s very outgoing and comical yet unafraid to hit back with a snappy remark; that bluntness tends to give Kansai people a rep as rough and hot-headed to the eyes of an outsider.
The Morning Musume line-up for “Osaka Koi No Uta,” however, only includes one member from the Kansai area. Ai Takahashi is from the Fukui prefecture, and if the reference in “Joshi Kashimashi Monagatari” is to be believed, she’s known in the group to let her home dialect slip. The rest of them can only act the part. Hitomi Yoshizawa (from Saitama, a prefecture in the Kanto region, or Eastern Japan) in particular compensates her lack of familiarity with her tomboy attitude when she recites the intro script: “itsumo zutto ishoyattakara, kizukahenkatta,” she sighs a line full of Kaisai-specific suffixes.
“Even if everyone tried to speak in a Kaisai dialect in daily conversation, the intonation definitely won’t be the same, but if you sang along with the melody, you won’t really make a mistake,” pointed out Rika Ishikawa (from Kanagawa in the Kanto region). “So this song made me feel like, ‘hey, I can speak in the dialect a little.’”
Ishikawa’s comments are true: none of the singers in “Osaka Koi No Uta” stumble with the lyrics or stick out like foreigners doing an awkward impression. Yet the melody scrubbing away that intonation removes a majority of what defines Kansai speak. Even if you don’t understand Japanese, I think you can hear the difference in the way people talk according to which region by hearing for that intonation and cadence.
Other than Yoshizawa’s intro script, it’s difficult to grasp the song’s incorporation of a region-specific talk unless one reads the lyrics. Conveying a Kansai personality matters, too, in the relationship talk of “Osaka Koi No Uta.” Admitting loss hits more devastating and reminiscences of kisses sound unexpectedly sincere when they come from the voice of a tough-skinned woman.
But thankfully, “Osaka Koi No Uta” works strong as a general pop song enough for the failure in the experiment to ultimately be a minor issue. The R&B production sets a great backdrop for the song’s melodrama with its squiggly electro beat and speedy breakbeats. The chorus responds to the heart-racing tension with a dramatic breakdown, the singers audibly falling to their knees faced with an imminent break-up. Morning Musume might not succeed in making Kansai R&B, but they still deliver compelling heartbreak pop.
[6]















