1) Was Ali really pregnant? Then what happened to the baby and who is the"beach hottie" who she thought got her pregnant?
2) Why was Ali desperate for money in the months before her death? She bribed her friends parents & made masks of her face for $$$.
3) Whose earrings did Ali and Aria find in Byron’s office? (Meredith said they weren’t hers. Did Ali plant her own to get more blackmail $$$?)
4) Which Rosewood girls were pimping out their friends to the N.A.T. club?(Jason says the N.A.T. club paid girls to set up their friends.)
5) Who was the N.A.T. club working for? (Jason thinks that by the time he left the club, Ian was filming for someone else.)
6) Who killed Marion Cavanaugh?
7) Who are Bethany’s parents?
8) Why did Mrs. D want to be so close to Bethany?
9) Why did Bethany hate Mrs. D?
10) How did Alison and Bethany know each other?
11) Why did Ali want Bethany to dress like her “that night”?
12) Why did Ali want Jenna to think she was dead if she only decided to run away after someone tried to kill her?
13) Who hit Ali over the head with a rock and buried her alive?
14) Who was Mrs. D trying to protect?
15) Who almost killed Bethany before Melissa buried her?
16) Did Spencer hurt anyone that night?
17) Were Emily’s memories of “that night” really mixed up?
18) Was Wilden at Ali’s house “that night”? CeCe says he was. Why?
19) Why was CeCe at Ali’s house “that night”? She and Jason say she was.
20) Why was CeCe dressed like Ali “that night” (according to Jason’s memory)?
21) Why did the A team rob “Ali’s” grave, then return the body? Mrs. Hastings said the police wanted to exhume “Ali’s” body before someone stole it. Did A replace the body with Bethany’s for the cops to find, but it was someone else’s? Was A checking the body’s identity?
22) Why did A (probably) switch Ali & Bethany’s dental records?
23) What does Eddie Lamb know and where is he now?
24) Why did CeCe dump Jason the day after Ali went missing?
25) Why did Jason think CeCe helped Ali run away when she went missing?
26) Is CeCe a double agent for Ali and A?
27) Why did CeCe get expelled for a girl getting pushed down the stairs at Melissa’s then-boyfriend Ian’s frat party?
28) Who pushed that girl at Ian’s frat party down the stairs?
29) How did Ali and CeCe meet?
30) Did CeCe really kill Wilden? Marlene says Ali THINKS she did.
31) How did CeCe escape the cops? Did someone help her?
32) Who is black widow? Big A or one of A’s minions?
33) Are Ali and CeCe the only red coats, or is there another who directed the A team?
34) Which redcoat lived in Mrs. DiLaurentis’s basement?
35) Why did Ali want copies of her mask “so her friends could look like her”?
36) Why did Ali have to have SO many damn fake IDs?
37) Did Hanna really see Alison days before her body was found, when she and Mona played with a Ouija board? If so, why was she in Rosewood?
38) Why did Mona want the PLLs to believe Ian killed Ali?
39) Who is the woman who hired Logan Reed to deliver money to the PLLs and pretend it was on Ian’s behalf?
40) Why did Garrett pay Logan Reed to leave town after Emily found him?
41) Who killed Ian? Mona was A, but says she didn’t know who killed him. Ali pushed him off the bell tower, but claims she saw him leave alive. Why did Mona compile his “suicide note” with A notes and made it look like he killed himself?
42) Why would Mona run over her “true friend” Hanna after Hanna thought she saw A, when ALL SHE SAW WAS NOEL?
43) Why did Noel suddenly break up with Mona?
44) What does Ali have on Noel?
45) Did Ali stay at Noel Kahn’s cabin (her bag was there) and why?
46) Why did Maya hide out at Noel Kahn’s cabin?
47) Why did Maya get in Garrett’s car the night she was killed? (Did he tell her who took the body and that’s what “MAYA KNEW”?)
48) What did Maya know? A’s identity? That Ali was still alive?
49) Why did A take Maya’s prescription pills? The pills were in Maya’s bag, which was at Noel’s cabin. Noel and Jenna were dating at the time. Mona was sneaking out her medication with a visitor, according to Wren. The pills Emily was drugged with were found in Lucas’s camera bag. If Emily was drugged with Mona’s pills, why did A take Maya’s too?
50) Who wrote “sorry for leaving you” on Emily’s menu when she was drugged and at the diner? (Holden, Jenna, and Noel were there that night and all of them knew Maya.)
51) Who was Jenna trying to protect when she lied about where she found Emily drugged? After Jenna lied that they found her in the street, Noel confessed that they found her at a diner. Jenna said she lied “to protect someone.”
52) Why did Noel and Jenna break up? Did she dump him for Shana?
53) Where was Jenna after her music camp ended and before school started (when she could secretly see again and prob knew Shana)?
54) Did Shana turn on Ali because of “the Jenna thing”, or were there other secrets she learned about. What were they?
55) Who did Jenna meet with before the masquerade ball, give a scarf-wrapped item to and tell, “they’ll all be at the party. you know what to do.”?
56) Why did Mona - as A - tell Lucas and Melissa to distract Jenna, and ask Melissa to wear a black swan dress?
57) What did Jenna plan to do at the masquerade ball? (She gave someone an item - probably a gun - and said “you know what to do”, Mona ordered Lucas and Melissa to distract her, and Jenna seemed to be texting and following Aria that night.)
58) Who did Mona tell, “I did everything you asked me to” in Radley after she was outed as A after the masquerade ball. The person wore a red coat (or Mona imagined that she did).
59) Why did Jenna suddenly hate Garrett after years of dating and even turn him into the cops for murder? (I think it’s because she found out he lied about killing Ali and learned that someone she knew died instead).
60) Who was Garrett talking about when he told Spencer “someone you know well has you completely fooled”, was he talking about Melissa losing her baby, Jenna seeing, Ali being alive, the identity of A or what??
61) How did Garrett know who took the body from Ali’s grave? Is that why he was killed?
62) How did Garrett get Ali’s charm bracelet to the antique shop when he was in jail? Who did he want to find it?
63) What did Wilden do that A blackmailed him over?
64) Why did A want to kill Aria on the Ghost Train?
65) Who killed Garrett? We know A wanted him out of jail and that A intended to kill Aria (“guess who won’t make it to the end of the line”), but did A definitely kill Garrett? Or did someone else and A just planned to get rid of Aria with his found body?
66) Who is the female who urged the male who was stabbed on the Halloween train to push Aria off with Garrett’s body?
67) Why did Mona agree to help A kill Garrett and drug Aria?
68) Did Toby help the A team kill Garrett and try to kill Aria? Why? Mona gave this person pills and bullets on Halloween when Toby was A team.
69) Who did Aria stab through the box on the Halloween train? (Jason and the body in the woods with Toby’s tattoo both had a stab wound).
70) Whose body did A plant to look like Toby in the woods? It had HIS SAME TATTOO. Who was it? Why was he killed? Why did he have a stab wound just like Jason’s?
71) Why did Toby run Lucas off the road? Because he didn’t kill Aria and dispose of Garrets body??
72) How long was Toby on the A team before he was caught? The waitress that called him “pretty eyes” called an A teamer “pretty eyes” in season 2!
73) Why did A blow up Jenna & Toby’s family home?
74) Who tried to drown Jenna?
75) Who tried to burn Jenna to death? This person texted Jenna claiming to be Jason, so she went to his house alone and the house was set on fire.
76) Did someone rig the elevator Jason and Emily were in? Who and why?
77) Why did Jason want Mona to make an apology video to the school? In the full video (on youtube) she notes that they’re “in this together” and asks if he’s having doubts. She also calls him “friend.” When she told the PLLs he supervised her video, she lied that it was her idea even though in the full video she tells notes that it was his idea.
78) Why did Jenna’s date to Wilden’s funeral, Nigel West, try to frame Toby for lighting the lodge on fire?
79) Who saved the PLLs + Mona from the fire and left Hanna behind?
80) What did Spencer bury with Alison? A sent every other girl the thing they left in her grave.
81) Why did Mrs. D deliver a suitcase to someone in the middle of the night soon before she was killed? Who did she give it to? (CeCe was later seen in clothes Mrs. D bought & was secretive about.)
82) Why did A kill Mrs. D?
83) Who did Melissa meet with outside of the barn at night, give something to and tell, “Do it. Trust me.”
84) Who is Ezra’s traveling “friend” whose cabin he stayed at?
85) Whose apartment did Ali stay at in New York while they were away?
86) Who is this & why was he helping A?
87) Who is Lucas’s girlfriend?
88) Why was Sydney conspiring with Mona & Jenna? What is her story?
89) Who did Mona, Jenna and Sydney meet up with?
90) What did Aria whisper to Mona?
91) Who is the mystery woman Mona watched Hanna with?
92) Who killed Mona? Was it more than one person?
93) Why did Mona faint (and have a bandaged arm) days before her death?
94) What happened between Wren and Mona? He helped her sneak in visitor CeCe, then she stopped trusting him when she found out “where his loyalties lie”.
95) Why did Wren want to stop Mrs. Hastings from defending Mrs. Marin about Wilden’s murder?
96) Why did Melissa and Wren get back together and move to London?
97) Who are the A team members helping big A? Do they know big A’s identity? Why are they helping him or her?
98) Was that really Ali at Radley when Spencer was there?
99) Does Ali have a twin? If not, why did her mom want her to lie to her dad when she found 2 matching dresses (one for her and one for someone else)? If not Ali, does someone else? So many hints are dropped. Who?
100) Why did A try to kill Emily at the sawmill?
101) How long has Holbrook known Ali? What is their history?
I could probably post 101 more :P We still have a LOT of questions but I hope reading through these helps before we get them! Thinking through these got my wheels turning. More theories to come soon! :)
