Listen. I just spent an hour and 15 minutes arguing with someone online who could not comprehend this, so I need to make a PSA:
ALL INSURANCE COMPANIES IN THE USA, IN ALL STATES, HAVE AT LEAST 60 DAYS TO RUN YOUR MOTOR VEHICLE REPORT (MVR) AFTER BINDING A POLICY WITH YOU. THEY CAN THEN ADJUST YOUR RATES, WITHIN THAT TIME PERIOD, BASED ON ANY NEW OR EXPANDED INFORMATION THEY UNCOVER. YOU CANNOT COUNT ON KEEPING THAT GREAT NEW RATE YOU GOT UNTIL 60 DAYS HAVE PASSED OR THE MVR HAS BEEN RUN.
So if you don’t report an accident? They can find it and surcharge your policy for it. If you report an accident as less serious than it was? They can find it and surcharge your policy for it. If you didn’t mean to report it incorrectly but you accidentally did because you’re not a fucking insurance expert? No static, but they can find it and surcharge your policy for it.
My solution to this is, whenever I contact a company to get a quote, I always call them on the phone so I can talk to a human being, and I ask that human being to go ahead and run the MVR at the quote stage. Typically they do this for me when I ask them to. That way, I can be reasonably sure the rate they’re quoting is the one I’ll get.
- Also -
Insurance rates fluctuate constantly in the background, kind of like gas prices but on a longer timeline. They will only CHANGE at renewal, but the fact that companies are constantly filing for rate changes based on other economic factors means your premium could go up, go down, or stay the same at any renewal. It doesn’t matter that you didn’t change your coverage. It doesn’t matter that you didn’t get any accidents or tickets. There are other factors that drive insurance premiums besides what you personally have done, and rates can change based on those other factors.
For instance: One of the industries that’s currently getting a ton of flak for using ‘inflation’ as an excuse to jack up their prices and throw money at their shareholders is the rental car industry. Insurance pays for rental cars. So if they jack up their prices, and we have to pay their prices (because the government hasn’t intervened and told them to stop fucking price hiking), then our premiums go up. The money has to come from somewhere, and premiums only come from one place - customers.
Another for instance: One of the industries that has increased their prices significantly lately due to COVID is the medical care industry. I absolutely believe nurses deserve massive pay raises after what we’ve put them through, I’m just pointing out that when they get massive pay raises, that raises the cost of medical care. Insurance pays for medical care. So when that price goes up, we need something to pay it with, and that ‘something’ is ‘premiums’.
I’m not currently discussing with anybody whether insurance is a giant scam or whether you should be legally required to have it or whether the pooled risk model is wonderful or terrible, because right now, none of that shit really matters. You ARE required to have insurance to drive a car, and these factors ARE influencing prices. Until that changes, all your objections are completely theoretical. The math is factual, and the math is what is affecting the cost of insurance, which affects all of our lives.
- sincerely, someone who has to explain this to people fifty times a day and really wishes I could have a different conversation once in a while.













