rating fishing minigames I have encountered in no particular order
red dead redemption 2/online: hard to learn, hard on the hands, but GOD is perfecting it satisfying as hell. also fun fact lures don't matter that much and good bait is cheaper than replacing the lure+easier to use, but they add valuable variety to the minigame. 9/10
enshrouded/sea of thieves (basically the same minigame reskinned): classic, simple, gets the job done, bit annoying when the fish touches an object and instantly escapes in SoT tho. 6/10
skyrim: barely even a minigame, boring as fuck, unnecessary restrictions typical of skyrim, the only purpose of the dlc is to add more food variety in my eyes. 1/10
stardew valley: fuckyoufuckyoufuckyoufuckyoufuckyoufucky-