Rick Riordan is a cishet white guy writing books about minorities kicking ass and saving the world, he’s bound to make mistakes when writing about things that he's never experienced. But I personally think that that’s exactly what Piper’s feathers, Hazel’s eyes, Reyna’s backstory or anything that you found disrespectful to your culture or identity were. Mistakes. I don't think they weren’t born out of racism, or sexism, or homophobia or any terrible things like that, they were born out of ignorance and the privilege that he has as a cishet white guy.
When people call Rick out on mistakes that he’s made, he apologizes, thanks them, and corrects it. The most recent example of this is the whole thing with Muslims not showering during Ramadan. How rare is it to see a content creator of any kind to listen and try harder when confronted with something they did wrong? I don’t think that any stereotyping or stigmatization was intentional on Ricks part, isn’t that all that matters? The Intention. His intention was to help poc, lgbt, and neurodivergent kids see themselves and accept themselves, and he screwed up a lot on the way. And in my opinion, that’s okay. As long as he continues learning and trying to be better. What he meant is the real testament to his character, but how people interpret it is what leads people who criticize him to believe what they do, and they’re entitled to their own opinion and all that. As Rick said in the quote below, what the people actually read is what’s important to them. I’ll leave you with this quote from his Stonewall Award speech, that I think sums this up.
“I am trying to do more. Percy Jackson started as a way to empower kids, in particular my son, who had learning differences. As my platform grew, I felt obliged to use it to empower all kids who are struggling through middle school for whatever reason. I don’t always do enough. I don’t always get it right. Good intentions are wonderful things, but at the end of a manuscript, the text has to stand on its own. What I meant ceases to matter. Kids just see what I wrote. But I have to keep trying. My kids are counting on me.So thank you, above all, to my former students who taught me. Alex Fierro is for you. To you, I pledge myself to do better – to apologize when I screw up, to learn from my mistakes, to be there for LGBTQ youth and make sure they know that in my books, they are included. They matter. I am going to stop talking now, but I promise you I won’t stop listening.”