Hi! I looove your blog. Spent days reading your posts. 😇
Anyways... some people on the internet say that "kiwi" is written by Louis. I was wondering what is your opinion on that.
Have a nice day/night! ❤️
Hi! Thank you <3 So so so sorry for the long wait anon, I had the idea to put anything and everything related to Kiwi, a whole Kiwi talk under here so I was just letting it chill in the drafts, but I think it’s gotten so big I need to split it up again.. So that’s why, oops.
To my understanding the idea that Kiwi is written by Louis comes from (twitter first of all) the point of view of the song making sense from his perspective and that Louis has said in an interview in 2017 he had written a song, a dance act, around 2015, and gave it to a big artist. I don't really see that calls for Kiwi being written by Louis because even if this was meant from Louis’ perspective (which I don’t think it is), guess what people can write from other people's perspectives. But I think that’s taking the song way too literal, and even if you were to pluck the words apart it’s still not from the perspective of the person that’s being told it’s his baby. "Oh I think she said: I'm having your baby", who is she saying this to? Sure it could be to the "I", but it doesn't have to be. "you[r baby]" can be anyone. And welp the song Louis gave to a big artist could be any song in the world yet somehow I feel like you can rule out Kiwi as he said the song was pitched for MITAM. Can you IMAGINE Kiwi coming out under 1D, with Louis' credits on it, or not even, just his voice on it alone, released during the height of bbg!? Or near it? Or??? Like are you kidding me? It's already insane enough Harry released it only about a year down the line. Like this stuff raises questions. I just think people take songs way too literal because they're confused Harry doesn't have a pregnancy scandal out there and then this explains it to them, then pair that with "proof" of Louis writing songs and giving them to other people as some kinda SEEEEEEEEEEEE he wrote Kiwi.
But none of that evern really matters to me much because if we just look at the lyrics it just reeks of Harry's writing. Louis' writing is very different, especially in 2015. Someone smart with these things could maybe do a deepdive into this and properly explain it, because I don't think I could put it into words. The buildup, the flow, the vagueness, the choice of words, the me me me, it all screams Harry.
