I wanna fuck ghostface so hard that he blacks out or passed out from the sheer feeling of pleasure and pain. 😭😭😭
Hell yeah. Same thoughts. 18+ TOP READER
Ghostface’s knees buckled, his legs consistently trembling while his hands scrambled around the mattress for purchase. The cheek of his mask was firmly planted against the sheets, finding himself unable to look back at you without interrupting himself.
“Oh God! Oh God—hnngh, right there!”
He punched out a moan, relishing in the way your thick cock ruthlessly carves an imprint on his slick-graced walls. His feet were on the ground, his upper half on the bed, and his ass raised to you. Your hands gripped his hips, forcibly prompting him to fuck himself back on your dick in time with your thrusts.
“Yeah? Right here?” You ask, pulling out enough to allow him to feel the threat of you leaving his entrance before you roughly bottom out and hit his sweet spot, earning yourself a high whine. One of your hands reach up, grasping his nape and pushing him down. Making him take it.
Ghostface can barely breathe, weak gasps barely managing to leave his agape mouth. You were fucking him like you hated him, his obscured face uncomfortably digging harder into the soft bedspread.
It hurt. Hurt so good.
Your hips were meeting with his backside with audible smacks, accompanied by a force that’ll surely cause him to become terribly sore. He clenches around your cock with a whimper, heat rushing to his gut, a climax rapidly approaching him.
It was dizzying. It was electrifying, and he was so horny. The killer groans out, long and broken, his mind momentarily numbing. He’s so close, his wet dick beginning to throb, and he can feel himself right—
Ghostface suddenly becomes limp, his hips subconsciously bucking forward as his pretty slit spits out his messy release.
feat. Billy Loomis & Stu Macher
ᯓ★ Who’s scared of a little blood? Certainly not these ghostfaces.
warnings! : NSFW 18+, fem!reader, canon divergence, ghostface!reader, violence, murder, very long intro whoops, groping (consensual), a lot of blood, unsanitary sex, sexual acts with blood, licking at wounds, they are not as concerned about their wounds as they should be, unrealistic wounds, dirty talk, wound fingering (I WARNED YOU), vaginal fingering, cunnilingus, blood as lube, unsafe sex, blowjob, deepthroating, cum swallowing, spitroasting, billy x stu action, you go to paris wink wink, creampie
ᯓ★ kinktober m.list || read on ao3
“Fuck you both!”
The door slams shut, the faint sound of Randy shouting and banging on it muffled, and you take that as your cue to boast your acting chops until the final confrontation.
“Sid?” You run your hands over your temple, the fake blood staining your fingertips. “The fuck happened?”
She cries out your name, running over to you and kneeling as you wince. “You’re alive!”
You let your eyes flutter open, just enough to meet hers. They were wide with shock and bloodshot from her tears. You know that look. You’ve seen it before. It’s the same one she gave Billy when she thought he was dead. And just like that, the power shifts. You fight back a smirk, knowing you have her in the palm of your hand.
“I—I thought they got you,” Sidney whispers, hand brushing over your fake wound with shaking fingers. She’s too amped up to notice there’s no actual cut present. “There was so much blood…”
You lean into her touch, giving her a weak, trembling smile. “I don’t know what happened. He just…came out of nowhere. I tried to fight back. Didn’t do much good.”
She swallows hard. Her eyes dart back to the door where Randy is still banging. “We need to get out of here. Now.”
You nod, wincing dramatically as you push yourself up. Every move is calculated, every flinch carefully rehearsed. You let her help you to your feet. She’s too distracted, too emotional to notice the knife tucked just under your shirt, itching to spill some blood.
Sidney grabs your hand, guiding you toward the kitchen. “Come on, we have to get out of here.” She brandishes her gun, and your eyes narrow. “We might have a chance.”
Before you can get any further, a loud thunk sounds from the top of the staircase.
Sidney gasps. “Billy!”
Billy is hunched over the railing, clutching his fake wound as he stumbles down the stairs, Sidney abandoning your side to rush over to him.
“I thought—”
“I’m fine.” He brushes her off with a pat on the shoulder. “Gotta get help.”
You chuckle weakly. “Knew you couldn’t be put down that easily.”
As he passes, heading towards the door, you share a silent smirk and a dark glint of excitement lights in his eyes.
Randy is still banging on the door, shouting to be let in.
“Wait!” Sidney stops Billy with a hand on his chest. “It’s not safe.”
Billy pauses for a moment. “It’s okay. Give me the gun.”
Sidney hesitates, her hand clenching tighter around the gun as her eyes dart down to the weapon and back up to Billy.
“Do it, Sid,” you coax, rubbing your hand on her arm. “You trust him, right?”
Sidney swallows hard, then nods, shaky hand outstretched with the gun. Billy snatches it and opens the door, met with Randy who has shock plastered all over his face.
He rushes in, grabbing Billy by the shirt. “Dude, you gotta help me. Stu’s gone mad.”
Billy pauses. His eyes light up with a vicious gleam, and you know it’s finally time for the big reveal.
“We all go a little mad sometimes.”
He points the gun at Randy’s head and fires.
Randy falls to the floor with a thud as Billy laughs. “Anthony Perkins. Psycho.”
Sidney looks absolutely shell shocked, hands quivering as she frantically surveys the scene, looking for an escape.
You continue playing your part. “Sid, the kitchen!” She tugs you through the house, but you’re both stopped as you run into Stu’s chest. He grabs you out of Sidney’s hands and pulls you to his chest, smirking into your neck.
“Where do you think you’re going?” His hands wander your body shamelessly as Sidney stares in shock, her eyes flicking between the two guys as she finally puts the pieces together.
You gasp as Stu squeezes your breast and you try your hardest not to lean into his touch—the touch that you desperately missed when you all were planning out this murdering spree.
Sidney narrows her eyes. “Let her go, you fucking asshole!”
Billy comes in behind Sidney, flaunting the gun as he blocks the entryway. The plan was in motion. She had nowhere to go.
“Sid…” you start, keeping your voice low and hesitant. But seeing her terrified face has you blowing your cover. You giggle, a smile forming across your lips. “I’m exactly where I want to be.”
You reach your hands back and fiddle with Stu’s pockets to the voice changer.
Sidney looks at you, confused and cautious. “What are you doing?”
You raise the compact phone to your lips, clicking the button to activate it. “Dropping the act.”
She stares at you, her face slowly twisting from confusion to horror. “No…”
You take a step closer. “Yeah.”
Billy’s laugh echoes throughout the room as Stu’s grin widens.
Sidney backs up toward the island, trying to put some distance between herself and the three of you, to no avail. Her eyes dart around the kitchen. “Why? Why would you—?”
“Why?” You tilt your head. “Because watching you run around like a clueless final girl has been hilarious. But mostly?” You shrug. “Because I wanted in on the fun. And Billy and Stu…well, let’s just say we all realized we don’t mind sharing.”
Sidney's eyes widen as she stumbles back in disbelief, shaking her head. “You’re messing with me.”
You grin wider. Billy chuckles darkly, stepping closer to her.
“She’s not lying, Sid. Pretty good actress, huh? Almost had me fooled until I saw the complete joy on her face after getting all messy from Himbry’s blood.”
Stu bounces on his heels, unable to contain his excitement.
“Yeah, she’s awesome, Sid! I mean—plot twist, right? Two killers is something, but a third? And it’s a hot chick? Totally insane!”
You glance at him with an amused smirk. “Told you I’d be a fun addition.”
Billy eyes you with that intense, half-possessed stare of his. “You really sold the whole ‘concerned friend’ thing. Even had me wondering whose side you were on for a second. Real. Impressive.”
“Why, thank you. I’ve always wanted to be a scene-stealer.” You give a playful little bow.
Sidney looks between the three of you and her face drains of color, betrayal written in every line. “I trusted you,” she says to you, her voice cracking. “You were my friend.”
You shrug, almost sympathetically. “I know. That’s what made it so easy.”
“You’re psychos!” She sneers. She reaches behind her to grab a knife, unbeknownst to the three of you who are too occupied with your premature celebration.
Stu cackles, coming up behind you and resting his head atop yours. “Hear that, babe?” He lowers his head, licking your neck and stopping at your ear. “We're psychos!”
Billy leans against the doorframe, cocking his head and giving you a nod, one that tells you that he’s giving you the go-ahead. “You know how the story ends, Sid. Only this time, we made a few edits.”
“Fuck you!” Sidney lunges at you, taking you by surprise which allows her to slice at your arm that you held up in defense.
The blade cuts deep, a sharp, white-hot pain flaring up your arm. Blood blossoms instantly, warm and sticky, but adrenaline dulls most of the pain.
You scream with rage, lashing out with your own knife. The metal flashes in the light, catching her side, just enough to make her stumble back with a grunt.
“You fucking bitch! You’re dead, you hear me?” you snarl.
Stu steps in with a crazed laugh, still too high on the moment to register danger. “Whoa—Sid’s got claws! Let’s see what else she can do!” he grins, moving toward her—only to catch a wild elbow to the jaw that sends him reeling back into the kitchen island. He hits the marble edge with a sickening crack, groaning as he slides down, dazed and bleeding.
“Stu!” Billy’s voice cuts through the chaos, but you nor Sidney pay them any attention.
Instead Sidney charges you again, but this time you’re prepared. You sidestep, twisting your injured arm behind you and driving your knee into her stomach. She doubles over with a breathless wheeze but grabs your wrist as you try to bring the knife down, managing to slice a shallow cut at your stomach before you’re able to tear the knife out of her grasp and toss it across the room.
“You’re not gonna win this,” she hisses, coughing up some blood into your face.
Before you can answer, Billy is suddenly behind her, grabbing a fistful of her hair and yanking her backward. She screams, thrashing in his grip. He slams her into the wall, pinning her arms.
“Hold her!” you snap, limping toward them, every step slick with the blood that has trailed down your arm and onto the floor.
“Got her,” Billy grunts through clenched teeth, his face inches from hers. “Say goodnight, Sid.”
You stop just short of her, panting, injured arm holding at your stomach while the other grips the knife with a trembling hand. Blood drips from your fingers, making your grasp slippery. Sidney glares up at you, defiant even now.
“You could’ve just died quiet,” you mutter, eyes flicking down to the knife in your hand.
“Go to hell,” she spits.
You smile thinly. “Already there.” You raise the blade.
“Time to rewrite this ending.”
And bring it down.
The knife slices cleanly across her throat, blood spurting out and hitting you in the face. You laugh as Billy releases her and her body collapses below you in an unflattering heap, crimson blood pooling around her and staining your shoes.
“Holy fuck,” you hear him utter.
The next thing you know, Billy is kissing you.
His hand holds the back of your head with an iron grip, forcing you to remain in his embrace. He presses himself against you, and you feel the hardness of his cock rub against your stomach as his tongue enters your mouth. The unmistakable metallic taste of blood invades your senses and fuels you on, your hands tightly gripping his shirt. Blood from your wound stains the white material, soaking it further but you pay it little mind.
Billy pulls away, and you get a look at the blood that smears his face that was transferred from you. He swipes at some on your cheek with his thumb and sucks on it, all without breaking eye contact. You inhale deeply, the sight stirring up a fire in your gut.
“Yeah? You like all the blood?” Billy pulls you forward with your injured arm, holding it up as he watches the blood drip down it from your cut. Leaning forward, he licks at the dribbling liquid from elbow to forearm, catching most of the flowing blood. You bite back a moan as you keep your eyes trained on Billy, who licks at your skin like a dog who hasn’t drank in days.
“Get’s me all excited, too,” he murmurs against your skin.
Your fingers curl into his shirt as you pull him forward, capturing your lips with his again. Taking the lead this time, you push your tongue into his mouth, shoving more of the blood on your lips into his. He groans and hikes up one of your legs to rest around his waist, pushing you forward until your back hits the wall.
You kiss with vigor, breathing each other in with no care in the world, as if there isn’t a dead body right below your feet. Billy’s arm wraps around your waist, pulling your lower half closer to him so that his clothed cock can grind against your own arousal. His fingers brush against your sliced side, and you inhale sharply, the touch sending shockwaves through your system.
“Touch it,” you moan against his lips between kisses. “My stomach.” Your body is on fire, arousal burning brightly and coursing through your veins.
Billy laughs sharply, and his grin widens as you mewl and arch into him when his fingers ghost over your wound again.
“Dirty girl,” he whispers in his ear. “Knew you’d be perfect for this.”
His lips drop to your neck, where he begins to kiss and suck at the skin, no doubt leaving hickeys in his wake. His fingers begin to poke and prod at the wound, as if testing your reactions before fully committing. You gasp and melt into him, your hips bucking into his hardened member the more he plays with the injured skin.
You yelp and clutch onto him as his fingers finally penetrate the wound. He pistons them carefully, feeling around with purpose, acting as if he were fingering your pussy. You hear the squelching of the blood and instead of grossing you out, it only turns you on more.
Stu groans from behind Billy, finally coming to. “You doing freaky shit without me?” You crane your neck around as he begins to pull himself up using the kitchen island for stability. He rubs at the back of his head and you notice the blood on his palm as he does so. There’s blood dripping down his face and neck, coming from his nose, most likely broken from Sidney’s elbow earlier.
He blinks seeing you two across the room, looking seconds away from stripping all your clothes off and fucking.
Hearing his voice, Billy shifts to turn towards Stu, and the movement exposes the way his fingers are sunken into your stomach wound.
Stu’s jaw drops just a little in awe at the sight. “Oh hell yeah.”
Stu comes up behind Billy grabbing on his waist and watching the steady flow of blood pool out of you as Billy’s fingers. By the way his hands tighten around Bill’s waist, you’re almost positive that he’s already hard and making it Billy’s problem. The thought has you giggling to yourself.
“Aw man,” Stu pouts, watching you and Billy grind against each other. Billy’s fingers are still occupied with your stomach. “I’m feeling a little left out here. I wanna finger her too.”
Billy rolls his eyes. “You can finger her pussy, dude,” he says without skipping a beat.
“Oh.” Stu giggles. “Right.”
He kneels down and pulls your pants and underwear down in one fell swoop. A soft squeak escapes from you as the cool air hits you unexpectedly, and your walls flutter as Stu’s fingers trail over your pussy.
“You’re so wet.” He begins to tease your entrance, his long fingers brushing along it before retreating. You whine at the loss, both him and Billy smirking. You soak his fingers when he finally pushes them back inside of you, curling up and hitting spots that have you mewling.
“Fuck,” you moan, your voice pitching higher and your breath coming out in hitched inhales. Billy smirks, aware of that being your tell when you’re about to cum.
“Shit, Stu.” Billy carries on with fingering your wound, his cock jumping at each gasp when they hit a new spot. “Pull my pants down, man.”
You whine when Stu’s fingers leave you, preventing your orgasm with it. He hastily undoes Billy’s jeans, pulling them down alongside his underwear. His cock springs free, the throbbing tip hitting your stomach.
“All nice and ready for you,” Stu says. His fingers spread open your pussy lips and your walls flutter as if begging to be filled.
“Fuck yeah,” Billy grunts. His bloodied fingers leave your wound and wrap around his cock, lubing himself up with your blood. Your chest heaves with need at the sight, your body unconsciously arching into his touch.
He lines yourself up with your entrance, seconds away from entering you before Stu pushes him back with a hand.
“Wait, wait!”
Billy huffs and mutters out a quick what now as Stu bends over and licks along your slit, blood on his tongue from his nosebleed acting as an additional lubricant for your already aroused entrance. Your hand flies down to tug at his hair, holding him securely in place as his tongue fucks into you.
“There we go.” He pulls away, his face covered in your juices and smeared blood. “Let’s get you into position.”
His large hand sprawls across the back of your neck, and he grips you as he turns you around and bends you over, face to him and your ass out to Billy. You settle on your knees and you’re eye level with his boner that strains against the front of his jeans.
You glance up at him, seeing his maniacal grin widen and his cock jump as he stares down at you, a hungry gleam in his eye.
“Now she’s ready.”
Billy laughs, rolling his eyes playfully. “Thanks man.”
His hands tighten around your waist and you gasp as he spears his cock into you, the force of it shoving your face straight into Stu’s bulge.
“Shit,” Stu groans. His hand reaches for the nape of your neck, pushing you against him. He fumbles with his belt for a bit as he manhandles you, subtly grinding his bulge into your cheek, the rough denim scratching at your skin.
Your breath comes out in short huffs as Billy ruts into you, the blood allowing him to easily slide inside of your aching pussy. Your walls stretch around him, tightening around his member as he buries himself inside of you.
“Open wide,” Stu quips, giving you no time to prepare as he shoves his cock inside of your mouth.
You cough around his cock, tears welling in your eyes as he begins thrusting mercilessly. His head flies back with a groan. “Yeah, that’s the stuff.”
From behind you, Billy’s rhythm remains as sturdy as ever, each hard thrust shoving you further down onto Stu’s cock.
He palms a handful of your ass before piping up. “Seeing you fight like that—” his words are interrupted by grunts as he fucks deep into you. “Looking all hot while covered in blood, God, I wanted to take you right then.”
You let out a faint moan of appreciation, unable to do anything more as you gag on Stu’s cock shoved down your throat.
“Keep making her do that, dude,” Stu says, his voice laced with pleasure, “feels real good around me.”
Billy continues to ramble. “When you stabbed Himbry, almost came in my pants.” He chuckles, remembering the way you brazenly killed the man, not a single bone of remorse to be found, but rather newfound excitement and exhilaration exuding from your figure.
“Yeah,” Stu chuckles, chiming in. “I definitely creamed them when you gutted Steve.”
You roll your eyes and Stu’s hold on you finally loosens slightly as he talks, allowing you to let up for air. “Glad I could add to your spank bank.”
You’re pulled back onto Stu’s cock, gagging around the long member as he fills every crevice of your mouth. “Babe, you are the spank bank.”
Billy huffs in amusement, his hands tightening around you as he shifts to get a better angle, pushing your stomach down and arching your ass up more. The new angle has him fucking you even deeper than before, and you moan around Stu.
“Stu, man, you’re dripping all over her.” You don’t even realize what Billy means until you feel another drop of blood land in your scalp, courtesy of Stu’s nosebleed.
“Oh shit.” Stu apologizes, but the mirth in his tone tells you that he’s anything but.
“No, don’t need to do that.” Billy responds, acting as if the apology was meant for him instead of you. You can practically hear the smirk in his voice. “It’s hot.”
Both guys thrust into you harder, spurned on by their brief conversation.
“Come here,” Billy says, and you feel the both of them leaning in over you.
Suddenly you hear the wet, sloppy sounds of Billy and Stu making out above you, a new wave of heat surging through your body as your pussy clenches at the sound. You wish you could see them, but each of them has an iron grip on you, preventing you from moving an inch.
As they each groan into the kiss, you feel Stu’s cock throb harshly in your mouth. You breathe in deeply through your nose, allowing yourself some semblance of air before deep throating his cock, trying your best to ignore your gag reflex.
Stu’s hips jerk irregularly, and the next thing you know you’re practically choking on his cum as he releases into you without warning, thick spurts entering your mouth. You swallow it in small amounts, but the taste of it continues to linger.
When they finally part, Stu giggles. “You taste like blood, man.”
“Nah,” Billy replies, “that’s from you.”
Your pussy squeezes tighter around Billy, enough so that he notices it this time. “I think she liked that too,” he points out, tone dripping with an air of smugness.
“Oh really?” Stu teases. His hands bury themselves into your scalp, pulling you off his cock and hoisting you up off the ground. Your frontside is practically soaked in the blood from the carnage around you, put you pay it little mind.
“Want a taste?” Stu asks, grinning widely, his teeth stained red from the blood.
You nod immediately, whimpers caught in your throat as Billy ruts into you from behind.
“Damn.” Billy winces in mock sympathy. “Doesn’t seem like she really wants it that much. Sorry, man.”
“Please!” You finally cry out. “I want to taste it.”
“There we go!” Billy shouts, slapping your ass as you gasp. “Kiss her, Stu.”
Stu obeys, tugging you towards him and slamming his lips against yours. The smell is familiar from when Billy kisses you earlier, but the heat of his kiss is different than the one with Stu’s. Stu is playful with it, his tongue flicking out to tease rather than to prove a point. He slides it into your mouth, probing the bloody appendage all around. You suck on it, relishing in the metallic taste of the blood. It invades all your senses, bringing you a type of pleasure you never really knew existed until this very moment.
As you and Stu battle with your tongues, blood and cum being passed between each other, you feel as Billy’s hand begins to coil around your front, leading all the way up to your stomach. A rush of heat floods your system as you bring one of your hands over it, almost as if to lead him to exactly where you want it to end up.
His fingers delicately trace the sliced skin of your open wound, so gently it almost feels as though he’s mocking you. Your hand hovers over his, following the movement so closely as if you were doing it yourself.
When his fingers finally enter it, you feel as though you’ve entered heaven, and you never want to leave. Practically all of your orifices are filled, each experiencing a different kind of pleasure that you’ve never had before.
With only a couple more thrusts your long awaited orgasm finally hits you, sending you over the edge with a shattered moan into Stu’s mouth. Your hands tangle themselves into Stu’s messy, blood-soaked hair and your body goes weak as you feel your juices rush out of you, soaking Billy’s cock.
Your legs go limp as you continue to cum, both men holding you up as they continue their ministrations.
Reaching down to tug on Stu’s cock, having already hardened again after his first orgasm, you feel yourself clench weakly around Billy’s member that continues rutting into you. Both actions are enough to make them each cum, a startled gasp leaving you as they fill you up with their releases.
Billy fucks you through his orgasm, the loud squelching courtesy of the blood and cum mixture filling the room.
When he finally lets go of you, fingers removing themselves from your wound and hands unlatching from their death grip on your waist, you pant heavily as you pull away from the two of them. You collapse onto the ground, uncaring about the pools of blood that will no doubt stain your bottom. You’re already covered head to toe in blood, a mix of your own, Stu’s and Sidney’s—what’s a little more?
Sidney’s body lays unmoving, eyes unblinking and skin paler than it was minutes ago.
Stu collapses next to you, holding a hand up to his nose. “Man, it’s really starting to hurt now,” he whimpers, wincing with every touch.
You give him a feeble yet comforting pat to the knee, your other hand holding onto your wounded side. “Tell me about it,” you mutter to yourself.
Billy is quiet, drawing his pants back up and sucking some blood off of his fingers, surveying the bloodied scene before him. He hums thoughtfully, smiling to himself.
He kneels down on the other side of you. “Beautiful handiwork,” he muses in your ear. “We’ve got a true artist in our midst.”
You chuckle weakly, your voice rasping from its earlier intrusions. “What now?”
Billy gives you a smirk that’s all wrapped up in confidence and amusement.
Summary: after a long day, you and stu went to the thrift store, although you didn't stay very long and ended up back at his place.
Stu macher x fem!reader
notes/warnings: semi-public, oral (fem receiving) teasing/bratty Dom!Stu, overstimulation, handsy, mirror use slightly, dirty talk, power dynamic, rough sex, hair pulling, light choking, possessiveness, praise kink, shower sex, fingering, p in v, clingy stu, aftercare. Just basically porn with little plot! Not proofread. lil off character Stu, but it's fine, It was fun. :)
Words: 5215
The bell over the door jingled as you stepped into the thrift store, your eyes lighting up at the racks of clothes. The thrift store smelled faintly like old wood and worn denim, dust and faded perfume, the kind of place with more potential than organization. Racks of mismatched clothes surrounded you, and the broken speakers overhead buzzed with some old song playing low in the background. You were in your element, browsing, flipping through hangers, already holding two oversized flannels and a soft-looking sweater over one arm.
Stu? Not so much.
He trailed behind you with all the patience of a kid on a sugar crash, his arms swinging lazily at his sides. But unlike a bored boyfriend, Stu didn't know how not to touch. His fingers brushed the hem of your shirt when you reached overhead. His palm pressed low across your back when you moved to another rack. When you stopped to compare the sleeves of two jackets, he took the opportunity to slide up behind you, nudging your hips with his lazily.
“God this place is a gold mine,”
“Looks like a gold mine for your ass, babe.” stu muttered, pressing a hand against the small of your back, then lower, until his palm cupped you through your skirt. You swatted his hand. “Stop it.”
“I am helping. Feelin’ for texture,” he teases, leaning close enough that you could hear the smirk in his voice. “Might need to try this one on…in private.” you gave him a quick glare over your shoulder, but you were too distracted flipping through a pair of jeans to stop him when his hands slid around your waist. He pressed himself behind you, resting his chin on your shoulder, swaying you both slowly with the music playing in the background. His fingers slipped under the hem of your sweater, just barely tracing the skin of your stomach.
You were mid sentence about color palettes when you felt his hand squeeze your ass, casual as anything. And his other breaks the band of your skirt.
“Stu,” you warned under your breath, swatting his hand away without even turning. “Stop.”
“What? Just seeing if these pants have…uh…” he asked, voice lower than necessary. “Stretch.”
“Yeah right, you idiot.”
He snorted and backed off only slightly, but you could still feel his gaze tracking every movement you made as you grabbed a few pieces off the rack adding to the pile you were going to take to the dressing room. You pulled a corduroy skirt from the rack and held it against your waist, inspecting the length in a nearby mirror. He leaned against the wall behind you, watching. “Cute. Bet it looks better off.”
You ignored him. He didn't stop touching you the entire way through the racks, hips bumping yours, fingers brushing the top of your thigh, a palm at the base of your spine that stayed just a little too long.
He moved again, closer this time when you stopped when something caught your eye. When you reached for the hanger, his hand brushed against your bare hip, just under your shirt. His thumb dragged slowly along the waistband of your skirt. You stiffened, but he just leaned in and murmured.
“Can I help you change?”
“Not a chance.”
He grinned. “I'm really good with zippers. Come on, babe. Let me supervise.”
“No.”
“I could just hold the hangers…”
You turned, pressing the armful of clothes into his chest. “You wanna be helpful? Carry these.”
He made a dramatic groan but took them anyway, following you toward the dressing room like a dog on a leash.
“You better stay out here.”
“Mhm. Sure thing, babe.”
When you slipped behind the curtain, he waited a beat…and then you heard it, the soft scrape of rings against fabric. And suddenly, he was in there with you, eyes already dark with mischief.
“Stu-!”
“Shhh,” he pulled the curtain shut behind him, pressing a finger to your lips. “Public place. Try to keep it down.”
“Were in public.” you said. He looked around the tiny dressing room like he was judging it. “Barely.”
Your jaw dropped. “Get out!”
Your mouth opened to scold him again, but he was already pressing close, hands grabbing your hips and spinning you gently around, “Nah. I think I'll stay. You looked way too hot flipping through those sweaters. Got me thinking.” he said, already closing the space between your body and the full length mirror behind you. The tiny room felt smaller with him inside it. His presence swallowed it whole. You gasped softly when he did so, one palm on the glass beside your head, the other slipping down your thigh again. “Thinking what, exactly?”
Roaming his hands everywhere, one large hand settled at your hip. The other slid beneath your sweater, fingers brushing bare skin, nails grazing lightly. “That maybe you should try something else on.” he whispered, and kissed your neck slowly. “Like my mouth.”
“I was shopping.”
“And I was watching. So technically, we were both doing our favorite things.”
You shoved at his chest, but he didn't budge, lips catching the side of your neck again.
“Bet no one even comes back here.”
“Get out-”
“Nope.”
And then he sank to his knees like it was the most natural thing in the world.
Your breath caught. “Stu-” you whispered, panicked, but your thighs tensed when his hands slid up under your skirt. His fingers were tugging your skirt up, bunching it at your hips as he looked up at you, tongue wetting his lips, pupils blown wide. “Gimme a taste,” he muttered. “Swear i'll be good.” he whispered, dragging your panties down in one smooth motion, lips brushing your skin the whole way up.
He did not stay good.
He kissed the inside of your thigh like it was routine, like this was a normal thursday afternoon. His tongue dragged slowly over your skin as he nudged your legs apart, lifting one onto the bench for better access. Your panties hit the floor. Cold air kissed your skin.
Then he leaned in, and nothing was cold anymore.
He moaned as soon as he tasted you, loud enough that your hand flew to slap his head in panic and then over your own mouth at the same time. “Shh!” you hissed. But he didn't care. If anything, it spurred him on, he just smirked against you, devouring like he didn't hear a thing. His mouth was messy, open, tongue flattening and curling with fast, filthy strokes. He devoured you with no restraint, like he needed it.
His tongue was fast, eager, curling and storking in ways that had you shaking almost immediately. The cramped room, the distant murmur of shoppers outside, the mirror rattling behind you every time your back shifted, all of it felt surreal and dangerous, and so good. Your fingers dug into his hair, your legs quivering around his shoulders.
You struggled to keep quiet. The dressing room floor creaked under the shift of your weight. The mirror behind you clattered softly as your back pressed into it. One of your hands gripped his hair, the other white knuckled around the edge of the wall.
“Fuck…Stu-” you breathed out, already trembling.
He didn't let up. He groaned into you, and the vibrations made you clench. His hand splayed across your thighs to keep them spread open wider as he fucked you with his mouth, his other hand slipping up to tease at your enterance while his mouth stayed locked on your clit teasing you in little cirlces while his tongue worked lower, slow, then fast, switching patterns right as your knees buckled. He knew what he was doing, and he loved that you were struggling to stay quiet.
Then someone walked by just outside.
Your heart stopped, but Stu didn't even flinch, he groaned into you, like the risk only made it better. His fingers slid in slow and deep, his tongue flicking in quick circles now, building your orgasm with maddening precision.
You were close, embarrassingly fast, but it wasn't your fault. He was relentless. Loving the way you struggled to stay silent. His tongue flicked just right, and suddenly your whole body locked up. You felt the pressure burst like lightning, your body twitching as the wave hit you hard, heat blooming low in your stomach and tearing through every limb. Your body pressing into the mirror as waves of heat rolled through you. You bit down on your fist to muffle the whimper that almost escaped. You nearly knocked over the bench trying not to cry out.
Stu kept going, he held you, licking you through it, tongue lapping up everything, fingers still stroking slow, moaning softly like he was enjoying every second of your aftershocks. He only pulled back when your legs were shaking too much to stay standing.
When he stood, his mouth was wet, his chin glistening, his expression smug as hell like he just won a prize at the fair, wiping his mouth with the back of his hand and licking the rest off his lips.
“Y’know,” he said, breathless, “I deserve an employee discount for that.”
You were still trying to breathe.
He reached for your sweater, smoothing it down with infuriating care, even tucking your panties into your purse like some twisted trophy. Then he kissed your cheek like nothing had happened.
“Wanna head back to mine?” he asked casually. “I think I forgot what your scream sounds like.”
You stared at him, flushed, ruined.
“Let's go.”
He grinned wide. “Atta girl.”
You barely made it out of the thrift store without crumbling. He had that look in his eye, like he wanted to finish what he started right there in the parking lot. You didn't trust him to behave, but the fastest way out was to get behind the wheel and drive. So that's what you did.
Big mistake.
Not even two minutes into the ride, he already had his seat leaned back, one arm draped over the headrest behind you, the other resting on your thigh like it belonged there. His fingers were not still. They traced slow, lazy patterns over the inside of your leg, dipping higher with every red light.
“Y’know,” he murmured, his voice pitched low and husky, lips dangerously close to your ear, “you should get an award or something.”
You glanced at him, tense. “For what?”
“Walking out of that dressing room without begging me to fuck you in from of the flannel section.” his fingers slipped higher. “Real restraint. I'm impressed.”
You gritted your teeth, eyes back on the road. “Hands to yourself.”
He laughed quietly. “Nope.”
He let his fingers dip between your legs, over the fabric of your skirt. You clenched your thighs reflexively and that only made him grin wider. “Sensitive still?” he whispered, his lips ghosting over your cheek. “God, you were shaking. Could feel it in my mouth.”
Your grip on the steering wheel tightened. “Stu…seriously.”
“I am serious,” he said, dragging his fingers slowly up your thighs again. “Serious about how fuckin’ good you taste. Serious about how I can still smell you on my face. Wanna crawl into your lap and finish what I started.”
“While I'm driving?”
“Wouldn't be the first time I made someone swerve off the road.”
You shot him a warning glare. He smirked, leaning in closer, and kissed just below your ear, soft, wet, and intentionally slow. “I can be nice,” he whispered, voice gone silk and sin. “Wanna rub you just a little. Over your panties this time. Let you soak through another pair.”
You let out a slow, shaky breath, trying not to press your thighs together. “You already took them off in the dressing room.”
He paused.
“Oh fuck. That's right.” you could hear the grin in his voice.
“Thats so fucking hot,” he muttered, sliding his hand beneath the hem of your skirt again. “Driving with nothing under this pretty thing. All fucked out and flushed. You're gonna let me touch you, aren't you?”
You didn't answer, you knew what you were going to say anyways.
His fingers found bareskin, and you gasped, hips twitching slightly as he brushed over your slit, already warm, still sensitive. He groaned softly like he was the one being touched.
“Oh, baby.” he breathed. “Still dripping. Can't believe I didn't just bend you over the hood.”
You hit another red light, and his fingers took full advantage, circling your clit lightly, just enough to make your eyes flutter and your jaw clench. You jerked slightly in your seat. “Focus,” he teased. “You wouldn't want to crash.”
“Stu.”
“I'm being gentle.” he whispered, his lips grazing your neck. “Wait til we get home. Gonna ruin you on every surface I own.”
He dragged his fingers down again, slow and teasing. “I'm gonna make you scream so loud the cops show up.”
You groaned, exasperated and turned on and just barely keeping it together as you hit his street. He leaned back smugly. “You're soaked. Look at you.”
“Your fault.” you said, breathless, pulling into his driveway.
He undid his seatbelt with a little click and leaned in one last time. “Not yet,” he whispered in your ear, palm sliding possessively over your thigh again. “But it's about to be.”
You watched as he jumped out of the car and ran over to open your door and his hands back on you like they never left.
He yanked you toward the house, fingers laced tight in yours, walking backward with that crooked smirk like he was already planning five different ways to break you. “Get inside,” he muttered. “Right now. I'm done waiting.”
You weren't sure your legs were even working properly, your thighs still slick from what his fingers had done in the car, heat pulsing between them, your breath caught somewhere in your chest. The second the front door slammed shut behind you, it was on.
His hands grabbed at your waist, spinning you into the wall with a solid thump. His mouth was on you, wet, open, needy, kissing you like the car, the store, the dressing room hadn't been enough. Like he needed to devour you just to breathe.
“I've been hard since you picked up that first damn sweater.” he growled against your mouth. “Watching you bend over like you didn't know i was about to fuck you stupid.”
You gasped as he pushed his thigh between yours, grinding up into your still sensitive core. “Still wet for me?” he asked, voice all low heat and smug breathlessness. “Felt it soaking through the seat. You're a mess, baby. Look at you.”
You tried to say something, some kind of retort but your words melted into a moan when his hand slid under your skirt again, rough fingers pressing directly against your clit. “No panties still,” he whispered with a sharp grin, teeth grazing your jaw. “You came to my house like this?”
“I drove-”
“And I touched you the whole way.” he pulled back just enough to look you over, eyes blown and dark. “You should've pulled over and let me eat you out on the hood.”
You didn't have time to answer before he was dragging you toward the bedroom upstairs. The hallway blurred. Your clothes didn't survive the trip. He tugged your sweater over your head halfway through walking up the stairs, tossed it somewhere off the railing over a lamp. By the time you made it into his room, your skirt was hanging off one hip, your bra strap twisted down your arm, and he was already kicking the door shut behind him. His shirt hit the floor next then his belt.
He pushed you onto the bed, and you bounced once, catching yourself on your elbows as he climbed over you, taller, flushed, already rock hard through his jeans. “Lie back,” he ordered, voice rough and low. “Legs open.” you hesitated for half a breath. His head tilted. “You wanna be a good girl now, right? After teasing me all day?”
You dropped back, breathing shaky, and spread your legs for him. Stu groaned. Groaned. He knelt between your thighs, kissing the inside of your knee. “That's it. There she is” then his mouth was on you again.
He didn't ease in this time, he devoured. Sucked your clit into his mouth with a groan like he was starving, tongue flicking hard and fast. His fingers dug into your thighs to keep you still while he worked, and your entire body jolted with overstimulation.
“Fuck, stu-” you gasped, hips twitching. He moaned into you and kept going.
Your thighs shook as the pleasure ripped through you, your second orgasm of the night hitting fast, messy, almost too much. You writhed under his mouth, grabbing at the sheets, his hair, anything. When your voice broke on a gasp, he pulled back just slightly, his mouth wet and swollen, chin glistening, the smirk still firmly in place.
“You gonna pass out on me?” he whispered, teasing, draggin his fingers through your slick and rubbing slow, taunting circles over your clit. “That’d be so hot.”
You barely managed a dazed glare. “Oh, you're still with me?” he licked a stripe up your thigh. “Good. ‘Cause I'm not even close to done.”
He yanked open his jeans, shoved them down just far enough to free himself, and grabbed you, flipped you over effortlessly, dragging your hips up into the air and lining himself up without hesitation. And then he slammed into you. You let out a full broken scream into the mattress as he buried himself to the hilt in one thrust. “Oh fuck yes,” he moaned, already moving, pounding into you hard and fast. “You feel that? Feel me stretching you out? So fucking tight still, Jesus-”
The bed creaked beneath both of you, the headboard slamming once, twice, rhythm syncing with his thrusts. He wrapped his hand in your hair, pulled your head back, and growled right into your ear. “I want them to hear you, baby. No more quiet. No more holding back. Scream for me.”
You did.
You were so loud you barely heard your own name as he chanted it under his breath, over and over, like a prayer and a curse. His hand slid up around your throat, not tight, just grounding, and you thrived under it. He slammed into you harder, every stroke deeper, filthier. “You take it so fucking good. Look at you. My perfect little mess.”
He leaned forward, angling his hips just right, and you shattered.
You came with a sharp cry, eyes rolling back, your body shaking so violently your elbows gave out, he groaned deep, hips stuttering before he came right after you, hot and thick, grinding into you with a final thrust as he filled you, panting like he'd run a goddamn marathon. The room went still except for the sound of your ragged breathing. Then stu collapsed half on top of you, arm slung across your waist.
You both laid there, completely fucked out, skin sticky, chests rising and falling like you’d survived a war. After a long moment, he murmured, lips against your bare shoulder. “...Think they heard us?”
You huffed a weak laugh into the pillow. “If they don't, they’re deaf.”
He chuckled, breath still uneven. “I'll test that theory on round two.” you groaned and turned your head just enough to glare at him. He looked down at you, flushed, glowing, hair a wreck, and smiled like he'd never been more proud of anything in his life.
“Hey,” he whispered, brushing sweaty strands of hair from your face. “You okay?”
You nodded slowly, heart still racing. “Yeah. you?”
His grin widened. “Never better.”
The bedroom still pulsed with heat and the faint scent of sweat and sex when Stu pushed his face into the curve of your shoulder and murmured, “Come shower with me before I drag your ruined ass back into round one and call it round two.”
You were already limp beneath him, but the way he said it, low, raw, still riding the high, had your stomach clenching all over again.
Before you could answer, he was already pulling you upright, leading you toward the bathroom with that loose, hungry confidence in his stride. He didn't even check the water temp, just cranked the handle all the way to hot, steam filling the space before you stepped in. the moment the first cascade of heat hit your skin, stu was on you.
You barely had time to blink before your back hit the tile wall, cool contrast to the hot water pouring over your chest. His mouth crashed into yours, breath damp and open mouthed, tongue claiming your mouth like he had something to prove. Water streamed off his hair as it hung around his face, dripping onto your collarbone as he pressed every inch of his soaked body against yours.
“God, you taste like heaven,” he growled against your lips, licking your bottom one, then biting it gently. “Bet your whole body does right now. Let me check.”
You moaned as he dropped to his knees, right there in the tub, water hammering over his shoulders as he grabbed your hips and yanked you forward like he owned you. One leg was slung over his shoulder before you could brace yourself, and his mouth was back on your pussy like he'd missed it the second he pulled out of you earlier.
He groaned loud, loud enough to echo.
“Still so fucking sweet.” he muttered, tongue already flattening against your clit in long, practiced strokes. “You can't not be ready for me, huh? I ruin you once and your cunt’s still begging.”
You whimpered, bracing both hands against the slick wall behind you, struggling to stay upright. The steam made every inch of your skin hypersensitive, from the heat on your chest to the cold of the tile against your back to the maddening friction of his tongue. Stu ate like a man on death row, greedy, thorough and filthy. His lips latched around your clit, tongue flicking in a quick rhythm while one hand held your thigh and the other snuck up to rub slow, teasing circles around your entrance with the tip of his finger.
“You're gonna cum in my mouth again, aren't you?” he said between licks, voice shaking with heat. “You're gonna give it to me because you can't help it. So good. So fucking easy for me.”
You were shaking. The water rushed over you, hot and relentless, cascading down your breasts as your thighs trembled around his head. He slipped two fingers in without warning, thick, deep, curling perfectly, and your moan cracked apart as your back arched hard against the wall. “Stu-”
“I got you,” he whispered, lips slick against your clit. “Come for me, baby.” your orgasm hit like a wrecking wave, all consuming, toes curling, hand slamming against the tile for support. Your entire body jerked as the pleasure tore through you, liquid heat pouring down your spine and locking your thighs around his face. He moaned like it turned him on just as much and didn't stop until you were twitching from overstimulation, panting, drenched inside and out.
He stood slowly, kissing your stomach, your ribs, your collarbone, all the way back up to your lips. “Still alive?” he murmured against your mouth. You nodded weakly, and that's when he caught you in his arms, spun you, and pressed your front to the wall. “I'm not done.”
You gasped as he pressed his hips flush against your ass hard again, impossibly, achingly hard. He reached down, grabbed himself and dragged the head through your folds, groaning low. “Still so warm for me,” he muttered. “You're insane.”
“Youre the one that- fuck!”
He thrust in without warning, deep and hard, burying himself in one stroke and punching the breath out of you. His hands braced your hips as he started to move, rough, water slicking both your bodies with every stroke. He grabbed your wrists and pinned them against the wall above your head, mouth at your ear. “Take it,” he growled. “Fucking take it.”
You moaned for him, loud, the wet slap of your bodies bouncing off tile as he rutted into you like he wanted to carve the shape of his cock into your body. His rhythm was punishing, his breath hot against your neck. “Mine,” he gasped. “Mine. Say it.”
“Yours…yours- fuck, yes..”
He groaned, slamming in harder. “Cant ever let anyone else hear these sounds. You get that?”
You nodded, head banging lightly against the wall as he pushed you closer to the edge again, impossibly fast. His hand snuck down between your thighs, fingers fast and messy against your clit as he panted at your ear, body shaking with effort. “Come with me. Right now.”
Loud and unfiltered, full body tremors gripping you as the orgasm tore through you, walls fluttering around him. His own release hit a second later, with a strangled groan and one final, sloppy thrust that buried him as deep as you could take him. Both of you stood there, breathless, dripping, wrecked. The water kept running. Neither of you moved.
Finally, he collapsed against your back, forehead resting between your shoulder blades. “Next time,” he panted. “Im just going to fuck you in the car. No waiting.”
You laughed, ragged and wet, out of breath. “Next time,” you whispered, “I’m not letting you touch me in the store.”
He kissed the back of your neck. “You say that now…” then he slowly pulled out, gentle this time, and helped you turn around into his arms. He cradled you against his chest, both of you standing under the stream, the world outside fogged away in the thick curtain of steam and silence. For a few seconds, there was just breathing.
The water shut off with a cough of pipes and steam still curling around both of you like fog in a horror movie. Stu’s hand immediately slapped to the wall, his chest rising and falling like he'd just outrun something. You barely had the strength to move, but he already had the curtain pulled open and turned around to face you, grinning through wet bangs.
“Still standing?’ he asked, stepping out like a dripping menace. “Because I might need you to carry me if my legs stop working. I saw heaven for a second, no joke.”
You rolled your eyes and followed, bare feet hitting the bath mat just as he threw a towel around your shoulders. His hands immediately went to drying you off, but his version of ‘drying’ was mostly groping disguised as affection. “Oh my god, look at this.” he murmured, dragging the towel over your ass with slow fingers underneath. “Look at you. Fuckin’ glistening. Like some fresh outta the lake slasher babe. Like you just walked out of a scene where you survived and everyone else died because you were too hot.”
“Stu,” you warned, but your voice was weak.
He snorted. “What? I'm complimenting you. Jesus, don't punish me for having eyes.” he worked the towel down your legs, kneeling as he went, completely naked and not caring at all that his hair was dripping onto your thighs. When he stood, his hand dragged along your stomach on the way up, fingers brushing under your tits like it was accidental.
“You keep lookin’ at me like that, and I'm gonna make this a trilogy. You want a part three, final girl edition? Huh?” you didn't answer. He grinned. “Thought so.”
You reached for your clothes from earlier. He made a noise like you just stepped on a puppy. “Babe, no. Nooo. those are dead to me. Those clothes got thrift store stink and shame on them. You think I'm gonna let you walk around in that when I've got like-” he yanked open a drawer, “a whole drawer of oversized t-shirts that would look way hotter on you than me? No. put this on. Put this on right now.”
He threw a black shirt at you. It hit you in the face, you peeled it off, smirking. “What is this? Its got blood on it.”
“Yeah. Sexy, right?”
You pulled it over your head and it dropped down to your thighs. He stared like he forgot what words were. “I-” he blinked. “Nope. Nah. You… uh-uh. That's not allowed. You cannot be walking around in my shirt like…like that. Thats so fucked up. You trying to make me propose?”
You laughed. “Youd propose over a T-shirt?”
He looked you dead in the eyes. “If you look like that in my shirt, ill get on my fuckin’ knees.”
He followed you into the kitchen like a cursed man, barefoot, still damp, towel barely holding onto his hips, muttering nonsense under his breath while watching your legs as you walked. When you opened the fridge, he groaned behind you. “Dont bend over. Dont-oh, come on! You're doing that on purpose.”
“I'm literally grabbing a drink.”
“Yeah, and I'm grabbing your hips in two seconds.” hands planted firm on your waist as you stood, tugging you back into his chest. He nuzzled your neck like it was instinct. His fingers slid under the hem of the shirt, just brushing over the back of your thigh. He didn't even try to hide it. “Fuck, youre warm,” he muttered, voice low. “You smell like me. You're wearin’ my clothes. Im..babe.”
You snorted. “So no food, then?”
“Oh no, i'm starving,” he said, spinning you to pick you up and put you on the counter like it was nothing. “But I figured I'd feast on you first. Just a little taste. Starter course. Appetizer. Treat.”
You laughed as he pushed between your legs, his hands sliding up your thighs, thumbs dragging warm against your skin like he couldn't stop touching you. His face was all flushed, pink from the steam and exertion, hair curling as he leaned in close, his nose brushing yours.
“Im serious,” he whispered, barely. “You're not leavin’ tonight. Ill block the fuckin’ door. You're staying, and I'm waking up to you in this shirt tomorrow or I'm committing crimes.”
You whispered back, “Yeah?”
He nodded, “And if you're not still wearin’ it, you better be naked. Either way, i win.” he kissed you, hot, open mouthed, no hesitation, all teeth and tongue like he didn't know how to be gentle for longer than three seconds. When he finally broke the kiss, panting against your lips, he just stared at you. Still holding your thighs. Still pressed up between them. Still shaking a little from how badly he wanted to start again.
My friends walk in your direction / Said "Don't you know [...]?"
Huh / When did you get hot?
Overview: You've been the awkward friend forever. Always lingering in the background of Stu and Billy's lives, never quite fitting in with their other friends. But when their current girlfriends are tired of worrying about your relationship with their boyfriends, they offer you a makeover. You just hadn't thought it would have made Billy and Stu so angry.
Apparently, doing your makeup isn't very final girl behavior. Whatever that means...
a/n: absolutely playing into the “taking down her hair makes her hot” trope rn. Also, the reader has curly hair. For the sake of the plot. (and because I’m tired of not living my curly-haired truth)
Also, X2 Sid and Tatum are a bit OOC. I was in love with Tatum when I was younger, but for this, I need her to be a bit of a bitch. It’s for the plot people, I don’t make the rules
wc: 7.2K
more at: Belle’s 3k Extravaganza
You can already see Stu grinning as he watches you run up to the fountain. Billy's there waiting beside him, flipping through a book you doubt he has any interest in. Your chest heaves as you come to a stop, hands propped on your knees as you try to catch your breath.
Stu snorts, “What’d you run here?” he taunts, with that stupid voice he always uses.
“Shut up,” you grumble, dropping your bag to the ground and pulling out a folder. “Here,” you toss it at him. It slaps against his chest, and he lets out a little grunt, just barely catching it before it slips to the water.
He leafs through the papers inside, though you know he never actually bothers to proofread. Bored waiting for him to be done, you hold out your palm. He glances at it with a dumb look, "What?”
“Seriously,” you tilt your head and let out a scoff. “Do you think I’m doing this because I love you?”
Stu rolls his eyes and fishes his wallet from his pocket. You let out a triumphant hum as he slaps the cash in your palm. Trying to step back, you don't get very far before his wrist is snapping out, fingers wrapping around your arm as he tugs you back toward him. You stumble between his spread legs, shooting him an unamused look.
He only grins at your ire. “Come on,” he urges. “You love me, you can say it.”
You roll your eyes, but dip down to meet his stare. “All right. I love you, Stu.” His grin falls as you add, “Thank you for being my benevolent little rich boy.” Billy snorts and Stu shoots him a look. It’s enough of a distraction for you to slip from his hold and pick up your bag.
Good timing, too, considering Tatum’s walking up with Sid and Randy. Tatum’s certainly chiller compared to his other girlfriends. You get along with her more than you ever did with Casey. But you can’t imagine anyone would be happy to see their boyfriend all handsy with his best friend. Even if handsy seems to be Stu’s default state.
“Ooh, another illicit deal, I see,” Tatum makes herself cozy, dropping right into Stu’s lap. You force out a stiff laugh and make yourself look away.
You’re just friends with Stu, same as Billy. Have been since you were kids. To them, you’ll always just be the strange neighbor kid who never seemed to get out of that socially awkward phase.
But how you look in their eyes doesn’t change the fact that puberty hit you first. It doesn’t change that you haven’t been able to look at either of them as just friends since you discovered the difference between boys and girls.
However, based on their caliber of girlfriends, they couldn’t make it any clearer that there isn’t a chance in hell of anything ever happening.
“That’s seriously pathetic, Stu,” Sid teases. She can't hide the undercurrent of disapproval in her voice. “How long are you going to let her get you through school?”
Stu’s sharp eyes cut to yours and you feel heat bloom under your skin. “Well? How long are you gonna carry me?”
Scoffing, you move to take your place beside Randy. He immediately offers you some of his food, which you take just to have something to do with your hands.
“However long you keep paying, rich boy.”
Tatum and the others laugh a little, but you feel like you got the question wrong from the look Stu’s sending you. You’re not sure what you could have possibly said that he would have approved of. But you don’t think you’ll ever fully understand him or Billy.
You doubt anyone ever will.
Tatum turns her attention away from you, instead speaking across her boyfriend to discuss some gossip with Sid. It’s typical that you’re left out of the loop.
Something about you seems to scream that you’re above petty girlhood experiences. Given the chance, you'd have more dirt on the people at this school than they would ever know. People trip up around the quiet kids, always seeming to forget they're there until it's too late.
But, as much as Tatum and Sid are nice to you, you’re still an outlier. Someone they think belongs more to the boys. While the boys seem to think you’d do better with the girls. There’s no safe middle ground for you to stand on. You’re sure that if you didn’t show up for lunch tomorrow, the only thing that would change is who Stu pays for his homework.
Running a hand over your hair, you let out a tired sigh as you leaf through your book. “You know,” Tatum’s voice startles you from your stupor. You glance up to find her eyes narrowed on your hair. “That puffed-up look has been done to death.” She pops a grape in her mouth with a sharp grin. “It’s not the eighties anymore, sweetie.”
Your eyes widen, hands shooting to your hair. Stu snickers, slapping Tatum’s hip, “That’s catty, even for you, babe.”
“Seriously,” Sid admonishes, shooting you a sorry smile. Billy’s eyes dart between you and her, but he doesn’t say a thing in your defense. Swallowing roughly, your gaze drops to your shoes. Self-consciousness drowns you so quick, you just want to run to the bathroom and hide out the rest of the day.
“What?” Tatum snickers. “I didn’t mean it like that. I just meant she could use some touch-ups.”
Your throat burns as your eyes flick toward the grassy courtyard. You’d prefer anything to facing them right now. Crying in front of the Stu and Billy is worse than chumming the waters before going diving.
“Christ, you’re the worst sometimes,” but Sid can’t hide the smile in her voice. She calls your name and you suck in a sharp breath before looking at her. “She’s sleeping over at mine tonight. Why don’t you come?”
“So you can give me some touch-ups?” you snap. Randy snickers at the perceived cat-fight, and you punch him in the arm.
“Innocent bystander,” he grimaces, shooting you a glare. You give him a sharp smile and shrug.
“Yeah,” Tatum agrees. “I think it’d do you some good to hang out with someone other than these bozos.” She doesn’t fail to include her boyfriend in the insult. Stu’s face drops behind her as he looks to Billy.
“Me?” he mouths, and Billy just glares at him.
“They’re totally holding you back, babe,” she pops another grape in her mouth and shrugs. “Your choice.”
“I can’t believe you let her talk to you like that,” Stu snickers, shoveling popcorn in his mouth as he sprawls across the loveseat.
You shift uncomfortably in your seat, clutching the throw pillow closer to your chest. “What the hell was I supposed to say?”
Billy glances over his shoulder at you, his legs kicked over the arm of the seat across from Stu. “Maybe don’t roll over and let her treat you like a doormat.”
You roll your eyes and pick up a piece of popcorn. Tossing it, it bounces off of Stu’s nose while you lean back on the couch. “She’s your girlfriend, you could have said something.” Stu watches the popcorn fall to his mom’s new, ridiculously expensive rug and snorts.
“Yeah right, like I’m gonna get in the middle of a cat-fight.”
“Oh yeah,” Billy rolls his eyes as he flips through the channels. “I’m sure that’s your nightmare.”
Stu laughs and tosses a handful of candy at Billy. Clearly incensed by your idea of trashing his mother’s pristine living room. “Shut up, man.”
You drown out their bickering, more than used to it, as food begins to fly across the room. Reaching up, you fiddle with a strand of combed-out hair. “Do you think she was right?”
They pause, eyes darting back to you. They share a look that you don’t understand and it only worsens your mood. “What? That we’re holding you back?” Billy questions, voice tight with something dangerous.
“No,” you snip, tossing your pillow at him. He deflects it with an irritated look, narrowed eyes meeting yours. “That I’m a mess.”
“She didn’t say that,” Stu objects, a cruel tilt to his lips. “Just that you need some touch-ups.” Billy chuckles and Stu joins him. The pair turns back to the TV and that’s that. You’re dismissed.
Frowning, you get to your feet and grab your bag. “Where’re you going?” Billy asks, not even turning around.
“I’m gonna head home,” you tell them, something souring your stomach the longer you’re in their presence.
“We haven’t even gotten to the movie, yet,” Stu whines. You ignore him, rushing toward his front door and throwing it open. With your back turned, you miss the harsh look the boys share. The type that would have had you turning around and sitting right back down on the couch.
Heading through the door, you think over Tatum’s harsh words. Cruel, but maybe necessary. Checking your watch, you figure it’s not midnight yet, surely Sid’s invite must still stand.
Sid’s surprised as she opens her front door. “Oh,” she offers a polite smile as she greets you.
Tatum pops up behind her, an impressed grin on her face. “Didn’t think you were going to show. Isn’t this your movie night?”
You sigh, fingers flexing around your bag. “Yeah. But you had a point. Your delivery sucked. But you had a point.” Tatum mushes Sid to the side and beckons you into the house.
“I know I did,” she’s far too proud of herself as she leads you over to the couch. Sid hovers behind you both, clearly not expecting you and unsure what to do with herself.
Tatum seems far more comfortable as she takes your bag from you. “I had hope you’d see sense,” she croons, dropping onto the cushion beside you.
Your shoulders tense and you try not to grimace at how enthused she is at making you over. You hadn’t thought you were that bad. Clearly, she disagreed. Tatum rifles through some magazines before dropping one in your lap.
“I have plans for you." It sounds more like a threat as you stare down at the glammed out model in the magazine.
An hour later, Tatum’s coiling freshly washed strands of your hair around her fingers while Sid sits in front of you, brushing eyeshadow across your lids. “You really don’t look bad,” she reassures. “But, it’s confidence that sells a look.”
“If a little mascara gives you some confidence, who knows?” Tatum shrugs as she spirals more hair around her finger. “Maybe you’ll finally get a boyfriend.”
The longer this little "sleepover" has gone on, the more you’ve felt they had ulterior motives. Sure, slumber parties in chick flicks always look fun. Pillow fights, makeup sessions, and gossiping with one another. But that hasn’t been happening. The girls seem strangely tense.
You’re pretty sure they’re hoping this makeover session will finally get you your own guy, so they can stop worrying about your relationship with their boyfriends. You hadn’t taken Sid as the insecure type, apparently you were wrong.
Still, this was nicer than some of the exes Billy and Stu had acquired. At least they were helping you out. Rather than starting rumors that you slept around with the teachers.
Thank you, Casey Becker.
You hadn’t exactly been sorry when you’d heard what the town’s new killer had done to her and her asshole boyfriend.
Billy and Stu had called you twisted when you’d said that, but you’d seen the way they smiled. You wouldn’t be friends with them if there wasn’t something a little off-kilter about you.
“Someone should have taught you how to do this a while ago,” Tatum mutters, talking about the hair you’d hardly ever put much thought into. You had been taught how to deal with it, but it was never your top priority. Typically, you braided it and just lived in it for a while.
Something about the way she says it reminds you of what she’d casually dropped at lunch. “What did you mean when you said Billy and Stu are holding me back?” Sid’s brush pauses on your cheek and Tatum’s hands still. You don’t have to look to know they’re sharing a silent conversation.
“It’s just something guys do,” Sid dismisses.
Your eyes narrow and she offers a tense smile. “Tatum?” You prod, knowing she doesn’t care about softening her words.
She lets out a little sigh and drops your hair. “Guys like having awkward girl friends. When they get dumped or go through a slump, she’s someone they can fall back on.”
“Like,” you pause, heart stuttering. “For sex?” Sid snorts at your blunt delivery and Tatum shrugs.
“Yeah, pretty much. They think if a girl’s lonely enough, she’ll sleep with anyone. It’s just a good way to keep a backup.”
“And you think that’s what they do with me?”
Sid’s eyes dart up to meet yours and you know she feels bad you’re having this conversation at all. “Sometimes. Sometimes they just like having someone around to make them feel better about themselves.”
Your heart drops to your feet and you don’t want to believe her. But something about what she says makes sense. Every time you complain about your clothes, hair, or anything too shallow or girly, the guys blow you off. They say stuff about not thinking you were into that vapid stuff.
Any chances you’ve had at a date, they’ll tell you shit about the guy you would never have guessed. Horrible things that make you uncomfortable and sick to your stomach. Half the time, you think they’re making it up, but you choose not to take the risk.
Every chance they get, they keep you all to themselves. And like an idiot, you’d just always thought that was because they wanted you the way you want them. Of course, Sid and Tatum would know better than you. They’re dating the boys after all. And it’s not so far out of character to assume Stu and Billy would be so malicious.
“Oh,” your stomach flips on itself and you blink watery eyes down at your hands. “Thanks for telling me,” you whisper. Tatum and Sid share a look over your shoulder. You see the guilt on Sid’s face, but you miss the wink Tatum sends her.
You follow what Sid and Tatum had taught you the night before, you don’t know which one you mess up worse, your hair or the makeup. You’ve missed first period by the time you finally make it out of the house. Meaning you manage to skirt around Billy and Stu right up until lunch.
Honestly, after what Sid and Tatum told you, no part of you actually wants to see them. But your boss at the video store is cutting your hours and you really need the cash Stu will give you for writing up his world civ essay.
Sucking in a sharp breath, you give yourself a little pep talk before forcing yourself to walk over to the fountain. Everyone’s there already, Sid and Tatum sprawled across their boyfriends. Meanwhile, Randy’s up and speaking with flailing arms. Like the court jester performing for the popular royals. It’s sickening what a cliche your friends have become when that’s what they’ve always made fun of.
“Watch the hands, Meeks,” you call out, nearly catching a slap to the face as he rants passionately about some horror flick you’ve never heard of.
He lets out a huff before turning to face you. Whatever argument he had dies on his tongue as he jerks back. You swallow roughly, hand reaching subconsciously toward your hair as he nearly pushes his nose against yours.
“Randy,” you whisper, mushing his face away. “What the hell is wrong with you?”
His thumb reaches up, swiping for your cheek, and you just manage to slap his hand back. “Is that glitter?” He questions, positively dumbfounded.
“It’s blush,” you snap, pushing him back. “Would you get out of here, you weirdo?” Shaking your head, you rifle through your backpack until you find the folder for Stu.
You try not to look at him as you walk up, chest tightening at the dead silence you’re now surrounded by. Stu grabs the folder, but his hand snakes up, grabbing at your wrist before you can back up.
“Huh,” he pulls you down, eyes roaming across your face. You glance at Tatum and she gives you an encouraging smile. “It is glitter.”
“Eyeshadow, doofus,” she swats his arm. “You did a good job,” she reassures you.
“Made me late for school,” you mutter, skin warming the longer Stu stares.
“Why?” Billy asks, before anyone can say anything else. Stu releases you at the sound of his voice and you stumble back.
“I don’t know,” forcing yourself to meet his eyes, you startle at the coldness staring back at you. “Maybe I wanted to look pretty.”
Stu snorts and cuts you a sharp look. “You didn’t need to do drag to look pretty,” he mocks. Your hand shoots up to your face. You hadn’t even done close to as much as Sid and Tatum had taught you.
“Stu,” Tatum snaps, shooting him a harsh look.
He lets out a chuckle and jerks back, “What?” He glances over at you, but the smile on his face isn’t genuine. “I was joking. It looks fine, dude.”
For some reason, you find yourself looking over at Billy. His jaw is tensed, eyes glaring down at the ground. He seems to feel your stare, gaze snapping up to meet yours. Biting your tongue, you swallow the burn in the back of your throat. “It looks good,” he finally admits, hardly sounding like he wants to compliment you.
You purse your lips and nod, barely wanting to be around them for another second. Clearly, the girls were right about their theory. “Really good,” Randy adds on, a goofy look on his face. You let out a sharp laugh and roll your eyes at him.
“I know it’s not your thing,” Tatum starts, sucking on her lollipop with a proud smile. “But you should come to Stu’s party tonight.”
You grimace and begin to shake your head. “Seriously,” Sid encourages. “You’ll have fun, for once.”
“What are you two planning, you little vixen?” Stu taunts, fingers pinching at Tatum’s sides. Your eyes narrow at the way he speaks through gritted teeth, voice tight.
Swallowing bile at Billy and Stu’s reactions, you straighten up, forcing your voice to be strong. “Even if I wanted to, I can’t.” The girls shoot you odd looks and you shrug as you pluck your bag from the ground. “I’m covering for Randy at the store.”
Randy’s head shoots up, eyes glazed over with confusion. “You are?”
“God,” you roll your eyes. “Remind me how many times they’ve fired your ass.” With a smug grin, he holds up five fingers and winks.
“What a shame,” Stu clicks his tongue and he doesn’t even bother sounding disappointed. “We’ll miss you reminding everyone of curfew.”
Hurt tightens your chest as you let out a sharp scoff. “Fuck off, Macher.”
His nose wrinkles and he presses his hand to his chest. “Ouch,” he hisses.
Billy reaches over and swats his arm, clearly telling him to knock it off. But you know that look on Stu’s face. He’s pissed, about what, you never have a clue.
Deciding to spare yourself any more embarrassment, you turn around and head back to the school. You didn’t want to go to his stupid party. But it would’ve been nice if they had wanted you there. If they could have just shown you something, that meant what the girls told you was bullshit.
“How many times do I have to tell you to alphabetize by genre?” Your boss, Jason, tosses Halloween at you and storms off. The VHS smacks you square in the chest and you let out a sharp scoff. The fuck does that even mean?
“Seriously,” you jump as someone’s pointy chin digs into your shoulder. “How many times does he have to tell you,” Stu bemoans, stealing the tape from your hand. You cast your eyes back and catch his grin as he backs off from you.
“Don’t you have a party to be planning?” You snap, not bothering to keep the venom from your tone.
“Someone jealous she didn’t get an invite?” Billy comes up on the other side of you, sharp eyes alight with a rare teasing glint.
It’s like being circled by hyenas with the pair of them. They always corner their prey, backing them up until there’s nowhere to run. Currently, it’s keeping you locked in the horror section as they block both ends.
“No,” you cut your eyes to Stu, irritation only growing worse at his stupid grin. “But you didn’t have to be such a dick today,” you tell him, snatching the tape back so you can shelf it.
“Oh,” he croons, catching your wrist and tugging you back into his chest. “I think I hurt her feelings,” he mocks, pouting at Billy.
Billy raises his brows, leaning on the shelves as he shrugs. “Did he?”
“Is there a particular reason you guys are being such assholes to me, or are you just bored?” Billy’s eyes narrow as he offers a sharp smirk.
Stu lets his chin rest in the crook of your neck, ignoring how you try to wiggle out of his hold. “Is there a reason you decided to do this?” He asks, tugging at one of your curls. “I liked the whole puffed-out dandelion look.”
“Ugh,” a disgusted groan slips out as you elbow him in the side. His breath whooshes out of him and his arms finally loosen. “Why do you have such a hard-on about whether or not I style my hair?”
“You never cared before.” Billy frowns, eyeing you up and down. “All the best final girls don't give a shit about that stuff.”
Your eyes fall into slits as a bewildered scoff leaves you. “What geeky language are you even speaking?”
Stu barks out a sharp laugh, leaning forward until he's back in your field of view. “Says you,” he taunts.
Your head falls to the side as you shoot him an unimpressed glare. “Do you guys need something? Jason already hates me. I don’t feel like having you two getting me fired.”
“Jason?” Billy questions. “The asshole that was bitching about genres?”
“That’s the one,” you hum, turning back to your cart and the piles of tapes you have to deal with.
“Dude seems like he needs to get laid,” Stu points out, eyes tracking Jason as he paces through the store. Yelling at the first person he sees over some made-up bullshit.
“Yeah, he probably does. But I doubt anyone’s that desperate.”
“No,” he taunts, and your hackles raise at his tone. “Not even you?”
You slam the tape down harder than you mean to. The noise echoes through the store, the shelves rattling beneath Stu and Billy’s careless bodies. Stu’s brows raise with poorly concealed excitement. “Get something or get the fuck out,” you hiss at him.
Taking hold of your cart, you shove past him before he can think of anything else smart to say. Insulting others seems to be the only time he’s capable of coming up with any wit of his own.
Of course, that means you get to be on the receiving end nine times out of ten. You make a good target for them, apparently.
Billy swats Stu’s arm, shoving him back and trailing after you. Stu lets out a snotty huff, randomly grabbing one of the tapes from the shelves as Billy falls into your check-out line.
“He’s a moron,” he excuses.
“And a jackass,” you snap, barely lifting your gaze to meet his. “Did you pick something?” Billy reaches behind himself, slapping Stu in the chest and making the other boy toss Prom Night on the counter.
You ignore how Stu’s gaze bores into the side of your head, scanning the VHS and looking over the blocky green letters on your screen. “You owe ten bucks for an overdue movie,” you tell him.
“Ten bucks?” he scoffs, “What movie?”
Tilting your head, you scoff, he’s such a cliche. “Basic Instinct, got a little crush on Sharon Stone, Stuart?”
Stu’s nose wrinkles as he glares at you. “Stuart?” he huffs, “You sound like my mother.” Pushing Billy out of the way, he props his elbows on the counter, chin resting in his palms. “Can’t you do your best friend a favor?”
You drop down to his level, matching his posture with a saccharine smile. “Why would I do that?” You tease, voice pitched with faux innocence.
Stu’s got a genuine grin on his face as you play along; it takes everything in you not to return it. “What are you doing?” The moment’s broken as you jump back, Jason’s harsh voice ruining the fun.
Sucking in a sharp breath, you turn back to the monitor and pretend to type some nonsense into the system. “Nothing, just checking them out.”
“Yeah, I’ll bet,” your head whips up at the insinuation, but he barely spares you any attention. He turns toward the boys with a sneer, “Just because you're friends with her, doesn’t mean you don’t have to pay like everyone else. Have the movie back by tomorrow, or you’re banned.”
“Jason-” you object.
“You’re already on thin ice,” he snaps, pointing his fat finger in your face. You resist the urge to snap your teeth at him. “Don’t push me,” he warns, as if he were scary at all beyond you not having a paycheck next week.
Stu watches him walk away with furrowed brows and a sneer. “God, what a prick.”
“Yeah,” you mutter, “you’re telling me.” Feeling ever so slightly vindictive, you clear the charge from Stu’s account and toss him his tape. “Keep the movie, he’s an ass.”
Stu cares little for the other people waiting in line as he reaches across the counter and cups your cheeks. You let out a little squeak as he drags you closer, planting an obnoxiously loud kiss on your cheek.
“What are friends for?” He mocks, pushing back from you.
“Ugh,” you wipe at your face and glare at him.
“See you,” Billy says as he shakes his head, yanking up Stu’s sleeve and dragging him away before he can make an even bigger scene.
You watch them leave with a disbelieving laugh. Stu could be a dick, but at least he was fun. Unlike other people, Jason, who got off on making everyone as miserable as them. Despite your general disinterest in drunk crowds of teenagers, you’d rather be at Stu’s party than deal with him the rest of the night.
You, however, didn’t receive an invite. So, you turn back to your cart of tapes and force yourself to go back to restocking.
Around midnight, you finish closing up the registers and pick up a cleaning rag and some spray. You hum to yourself as you move to the windows, beginning to wipe them down.
Jason is hiding in the back. Shirking all his responsibilities on you as you close up tonight. Meaning you probably won’t be getting home until one at the earliest.
Muttering to yourself, you work on scrubbing out a particularly tough stain. Whatever it is clings to the fabric of your rag, each wipe seeming to spread it more. With a huff, you lean down to spray some more cleaner when a dark shape moves in the corner of your eye.
Frowning, you straighten back up. The window before you is fogged with whatever ruined the glass. Tilting your head past it, you find a screaming white mask staring back at you.
“Fuck,” you jump back with a gasp, rag slipping from your hand. The figure stares, head tilting slowly as he surveys you. You can only stare for a minute, heart trapped in your throat as your chest stutters. Visceral panic fills you, spikes through your blood until you feel lightheaded.
He takes a step forward and your body jolts back to life. Stumbling over yourself, you rush to the door, flipping the lock before he can get any closer.
Of course, you knew all about the Woodsboro killer. Casey Becker's murder was worse than even Sid’s mom. But it still seemed so far disconnected from you that you hadn’t really thought about it.
After all, why the hell would anyone want to kill you? You never did anything.
But he’s staring right at you now. Beneath that ridiculous mask are the eyes of a killer. And they're set on you.
Too afraid to take your eyes off him, you stumble back until your hip is smashing into the corner of the counter. A pained hiss slips past your lips as your hand gropes blindly for the phone. He almost seems amused as he watches you, relaxed and at ease as his head follows your clumsy movements.
Finally managing to wrap your hand around the landline, you hastily press it to your ear. The monotonous ringing on the other end is possibly one of the worst sounds you’ve ever heard.
The phone slips from your hand, cracking against the floor as you stare at him. His head tilts and he shakes it slowly, mocking you.
“Jason?” You shout, forcing your eyes off the killer in front of you. With a sharp breath, you push off from the counter and run to the back. The door to Jason’s office is cracked, light spilling out from within.
You shove through, eyes burning as you fight back your panic. “Jason, we have to call-"
Your voice trails off into nothing as you take in the scene before you. His fan buzzes in the corner of the office, a droning noise amongst a scene straight from a crappy slasher movie.
Blood drips from the open gash of his throat. It trails down his arms, pooling along his fingers until it splashes against the floor. The noise echoes through the quiet space as your breath trembles. You trip over yourself as you back out of the office, stomach clenching painfully the longer you look into the open flesh of his throat. His eyes have rolled back, hidden beneath his eyelids, as his body goes cold.
“Oh,” you let out a revolted moan. “God,” you clap your hand over your mouth, tripping as you run from the room.
He had already been in here. Somehow, that psycho killed your boss. Then, for some reason, he decided to wait around for you to notice him outside. He’d been smart enough to cut the phone line. Why is he playing with you now?
Racing back to the front, you find him right where you left him. Just outside the front door, head still tilted with amusement. “What the….”
He taps his knife against the window. Tap, tap, tap, slowly, he lifts his head, straightening up as he nods behind you. Just barely, you managed to turn in time to see the knife slashing toward you.
With a shrill scream, you dive to the side, terror filling you as you realize there are two of them. They don’t give you long to dwell on that. The second one dives for you while the one outside works on breaking the glass door.
Kicking your leg out, you manage to catch the one in front of you in the shin. He lets out a raspy groan, muffled by the mask, as he falls forward. Your hands grope along the floor, desperate for any sort of weapon. The best you have is a VHS. You don’t let that stop you from smacking the sharp corner into the temple of the man next to you. His hand flies up to his head, another pathetic groan leaving him.
You scramble to your feet just as the sound of glass shattering echoes through the store. A brick skips across the carpet, stopping just before your shoes. With a shaky breath, you look over to find the second man stepping slowly through the empty doorway.
His gaze flicks to yours and you let out a small whimper as the other one begins getting to his feet. “Shit,” you hiss, not sparing them another glance as you rush to the back. You can hear their footsteps quick behind you, just barely managing to slip into Jason’s office as they catch up.
You slam the door shut, body jolting roughly as they try to barrel through. With a groan, you shove your shoulder forward, shoes squeaking against linoleum as you force the door the rest of the way closed.
Panic-slick palms slip against the handle until you’re finally turning the lock. The door rattles violently as you step away, their bodies thudding against the wood as they try and batter their way through.
You don't waste any time, whipping around toward Jason’s computer and dialing into the modem. You work around your boss’s dead body, eyes burning at the smell of death and copper that floods his office. Your fingers fly across the keyboard, quick to connect to emergency services. You just manage to send your address when the door flies open behind you.
A scream rips from your throat as you jump around the desk. They both stand in the doorway, shoulders heaving as their muffled breaths fill the air. Your hands tremble at your sides as they split away from one another. The tallest lingers by the desk, the shorter one hovers in the doorway. They’ve cornered you, left you nowhere to run.
You back up as much as you can, wincing as your back connects with Jason’s metal filing cabinets. The shorter one lunges first. Your hand wraps around the handle of one of the cabinets and you wrench it forward, jumping back as it slams into the ground.
You manage to catch him off guard as he jerks back. You leap over the fallen cabinet and shove past him. A gloved hand wraps around your elbow, roughly shoving you forward.
Right into the tip of his blade.
A low moan escapes you, heart beating furiously against your chest as blood begins to weep from your stomach. Your eyes flutter shut at the sharp burst of pain. Fire lights up along your nerves.
When he begins to pull away, trying for another hit, you shove him back with all the strength you have left. He stumbles with a grunt, tripping over the cabinet and crashing into the other one.
You press your hands against your stomach, running from Jason’s office, and leaping through the shattered front door. You can only hear the crunch of your shoes against the broken glass. You can’t spare any attention to what might be following behind.
You don’t let yourself stop, pushing forward even as your lungs tighten until it hurts worse to breathe than it did to be stabbed. By the time your legs finally give out, lights are speeding down the road toward you. Doors slam and familiar voices call your name as you crash against the pavement, blood pooling from your hands and onto the asphalt below.
“I’m not the one who thought we should test her.”
Consciousness is slow to come back to you. Distantly, you can hear familiar hushed voices. “Well, I’m not the one who tried to fucking gut her.”
You hear what sounds like a slap and then a harsh, “Shut the fuck up!”
Your mind is fuzzy, dulled by the edges of pain and sleeping too long. You can hardly recognize the voices, let alone understand what they’re saying.
“You’re lucky she’s still alive.”
There’s a brief pause and then a low chuckle that makes shivers run up your spine. “What the hell were you going to do if she wasn’t?”
A strange sound slips from your lips, a groan, maybe. It’s hard to tell as your eyes adjust to the sterile lights of the hospital room.
Immediately, there’s a weight sat beside you, large hands covering your own. You blink slowly, forcing your eyes to focus as you take in your surroundings. “Stu?” You mutter, voice wrecked as your gaze dips from his concerned face to Billy’s stoic one.
Your head tilts, nose wrinkling as you notice they’re both wearing hospital gowns. Stu even has an IV hooked to his arm.
“What’s going on?” You try to straighten up, but your arms buckle out from under you. Stu reaches forward, gentle for once, as he helps you sit up.
Slowly, Billy makes his way to your side, perching just beside you, mirroring Stu. “How do you feel?” He asks, dodging your question.
You blink, struggling to take inventory of yourself. “Uh,” you shrug, frowning at the pain burning through your stomach. “Weird.”
“That’s the meds. They’ve got us on the same shit.” Stu lets go of your hands to lift his gown, showing a large, red-tinted bandage along his side.
“Jesus,” you reach out, fingers just brushing the edge. “What the hell happened to you two?”
“Sid’s dad,” Billy cuts in. Your head whips around to him so fast you’re surprised it doesn’t pop off. He offers a sardonic smirk as your jaw drops.
“Sorry, what?”
“Yeah, apparently the dude lost it,” Stu cuts in, eyes wide with something you don’t like. “Freaked out and just went on a bloody spree. He got us last night.” Billy reaches over and swats Stu’s arm. He lets out a little huff, “He got Tatum, too.”
“Stu-“
“And Sid.” Billy cuts you off before you can even start to console. Your eyes clench shut before shooting back open. This is way too much to be processing when you’ve just woken up from a drug-induced coma.
Your lips part, condolences ready on your tongue. But neither of them seems especially desperate for that. Stu’s got your hands in his, eyes watching every micro expression of yours like it's the most interesting thing in the world. Billy seems distant. Expected when your girlfriend is murdered by her father. But this is different, somehow.
There’s something he doesn’t want you to see.
“I,” your mind races with a hundred different thoughts before settling on one. “I don’t get it. Why'd he come after me?”
Stu scoffs, “Why'd he murder his daughter? Nothing about this will ever make sense.”
“Yeah, but-"
“We should let the doctor know you're awake.” Billy gets to his feet, cutting you off again. Stu lingers for a moment before reluctantly releasing your hands. Your eyes dart between them, not eager to just be left on your own again.
“We’ll stop by later,” Stu promises, the wheels of his IV drip squeaking as they both shuffle from your room. Your hand drifts to your stomach, mind growing consumed with the throbbing pain. Something isn’t right.
When you’re well enough that your meds can be cut back, you go off on your own to find the boys. You’re sick of being alone in your room. Terrified that every time you look through your window, that screaming mask will be staring back at you.
Sid’s dad is dead. Dewey and the others had reassured you a hundred times. But that didn't mean that Ghistface was dead. You saw him.
Saw them.
It wasn’t just one man behind the slaughter. But you hadn’t told Dewey that. Hadn’t told the sheriff. Not even the nosy ass reporter that kept sneaking her way past security.
No part of you had been able to reason away why you kept that information to yourself. There was no plausible excuse to protect the men who tried to kill you. Still, you can’t help but feel that if murder really had been their plan, you wouldn’t have gotten away that night.
Shuffling through the hospital halls, you keep an arm wrapped tight around your wound as you make your way to Stu’s room.
He seems miserably bored as he flips through channels on his TV. His face lights up when he sees you in the doorway. You chuckle as he tosses his remote away. Beckoning you closer as he pulls back his sheets.
Carefully, you help yourself into his bed, letting out a pained sigh as you try to get comfortable. “Where’s Billy?”
Stu shrugs, “I don’t know, probably using the bathroom. The meds they’ve got us on have me pissing like crazy.”
You let out a little snort and swat his arm. “You’re disgusting.”
Stu catches your hand in his, lacing your fingers together. His eyes bore into the scratchy hospital blanket, stare pensive. You think about offering to bring him something more comfortable when he speaks.
“Do you even like horror movies?”
Your brows furrow. Out of anything he could have said, that was probably the last thing you were expecting. “What?” You let out a disbelieving chuckle and he shrugs.
“We always force you through them on movie night. But I don’t think you’ve ever said you like them.”
You frown, picking at the threads of his fraying blanket. “I don’t know, what’s it matter?”
“Humor me,” he insists, tone unsettling. Looking back up, you nearly pull away. The vacant look in his eyes is disturbing.
“No,” you whisper, feeling like you’re telling him something you shouldn’t. “I don’t like them.”
“Why do you watch them?” He pushes, sitting up until his nose is nearly brushing yours. You would pull back if it didn’t feel like his stare had frozen you to the spot.
“I feel like if I don’t, you guys won’t want to hang out with me anymore.”
“Why would you think that?”
“Why are you asking me all this?” You whisper, eyes burning the longer Stu stares into them. He stays still for a moment, gaze running across yours. With a sharp bark of laughter, he falls back onto his pillows. You jump at the sudden movement and finally realize just how hard your heart is pounding against your ribs. His face cringes with pain as he tugs at his stitches.
“Wanna know my favorite trope?” He brushes past your question, armed with another series of his own. Fingers flexing under his tight grip, you try not to grimace. He doesn’t wait for you to answer.
“The final girl,” he whispers, waving one hand as if it’s some big reveal. “She never goes out. Never parties. Doesn’t care what she looks like,” his grip tightens infinitesimally around yours.
You want to tell him it hurts, but you can’t force the words from your tightened throat. “Always manages to outsmart the killers. She's always so perfect. Except,” he holds up one scolding finger with a sharp grin. “When she helps assholes like me cheat on his homework.”
You jerk back, flesh stinging like you’ve been burned. Stu lets you go, smile creeping ever wider. “What the hell are you saying?” You demand, voice cracking as you get to your feet.
“What’s the matter?” He asks, barely concealing his excitement as you back out of the room. “It’s just a joke,” he needles.
Your back slams into something firm and your breath catches in your throat. “I don’t think we ever asked,” Stu taunts with a chuckle.
Tilting your face back, you see Billy standing behind you, eyes dark and cold as they bore into yours.
⋆˚࿔ NSFW 18+ you are the only one in control of the media you consume, read the contents before you continue
⋆˚࿔ contents: somnophilia (obvi), stalking, breaking and entering, non-con, fingering, p in v, unprotected (wrap b4 u tap), pulling out, he's gentle i promise, lowercase intended
· ──────── ꒰ঌ·✦·໒꒱ ──────── ·
ethan landry liked to watch girls sleep. he'd spend his off nights peering through the windows of the college girls, standing with eerie stillness. and now he's found a special person of interest. his new obsession. you.
he'd first seen you in his evening economy lecture. you sat exactly 2 rows down and 5 to the left of him—he took extra care in remembering every detail. you [insert trait here], you stick your tongue out a little when you take notes. he took a picture in his mind of every little quirk, every movement, every moment he saw you.
he couldn't help but picture what you look like sleeping, how vulnerable and helpless you'd be under his gaze. his eyes darkened at the thought.
thursday, november 2nd. 9:41 pm. your professor dismissed class, wishing you all a good weekend. no one fully listened, of course, too busy collecting bags and escaping the labyrinth of lecture hall seats. ethan watches as you clumsily swing your backpack onto your shoulders, the weight of your textbooks making your feet stumble. he mindlessly gathers his things into his own backpack, his eyes keeping his piercing gaze on you the entire time.
he watches as you approach the classroom door and push it open, making quick work of the aisles to catch up to you.
your left foot moves forward, so does his. your right foot moves forward, so does his. he matches your pace, keeping gaze halfway between his phone and you so he doesn't look suspicious. he couldn't afford you giving him any second looks.
the darkness of the night sky takes hold of the atmosphere, not a drop of sunlight left to give. your apartment was a ten minute walk from the classroom building. you hold your keys between each finger as a precaution, but it wouldn't protect you from what's to come.
ethan kept closely behind you, but far enough to stay hidden in plain sight. the hustle and bustle of the city nearby brings an ounce of comfort in the darkness.
the walk is long and nerve-wracking, but in time you reach your complex. you enter the entrance code and push the door open with a grunt. just ethan's luck, it's also his complex. he takes his own student card out with trembling hands and enters the complex. he follows you onto the elevator.
you give him a quick once over. he seems innocent enough, but you keep your guard up anyway. with a serial killer on the loose, you can never be too sure.
he glances at the button you pressed. floor 3, a floor below him. he doesn't click his own button.
"same floor, huh?" he musters up the courage to comment.
"guess so," you sigh in response, just managing to hide the anxiety in your voice.
the elevator dings and the doors slowly open. you exit with haste, and he follows shortly behind, keeping a 5 foot distance between you.
20 feet from the elevator is your room. as you unlock the door, ethan takes careful note of the room number and the decorations on the door. he takes some misleading steps further, turning down the corner. he stops and waits for you to go inside before he doubles back for the elevator.
he makes haste for his elevator, repeating your room number in his head like a mantra. 2237, 2237, 2237, 2237, 2237. he practically sprints down the hallway to get to his room.
you wouldn't be asleep for while he thought. best to wait it out. he changes into all black, best to not be seen. his ghostface mask, cloak, and knife wait dormant in a box in his closet.
he lays back on his unkempt bed, staring idly at the ceiling. sleep doesn't come—he doesn't want it to, anyway—his impatience and arousal to great to bear. he wants so badly to ease the ache in his jeans, but patience is a virtue, even for a sinner as he. he'd be rewarded soon. soon.
his eyes glance between the ceiling and the clock.
10:07.
10:24.
10:42.
10:51.
11:03.
11:17.
11:30.
11:36.
11:58.
12:02. surely you must be asleep by now. the hall lights were dimmed, and it was monday, so no party girls drunkenly scampering back to their rooms. he opens the box, his mask and knife staring back at him, as if sentient. he shoves the blade into a holster and pulls the mask over his face.
he makes his way to the stairwell, not wanting to risk running into anyone. he walks down the stairs with caution and opens the door as quiet as he can. he's reached the second floor.
2237. 2237. 2237. 2237. 2237. 2237. 2237.
he finds your room and begins picking your lock. he manages to get it open. with extreme caution, he opens the door, careful to not wake you. he crept through the narrow halls of your apartment, tracing his finger along the walls to guide him in the darkness. he approaches a cracked door and peers inside, finding you fast asleep, clad in nothing but panties and a cheeky baby-tee. he shudders, his arousal traveling quickly to his sex. with practiced caution, he opens your door just wide enough to squeeze through. he gingerly approaches your sleeping form and kneels down.
he stares. he stares for what feels like hours, as if frozen in place. after a many a moment his hands finally move, lightly tracing along your curves. to his surprise you barely stir, only whimpering lightly in your sleep. he crawls onto your bed, your body tucked into his.
his hands travel from your shoulder, to your breasts, to your stomach, to your waist, to your sex. he could feel your wetness through your soft panties.
"all for me, pretty girl?" he whispers against your ear. you shudder, but don't wake.
he toys with your clit above the fabric of your panties, your arousal growing more by the moment. with a sigh he moves the fabric to the side, revealing your supple lips. he inserts a gloved finger into you, curling and thrusting in slow motions. you whine, but don't stir awake, still deep in sleep.
must be a wet dream, he thinks. a small part of him hopes you're dreaming of his fingers pleasuring you, his arousal pressed against you.
he inserts a second gloved finger, working in scissoring motions. his free hand reaches down to his groin and begins undoing the fly of his jeans, pulling them and his boxers down with shaking hands. he lines his cock up with your entrance, gently pulling his fingers out. he inserts himself slowly, his masked face buried in the crook of his neck. he thrusts at an unhurried pace, savoring the feeling of you sucking him in.
he whines, the sound muffled by the mask. your old wooden bed creaks with the pace of his thrusts and grunts, as if harmonious. he counts his lucky stars that you haven't awoken from your deep slumber.
his thrusts become faster, uneven, more desperate. your sex is squeezing him so tightly, as if made just for him.
"c-cumming, cummingcummimg...!" he whines through the mask, the plastic resting against your shoulder.
he pulls out just before he cums, his sticky semen coating the sweet spot between your legs. he breathes a heavy sigh, utterly exhausted, but he doesn't move. he relishes in your warmth, the scent of your shampoo, the softness of your bare skin. how he wishes this moment could last forever, but all things are fleeting. he tucks himself back into his jeans and leaves your warmth with heavy reluctance.
before he retreats back to his room, though, he pulls out his phone and takes a few pictures. of your sleeping face and the mess he made between your thighs.
as they say, pictures last forever.
· ──────── ꒰ঌ·✦·໒꒱ ──────── ·
hope you guys enjoyed this one!! please please please send me ideas to write !!
if requests are open… i beg of you, the ethan writer…. to please write something about ethan being a certified munch… like you can’t tell me he doesn’t eat pussy for a SPORT. sure he’d love you to sit on his face but… i can just imagine him folding your knees up into your chest so he can have full access to you
A/N : Hii ! <3 I loooove your request so much, it just SCREAMS Ethan Landry to me, this man would happily die between your legs if it means he can eat your pussy for hours and make you cum multiple times !! 🤤🖤 Please tell me if I did justice to your request and you know where to find me if you want other Ethan’s fics 😘✨
Ethan Landry lives for eating you out as he loves giving the sweetest pleasure to your pussy…or is it his ?
❦ Even though Ethan Landry is inexperienced when he first starts eating you out, your boyfriend would improve so quickly because of two simple reasons. First, because Ethan wants to do things right and would absolutely listen to your advice when he asks you what feels good or not, taking mental notes of which spot makes you moan the loudest and which pace makes you cum the fastest. Secondly, because Ethan wants - need - to eat you out so frequently that he, anyway, grew to be very good at it.
❦ Ethan would definitely leave hickeys on your inner thighs before he even touches you pussy, his head nicely snuggled between your thighs as he nips, bites, licks and kisses your skin that will show his marks, only for him to know who you really belong to.
❦ He would then press his fingers on your pussy, his thumb rubbing on your clit through the pretty lace material of your panties that he offered you a few days ago, teasing you as Ethan feels the wetness dampen the fabric underneath his fingertips and proudly smiles when he realizes that he can work you up this nicely by barely touching you.
❦ Ethan would also always, and I say always, kiss your pussy through your panties before starting to eat you out, almost like he’s greeting your little cunny like the sweet boyfriend he is.
❦ This man could die between your thighs and he would be the happiest man ever. He would literally overstimulate your pussy for hours because Ethan cannot even realize how long he’s been giving you pleasure and he doesn’t care, he just wants you to feel good and…Ethan also gets excited just by eating you out.
❦ In fact, Ethan would get so painfully hard from pleasing you only with his mouth that he would start humping the bed to get some relief, cumming in his pants a few times seeing how much he’s desperate for you, and only you, making his head spin with pleasure.
❦ I also believe that Ethan’s hair is quite sensitive and with how much you would be pulling on his curly strands when he gives you orgasm one after the other, Ethan would whine, moan and grunt so much against your pussy, creating the most delicious vibrations against your sensitive clit.
❦ If you try to remove his head from your pussy (and if it’s still consensual of course), you won’t have any chance against his strength, his head won’t budge away from you. Nothing will stop Ethan if he isn’t finished with you yet and he will pin you down with his free hand by pressing against your tummy if he has to.
❦ Ethan will also bite your thighs if you contain your sounds of pleasure, he doesn’t want that and absolutely won’t let you do it. Ethan relishes in the way you so beautifully moan his name, whine in a pitched tone when you’re close to your climax and when you softly tell Ethan that you love him between soft whimpers after he overstimulated you.
❦ If he eats you out from behind or when you sit on his face, Ethan makes sure to grab handfuls of your ass while your thighs tremble and shake under his sweet indecent ministrations.
❦ Hell, this man would even eat you out at school between classes when Ethan really can’t wait to have you alone for himself. Ethan would take you to the restroom and press you against the wall as he kneels before going down on you. His head would be snuggled between your thighs as you look down to find his filthy gaze not leaving yours until he can hear you moan his name while you cream on his tongue. It simply feels like heaven to Ethan.
❦ Your boyfriend will even eat you out just to get rid of his stress, as Ethan paws at your skirt and then sliding his hand underneath it to caress the lace of your panties, after you both came back home from a long tiring day. « Please baby… I’m stressed, just need to eat you out real quick… I’ll be good… Can I ? », Ethan pleads you as he nuzzles your pulsating neck with his cold nose, pressing encouraging kisses there.
❦ Ethan feels immensely proud about giving you such pleasure only with his mouth and to hear those sweet sounds of yours mixed with little cries of his name, it all sounds like the most perfect music to his ears. After a session where your boyfriend knows that he did a particularly good job at making you feel good just by seeing the blush on your face, Ethan would silently look at you with a smug smile like the nerd he is.
❦ Ethan would make eye contact with you when he knows you’re close to reaching your climax. His eyes being half lidded white how pussy drunk he is.
❦ If you squirt while he eats you out, Ethan will feel so proud that he won’t ever shut up about it as he gently encourages you to do it again for him.
❦ After giving you so many orgasms with his mouth, a long session that leaves your pussy sensitive and puffy because of his lips, Ethan would so gently and softly kitten licks your pretty cunt and press little kisses on your clit, like the sweet boyfriend he is.
❦ While going down on you and after taking care of you, Ethan would praise you so much as he leaves kisses all over your face and pampers you with lovely words that he reserves only for you, his perfect girlfriend, « You did so well for me, angel. »
❦ Well, Ethan worships your pussy if that wasn’t clear enough.
❦ But what Ethan favors to do the most is folding your knees up into your chest so he can have full access to you and literally do whatever he wants to your pussy. Ethan would sometimes add two of his fingers when he wants to give you even more pleasure while sucking on your clit, twirling his tongue around it and lapping at your folds like the sweet puppy he is as he tries his best to tongue fuck you.
❦ When Ethan’s finished with you, as you’re so overstimulated that your legs go limp when he releases them, barely able to feel your legs anymore seeing how much strength your boyfriend applied on them. Some marks already start forming as Ethan apologetically presses kisses on your bruised skin, his face now covered in your juices as his mouth glistens. Ethan would give you the sloppiest kiss ever to make you taste yourself on his tongue, as he whines in your mouth at the feeling of having done a good job at making you feel good. During this kind of kiss, Ethan feels restless as he uncontrollably paws at your chest and holds your face to deepen the kiss, as he rubs his still hard-on against your pussy. His pants dampened with his cum after cumming in his pants so many times, feels sticky on your skin while he humps himself on your poor overstimulated and swollen clit. Yet, Ethan will never forget aftercare as he cleans you up like his dear little princess before cuddling you. Ethan is the loveliest puppy as he holds you tight in his arms, moving you closer to his body before he gets sleepy and rests his head on your shoulder, snoring lightly in your ear while he nuzzles against your face.
ever since leaving your hometown, and moving to where you attend the biggest college campus in NYC, you've felt free. the freedom nearly makes your skin tingle sometimes, since you've made more friends in four months than you had in 20 years.
with the new confidence, you've gotten a little over yourself.
every notification from your phone sends a chill to your spine, the good chill, since you know those notifications, especially the ones from imessage, are coming from chad or ethan.
chad, a football player in your sports psychology class and ethan, the smart economics major who sits beside you during communications lecture.
they're both everything you crave. chad is such a ladies man, you think, with his easy smile and gentle teasing. he is so chill, so chill that it scares you sometimes.
ethan seems shy on the surface, but has a commanding presence during projects that make you weak in the knees.
you didn't think twice about juggling them both, slipping into flirty messages with one while the other waited for a reply. it's harmless fun, or so you tell yourself, at least until you get caught up.
one evening, after finishing an english homework assignment in your dorm, your phone buzzes on cue. you smile, glad to be out of your academic bumble.
chad
hey, come over?
my roommate is out, it'll just be you and me.
your lips curve into a smirk with heat pooling low in your belly at the thought. you type back quickly, almost too quick.
y/n
on my way :D
during sports psych, your eyes always drifted to chad's hands as he wrote down notes from the table in-front of you sometimes. right now, you can imagine those big hands on you, knowing the way he makes you feel so safe and wanted.
you grab your black jacket with your heart racing as you head across campus to their own off-campus apartment away from yours, with the cool night air doing nothing to dampen the anticipation building inside you.
twenty minutes later when you knock, chad opens the door with a happy and familiar grin, with his broad shoulders filling the frame.
he's wearing a simple black t-shirt that clings to his chest, with jeans slung low on his hips. you're wearing a black jacket, with black foldover leggings, a typical outfit.
"hey, you," he says, pulling you inside with a soft kiss on your cheek.
the apartment smells like fresh coffee and his cologne, comforting and inviting as you follow him into the living room, where the brown couch sits against the wall, plush and worn from countless lazy nights from him and his roommate.
"hey, chad. how are you?" you ask, sitting down on his couch as he flops right beside you, so close to where your thigh is touching his.
"oh i'm wonderful! how about you? what'd you do today?" he asks, one hand moving to rub up and down your upper thigh, the other is stretched on the back of his couch.
you break a smile, "oh nothing much, I had my communications lecture, then I got all of my homework done before the 11:59 due date.
"you got all of your homework done?" chad hypes, "good girl," he murmurs after.
somewhere underneath the hype and happiness of his voice, there was a hidden note that you did not notice. this was a set up, and chad was nearly excited for what was going to happen next.
you nod, settling onto the couch, but before you can lean in for more from chad, a door creaks open down the hall.
ethan steps out, his dark eyes locking onto you like a predator spotting prey.
at first, your eyes didn't notice the familiar guy, just the fact that he's shirtless, with grey sweatpants hanging loose and his lean muscles flexing as he crosses his arms.
once you notice the arms, your eyes go wide.
"surprise!," ethan drawls, a smirk twisting his lips as he notices the shock plastered on your face. your stomach drops, with that shock freezing you in place. how—? they're roommates?
the realization hits like ice water poured over the head with your body still frozen as you stare between them.
"what the hell?" you blurt, voice pitching higher than intended, "you two… you know each other? how—?"
chad chuckles softly, sitting beside you on the couch, his hand resting possessively on your thigh.
"oh, sweetheart, we've been roommates for a year so far. close friends, too. you really thought you could play us like that? talking to both of us behind the other's back?" the footballer player's tone is gentle, almost pitying, but there's a condescending lilt in that voice which makes you squirm.
ethan saunters over, towering above you as he leans against the arm of the brown couch, caging you in-between the two men.
"naughty girl, aren't you? you've been fucking me for months and turns out after showing my good roommate here a picture of you, I find out that you've been trying to get into his pants too.." ethan laughs before continuing, "you thought you could have it all without consequences, huh?"
the white guy's words have a bite, almost forced anger, but there's a hint of amusement that softens the meanness making it feel like playful scolding rather than outright cruelty.
you open your mouth to protest with your cheekbones burning with humiliation, but chad's fingers tighten on your leg, silencing you.
"shh, no excuses... we know everything down to your flirty texts, the late-night calls, and how you invited ethan to your apartment multiple times already... you're ours now, y/n." he claims.
you look to your right, at ethan who looks at chad with a smirk, "is it time to teach our girl a lesson?"
"yep... time for a lesson." chad mocks with a sweet poison that makes your pulse thunder.
ethan grabs your chin at that moment, forcing you to meet his bright brown eyes from above, "you're going to learn not to mess around with us. get on your knees, now, show us how sorry you are." the econ major's grip is firm, a little rough and you whimper as you slide off the couch onto the carpet, with your knees hitting the soft dark green rug as they both stand over you, pulling down their pants in unison.
chad's cock springs free first, so heavy, dark and veined and already half-hard with the excitement from this exposure of you. he strokes it lazily, thumbing the tip as he looks down at you with that infuriatingly kind smile. "that's it, baby.... open up for me. you know you want to make it right." his voice is coaxing and condescending like he's praising a petulant child, rather than a girl who got caught talking to his roommate.
you part your lips, tongue darting out to lick the underside of chad's shaft for the first time, tasting the salty bead of pre-cum at the head. ethan watches, his own erection straining against his hand as he pumps it slowly. "look at her, chad. our eager little thing already drooling for it.... shit, I bet she's been dreaming about getting caught like this." ethan scoffs, but his eyes are gleaming with hunger rather than pure disdain.
after ethan's words as he stands behind your head, you take chad deeper, hollowing your cheeks as you suck and bob your head with practiced rhythm. the footballer's hand tangles in your hair, guiding you gently, "good girl, just like that... fuck you have such a pretty mouth, was it made for this?" the praise washes over you, urging you to please him more.
you gag softly as he hits the back of your throat with tears pricking your eyes, but you don't stop, swirling your tongue around the girth which nearly touches the top wrinkle of his heavy balls.
ethan kneels behind you on the carpet, yanking your leggings down over your ass and thighs, "spread those legs. let's see how wet you are from all this." the man's fingers hook into your black panties, pulling them down with a firm tug.
right away cool air hits your exposed pussy, and you moan around chad's cock, the vibration making him groan as ethan's big right hand lands a sharp slap against your ass, the sting echoing in the room.
"damn, you're soaked... fuck chad she's dripping!! what a greedy girl—getting turned on by your own mess-up."
chad thrusts shallowly into your mouth, his free hand cupping your cheek, "aw, don't be too hard on her, ethan. she's learning. aren't you, sweetheart? sucking me so nicely while he touches that pretty ass." you nod as best you can, saliva trailing down your chin as your body arches into ethan's touch despite the burn.
the guy behind you doesn't give you time to recover with two fingers plunging into your slick folds without warning. you cry out, the sound muffled by chad's length, but ethan curls them ruthlessly, hitting that spongy spot on the side that makes stars burst behind your eyelids.
"not so fast, don't go squeezing and cumming yet... this is about us setting things straight, not your fun." ethan's thumb circles your clit teasingly, building the pressure but pulling away each time you get over the edge.
frustration builds, and chad can tell from the way that your eyebrows flare and your jaw tenses. your hips start bucking involuntarily, but chad holds your head steady with his cock in your throat, "patience, baby. focus on me. make me feel good, and maybe we'll let you have a taste of finishing later." you redouble your efforts, deepthroating him with sloppy, wet sounds filling the room.
chad's breaths come faster, with his hips snapping forward as he praises you through gritted teeth, "fuck, yes! such a good little cocksucker. taking it all for me.... man, she is so obedient, you're luck you've already fucked her before."
ethan nods, looking up at chad with a smirk before he adds a third finger in your pussy, stretching you wide as his other hand delivering another firm spank that leaves your skin tingling, "she's obedient? ha... she's a needy thing who needs to be reminded of her place. look at her clench around my fingers... y/n is begging without saying a word."
he pumps harder, denying your climax again as your body trembles with unmet need. tears stream down your face, mixing with the mess on your chin from chad's cock, but the humiliation only heightens the ache between your legs which makes you drip all over ethan's hand.
finally, chad pulls out of your mouth with a wet pop, with his cock glistening, "enough enough enough, get up on the couch, y/n."
they guide you onto the brown cushions, positioning you on all fours facing chad again, the same position from on the ground. your knees sink into the soft fabric, ass raised toward ethan like an invitation as chad settles back against the armrest, his erection bobbing as he strokes it, "okay... keep going, sweetheart. suck me while he takes care of you from behind. show us you can handle both."
you lean forward, taking him back into your mouth with a hungry moan, your lips sealing around his shaft as you bob eagerly. ethan grips your hips, lining himself up with your dripping entrance.
lube isn't needed since you're slick enough from his earlier finger fucking. ethan pushes in slowly, the stretch making you gasp around chad's cock, "that's it, take me nice and deep. you wanted both of us? now you get it,." his voice is gruff, a touch mean in the way he holds you still.
thankfully, there's an undercurrent of encouragement, like he's enjoying the control without being vicious.
ethan starts thrusting, with backshots that rock your body forward, forcing you deeper onto chad with each snap of his hips. the couch creaks under the motion as your hands brace on chad's thighs as you suck him off, with your tongue working the underside while ethan pounds into your soaked pussy from behind.
chad's hand threads through your hair, guiding your pace, "breathe through it, baby. you're doing amazing... taking my cock in your mouth while he fucks you. such a good girl for us."
the dual sensations overwhelm you. you've never known how much you needed this until now.
ethan's relentless drive hitting deep inside, grinding against your walls. "fuck, she's gripping me so tight," ethan groans, with his fingers digging into your hips as he picks up speed.
the guy leans down eventually, with his lips lingering against your earlobe and his curls nearly hit chad's hipbone, "you're such a greedy and naughty girl, clenching like that. you love being in the middle, don't you? you're just our little shared plaything, right?"
you moan around chad, with the vibration drawing a hiss from him. chad cups your face as ethan moves back up, with his thumb brushing your stretched lips, "i know it feels intense, sweetheart, but hold back... no cumming until we allow it. prove you're sorry by pleasing us first." the words make you whimper, with your body trembling as ethan's thrusts push you closer and closer to the edge.
soon, ethan reaches around and his big fingers finding your clit and rubbing in firm circles, but he stops just as the coil tightens too much.
"not yet. you don't get to finish until we've had ours. keep sucking chad like the eager thing you are." the denial burns as your hips grind back against eth desperately, but he controls the rhythm and pulls out almost fully before slamming back in, each backshot jolting you forward onto chad's cock, your nose digging in his pubes.
sweat slicks your skin, and the room is filled with your muffled cries and skin slapping skin. chad's breaths grow ragged, with his hips bucking up into your mouth, "almost there, baby. swallow it all... be a good girl and take my cum." you hollow your cheeks, sucking harder, and he comes with a low groan, with hot spurts flooding your throat.
you swallow greedily, milking his balls dry as tears of effort streak your cheeks.
ethan doesn't let up, his pace turning erratic as he chases his release, "fuck.. 'm, fuck! gonna fill you up back here too. take it, all of it." he buries himself deep, pulsing inside you as his cum starts spilling hot on your gummy walls.
the sensation nearly tips you over, but he pinches your hip sharply, yanking you back from the brink.
"no, hold it. the lesson's not over."
you collapse forward onto chad's lap, panting as your body quivers. ethan pulls out slowly, a trickle of his release leaking down your thigh and he starts to rub your ass soothingly this time, the meanness fading into something almost affectionate.
"see? that's what happens when you play games.... but you're ours now, there is no more secrets and you get to have what you wanted."
chad strokes your hair, pulling you up to rest against his chest on the couch, "that's right, sweetheart.... behave, and we'll make it worth it next time."
you nod weakly, nestled between them, as you feel ethan's hand massage the sting on your asscheek.
there was no more juggling... you belonged to chad and ethan completely.
