The problem with Authentic Assessment
*Gasp* What? There is a problem with authentic assessment? But how can that be?! It is the way we will stop this horrific testing!
Yes, I say there is a problem with authentic assessment. And the reason is simple...what is Authentic? What does it mean to have Authentic Assessments?
Example: Some of my students this year were required to read a book and summarize it into a 10 page children’s book. Sounds great, right? Students are reading, summarizing, and creating. The perfect Authentic Assessment? Maybe. But let’s ask this: will this help students determine which Car is better for them based on reviews and dealer stats? Will this help students look at the different Republican/Democrat/Independent candidates and choose the one they most agree with?
Again, maybe. We want Authentic Assessment to be meaningful to students...be “Real-world”...but what is real world? Is real-world the fact that you can summarize a book, or summarize an article? Is real-world that you can summarize the positions of the political candidates in the current election? Or is it somewhere in between?
The key for teachers to understand as we begin to bring Authentic Assessment into our classroom isn’t necessarily the fact that students are learning and being assessed by something other than a test...but instead the fact that Authentic Assessment may look different to each student. You will never be able to please every student, nor will your great, awesome, WONDERFUL authentic assessment always produce the results you hope. Sometimes what you feel is Authentic for students is really only Authentic to you. It is important to keep this in mind when you are designing your lessons.
Check out this article if you want to think about this topic further: http://calpro-online.org/eric/docs/custer/custer4.pdf