Never Trust a Pretty Girl With An Ugly Secret - Reaction/Response & Theory
In regards to @the-outlast’s Pretty Little Liars Blog/Theory “Never Trust a Pretty Girl With An Ugly Secret.”
First of all. Absolutely insane and bone chilling theory. It makes absolutely perfect sense. It’s not just like the liars coming up with some insane or stupid theory that came out of nowhere. This is some serious crime detective/private investigator investigating stuff.
Secondly. Ok remember that scene when Spencer visited Hannah while she was locked up by A.D. after she lied about killing Charlotte and got captured. Now, I don’t know about anyone else, but I thought that it was a dream. But think about it. EVERYTIME the liars got visited by Alison before she was revealed to be alive, they thought it was a dream, but it wasn’t. It was really her; just visiting at night when they had already fallen asleep so she could fool them into believing it was just a dream or a figment of their imagination, so it’s not impossible to think that it wasn’t a dream, and that it was actually Spencer.
Thirdly. Notice her hair. Some might think it wasn’t a big deal. Heck, I didn’t think it was small, but I didn’t think it was a HUGE deal until I read @the-outlast’s theory, and it got me thinking about this one scene that I couldn’t seem to shake off. I mean, I had already thought it was a dream. How could Spencer have possibly known where A.D./Amoji was hiding Hannah, and not get her out of there. Plus, look at her hair. It was a side bang, going to the left, which was the old way Spencer had her hair. Now, 5 years later, she has bangs. I mean parted in the middle and covering almost her whole forehead bangs, so it must have just been new Hannah just imagining up old Spencer in her head to think of a way to get out.
Although, maybe her hair was like that to make Hannah think it was a dream. I mean, come on, if Spencer is A.D., then she would know exactly where Hannah was being held at, but of course she couldn’t save her or else her friends would know somethings up. Sometimes simple things happen to explain complex situations. So, why not change her hair, that way she wouldn’t think that it was present Spencer visiting her. She had to make Hannah believe that she wasn’t real.
Fourthly, and I literally JUST thought of this. Why does Spencer know the cryptic meaning of every message A sends them? Like, even in the past, whether it was some foreign language, or Shakespeare, as @the-outlast has pointed out, she knew what it was or what it meant. Obviously, hopefully so we can finally end this confusing and curious torture, she has to be on the inside. Even if she’s not A, she’s gotta be working on her own on something, because she’s known, and always has, more than the other liars.
