#scenario scoreboard

[kinkmom]

if you still wanna rate scenarios, heres one ive been thinking about for a while. beta roxys sweet son dave is going to college, and she wants to make his last night home special. shes controlled herself around her son for too long. mom drugs him and has him tied up in their basement. shes gonna show dave just how much she loves him, and nothing will stop her. dave is paralyzed the entire time, drifting in and out of consciousness and absolutely helpless. i cant decide how she rapes him, if she rides him or fucks him with a strap on, or both. the whole time shes sickeningly sweet and affectionate, because she just loves her baby boy so much. idk if this is anything lol

You're slightly mistaken here, I really don't want to rate scenarios, the harsh judgement is supposed to deter sending in random scenarios. :'9 But damn, this is so inoffensive I can't get a single bingo hit off of it.

Nothing too convoluted, simple and sweet premise with just the elements needed to complete it.

We've got the noncon right way around. I don't like raping moms, that just doesn't sit right with me.

I'm not huge on MomDave where he's properly her son, I prefer wow-Rose's-mom-is-so-hot and wait-me-and-rose-are-siblings-then-OH-SHI- flavours. Also college boy Dave. 😳

But yeah, huh. Femdom, drugging, bondage, riding and sickeningly sweet affection? That's all good. I don't care for strap on rape myself, but each to their own. I think Dave needs to be sweet and flustered when he gets strapped. :3c

Final Score: 8/10

Getting there?

[kinkmom]

Epilogue shenanigans. Raver Rose slips Dirk a note that Dave gets by accident saying meet me in the bathroom along with a circle (for some glory hole fun) Dave knows what it means and takes the risk to fuck Rose. Possibly ends badly

Okay, dropping another meticulously peer reviewed scenario here.

Instant -100 points for mentioning the epilogues.

The rave setting is fun and sexy, I like it. Very good costuming potential and also rampant drug use.

My co-judge gives -50 points for glory hole, I don't mind as much, but I'm only interested in them when the result is surprise incest, which this isn't exactly going for. And that's the weak point here, I feel. I cannot see any universe where Rose would want to fuck Dirk but not Dave to the point that tricking her "possibly ends badly", when the incest clearly isn't the problem. The inclusion of Dirk makes the setting really fall apart. If she was inviting someone else the unexpected brotherfuck would actually have some sort of impact.

Final score: -122/10

I propose they get some ecstasy and have just an honest to god threesome.

Rose makes the boys kiss. 😚

Pillowfort link to take a look a liiiittle further down.

[kinkmom]

I made it. Proudly unveiling the scenario submission bingo board, a collection of the most frequent stumbles, everything lovingly handpicked from your favourite hard-to-please mommy's inbox! Now you too can play along at home!

Now I'm itching to build a general inbox bingo too...

[kinkmom]

Dave catches Kanaya having an affair with someone else and blackmails her into sex. Kanaya accepts afraid of ruining her marriage on the condition Dave wears a mask so Kanaya can flimsily claim some purity back. Rose catches the two and while Kanaya is horrified Rose unexpectedly eggs her on admitting to her own adulterous fantasies. Unaware of it being Dave that used her wife Rose fucks him too before finding out the truth.

You're terribly, terribly brave. Very well.

First off, big no to DaveKan. I love Kanaya, but I want to see Dave fucking only his siblings or his mom and absolutely no trolls.

Despite joking about it frequently I really don't have a cucking fetish. I accept incest-cucking and NTR when it ends up in incest, but this ain't it since Rose wasn't the specific target. It's not stated whether or not Dave wanted to fuck his sister, but it would be funny if he really didn't and went through with it just to not out himself in the moment. I'm actually more interested in the moment Rose is done fucking around and finds out. :'D

Concealed identity incest is great, but hard to implement in a way that I find plausible. The mask is okay, I'll give Rose the benefit of the doubt since people are harder to recognize in the wrong context and Dave's context is not without clothes in bed with her wife.

Final Score: 2/10

I'd be more interested if Rose and Kanaya's roles were reversed.

[kinkmom]

Roxy the loving mother has a noncon fetish and has a hankering for Dave but can't tell him. So Roxy flaunts to Dave until Dave pops and gives Roxy a late night visit while Dave thinks Roxy's to drunk to wake up. Roxy wakes up but acts asleep to fulfill her fantasy. Unfortunately for Roxy the condoms she's been leaving out to tempt Dave got so old that it breaks and Roxy gets knocked up

4/10, good pair, clearly trying to play off of things I've shown interest in with one fatal flaw: I don't like consensual noncon. That's the coward's choice in my books. Go big or go home. While Roxy definitely seems like the girl to like cnc, the only bitch with a rape fetish up in this joint is me.

A bit too convoluted setup for such a simple and clean somno scenario. Dave already wants to bang his mommy, Mom really doesn't need to flaunt it to have it happen. Also, why not personally make sure she's as hammered as he believes she is? A bit risky to just assume so, he should be smarter than that. How about they drink together and Dave encourages her to drink until her legs give up? Why not slip something in her drink? Dave is a good and responsible boy to use a condom, but my god, she tempted him with condoms?? All I can see is this:

[kinkmom]

Jade being the exhibitionist and fond of beaches usually ends with nude sunbathing. John finally prepared and uses her narcoleptic episodes to fuck. He's considerate and uses a condom. It breaks and breeds Jade anyways.

It's frustrating that the gist is literally what I've said goes for me (somno, condom breaking in the heat of the moment, breeding) but I'm still not feeling it. Believe it or not, but I'm not a JohnJade shipper, people just commission it from me because I'm agreeable to incest pairs.

And ah, beach sex, the bane of my existence when looking for Soriku fics.

Final Score: Sand In Pussy/10

[kinkmom]

So, I've thought about a prompt: A fucked up Bro who kills people returning to the Strilonde hometown (in my au, it's called Thornhill, Texas) and the only one remaining is our dear Rose. They get close and Bro eventually noncons her, but she ends up enjoying it and coming back for more. They play a dangerous game of "will he won't he" until one day, Bro let's slip the big "I love you" when they're fucking and instead of pushing him away, Rose returns the sentiment. All I'm saying? Murder husband and his equally deranged murder wife.

Thoughts?

I take a little issue calling it a prompt when sending it to me, I don't take prompts. I might at times humor requests if I can get something fun out of them. But sure, thoughts.

I'm not a fan of BroRose noncon, it's in a weird spot for me where I prefer femdom instead. Murder partnership is a classic though, nothing wrong with that. I'm sure there is some delightful tension in the AU but it doesn't really come across in a short summary like this. How do they get close? What sparks the rape? Does Bro plan it or is it in the heat of the moment kind of thing? Did he intend to murder her but decides he likes her too much? Does he just leave her or do aftercare? What does Rose do or feel afterwards? Why does she feel the need to get back to him? Why would she even consider pushing him away if she voluntarily fucks him anyway? What makes her the deranged murder wife, was she already secretly fucked up? ...and where did the other Strilondes go??

Then there's the "ends up enjoying it" part. Like, right away? I personally don't like noncon that's enjoyable for the victim, especially the first time, it really defeats the purpose. The long term Stockholm syndrome is the fun part, I'm a sucker for slow burn.

Also I'm a little concerned about the relatedness, please don't say he's supposed to be her dad.

Final Score: 5/10

There's potential and I feel like the presentation created more questions for me than answers.

[kinkmom]

alpha dave but rockstar by nickleback? he makes a deal with the devil for fame- and of course, that comes with enough power to get the whole band to submit to his will- even his particularly defiant twin sister and ex-best-friend rose lalonde.

Huh. This one sounds like it has some Lore that's not coming through in such a short message. Being a rockstar, okay, I get that part, I dig it. A deal with the devil? A falling out with Rose? "Defiant"? What is going on? ;;

The song's got pretty sexy lyrics though. :]