What song would they dedicate to you?
Disclaimer: FEM! Reader, wlw, men get tf away from here, although it’s all sfw!! It’s like an analysis abt their personality and the way they love, so don’t expect it to be short.
Characters: Jane the Killer, Clockwork, Kate the Chaser, Rouge, Zero, Nina the Killer, Laughing Jill, Nurse Ann.
When your girlfriend is the only thing that feels real in a world where you are on the verge of collapsing because you don’t even recognize yourself in the mirror, the best thing to do is to show it to her with all the humanity you have left. You don’t care how much it costs you to control the sharp pain, or the mind control that Slenderman exerts over you—because that woman goes against every plan he has for you, and you must protect her as if she were the embodiment of the little sanity you have left (because, in a way, she is).
With a feeling that still resides in your chest regarding all the struggles you faced before becoming the killer you are now, and with that living need to feel love despite the circumstances, what better way to show it to her than with that artistic sensitivity you excelled at before everything fell apart? To prove to her that you, too, have a human heart.
- “Every Breath You Take” / The Police: “Oh can’t you see / You belong to me? / How my poor heart aches / With every step you take”
“Every Breath You Take” talks about how basically hounding someone can become the most romantic thing when you miss them.
I feel that Natalie wouldn't think of it that way, but rather from a simpler perspective: she literally watches over you. In a world where she can no longer distinguish between what is real and what is just in her head, realizing that you are genuinely something real—something that can be "stolen" or "seen" by others—would awaken a primitive need in Natalie to always know that you are HERS.
You live within Natalie's memories, thoughts, and delusions. When she manages to fall asleep, she dreams of you; when she stands appreciating the forest at night, she thinks of you; when she loses herself in the blurred memories of her past, the only cure is the vision of your loving gaze.
I can easily see her, when the song comes on, pulling you by the waist to slow dance…. Her lips brush gently against your ear to sing the verses that make her think of you the most, wearing a small, satisfied smile from having you so close.
- "Sofia" / Clairo: “You know I’ll do anything you ask me to / but, oh my god, I think I’m in love with you”
“Sofia” by Clairo is literally a passionate love letter that seems to come from a girl falling in love with another woman for the very first time. She was supposed to be in love with Jeff; why, then, did she get so nervous whenever she was with you?
Nina probably spent a few days locked in her room, wondering what was happening to her and trying to explain her feelings through this song. Yet, the more she listened to it and thought of you, the more confused and flushed she became.
At the end of the day, the singer's sweet voice reminds me of her. I can picture you two just chilling, and suddenly she plays the song, grabs a hairbrush as a microphone, and starts belting it out just to make you laugh for a bit—even though every shouted lyric is a declaration of how much she loves you.
Eventually, you might even get a letter decorated by her, featuring the verses that remind her most of you now that you are girlfriends, which would probably be: “I think we could do it if we tried, if only to say, ‘You’re mine’ / Sofia, know that you and I shouldn’t feel like a crime.”
- “Pale Blue Eyes” / The Velvet Underground: “Linger on you pale blue eyes / if I could make the world as pure / and strange as what I see / I’d put you in the mirror / I put in front of me”
"Pale Blue Eyes," in my opinion, speaks of an unconditional love during difficult and painful times.
Even if you don't necessarily have blue eyes, the windows to your soul are the closest thing Kate has to a home. Kate doesn't need you to be anyone special in life; your mere existence and love will bring peace to a soul almost in ruins.
The stanzas I mentioned specifically speak to us about creating a new world—a perfect one for the two of you, where you can love each other without prejudice. Slenderman and the corruption he exerts over Kate don't let her live in peace, but she is willing to embrace all her pain just to keep the feeling alive and, above all, to keep you by her side.
In the song, the singer simply accepts that the world complicates their relationship, but he doesn't care, because that is what true, unconditional love is. Kate understands the magnitude of this word; therefore, if she consciously wants you by her side, it is because her love goes beyond all the things that prevent you from being together.
I imagine the two of you together, perhaps cuddled up in bed while this song plays on the radio. Her fingers, which were previously caressing your back, begin to follow the rhythm of the song. You hear her humming the melody under her breath, and her grip around you grows tighter. I can easily see her confessing that she thinks of you when she listens to it, and so that you live on in her memories, she has started listening to it more often.
“Lovesong” / The cure: “You make me feel like I am young again / Whenever I’m alone with you / you make me feel like I am fun again”
With the stanzas I marked, I feel that Jane would be referring to all the pain she went through after her burns. Deep down, she must be very insecure about it. The fact that you make her feel young and fun again speaks to how you have the ability to practically give her back her essence and her life.
She is one of the most mature when it comes to romance; she has no trouble telling you exactly why she thinks of you when she listens to the song, how many times she plays it, and how grateful she is to you. At the same time, being one of the most mature, she holds onto this sense of devoted love and monogamy. The song is a love letter entirely willing to show everything to the other person, as if Jane could pull down the stars for you and take you to the moon.
The song commits to loving the listener no matter what happens, despite distance, obstacles, or choices. But I feel that Jane might think of you once her feelings are completely clear and, above all, once she knows you are ready for that level of emotional maturity.
I feel like you two could be quietly watching a movie, and out of nowhere, that song starts playing in the background. She, with all the calmness in the world and a hand on your waist, would say, “this song reminds me of you,” before giving you a gentle little kiss on the top of your head.
“Witches Tale” / Jah PHNX: “Blood spills cheap thrills make for great art / If you give me direction / I can find my way out of this dark”
“Witches Tale” literally screams Nurse Ann.
After such a tragic ending, where she was only searching for love from the person she trusted most, only for him to do what him did to her, she never believed she would experience such a vulnerable feeling again. She promised herself never to trust anyone ever again.
So why, if she was so foreign to love, did she find more peace in having you by her side than in killing you?
The song directly asks the listener if they somehow cast a spell on her heart, and I feel that would be something Ann would spend hours trying to decipher: what you did to her. Furthermore, although Ann obviously wouldn't feel the need to change her actions for "the greater good" of the relationship, I do feel that by your side, she would control herself a lot more, stepping out of her darkness for a few moments.
I feel that the aesthetics of this song are very much in line with her way of loving and the things she would say to you.
I can completely picture this scenario: you are just chilling when you find a small, heart-shaped box sitting on your desk. When you open it, you find a piece of her SKIN, along with a letter written in blood: “I tear my skin to keep you warm” and a very well-drawn heart, probably made with those super old pens.
“Perfect” / The Smashing Pumpkins: “We Just can’t pretend that lovers make amends / We are reasons so unreal”
"Perfect" by The Smashing Pumpkins is a 90s alternative rock song that captures that exact blend of nostalgia, melancholy, and a deeply honest devotion. For someone like Zero, whose visual and mental world is fragmented in black and white, music becomes the only bridge to express the colors she feels when she is with you.
Zero probably spent many sleepless nights, in complete silence, playing this song over and over again while staring at the ceiling. Her mind is usually a whirlwind of chaotic thoughts, but when she hears the guitar chords, all that noise stops and only your face remains in her head. It is a song that helps her arrange the puzzle of her own emotions when regular words are not enough.
The atmosphere of the song has that somewhat gritty yet deeply protective texture that fits her essence. I imagine the two of you sharing a moment alone, far from all the chaos, where she hands you one of her earphones so you can listen together in silence. While the music plays, Zero says nothing, but she holds your hand tightly and rests her head on your shoulder, letting the melody speak for her and show you that, by your side, she finally feels complete and real.
If she decided to put what she feels onto paper, you might find a hidden note among your things, written in her quick and decisive handwriting, highlighting a small poem for you: “They can pluck every flower that grows, but they can never stop the spring from being born. If you are the garden's strongest rose, no one will ever tear you from my own.”
-“Everlong” / The Foo Fighters: And I wonder, when I sing along with you / If everything could ever feel this real forever / If anything could ever be this good again.
"Everlong" by Foo Fighters is literally a rush of adrenaline and pure love that sounds exactly like what a girl feels when she finds her safe person in the middle of a wild and chaotic life. Rouge is supposed to spend her time watching, hunting, and staying alert in the coldness of the night; why, then, did all that protective instinct completely disarm itself and turn into pure warmth whenever she was with you?
Rouge probably discovered the song by accident on an old radio station while scouting around, and she froze completely upon hearing the drums and the distorted guitar. She spent the next few days with the rhythm stuck in her head, realizing that the intensity of the music perfectly matched how hard her chest beat every time she looked at you. Although she initially tried to shake off that feeling because she didn't understand what was happening to her, she ended up surrendering to the emotion, smiling to herself in the dark upon accepting that she was hopelessly in love.
At the end of the day, the raw, passionate, and free energy of the song reminds me so much of her true essence.
I can totally picture you both in some half-abandoned parking lot, eating fast food she snagged from somewhere. In the background, coming from a pretty mediocre bar, that song starts to play. Maybe she doesn't say a word to you, but you notice how her gaze changes, softening and lighting up tenderly as she looks at you despite the darkness of the woods. You don't know if she is actually paying attention to what you're telling her, or if she's picturing you in every single verse of the song.
Eventually, on any given day, you might find an old cassette in your backpack with the name of the song written in black marker by her, right next to a slightly torn but carefully kept note where she underlined the confession that became her definitive declaration of love:
“One day, I’ll explain with every kiss I sign, why my soul trembles when your eyes meet mine.”
- “La vie en Rose” / Édith Piaf: “Il est entré dans mon cœur / Une part de bonheur / Dont je connais la cause”
(Ik it talks abt a boy, but imagine it’s abt a girl. That’s all.)
"La Vie En Rose" by Édith Piaf speaks of a devotion so magical and absolute that it is capable of bringing color back to a reality that had turned completely gray. Jill; who literally lost all her color, her joy, and her brightness after being left alone in a monochromatic world, your presence and your smile are the closest thing she has to reclaiming the spark that once defined her. Jill doesn't need the world to become the colorful carnival it used to be; your mere existence is enough to ignite a massive light in a heart that was submerged in the monotony and loneliness of its own transformation.
The verses of this song speak to us about seeing life through a rosy filter, where problems fade away when you are with the right person. The weight of abandonment and the emptiness that turned her into a tragic being won't let her live in peace, but her way of loving is based on contrast: using what's left of her artistic sensitivity to protect you from the darkness. She is willing to leave all her bitterness behind just to focus on the warmth of your affection and, above all, to make sure that her new nature doesn't overshadow your light.
In the song, the melody flows with an elegance that accepts love in an open, theatrical, and deeply sincere way. Jill understands what it means to go from a rainbow to grayscale, which is why her love is intensely protective and devoted; if she seeks you out with such tenderness, it is because what she feels for you is the only real and colorful thing left in her existence.
I can totally picture the two of you together, maybe sharing a quiet moment in your favorite spot while this beautiful song plays in the background. Her hands gently guide you to sway from side to side to the rhythm of the music. You hear her let out a soft, bittersweet chuckle before whispering the lyrics into your ear, holding you with immense delicacy. I can easily see her confessing that you are the reason her world makes sense again, and that she adopted this song because it describes exactly how you changed her reality from the moment you stepped into her life.
Hope you liked itttt!!!! I’m trying to open like a section where you can ask me everything (reactions/hcs/scenarios) AS LONG IT’S CREEPYPASTASSSSSS.
