Shit I Hate #1: Killing Villains
I love movies. I love superhero movies in particular. These statements should be no surprise to anyone. But like everything I love, these things have a lot of elements that just grind my gears, so I’m making an infrequent series for me to detail my issues in depth. And what better issue to start with than one of my biggest pet peeves with the superhero genre: killing the villain.
Now, comic books have always had wonderful rogues galleries full of insane and creative foes for the heroes to fight; sure, Spider-Man is interesting on his own, but he’s even better when you set him up against someone like Green Goblin, Mysterio, Venom, or Kraven the Hunter. Heroes are only as cool as the villains they fight, basically. And comic book movies have always done a great job of bringing villains to the screen, be they obscure or beloved… the problem is, by film’s end, these villains are typically dead.
Now, this pisses me off for a great many reasons, the chief among them that killing off the rogues gallery tends to spit in the face of the comics; sure, people like Norman Osborn have died before, so him dying is perfectly fine, but when you kill characters like Doctor Octopus, Ronan the Accuser, and the fucking Joker of all people, there’s a big problem. This almost always leads to cases where villains who could have been interesting recurring foes get totally shafted as a best-case scenario (which is the case with characters like Ronan, Joker, Penguin in Batman Returns, Ultron, and so on), or worst case a villain who was boring or poorly developed is not allowed to improve since they are now dad, with Malekith being the worst offender in this regard.
Now, to show you how widespread this issue is, I’m going back to the big kickstarter of this trend, Tim Burton’s Batman, and showing all the major superhero films that did this between then and today. Obviously I’m only going to focus on films that kill a major rogue of one of the main hero.
Batman: Jack Nicholson’s Joker is killed off
Dick Tracy: Almost every antagonistic force in the film is dead by the end.
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Shredder dies at the end. I believe this keeps in line with the original comics, but at this point in the franchise Shredder was an established archenemy; it’s a very weird case.
Batman Returns: Penguin and Catwoman are both dead at film’s end, though Catwoman is ambiguous… though she may as well have been dead for all the later appearances she made.
Mask of the Phantasm: One of the few animated films that sort of fall into this, Joker’s fate is rather ambiguous. While he still shows up in the series, this movie almost seems like it’s in its own canon. Again, very weird case.
Batman Forever: Two-Face falls to his death, though Riddler lives; he’s totally insane at this point but it’s still something.
Batman & Robin: As more evidence that this isn’t a terrible movie, none of the major villains die; Ivy and Freeze are both alive and locked up by film’s end, as Batman would do in the comics. Hell, Clooney’s Batman is the only Batman that has not in any way been responsible for the death of one of his foes in some way.
Return of the Joker: Batman’s biggest foe comes back only to be completely erased forever. He dies twice over the course of this film.
X-Men: Magneto is one of the biggest names to avoid this, as he has consistently survived every movie he’s in. Toad and Sabretooth are not quite so lucky here.
Spider-Man: Green Goblin dies, though at least this is in line with the comics and he does impact the whole trilogy. Still counts though, as he was a major antagonist for a long while before his first ‘death.’
Daredevil: This one actually has both Kingpin and Bullseye live; in fact, it is one of the heroes, Elektra, who dies.
X2: X-Men United: Stryker does die in this, as does Lady Deathstrike.
The Punisher: I really shouldn’t have to even list this, because with a guy like Punisher, no villain is coming out alive. This goes for War Zone later on down the line.
Spider-Man 2: Doc Ock is dead by film’s end. At least he didn’t posses Peter’s body.
Batman Begins: While Scarecrow is a notable aversion as he cameos in the following two films, the one DC villain best known for being immortal, Ra’s al-Ghul, dies at the end.
Superman Returns: Proving yet again that this film, while flawed, has the heart and spirit of
Superman right, Lex does not die in this film.
Fantastic Four: Doctor Doom doesn’t die, surprisingly.
X-Men: The Last Stand: Phoenix gets snikt’d by the end. Magneto, however, gets away.
Spider-Man 3: 2 out of 3 villains die, with only Sandman surviving; Venom and Harry Osborn are both dead at film’s end.
Ghost Rider: Blackheart dies, and I’m pretty sure a powerful demon like that doesn’t just die in the comics.
The Dark Knight: In a depressing twist, Joker lives, but Heath Ledger did not. Two-Face plays this straight yet again, dying with very little time to shine.
Iron Man: Interestingly, Iron Monger was originally going to be hinted to have lived. Perhaps he did, but right now everything points to dead.
The Incredible Hulk: Depressingly, every villain lives, but due to issues with distribution rights for Hulk, none of their plotlines have been followed up, meaning Abomination and Leader are in cinematic limbo.
The Spirit: The Octopus dies, which is the least of this film’s problems.
X-Men Origins: Wolverine: Deadpool dies, which is bad enough.
Iron Man 2: Whiplash is dead, but Justin Hammer is in jail. Yay. The lame villain lives.
Captain America: The First Avenger: Red Skull is maybe dead… though it’s not only ambiguous, but highly probable he’s still out there. For now, he’s presumed dead.
Thor: Loki is another notable aversion; he still hasn’t died after appearing in three major films.
X-Men: First Class: Not only does Sebastian Shaw die, but every single villain dies offscreen between this film and the next, which includes Emma Frost and Azazel.
The Amazing Spider-Man: The only thing this movie does right is letting the villain live.
The Avengers: Loki lives, as stated above.
The Dark Knight Rises: Bane and Talia are both dead by the end of the movie.
Ghost Rider: Spirit of Vengeance: Blackout dies.
Iron Man 3: The Fake Mandarin dies.
Man of Steel: As is well known by now, Superman snaps Zod’s neck, and Zod’s pals don’t fare any better.
Thor: The Dark World: Malekith dies, wasting any potential he may have had.
The Wolverine: Viper and the Silver Samurai both die.
The Amazing Spider-Man 2: In this not-so-amazing sequel, Electro maybe dies. Goblin and Rhino live, however.
Captain America: The Winter Soldier: Arnim Zola may or may not be gone for good; it’s pretty likely he’s still out there, but again, gotta presume him dead. Pierce is definitely dead.
Guardians of the Galaxy: Ronan the Accuser dies.
X-Men: Days of Future Past: Trask doesn’t die, yet another reason this movie is amazing.
Ant-Man: Yellowjacket dies at the end.
Shitastic Fuck: In this turd, Gimp Doom dies.
Avengers: Age of Ultron: Ultron is killed in an ambiguous fashion. Klaw, however, is ok, if down by a hand. Strucker on the other hand… dead. And so is Quicksilver.
Doctor Strange: Kaecilius is probably dead.
Batman v Superman: Luthor is sadly not dead, but Doomsday and KGBeast a re.
Suicide Squad: Enchantress gets killed in the end.
Captain America: Civil War: Zemo is thankfully alive at the end.
X-Men: Apocalypse: Apocalypse is blown apart in the end.
A LOT of these villains are dead, or if not, they never amount to anything ever again. It pisses me off that studios refuse to continuously utilize beloved foes, especially when it ends up going against a heroes code by letting the villain die or killing them themselves. It’s a trend I really hope dies off soon (ha ha).