rpaprika replied to your post “i wasnt trolling im sorry if i came off as that :( i just think it...”
My friend, who never read the books, understand everything that is going on at least and can follow 😊 she is saying that even if she doesn't have the answers to everything she feels like it is intriguing. I personally quite love the changes they make, as it can allow us to rediscover the story. I feel like it is sort of a gift for readers that can understand who exactly John Parry and his family are but not viewers? Or I just miss Will haha. But I can also feel that
…this is a bit disturbing 😅 but I haven’t read the books in more than 10 years so my memory is a bit confused about the storyline 😅
But yes just giving away major plot surprises in just a few episodes is disturbing 🙄😔 I don’t want to be spoiled (it feels like it when I don’t remember the plot) by the serie while I am rereading the books 😅
Like I’ve said before, I don’t mind changes or them organizing the story differently, and I think that it’s interesting to re-construct the story in an order that isn’t entirely linear, as we’ve known it. I don’t have a problem with that, I thought that the incorporation of La Belle Sauvage was very smart, for example.
My original post had to do with the storytelling focus overall and how the way in which it pushes Lyra’s perspective (not presence) aside can be seen as them considering that the story of a 12 year old girl protagonist might not be worth the attention of the audience they want to cater to, despite how complex the story is and despite who the audience of the books was. Time will tell, I guess.
But, like I said, that is my personal worry and my interpretation, I understand that it’s an unpopular opinion and most people love the series as it is and disagree with me, or most people who are being vocal about it, at least. I’ll keep watching it, of course, and it doesn’t mean at this point that I won’t continue it, but it’s a worry that I have in terms of intentions and focus, not specifically on what they change or not.
And I’m glad that your friend is liking it so far :)