You’re here with me, it’s like a dream [Early Draft]
Atticus had been pacing in the small hotel room for the better part of a hour, gripping a bottle of whiskey and trying to calm himself down. As soon as they had gotten back he had told the others to leave him alone, perhaps harsher than he meant to, and locked himself up in his room. He couldn’t stop thinking about those memories that had flashed through his head when Donahue cornered him. That fateful flash of light. William and Nancy lying on the ground. The dawning realization that they were dead. The memories had faded over the years, but now they were flooding back, as strong as ever.
Then there was what Donahue said. “No one will ever love you, Atticus. Because you aren’t worth loving.”
And Atticus believed him.
A knock on the door startled Atticus out of his thoughts. He chugged some of the alcohol, stormed towards the door, and almost ripped it open. Jesse was standing on the other side, flinching as the door flew open. “What do you want?” Atticus asked.
“Can we talk?” Jesse asked.
“No,” Atticus tried to shut the door, but Jesse stopped him.
“Please, I just want to help you.”
Atticus snorted humorlessly. “Why the hell would you want to help me? Leave me alone.”
“Atticus, please, I’m worried about you. Clara and Florence are too,” Jesse said.
Atticus’ jaw clenched. “Why do you people want to bother me so much? Just leave. Me. Alone.”
There was a few moments of silence before Jesse shoved his way through the door. “Okay, you know what? No. You’re not doing this shit tonight.” He closed the door behind him. Atticus took a step back, surprised by Jesse’s sudden shift. “You’re not going to push me away like this. I’ve been trying to talk to you through this whole trip, but you’ve just ignored me.”
Atticus snorted and set the bottle of whiskey down on the nightstand. “Oh come on, the last thing I need right now is a lecture from you-“
Atticus snapped his mouth shut, again startled by Jesse’s harsh tone.
“You can’t just shove people away like this. It’s not good for you, or us. You’ve done nothing but act like a pessimistic asshole this whole mission. Do you really want to treat us like that. Do you want to treat Clara like that?” Atticus winced at the mention of her. “Every time one of us tries to reach out and help you, you just run. But you can’t run from your problems forever. You can’t bottle up your emotions like you have been and wallow in your own self-destruction. If you just let one of us talk to you, we could help you. I could help you. But you have to let me help you.”
”…why are you so insistent on this?” Atticus asked dryly.
“Oh for god’s sake- because I care about you!” Jesse snapped. “We all do! Atticus, we’re your friends. Friends care about each other they help one another when they need it most. I don’t want to see you like this.” He took a deep breath and stepped closer to Atticus, resting a hand on his shoulder. “Please just…talk to me. Talk to me about what’s going on.”
Atticus’ heart was pounding in his chest. He couldn’t speak, and he could barely breathe. Jesse was right. Of course he was. He couldn’t run from his past forever. It seemed like it had a habit of catching up to him at the worst of times. But he was so scared of it. Scared of confronting it, scared of acknowledging that it happened. Because that meant facing the fact that he failed to protect two innocent people. One of which being his brother, no less.
“Fine,” Atticus finally said. “Fine. Let’s talk.”
Jesse looked relieved as he walked around Atticus. He grabbed the chair from the desk by the window. He put it in front of the bed, sitting down. Atticus sat on the bed, crossing his legs. “So, what happened back at that house?” Jesse asked.
Atticus glanced away, figuring out how to phrase his words best. “I ran into someone who…hurt me. He hurt my brother too, a long time ago.”
“Edward Donahue,” Jesse said.
“What did he do, exactly? Did it have to do with non-mages?”
Atticus felt his throat close up and could only nod. He really didn’t want to talk about this. He certainly didn’t want to talk about it to the man he was jealous of. But now he felt like he had no choice. So he looked out the window and began. God, he wished he had more whiskey right now.
“My brother William. He fell in love with a non-mage, Nancy, and broke the Code of Secrecy. He didn’t want to break things off with her though. So he planned on moving to Ireland or Scotland with her. You know, somewhere where the rules are a lot looser. He convinced me to come along. Thought I was too unhappy in New York and that a change of scenery would do me some good.” Atticus looked down, plucking at a loose thread on the blanket.
“I don’t know how, but the Keepers found out. We were traveling at night to the docks when they confronted us. An argument broke out, and Will tried to protect Nancy from getting her memories wiped. He casted a shield spell, and Donahue mistook it for a threat. So a fight broke out. I was just trying to fend off the Keepers, trying to get Will and Nancy out of danger. I didn’t want to hurt anybody. Then Donahue-” Atticus had to pause, his voice shaking as he spoke again. “He killed them. Both of them. He claimed it was an accident but I knew better than that”
“Then they arrested me. The jury said I was innocent and only trying to defend myself, but I think the USMC was just trying to cover their asses and keep the newspapers off their backs. Donahue wasn’t happy. He thought I should be sent to prison and rot as a traitor. So he did the next best thing he could think of.” His body was trembling now. He grabbed his right arm, running his thumb along the inner side of it. “He ganged up on me with a couple other Keepers as I was going home and…”
He gestured vaguely at the scar that covered the left side of his face. Jesse’s eyes widened with horror as the realization dawned on him. Atticus shrugged. “I suppose that’s what I deserve for failing to protect them.”
For a minute neither of the two men spoke. The only sound was some faint chatter in the hallway. Atticus couldn’t meet Jesse’s gaze. Each time he tried he felt like he was about to fall apart.
“I’m not a good person to be around, Jesse,” Atticus finally said, his voice hitching a little. “All I do is hurt people. It’s what I do for a living. And the people I care about get hurt or killed, so it’s for the best if they just stayed away from me. Because if I don’t hurt them, I’ll just be a burden on them. And I don’t want to put that on anyone.”
He put his head in his hands. He couldn’t do this. He needed to leave. He was just a drunken nuisance the others had to deal with. They didn’t deserve to deal with his shit. Not Jesse. Not Florence. Not Clara…God, not Clara. Not after how kind she had been to him. Panic flooded his chest. He couldn’t do this. He-
“Atticus. Atticus look at me.” Atticus flinched at the voice, and looked up to see Jesse was sitting beside him on the bed. He forced himself to look him in the eye. His gaze was soft and filled with empathy. “It’s not your fault. You are not a burden.”
Atticus took a deep, shaking breath. “You don’t know me Jesse, I’m not…I’m not a good person.”
“I think you are,” Jesse said. Atticus blinked. “The past doesn't define who you are, what you do now does. But only you can make yourself better. Nothing is going to change until you do. And you can’t love anyone else until you stop destroying yourself over something that’s not even your fault. And sure, maybe I don’t know you that well. But I believe you have as much capacity for good as anyone else. You just need to find it.” He took Atticus’s hand in his own, making his heart flutter a little. “It’s going to be okay.”
“You’re going to be okay.”
Atticus felt his resolve finally break. Tears he had been holding back desperately spilt out and ran down his cheeks. “How? How do I keep going when I have nothing left?”
Jesse pulled Atticus into a warm and tender embrace. “You don’t have to do it alone. You never did. You have The Order, you have Florence, you have Clara, and…and you have me,” he spoke gently, voice thick with emotion. Atticus buried his face into Jesse’s shoulder, letting out a sob. “We’re not leaving you. No matter how bad things get, not matter how dark the road ahead is, we’ll be right here with you.”
Atticus gripped Jesse a little tighter, and felt him adjust so they were leaning against the headboard. And for the first time he felt a spark of something he hadn’t felt in a long time.
It felt so small and so fragile, but it was there. That was all Atticus needed for now.
“Can you stay for a little longer?” Atticus asked weakly.
“Of course,” Jesse replied, resting his hand on Atticus’s head. “As long as you want me to.”
Atticus relaxed completely, practically melting into the embrace. Silence enveloped them again, but it felt more comfortable now. He focused on the sounds around them. Jesse’s steady breathing, the gentle thump of his pulse, faint voices from the hallway. For the first time in years, he felt completely at ease. He stayed holding onto Jesse and lost track of time.
Atticus didn’t realize he’d dozed off until sunlight hit his eyes the next morning. His head was pounding. He lifted his head and realized he and Jesse were still holding each other. Jesse was peacefully asleep, resting against the headboard of the bed. Atticus smiled a little at the sight. He slowly untwined himself from Jesse’s arms, making sure to not wake him up. He got out of bed and noticed the bottle of whiskey on the nightstand. It was almost empty. He thought about the conversation him and Jesse had the night before and grabbed the bottle, tossing it into a bin.