I know the writers tried to be subversive by making Salem already immortal but obviously didn't really think through the full implications of what that meant. Such as her being relatively inactive for centuries despite her overpowering everyone and freely able to move as she pleases. Ozpin despite his vast accumulated knowledge could not figure out a way to defeat her in all that time. Not to mention writing themselves into a corner regarding how our band of moronic heroes are going to beat her.
okay but thinking of this there’s such a good comparison to salem & really what she should’ve been in the show; solas from dragon age.
solas is an immortal elf from the series who is the main reason for all the drama in inquisition, & a main reason why he wasn’t able to enact his plan of basically destruction of the current world for his vision of the world is because he was put into a long sleep. even when he woke up he was too weak to enact his plan so instead he gave the catalyst for it to a magister called corypheus but then his plan was foiled by the dragon age equivalent of ruby, the inquisitor.
the anchor is also very easily compared to silver eyes in that it’s the maguffin of the universe that is the key to completing or undoing a plan. but the pro that dragon age has is that solas’s plan is solidified, whereas in rwby it feels like salem, or the writers, change their minds every five minutes so her actions always feel vague or nonsensical, there’s no set goal for her to work towards or for rwbyjnr to fight against in any meaningful way.
in dragon age, there’s also a major question of how the inquisitor is going to defeat solas & prevent him from destroying the world by opening the fade, possibly killing millions; but there are a fair few viable options of how, if that’s the option your inquisitor even chose. whereas with rwbyjnr it really feels like they’re 20 steps behind any type of plan salem has considering the fndm figured out it was them who needed to do something about salem & not ozpin; yet that wasn’t even brought up until 2 volumes later.
in the end they’ve tried to make salem mysterious by shrouding her motivations & what her true plan is but then she just ends up confusing & vague. characters who actually pull off the mysterious vibe without being a confusing mess are solas & flemeth, flemeth is honestly what salem should’ve been smh.