repmet replied to your post: on reflection i think amy is probably my fave...
Moffat wrote some of my favourite stand alone stories and episodes from Dr Who but once they handed him the whole show I feel like he just… couldn’t handle longer stories lol. I’m still mad at how he ruined the weeping angels so completely by not knowing how to leave them alone :/
Lol my feelings on Moffat are well documented on this blog years ago and they’re mostly negative. But something I always found frustrating about his writing was how often there’d be like, the seed of something I liked and then the execution would just not at all go where I wanted it to go. Amy was a great example of that, but now years on I think it has left me with more overall affection for her than for the companions that followed her. The IDEA of Amelia Pond is very good and I can remember that feeling from way back when Eleventh Hour aired.











