Continued from here @stellamane (because the post is a legacy post and it wasn't cropping/editing properly and I was tired of its madness, haha)
"Supposed to be?" Sabrina repeated back to him, giving him a look of daughterly exasperation as she did so. "You realise that's not actually a reason, right? It's the same as 'that's the way it's always been'. And, I'm sorry, but I'm never going to be on board with the idea of people being punished who don't deserve it." People like Jimmy, however? Oh yeah, they definitely deserved it.
"Snuffed out?" Sabrina winced, not entirely keen on the concept. Why couldn't their energy go into a new life, be reborn? Why did everything in have to be so...final? Wasn't there some nice, reincarnation option? Or, better yet, a test that someone could take to prove they didn't belong in Hell. "There's gotta be something better. You're telling me that in thousands and thousands of years none of you, not in Hell or Heaven, has ever thought that maybe the system is a little bit broken?"
And Heaven sounded just as bad as Hell. Judging people for what had happened to them, and rejecting them for their sexuality; how did that make them any different from Hell? They were all punishing people who didn't deserve it, not caring about which ones were actually bad people. It was awful, it was wrong, and it needed to change.
She was aware her father was trying to dig the infernal knife in with Lilith, trying to point her frustration and anger in that direction, but as many problems as she had had with the First Witch in the past, Sabrina couldn't deny that she'd also been helpful. And that she was generally more easily persuaded than her father. And, after all, she hadn't rejected the idea of a reformation of Hell when she'd been her regent...
"Sorry?" Sabrina realised she hadn't been listening, her mind consumed with other thoughts. She made herself quickly catch up "Yeah, it was a séance. The Weird Sisters and I, using my mother's wedding dress, why?"
It had been the one real time she'd ever gotten to speak to her mother, gotten to see her, to listen to her advice, and now her father was trying to taint that? Make it seem as if it had all be false, just some...what? Practical joke? A mean trick from the spirit world?
"She did got to Limbo, yeah, but she said that she could move on after..." Sabrina trailed off, frowning. "What do you mean someone would have used it for their own agenda? Pretending to be my Mom? Who would even do that? Who would even care that I wanted to talk to her about Harvey?" Why would it have even been a big deal? She wondered herself, unable to imagine it as important to anyone but a teenage girl. And who would known enough about Diana Spellman to pretend to be her? But then, Sabrina realised, she didn't really know her enough to challenge it.
"You'd do that? Bring my mom here, to Hell?"