https://www.tumblr.com/a-crumb-of-whump/725498844041887744/i-give-cohen-the-choice-between-cutting-eli-open?source=share
I strap cohen down to a table and grab my sharpest knife, using it to cut down his shirt until the entire middle is ripped. Then I plunge the knife shallowly into his stomach before dragging it down the middle until It's big enough that I can dig a few fingers in.
After playing with his insides for a while, I stitch him back up and praise him on how well he took it before releasing Eli and him so they can be together <3
Content: Forced to watch, self-sacrifice.
Cohen groans as he watches you cut the fabric apart. "You could'a just taken it off. That was my favourite fucking shirt."
All that is forgotten, however, when he feels the knife dig into his stomach. It's sharp, but that doesn't take away any of the pain. Just makes the process easier.
Eli sobs, struggling to cover his ears with his hands above his head as Cohen's screams echo endlessly through the building. Even just watching is enough to trigger him, and he could not feel more guilty for being the one who gets to sit and watch, despite having no say in the matter.
It feels like forever that it goes on. Eli is terrified that he's dead when the screams and cries start to die down, but those fears start to ebb away as soon as he sees you begin to stitch the wound. There would be no reason for you to do that if he really was dead.
Cohen is barely lucid enough to hear your praises. It hurts to breathe. Everything hurts and he just wishes you would get out of his face.
As soon as you let Eli go, he shoves you out of the way and scrambles for the table, pressing his ear to Cohen's chest in an attempt to hear his heartbeat. He knows that he's alive, but the sound gives him an immense amount of relief nonetheless.
Cohen uses what little strength he has left to rub Eli's back a few times, both his hands holding a light tremor to them that can easily be felt under his touch.
"Thank you, thank you, thank you," he whispers, eyes squeezed shut as he forces back another sob. "I'm so sorry. You- you can- you can get me back, if you want. I- I won't resist, but please have mercy when you do."
"Oh, shut up," Cohen mutters. Despite the irritation and discomfort evident in his voice, it's clear it's not directed at him. "Didn't mean what I said 'bout you owin' me."
Assuming they're allowed to leave: Eli helps him to his car and drives him home, despite not having a valid license on him.
Assuming they're not allowed to leave: The two stay there in that position for a little while longer before Eli helps him onto the floor and lays him down flat again.