── ★ ˙🔦 ‧₊˚ that was the worst part . . ᵎᵎ
ೃ⁀➷ pairing : post void!stiles x bsf!fem!reader
˗ˏˋ synopsis : the pain from the nogitsune doesn't leave with him and you're left trying to pick up the pieces of your shattered heart without your best friend. ୭ ˚. ᵎᵎ
𑁥౿ note : feeling angsty... hope u guys enjoy!!☺️ barely proofread, description heavy, miscommunication and arguing, the title is based on the demo of my boy only breaks his favorite toys by taylor swift and i would recommend listening to that if you can because omg it's so sad, maybe a happy part two ?
you knew stiles would never see you like that.
you knew. and yet you still couldn't help but feel it—a terrible, gut-wrenching need for him. all of the small, friendly, moments you could romanticize in your head meant more to you than anything any other guy had done for you.
there were plenty of them to choose from, you had guys lining up to treat you right. but you couldn't get yourself to like them.
you expected to live with this sinking feeling in your stomach every time he was around lydia—or any girl he liked—forever. he had no idea what it did to you, and you wanted it to stay that way.
but of course, of course, the nogitsune would see it. and of course he would use it. because why wouldn't he?
it was perfect.
you were stupid to not realize. the confession, the moment he kissed you, everything after that. it was all fake.
not the dream kind of fake, where you could accept that it was in your head, but the kind where it happened and still none of it was true.
it was a spirit, doing it for the sole purpose of your pain.
after the whole nogitsune and oni thing was over, you thought it would go back to semi-normal. you knew he knew. stiles had said he remembered everything.
everything, every moment he used your feelings to hurt you.
and you knew stiles, he wouldn't completely hate you for feeling like that. he probably wouldn't even be mad—probably not even uncomfortable. you thought he would come back to you no matter what, like he always said he would.
it started to slip your mind for a while—the death of allison, the whole introducing malia to the group, issac leaving—it wasn't your biggest problem.
but a week or two passed, then a few more, and the thought crawled right back in. it stayed at the forefront of your mind, torturing you all the time by never leaving.
you never talked to him.
you spoke—very briefly, in a group setting—but never talked.
you weren't expecting a love confession, or even to talk about any of it. not your feelings, not the things you assume he wouldn't want to relive. but you expected to at least have your best friend back.
every time you saw him it was like another stab in the chest. he stopped instinctively smiling at you but frowning, he avoided eye contact, he avoided sitting or standing beside you.
but he had no issue with malia, who was clearly all over him.
of course, that thought had you feeling insanely guilty. none of anything that was happening to you was her fault.
the day you finally snapped was when stiles deliberately ignored you.
you sat next to him on scott's couch while the others were still in the kitchen. not crowding, not even on the same sofa cushion. there was an entire body space between you, but still it felt charged with unspoken words.
you knew he felt it, your eyes on him, your need to talk.
there were no butterflies, no exciting nerves. only a deep fear of being rejected of friendship by your supposed best friend.
he glanced up to you—quick, too quick—and stood and left. you watched his frame leave the room, leaving his food and his drink on the table, the smell of his cologne still lingering in his absence. the cologne you bought him for his birthday.
silence. your brain was completely empty.
the bathroom door clicked closed, a sign that the moment was already over before it even began.
you hadn't even realized that you were crying. it wasn't loud, it wasn't supposed to be seen. the cold winter air bit at your face, sharp against your nose and ears, but you barely even felt it.
the warmth of your tears on your cheeks didn't register, and the lack of oxygen in your body wasn't enough to snap you back into it. there was a sinking, empty feeling in your gut, and you felt nothing else.
your breaths were shaky, uneven and short. your sobs racked through your trembling body—the cold only worsening the shaking.
when stiles emerged from the bathroom, he expected to see you either still sitting there or back to talking with lydia. when neither were there, he questioned it.
he knew it was wrong of him to avoid you, but every time he looked at you, all he saw was the pain in your eyes when he hurt you. he couldn't do that again. so he ran.
through the window, he could see you standing on the porch, crying. instinctively, he rushed out to comfort you, to hold you like he normally would. he regretted it the moment he saw your face.
your usually warm eyes, full of love and life, looked exactly as they did when the nogitsune hurt you. exactly what he'd been too scared to face.
and it was completely his fault this time. nobody controlled him but himself, and he made you look like that.
you turned around, expecting lydia or even scott. not stiles.
the scoff escaped your throat before you could stop it. "go away, stiles." you hiccuped, "please."
he watched you try to wipe your tears away, only for them to be replaced in an instant. your body language screamed that you were scared—of him, he guessed.
"are you—"
"stop." the finality in your voice caught him off guard, but he still didn't step back into the house. "i don't want to be around you right now. please, for the love of god, go inside, stiles."
your smile was a weak attempt at pretending you were fine.
stiles was always known to be stubborn, but for some reason you thought he might listen. you were wrong. "no, i'm not leaving you out here when you're crying."
"i want you to leave me alone."
"i'm not going to."
"fine. tell everyone i was sick or something, i'm leaving." you said firmly, ready to walk away. you were surprised by how well you held yourself strong against him, that you didn't cave, that your voice only barely cracked.
"no, you stop. what's going on with you?" he asked, his voice gentle along with his barely-there brush against your arm. your body turned to face him against yourself. "talk to me."
any crack in your walls was gone at that. he unknowingly ruined his chances of getting you to open up. you pulled your arm away, away from his touch that you so badly wanted to lean into. "fuck you."
"huh—what?"
"fuck you." you cried, another sob racking through you. his hands rested at your shoulders and you couldn't help but let him. your hands raised to his chest, stabilizing yourself.
"i have waited weeks for you to talk to me, about literally anything. and the one time, i just want to be left alone, you have to come and demand i talk. i don't want to talk, stiles!"
your voice is cracking—the sound of poorly repressed tears evident in your words—and you're hitting his chest. you feel like you're being mean but you can't find it in you to care. you want to hurt him like he's hurting you, even if it's impossible.
stiles was speechless. standing there, raking his fingers through his hair and debating what to do next.
"i'm sorry."
"i hate you."
"no, you don't."
"i wish i never met you."
you know you don't mean it. he knows you don't mean it. but it still lands exactly where you wanted it to.
you didn't know why you said it, honestly. maybe to get him to really leave you alone, maybe because your feelings were bottled up for too long, but you wished you could take it back.
he didn't say more. he just nodded, turned around, and went back in the house. his eyes were brimming with tears that he wiped away, and when everyone asked where you were, he did what you said to and told them you felt sick and went home.
nobody questioned it, but everybody knew it wasn't the truth.
when you got home that evening, you wasted no time in going to your bed to sulk. your body was exhausted from the sobbing and the fighting earlier, but yet your tear ducts weren't done.
and when you were halfway to sleep, the tears finally over and crusted on your cheeks, the framed photo of you and stiles on your nightstand flipped over because you couldn't stand to look at it anymore, your phone lit up with another ding.
9:02 pm
mischief: did you get home safe?
9:05 pm
mischief: look i know you don't want to hear from me, but if you don't answer i will come check for myself
12:16 am
new! mischief: we need to talk
new! mischief: please
new! mischief: i can't lose you
your plan to continue ignoring his messages was interrupted by a very quiet knock on your window. sliding it open, you held your ground and kept him out. "what are you doing here?"
masterlist
part two












