Nancy Wheeler from Stranger Things is a lesbian!
(Requested by anon)

seen from United States
seen from Indonesia
seen from United States
seen from United States

seen from New Zealand
seen from New Zealand
seen from United States
seen from United States

seen from United States
seen from Netherlands
seen from Israel

seen from Israel

seen from Sweden
seen from United States

seen from United States

seen from United States

seen from Israel
seen from United States

seen from Israel
seen from Sweden
Nancy Wheeler from Stranger Things is a lesbian!
(Requested by anon)
My Favorite Version of You
Pairing: Nancy Wheeler x Fem!Reader
Summary: While Nancy spends the afternoon buried in homework, you stumble across an old Polaroid camera and decide to capture your favorite version of her — the one no one else seems to notice.
Warnings: Just Fluff (Another fluff!?!? I must have been kidnapped and invaded by the body snatchers)
Word Count: 3.3k
A/N: I have been working on this for an embarrassingly long time, but we finally made it! I don't know why, but I envisioned Sodapop Wheeler for this fic, so here we are. It's funny because I originally planned for this to be a short, cute fic, but as in life, I don't know how to stop yapping. It was fun to do some pure fluff these past two fics, but I am ready to return to my regular angsty programming. As always, thank you so much for reading! I hope you enjoy and that you have a wonderful remainder of your day!
- Nebula
Masterlist | Stranger Things Masterlist
You make it fifteen minutes before the boredom sets in.
Nancy's room had settled into its familiar afternoon rhythm, pages turning beneath her fingertips, pencil scratching steadily across the margins of her notebook, the occasional creak of her desk chair folding into the faint hum of the neighborhood drifting through the open window.
And at the center of it all, you lay across the foot of Nancy’s bed, flipping lazily through one of the beauty magazines Mrs. Wheeler keeps in the living room. Every now and then you read one of the headlines aloud.
“‘Ten Ways to Make Your Hair Bigger.’”
Nancy hums absently from her desk, one knee tucked beneath her as she scribbles another note into the margin of her textbook.
Afternoon sunlight spills through the window, turning the dust drifting lazily through the room into tiny flecks of gold. It catches the loose strands of hair escaping her ponytail, softens the sharp edges of her desk, settles across the quilt beneath you. Somehow, the whole room seems to breathe around her.
Every so often she pauses, tapping the end of her pencil against her lip before returning to whatever problem has stolen her attention.
You don't mind. Not really.
There are worse ways to spend an afternoon than watching Nancy Wheeler disappear into her homework.
Watching Nancy do almost anything has always felt a little like watching rain gather against the window or listening to a favorite record play from beginning to end. Nothing extraordinary is happening. You're simply happy to be there while it does.
"'Are You Accidentally Ruining Your Skin?'" you read with exaggerated concern.
Nancy glances up, the eraser of her pencil caught between her lips. You catch the smile she's trying very hard not to let you see.
Victory.
You smile back as she ducks her head once more.
The magazine quickly loses its charm. You skim another page, then another, until a tiny blurb tucked into the corner catches your eye.
“This quiz claims it can tell me which celebrity I'm destined to marry,” you say with a gasp.
“That's nice, sweetheart.”
You grin.
“Want to know who I got?”
Nancy doesn't even pause her writing.
“I have a feeling you're going to tell me anyway.”
“I got you.”
This time she laughs.
It's barely more than an amused breath, quiet enough that someone else might have missed it.
You never do.
“That's not how those work.”
“It is now.”
She only shakes her head before returning to her homework.
Silence settles gently over the room once more.
Not empty silence.
The soft scratch of Nancy's pencil continues across the page. The clock on her nightstand ticks away another quiet afternoon. Every few seconds another magazine page whispers beneath your fingertips. Somewhere outside, a car rolls slowly down the street.
It’s the kind of quiet that doesn’t ask to be filled.
For another five minutes, it's enough — watching her. Sharing the same small patch of afternoon.
Then the boredom finally catches up with you.
You flop dramatically onto your back. “I'm bored.”
Nancy doesn't even look up. “I know.”
“No, I don't think you understand.”
“I understand perfectly.”
You throw an arm over your eyes. “I'm really bored.”
“You've told me.”
“I'm wasting away.”
“Mhm.”
“I'm going to perish.”
“Mhm.”
“They're going to find my lifeless body wasting away in your bedroom.”
That finally gets her attention. Nancy glances over her shoulder, one eyebrow lifting.
“That seems dramatic.”
“I think it's appropriately dramatic.”
“You've been here…” she checks the alarm clock “...twenty-three minutes.”
“And twenty-two of those minutes have been unbearably dull.”
She smiles despite herself, rolling her eyes before turning back to her notes. “I told you I had homework.”
“I know.”
“And you still wanted to come over.”
“Of course.”
“So this is entirely your own fault.”
“Maybe,” you say with a shrug.
Nancy huffs an amused laugh before turning back to her notes.
A few quiet moments pass before Nancy’s hand begins moving toward the edge of her desk. She doesn’t even look, just reaches blindly for the mug she'd abandoned ten minutes ago. Without thinking, you lean over the side of the bed and grab it, placing it into her waiting hand.
“Thank you.”
“You're welcome.”
Nancy takes a sip, still scribbling in the margins of her notebook. You can’t help but smile as you watch her.
God, she's so cute.
The tiny wrinkle between her brows when she's concentrating. The graphite smudged against the side of her hand. The pencil balanced carelessly between her fingers. The loose strands of hair catching in the afternoon light.
There are people who would only ever notice Nancy Wheeler when she was extraordinary.
You have always preferred this version.
Nancy catches you staring. “What?”
You blink.
“Hm?”
“You've been looking at me for an awfully long time.”
“I have a pretty view.”
Her cheeks pink just enough for you to notice. “Oh, stop.”
“I'm serious.”
“I know you are.”
She tries to sound exasperated, but she doesn't quite pull it off.
Nancy ducks her head again, hiding behind her homework. You watch her for another minute before deciding she looks entirely too focused to be distracted anymore.
Which leaves you with only one option. Entertain yourself.
Quietly.
You slide off the bed without a word.
Nancy doesn't notice. Her attention is still tucked safely inside her homework, exactly where she left it.
You wander toward her bookshelf, tracing your fingers over the worn spines of mystery novels you've already borrowed twice. Beside them sits a stack of old notebooks, their corners softened from years of being opened and closed, studied and forgotten. You pull one free, flip through a few pages of impossibly neat handwriting, then slide it carefully back into place.
"Hm."
Nothing interesting there.
Your gaze drifts lower until a shoebox tucked beneath the bottom shelf catches your eye.
Curious, you kneel down and pull it into your lap. The lid lifts away with a soft scrape. Inside is a little archive of Nancy.
Movie ticket stubs. The pressed flower you tucked behind her ear during your picnic last spring, its petals more fragile now than you remember. A handful of cassette tapes with careful handwriting stretched across their cases. Old photographs gathered together with a fading rubber band. Little pieces of an ordinary life, saved because they meant something to her.
You smile to yourself.
"You're sentimental," you murmur.
She would probably call it organized.
You know better.
Nancy has always collected moments the way other people collect photographs — quietly, carefully, never imagining anyone else would find them worth keeping.
"Hm?" she hums absently, never looking up.
"Nothing."
You keep digging. Your fingers brush against something smooth beneath the photographs.
You pause.
Then lift it free.
“Oo!”
An old Polaroid camera.
Your grin spreads before you even realize you're smiling.
Nancy hears the tiny sound from across the room and thinks nothing of it.
At first.
Finding little treasures has always been one of your favorite hobbies, especially when they happen to belong to her.
Her pencil keeps moving.
Another line in the margin.
Another page turned.
The clock still ticks softly from the nightstand. Somebody's lawn mower still drones lazily somewhere down the street. Everything’s the same, except for one thing…
You’ve gone quiet. Too quiet.
No commentary.
No humming.
No dramatic sighs about dying of boredom.
Nancy's pencil hovers over the page.
“...Sweetheart?”
No answer.
She frowns.
Silence has never really meant silence where you're concerned. More often than not, it means you're about to do something she probably isn't going to like.
Very slowly, she looks over her shoulder and finds you kneeling on the floor with the sweetest smile she has ever seen sitting innocently on your face. One hand clutches her old Polaroid camera against your chest. The other already threading the strap around your wrist.
Nancy narrows her eyes.
“...What are you doing?”
“Nothing.”
Nancy points her pencil at you. “I know that face.”
“What face?”
“That one.”
You glance down at the camera in your hands as though you've only just noticed you're holding it. Your smile grows brighter.
Nancy's stomach drops.
"Oh no."
Before she can cross the room—
Click.
The flash washes the room in white.
For the briefest heartbeat, Nancy's bedroom disappears entirely.
Then the afternoon comes rushing back all at once—the sunlight, the ticking clock, the smell of old books, your laughter filling every corner of the room.
Nancy throws a hand in front of her face much too late.
“...Seriously? You are unbelievable.”
She presses both hands over her face.
“I wasn't ready!”
You glance down as the square photograph slides from the front of the camera. Nancy lets out the most long-suffering sigh you've ever heard.
“You can't just take pictures of people without warning.”
“I absolutely can.”
“You absolutely cannot.”
“I just did.”
You carefully pinch the developing Polaroid by the edges, giving it your full attention. The glossy square is warm in your hand — the image is only a pale wash of color. Like the photograph is waking up.
“It's coming…”
Nancy folds her arms across her chest, not even looking at the photograph. She’s looking at you.
“I look awful.”
“You don't even know what it looks like yet.”
“I don't have to.”
“My hair's a mess.”
“Mhm.”
“I'm wearing one of my dad’s old sweatshirts.”
“Mhm.”
“I’ve been doing homework for an hour and I'm not even wearing any makeup.”
You finally look up at her.
“I know.”
Nancy blinks.
For a moment, she just looks at you.
"Then why would you take the picture now?"
You tilt your head, genuinely confused by the question.
"Because you look beautiful."
Nancy snorts. "I look like I haven't left my desk all afternoon."
"Exactly."
She stares at you and you smile — softer this time.
"This is my favorite version of you."
Nancy's brow furrows ever so slightly. "What?"
“Your ponytail's falling out,” you say, gesturing vaguely toward her head. Nancy instinctively reaches toward it and you smile.
You nod toward the graphite on her hand.
"You've got pencil all over your hand."
Her eyes instinctively flick down to the smudge. “...Oh.”
"You're swimming in that sweatshirt."
Nancy looks down at herself.
"It's comfortable."
"I know."
A tiny smile tugs at the corner of your mouth.
"The little wrinkle you get between your eyebrows when you're trying to figure something out."
Nancy's expression smooths immediately.
You laugh. "You stopped thinking."
Nancy narrows her eyes at you, though the smile tugging at the corners of her mouth gives her away almost immediately.
You are very familiar with the look on her face — equal parts fondness and exasperation. The sort of look that says she has every intention of rolling her eyes at you, even if she's already halfway to smiling.
The room settles around the two of you once more. The clock keeps ticking softly from the nightstand. Somewhere down the street, the lawn mower is still making its lazy passes back and forth. Afternoon sunlight stretches a little farther across the floorboards than it had a few minutes ago.
Between your fingers, the little white square waits patiently, changing slowly enough to make you question whether it's happening at all. At first there's nothing but pale washes of color, vague shapes, the promise of something waiting beneath the surface. Then, little by little, the picture begins to find itself.
You hold it carefully, watching the image bloom beneath the glossy surface.
Nancy finds herself watching you instead.
Not the picture in your hands, but the quiet delight blooming across your face as you wait for it to appear.
The way your eyes are practically sparkling with anticipation. The tiny smile tugging at your lips. Like you're waiting to unwrap the world's greatest present.
She huffs out a quiet laugh. “You know you're supposed to just leave it alone, right?”
You don't look away from the photograph.
"I am leaving it alone."
"You're staring at it."
"I don't think that's against the rules."
"I don't know…” Nancy leans against the edge of her desk, folding her arms. "I think excessive staring probably slows it down."
You finally glance up.
"...You're making that up."
"I might be."
"I knew it."
A grin tugs at the corner of Nancy's mouth.
“You looked concerned.”
“I was. I care about photographic science.”
Nancy laughs again, soft and easy, the sound folding so naturally into the afternoon that it almost feels as though the room had been waiting for it.
Your attention drifts back to the photograph.
"...It's changing."
Nancy instinctively steps closer.
The image is still faint — little more than soft shapes and shadows. But slowly, the outline of her desk begins to emerge. Then the window behind her. Then...
Nancy.
"There you are."
Nancy leans over your shoulder despite herself.
"...Let me see."
You hold it just out of reach for another second.
"No peeking."
"I'm literally the subject."
"Exactly."
"That means I should get to see it."
"You'll see it."
"When?"
"When I'm done admiring it."
Nancy rolls her eyes.
"You are impossible."
"So I've heard."
The picture grows clearer — more color, more detail.
The afternoon sunlight catches the loose strands escaping her ponytail just like you'd hoped. The oversized sweatshirt nearly swallows her whole. Pencil pointed at you as she had been warning when you pressed the shutter.
You stare at it for another long moment. Completely captivated.
Nancy shifts her weight. "...Well? Is it really that bad?"
Your head snaps toward her.
"What?"
"The picture."
"I never said it was bad."
"You've gone awfully quiet."
You look back down at the photograph.
Then smile so warmly it almost makes Nancy's chest ache.
“See for yourself, pretty girl,” you say, handing the photograph over.
Nancy groans immediately, rolling her eyes as she takes it carefully. She studies it and her nose wrinkles.
"I look tired."
"You look comfortable."
"My hair's doing something weird."
"It always does that."
"Thanks."
"I mean that as a compliment."
Nancy shakes her head, unable to stop smiling.
"You are so strange."
You step a little closer until your shoulder brushes hers. Neither of you moves away.
The photograph rests lightly between Nancy's fingers.
Outside, the lawn mower has finally gone quiet.
For the first time all afternoon, the house feels completely still.
"Maybe," you say softly, " But I think I like these moments best."
Nancy looks up.
"What moments?"
You glance at the photograph before looking back at her.
"The ones where you forget anyone's looking."
Nancy doesn't answer. She just waits.
You smile.
"I don't know..."
Your thumb brushes absentmindedly against the edge of the Polaroid.
"Maybe I just love these moments because I get to see the you that no one else gets to see."
Nancy only stares at you. For a long moment, she doesn't seem to know what to do with the words.
Her eyes drift back to the Polaroid resting in her hands, now fully developed, as though seeing both of you a little differently than she had a moment ago.
There she is.
Messy and ordinary — expression caught somewhere between exasperation and amusement.
Nancy studies it for a long moment.
“I still think I look ridiculous.”
You laugh softly. “I know.”
She glances up at you.
"You really mean all of that, don't you? You..." Nancy searches for the right words, her thumb absently tracing the white border of the photograph. "You really think this is the prettiest I've ever looked."
You smile.
"I didn't say the prettiest."
"No?"
You take a small step closer. "I said this is my favorite."
Nancy's breath catches almost imperceptibly.
"They aren't the same thing."
Her brow furrows.
"I don't understand."
"I know."
You reach out, gently brushing a loose strand of hair back behind her ear.
"Most people only get to see Nancy Wheeler."
Your hand slips gently into hers.
"The Nancy who's always got a plan. The one who always seems to know the answer before anyone else has even figured out the question. The girl everybody expects to have everything together."
Your gaze drifts toward the photograph.
"But I get this Nancy."
You smile softly, your thumb still tucked against her hand.
"The one who falls asleep halfway through movie night and swears she was 'just resting her eyes.'"
"I was."
You raise an eyebrow. "You were snoring."
"I do not snore."
"You absolutely snore."
"I absolutely do not."
You grin.
"The jury's still out."
Nancy nudges your shoulder with hers. "You're annoying."
"I've heard."
Your smile softens again.
"The point is..." You glance at the photograph. "I get the version of you that doesn't have to impress anybody."
Your eyes find hers once more. "And I think she's wonderful."
Nancy doesn't answer. She can't. Her throat feels too tight.
Instead, she looks back down at the Polaroid. Very carefully, she walks over to the open shoebox still resting on the floor. You follow behind her, curious.
Nancy kneels, lifting the stack of old photographs, the movie ticket stubs, the pressed flower from your picnic. All the tiny pieces of a life she'd quietly decided were worth keeping.
Then, with the same quiet care she'd once used to save the other momentoes of her life, Nancy slides the new photograph beneath them.
Another ordinary afternoon.
Another moment she can't quite bear to lose.
You smile. "Already?"
Nancy looks up. "It belongs in here."
"With all your keepsakes?"
She nods once. "Yeah."
You laugh under your breath.
"I feel a little honored."
Nancy closes the lid and sets the box back beneath the shelf.
When she stands again, she's standing very close. Close enough that your hands brush. She reaches for yours without thinking. Her fingers weave through yours like they've done it a hundred times before.
"...Can I tell you something?"
"Always."
Nancy looks down at your joined hands before meeting your eyes again.
"I spend so much time worrying about who I'm supposed to be..." She gives a small, almost embarrassed laugh. "...that I don't think I realized how nice it feels..." Her thumb strokes lazily across your knuckles. "...to know somebody loves who I already am."
Your heart aches. "Nancy..."
She shakes her head. "I'm serious."
Her smile is small. Shy.
"You make me feel like I can stop trying so hard."
Emotion catches unexpectedly in your chest. You lift your free hand to her cheek.
"You never had to earn being loved."
Nancy's eyes flutter closed for just a second, leaning instinctively into your touch.
"I know."
When she opens them again, they're impossibly soft.
"I think..." A tiny smile tugs at the corner of her mouth. "...I'm starting to believe you."
Your own smile trembles.
"I'll spend the rest of my life reminding you."
Nancy lets out the quietest laugh.
"I was hoping you would."
She closes the last few inches between you.
The kiss is unhurried, warm, familiar in the way only something well-loved can be, carrying none of the urgency of first confessions and all of the quiet certainty of finally being understood.
When you finally pull apart, neither of you moves very far. Your foreheads rest together.
You grin. "So..."
Nancy hums.
"Am I allowed to use the camera again?"
She narrows her eyes immediately.
"...Absolutely not."
You gasp dramatically.
"What if I ask nicely?"
"No."
"What if I promise to only take pictures of my favorite girl?"
Nancy groans, even as a laugh escapes her.
"You are never letting that go, are you?"
"Not a chance."
She rolls her eyes.
Then steals one more quick kiss anyway.
"Hopeless."
You smile against her lips.
"Completely."
Outside, the afternoon sun slips a little lower, filling Nancy's room with warm, golden light.
Inside the shoebox beneath her bookshelf, the newest Polaroid rests beside a pressed flower from last spring, a handful of ticket stubs, and a dozen other ordinary moments that had somehow become impossible to throw away.
This afternoon has quietly joined them. Saving one more version of Nancy Wheeler worth remembering.
If you want to be a part of my tag list, please submit an ask specifying series, fandom, or all and I will happily add you (If you don’t specify, I’ll just assume you want to be on the general list)!
Taglist: @paradoxicalconundrum @alyssajennwrites @miomao-ehe
Nancy Wheeler — Season 1
Woman of the Hour Part One
Pairing: Nancy Wheeler x Fem!Reader
Summary: As Nancy Wheeler’s career skyrockets, you find yourself struggling to fit into the polished, high-profile world that seems to suit her so effortlessly. After one devastating night at an awards gala leaves your insecurities spiraling out of control, Nancy is forced to confront just how deeply you believe she’ll one day outgrow you — and just how desperately she needs you to understand that she never will.
Warnings: ANGST (Hello, it's me! As if there would be anything else??), Insecurity/Feelings of Self-Doubt, Jealousy, Emotional Breakdown, Public Humiliation (Just an eensy amount. Nothing really major), Hurt/Comfort. Let Me Know If I Forgot Something
Word Count: 5.5k
A/N: This has turned into a mini rant, so if you want to se my real A/N , please see Part 2. So, ANNOYINGLY, I have to divide ANOTHER fic into two parts which is incredibly frustrating. I see fics on here that are like 13k, 22k, etc. But my 10k words can't be one full post. It's really so incredibly aggravating, especially since I KNOW you can post longer fics on here. I just wanted to get that off my chest and to say that, tragically, once again, there is a second part to this post. PLEASE read it, I beg. Since this seems to be a thing, would it be more helpful if I posted the second parts at the bottom of the fic rather than the top? Let me know
- Nebula
Masterlist | Stranger Things Masterlist
Woman of the Hour Part Two
Muted city lights filter through the floor-to-ceiling windows of the hotel suite, turning the room gold in places where the lamps don’t quite reach. Somewhere down the hall, a door slams and laughter echoes faintly from another suite. The entire floor is crowded with people attending the awards ceremony downstairs, all expensive perfume and pressed suits and carefully curated confidence.
Nancy fits into it all so naturally now.
Sometimes you still have to stop and stare for a second.
Not because you're surprised she made it here — you never doubted she would — but because you remember the girl hunched over newspaper clippings at two in the morning. The girl who chased stories with a kind of stubborn determination that bordered on self-destruction. The girl who spent years kicking down doors people tried to keep shut.
And now those same doors seem to swing open the moment she walks into a room.
You watch her from across the room as she stands in front of the mirror adjusting the cuffs of her cream-colored blazer, brow furrowed in concentration.
Some things, apparently, never change.
Even after years of interviews, front-page exposés, televised panels, and enough journalism awards to force the two of you to buy another bookshelf last spring, Nancy Wheeler still looks personally offended every time formalwear refuses to cooperate with her immediately.
A smile tugs at your mouth.
“You’re glaring at your sleeve again,” you say from your place on the bed.
Nancy looks up sharply through the mirror. “Because it’s crooked.”
“It’s a cuff.”
“It’s a crooked cuff.”
You laugh softly as you push yourself off the mattress and cross the room toward her.
“Move.”
Nancy huffs but obediently holds out her arm for you.
Up close, she looks beautiful enough to steal the air from your lungs. Not in the untouchable way celebrities look beautiful. She has never looked polished in the way magazine covers want women to look. Even now, there is still something slightly rumpled about her beneath all the expensive fabric and professional composure. Something sharper. Warmer. Real.
She has the kind of beauty that reveals itself slowly in her expressive eyes, her determined words, her crooked smiles, and the coffee-stained notes that scatter across the apartment at two in the morning. The kind that snuck up on you way back when, before you even realized it was happening.
The kind that somehow keeps finding new ways to take your breath away years later.
Your fingers smooth over the cuff, fixing it in less than five seconds.
“There,” you murmur. “Tragic fashion emergency resolved.”
Nancy narrows her eyes suspiciously. “You’re making fun of me.”
“A little.”
Her hands settle automatically at your waist.
Easy.
Instinctive.
“You nervous?” you ask her quietly.
For the first time all evening, Nancy hesitates.
Just slightly.
Enough for you to notice.
That, too, never changes.
To everyone else, Nancy Wheeler is composed confidence wrapped in sharp tailoring and clever answers.
But you've known her long enough to recognize the tiny tells. The way she taps her thumb against her index finger when she's thinking. The way she triple-checks things she already knows are correct. The way she gets quiet right before something important.
You know how much she cares. How badly she still wants to prove herself, even after everything she’s already accomplished.
“You already know the answer to that,” she tells you.
You smile gently at your girlfriend.
“You’re about to win another major journalism award, Nancy,” you shake your head, unable to stop smiling. "Do you have any idea how insane that is?"
"Apparently not."
"I do."
Because you remember every rejected pitch.
Every late night.
Every story that almost didn't make print.
Every time someone told her no and watched her find another way through anyway.
"Trust me," you murmur. "I know exactly how hard you worked to get here."
Nancy leans down and presses a quick kiss to your forehead.
“You look beautiful tonight,” she says.
You roll your eyes, fighting a smile. “Nancy—”
“You do.”
The words are quiet.
Certain.
Her gaze drifts briefly over your face before settling back on your eyes.
And suddenly you're painfully aware of every second you spent getting ready tonight. Every outfit you tried on. Every moment you stood in front of the mirror wondering if you looked out of place next to someone like her.
Because Nancy is looking at you like you're the most beautiful person she's ever seen.
Like she always has.
Like she always will.
Your throat feels suspiciously tight.
Which is ridiculous.
You've been together for years. You should be immune to this by now.
Instead, Nancy Wheeler somehow remains your greatest weakness.
You look away.
Dangerous. This woman is dangerous.
A slow smile spreads across Nancy's face. One she's clearly trying — and failing — to suppress.
"Oh, good," she says.
You narrow your eyes.
"Good?"
"I was starting to worry I'd lost my touch."
A laugh escapes you despite yourself.
Nancy's smile widens immediately, victorious. She still treats making you blush like a personal achievement.
She squeezes your waist once before she reluctantly steps back.
“We should probably go down before Elaine sends a search party.”
“You mean before she has an aneurysm because her star reporter is seven minutes behind schedule?”
“Exactly.”
You reach for your bag while Nancy grabs the room key, speech cards, and—
Your eyes narrow.
“What was that?”
Nancy freezes near the door.
“What was what?”
“That panic move you just did.”
“I have no idea what you’re talking about.”
“You just checked your pocket like someone carrying state secrets.”
Nancy scoffs far too quickly. “I’m making sure I have my note cards.”
“Mhm.”
You’re completely unconvinced by the explanation, but slip your hand into hers anyway.
Nancy intertwines your fingers immediately.
And just for a moment, before the doors open and the cameras start flashing and the networking begins and everything becomes overwhelming, she looks at you with something unbearably soft.
“Stay close tonight, okay?” she murmurs.
You beam at her, something warm settling in your chest.
“Always.”
The ballroom downstairs looks like something pulled from a movie.
Crystal chandeliers glitter overhead, reflecting warm amber light across polished marble floors and tables dressed in gold-trimmed linens. The room is filled with people important enough to make you instinctively straighten your posture when they walk by. Waiters weave gracefully through the crowd balancing trays of champagne flutes on silver trays while conversations melt together into a constant sophisticated hum.
It’s elegant.
Intimidating.
And painfully expensive.
Your hand tightens slightly around Nancy’s as the two of you step inside.
She notices immediately. Her thumb brushes once across your knuckles.
“You okay?” she asks softly.
“Yeah,” you answer quickly. “Just a lot of people.”
That earns you a knowing look. Nancy had always been unfairly good at reading you.
“We can leave early,” she murmurs.
You blink. “Nancy.”
“I’m serious.”
“You are literally receiving the Worth Bingham Prize tonight.”
“And?”
“And you cannot skip your own award ceremony because I got socially overwhelmed."
"Sure I can."
"Nancy."
"I've done it before."
"You skipped an awards ceremony?"
"No."
Nancy squeezes your hand.
"Left one."
"That's not better."
"It wasn't a very good speech."
You stare at her and she stares right back.
Completely serious.
Which is the problem.
She isn't joking.
Given the choice between a room full of influential journalists and spending the rest of the evening hiding upstairs with you and room service, Nancy would be in the elevator before anyone could stop her.
The realization settles somewhere warm in your chest — equal parts ridiculous and endearing.
God, she’s impossible.
“You’re terrible,” you inform her.
“And yet you remain obsessed with me.”
“Debatable.”
Nancy grins.
Before she can respond, a sharply dressed man with silver at his temples appears beside her.
“Nancy Wheeler,” he greets warmly. “There she is.”
Nancy straightens almost instinctively, professional polish sliding into place so seamlessly it almost startles you.
“Richard,” she says easily, shaking his hand. “It’s good to see you again.”
Again.
Right.
These are her people.
You stay slightly tucked against her side while the conversation shifts quickly into publication numbers, investigative sourcing, media strategy, and names you only vaguely recognize from magazines left scattered around your apartment.
Nancy handles it effortlessly, looking completely at home.
That’s the thing.
Years ago, she had to fight to be heard in rooms like this. Now people quiet for her.
It should probably feel strange seeing the same girl who once sat cross-legged on her bedroom floor ranting about corruption theories now being introduced as one of the most respected investigative journalists in the country. But the realization fills you with overwhelming pride.
The conversation moves on naturally without anyone acknowledging your silence.
Not intentionally rude.
Just easy to overlook.
Eventually, Richard's attention shifts toward you — a flicker of realization crosses his face — like he's only just noticed you're standing there. “And you are?”
Before you can answer, Nancy’s expression softens immediately.
“This is my girlfriend.”
She says it proudly, fondness warming her voice.
Something in your chest loosens.
Richard smiles politely and shakes your hand, though his attention drifts back toward Nancy almost immediately afterward.
You try not to let it bother you. After all, this night isn’t about you.
It’s about Nancy.
Everything she’s worked for.
Everything she deserves.
And nobody deserves this more than she does.
So you smile. Stay close like you promised. You listen quietly while Nancy moves through conversation after conversation with impossible ease.
Editors.
Reporters.
Executives.
Television hosts.
Everywhere she goes, people know her. Want her attention. Want her opinions. Want a piece of her time.
And through it all, Nancy keeps finding little ways to reach back for you.
A hand at your lower back.
Fingers brushing yours.
Small glances across conversations.
Silent check-ins only the two of you understand.
She’s trying. And so are you.
You smile when you're supposed to. Shake hands. Introduce yourself. Laugh when everyone else laughs.
For a while, it works — or at least you think it does.
Then someone makes a joke about a publication merger and the entire group laughs. You smile half a second too late after realizing everyone else found it funny.
A few minutes later, two reporters begin discussing a story that apparently dominated news cycles three years ago. You vaguely remember Nancy mentioning it once over dinner. Everyone else seems to have opinions, but you mostly nod and hope nobody notices you're lost.
Later, an editor asks where you're working these days and when you tell him, he smiles politely, moving on before you've even finished your drink.
The longer the evening stretches on, the more the room begins to feel like a world built in a language you only half understand.
And Nancy speaks it fluently.
Eventually, the noise becomes too much and you feel exhausted.
You’ve spent all evening trying to find your footing in a room where everyone else seems to know the dance already.
Conversations continued to flow effortlessly from one topic to the next: publications, elections, investigations, funding. Names and organizations and stories you only half recognize.
You tried your best to keep up, but now you need a break.
Nancy is currently cornered near one of the banquet tables by two senior editors deep in conversation about investigative funding cuts.
She catches your eye briefly across the room.
You tug on your left ear in silent reassurance — I’m okay.
Nancy’s expression lingers for a second longer like she isn’t entirely convinced before one of the editors reclaims her attention.
You wait until she looks occupied before quietly slipping toward the hallway leading outside the ballroom. The second the doors close behind you, the silence hits like a deep breath after being underwater too long.
You exhale slowly.
God.
You lean briefly against the wall, closing your eyes for a moment.
A burst of laughter echoes nearby.
Your attention drifts automatically toward the partially open lounge area a few feet down the hall.
Three people stand near the window alcove, drinks in hand.
You recognize two of them vaguely from earlier introductions. Executives maybe. Producers. Something important enough that everyone else in the ballroom had treated them like royalty.
You probably would’ve ignored them entirely if you hadn’t heard Nancy’s name.
“…brilliant, obviously,” one man says. “Probably one of the best investigative journalists working right now.”
Another person hums in agreement.
You beam with pride hearing them talk so highly of your girlfriend.
Nancy is brilliant. You've known that longer than most people in this room.
Long before the awards.
Long before the news articles and magazine covers.
Long before entire industries learned her name.
You knew.
You linger, listening as they continue talking about her. Discussing her latest investigation, her career, her future. Listening because you never really get tired of hearing people recognize what you've always known.
Pride swells warm and familiar inside your chest.
Then the woman of the trio laughs softly into her drink.
“I still don’t understand the girlfriend thing.”
Your stomach tightens instantly.
The woman speaking sounds amused more than malicious. Which somehow makes it worse.
“What do you mean?” someone asks.
The woman swirls her drink.
"I don't know. Nancy's become one of the most influential investigative journalists in the country," she shrugs. "I guess I expected..."
She trails off delicately.
Another voice finishes it anyway.
"Someone more established?"
Heat rushes immediately to your face.
You should leave.
Right now.
Instead, your feet stay rooted to the floor.
“She seems nice enough,” the first man says carefully.
“Oh, I’m sure she is,” the woman replies. “But image matters in this business whether people want to admit it or not.”
A quieter voice chimes in,“You’d think someone at Nancy’s level would want a partner who could actually navigate rooms like this.”
Soft laughter follows.
Not loud.
Not vicious.
Almost conversational.
Like they’re discussing politics or stock prices instead of another human being.
“She just appears so out of place. She looked absolutely miserable talking to Richard earlier,” one of them adds. “I honestly thought she was somebody’s assistant at first.”
That one lands cleanly.
Sharp enough to make your chest ache.
The woman gives a small laugh. "Honestly, I felt bad for her."
"For Nancy?"
"For the girlfriend."
The three of them share a laugh.
You want to argue. To list every reason they're wrong. To tell them they have no idea what they're talking about.
They don't know your relationship. They don't know Nancy. And they certainly don't know you.
But the argument loses momentum almost immediately.
Because tonight you had looked lost. Had stumbled through conversations. Had spent half the evening trying to figure out when to speak and when to smile. Had needed Nancy to rescue you from awkward silences more than once.
And suddenly every uncomfortable moment from the evening comes rushing back.
The woman sighs lightly.
“I just think Nancy could do better.”
She continues after a short pause, “Socially. Professionally.”
Something hot and humiliating climbs up your throat.
Not anger.
Not even jealousy.
Shame.
Because for one terrible moment, standing in the hallway outside the ballroom, you can see exactly what they see.
Nancy surrounded by brilliant people.
Powerful people.
People who know how to belong in rooms like this.
And then you.
You swallow it down hard.
One of the men gives an awkward chuckle. “Feels harsh.”
“Doesn’t mean it’s untrue.”
That finally forces your body back into motion.
You turn quickly before anyone can spot you standing there and head back toward the ballroom on unsteady legs.
By the time you slip back inside, your expression has settled into something carefully neutral.
Earned from years of practice.
Across the room, Nancy looks up almost immediately.
The second her eyes find you, her entire face softens. Like seeing you is the easiest thing she’s done all night.
The sight nearly breaks your heart.
Because if Nancy looks at you like that, why does everyone else seem so confused by the two of you?
You will your heart to stop racing as you move through the crowd, smoothing invisible wrinkles from your outfit just to give your hands something to do.
The conversation from the hallway still echoes unpleasantly in the back of your mind.
Out of place.
Nancy could do better.
Image matters.
You hate how deeply the words have lodged themselves beneath your skin.
Relief flickers briefly across Nancy’s face as you approach her. Not subtle relief, but the genuine kind. The kind that says she'd been looking for you.
Guilt twists sharply in your stomach.
Because while you've been standing in hallways listening to strangers dissect your relationship, Nancy has been worried about where you went.
She excuses herself from the group surrounding her and starts toward you without hesitation. Like finding you again had become her first priority.
“There you are,” she says gently when she’s finally in earshot.
Something in your chest aches.
You force a small smile. “Sorry. I just needed a minute.”
Nancy slows in front of you, eyes scanning your face carefully enough to make your pulse jump.
"Hey."
The single word is soft. Attentive.
Her brows furrow slightly.
“You okay?”
The question is gentle.
Genuine.
Which makes lying feel worse.
“Yeah,” you answer quickly. “Just needed air.”
Nancy's gaze lingers.
You know she knows that isn't the whole truth, but you can see her deciding whether to push.
Her hand settles automatically against your waist anyway, thumb brushing once against the fabric there.
Grounding.
Familiar.
Usually enough to settle every anxious thought rattling around your head.
Tonight it only makes you feel fragile.
“You sure?” Nancy asks softly.
Not suspicious or demanding.
Concerned.
Always concerned.
“Yeah,” you assure her.
The lie feels clumsy the moment it leaves your mouth.
Before she can ask anything else, you lean forward and press a quick kiss against her cheek.
A distraction.
“Aren’t you supposed to be networking right now, award winner?” you add quickly, forcing brightness into your voice.
That finally earns a reluctant smile from her.
“You’re making fun of me again.”
“Only a little.”
“Hm.”
Nancy studies you for another lingering second like she’s trying to solve something.
Then, mercifully, she lets it go.
“For the record,” she murmurs, leaning slightly closer, “I was already looking for an excuse to escape that conversation.”
You huff a laugh despite yourself. “Bad?”
“One of them said the phrase ‘media synergy’ four separate times.”
“Oh, that’s horrifying.”
“Thank you.”
The tension eases slightly.
Not gone, but manageable.
Nancy guides you toward the bar a moment later, her hand remaining steady at the small of your back.
Protective.
Instinctive.
Around you, conversations continue uninterrupted.
Everyone seems to know everyone. Everyone seems to belong.
A woman in a navy dress waves Nancy over from across the room and Nancy waves back automatically.
Another person stops to congratulate her.
Then another.
And another.
And suddenly all you can think about is how easily she fits here. How naturally she moves through all of it.
“Just another hour,” she promises as the two of you reach the bar.
“You say that like an hour isn’t devastatingly long.”
She snorts softly as she accepts two champagne flutes from the bartender before handing one to you. “You’re very brave.”
“I know.”
Her smile softens around the edges as she looks at you.
And there it is again.
That look Nancy gives you sometimes.
The one that still manages to make your stomach flip after all these years. Soft enough to make the entire room disappear for half a second.
Like no matter how many important people demand her attention tonight, you are still the person her eyes search for first.
Your chest tightens painfully.
Because if Nancy looks at you like that, if she still reaches for you first, if she still smiles every time she catches your eye across a crowded room...
then why do those comments hurt so much?
Why does a small, awful part of you keep wondering if everyone else noticed something you've somehow missed?
Something that won't matter tonight.
Or maybe even next month.
But someday.
Someday when Nancy finally realizes there are people in rooms like this who understand her world in ways you never will.
“Nancy Wheeler?”
The voice behind you is bright and confident.
You turn alongside Nancy to find another woman approaching the bar, somewhere around your age, dressed in an elegant, sharply tailored black suit with the kind of effortless confidence you immediately envied.
Pretty.
Polished.
Perfectly composed.
The kind of person who probably never felt awkward holding a champagne glass in rooms like this.
Recognition flashes across Nancy’s face almost immediately.
“Oh my god,” Nancy says, surprised. “Jordan Reyes?”
Jordan laughs warmly. “Okay, wow. I can’t believe you actually remember me.”
“Are you kidding? The Chicago corruption piece?”
“You read that?”
“I referenced that article for months.”
Your stomach dips. Not because of what she said, but because of how excited Nancy looks talking to her.
Not polite.
Not networking-mode interested.
Genuinely excited.
Jordan grins, clearly just as caught off guard by Nancy’s enthusiasm. “Honestly, hearing that from you might be the highlight of my night.”
Nancy laughs softly, and the sound scrapes against something raw inside you.
You hate that.
Hate yourself for reacting this way.
Nothing happening in front of you is inappropriate. If anything, it’s harmless.
But after the conversation in the hallway, your brain has apparently decided to weaponize everything.
Jordan speaks with effortless confidence, easily matching Nancy’s pace as the conversation shifts toward investigative ethics, publishing politics, and international reporting.
And unlike you, Jordan understands all of it. She understands the industry.
The networking.
The references.
The rhythm of this world.
And standing beside Nancy, she looks like she fits there effortlessly. Like she fits beside her effortlessly.
Meanwhile, you stand quietly off to the side suddenly feeling hyperaware of every awkward thing about yourself — where your hands are, whether you look uncomfortable, whether your silence seems obvious.
Jordan turns toward you with an easy smile.
“And you are?”
Nancy answers before you can, moving slightly closer to your side.
“This is my girlfriend.”
Immediate warmth softened her voice.
Pride.
Affection.
Possession, in the gentlest possible way.
It should’ve reassured you.
Normally, it would’ve melted you.
But tonight, your brain cruelly only hears girlfriend.
Not partner.
Not future.
Not enough.
Jordan offers her hand. “It’s nice to meet you. I’ve heard Nancy mention you before.”
That catches you off guard.
“You have?”
The question slips out before you can stop it. It sounds more surprised than you intended. More skeptical, too.
“Oh yeah,” Jordan says lightly. “Usually when she’s trying to pretend she has work-life balance.”
Nancy groans immediately. “Okay, that’s slander.”
Jordan laughs.
“Oh, so you two talk a lot?”
The words leave your mouth before you can stop them.
Not rude.
Not quite.
But enough.
Jordan blinks.
Nancy glances at you.
"We've crossed paths a few times," Jordan says easily, leaning against the bar.
Effortless and charming.
And another ugly feeling twists tighter in your chest.
Because Jordan fits here so naturally. Fits beside Nancy naturally.
Beautiful.
Smart.
Charming.
Accomplished.
She doesn’t need context. Doesn't spend half the conversation trying to catch up.
She keeps pace with Nancy effortlessly.
Challenges her.
Understands her.
And suddenly all you can hear again is: Nancy could do better.
What’s worse is you can see it.
The version of Nancy's life everyone in that hallway had been talking about.
Industry events. Awards. Long conversations about stories and politics and investigations.
Someone beside her who belongs in every room she walks into. Someone who speaks the same language. Someone who isn't constantly wondering whether they're enough.
Your grip tightens slightly around your champagne flute.
Nancy notices immediately.
Of course she does.
Her attention shifts toward you at once, brows pulling together subtly.
“You okay?”
Too perceptive. Too caring. Too much.
Because if Nancy keeps looking at you like that, you're going to tell her the truth. And the truth is ridiculous.
Embarrassing.
“I’m fine,” you say too quickly. Too sharply.
A tiny crease appeared between Nancy’s brows.
Jordan’s gaze flicks briefly between the two of you before she politely looks away, clearly sensing the shift in atmosphere.
“Well,” she says, “I should probably go rescue my editor before he starts introducing himself to senators again.”
Nancy laughs. “Probably wise.”
“It was really nice meeting you,” Jordan says sincerely to you.
"Mhm."
Jordan's smile falters almost imperceptibly.
Not hurt.
Just surprised.
“What was that?” Nancy asks quietly once Jordan disappears back into the crowd.
Her voice is low. Careful. Like she's trying not to push too hard.
Which only makes the guilt worse.
Your stomach twists.
“What was what?”
“You’ve seemed upset ever since we got here,” Nancy says carefully, the concern in her voice making everything feel worse.
Because she loves you so openly.
So instinctively.
And somehow you still feel like you’re standing beside a life you don’t belong in.
You look away first.
A mistake.
Nancy always notices that. Her expression sharpens immediately.
“I’m not upset,” you mutter before she can ask another question.
“Nobody says ‘I’m not upset’ like that unless they are absolutely upset.”
Normally, that would’ve made you smile. Made you roll your eyes. Made you admit she was annoyingly correct.
Tonight it just makes you feel exposed.
Before Nancy can press further—
“Nancy!”
Another voice calls her name from across the ballroom, waving her over to the stage area.
Frustration briefly flickers across her face.
“I have to—”
“I know,” you interrupt gently.
Nancy hesitates, clearly reluctant. “I’ll come find you after the speech, okay?”
You force a small smile.
“Go be famous.”
That finally earns the tiniest laugh from her.
But even as she steps away, Nancy looks back at you twice.
The second time, she almost stops walking altogether. Like she's reconsidering. Like some instinct deep in her chest already knows she shouldn’t be leaving you alone.
But they call her name again, escorting her closer to the stage and further away from you.
The ballroom lights dim slightly as the ceremony shifts toward the final award of the evening.
Around you, conversations soften into scattered applause while people reclaim their seats near the stage.
Nancy catches your eye from several rows ahead just before taking her place near the aisle.
You manage a smile.
She smiles back immediately.
Small.
Soft.
Only for you.
Then the announcer begins reading her introduction.
And suddenly the entire room belonged to Nancy Wheeler.
Not because she demanded attention. Because she earned it.
“Tonight’s recipient has consistently redefined what investigative journalism can look like in the modern era…”
Applause erupts around the ballroom.
You barely hear it.
Because Nancy is walking toward the stage now, elegant and composed beneath the golden lights, and despite everything twisting painfully inside your chest—
God, you are still so proud of her.
That feeling never disappeared.
Not even now.
The announcer continues listing accomplishments as Nancy reaches the podium.
International investigations.
Political exposés.
Awards.
Publications.
Legislation influenced by her reporting.
Every word makes the room admire her more.
And every word makes you feel smaller beside it.
You clap anyway. Because in spite of how you feel, Nancy deserves it.
She glances briefly toward the audience as the applause settles.
Toward you.
Always toward you.
Then she smiles faintly and adjusts the microphone.
“Wow,” she begins, breathless in that familiar way she gets when emotions catch her unexpectedly. “Okay. I had a speech prepared, and now I’m immediately reconsidering all of it.”
Soft laughter ripples through the room.
Your chest tightens painfully.
There she is.
Not the polished journalist everyone else sees.
Your Nancy.
The one who rambles when nervous. The one who steals your sweaters and denies it despite overwhelming evidence. The one who still leaves sticky notes on the coffee maker when she leaves early for interviews.
You swallow hard.
Nancy glances down briefly at her note cards before continuing.
“There are a lot of people I’m supposed to thank tonight,” she says. “Editors, researchers, sources, mentors… people who took chances on me long before I deserved it.”
Another ripple of quiet laughter.
“She cleans up well, doesn’t she?”
The voice beside you startles you slightly.
You turn to find an older woman settling into the empty seat next to yours, champagne flute balanced elegantly in one hand.
Nancy’s editor.
Elaine.
You’d met her a handful of times before.
Sharp.
Respected.
Intimidating in that effortless way powerful women often are.
You manage a small smile. “She does.”
Elaine’s expression softens slightly as she looks toward the stage.
“I remember the first time she pitched a story to me,” she says. “Terrifyingly intense. Twenty-two years old and already arguing with editors twice her age.”
A laugh escapes you quietly.
“Sounds like Nancy.”
“Oh, it absolutely was.” Elaine smiles faintly. “She’s only gotten scarier since then.”
Onstage, Nancy glances down at her speech cards before continuing. Your gaze stays fixed on her instinctively. You know that expression.
Nancy’s nervous.
Not visibly.
Nobody else would notice.
But you do.
You always do.
Elaine notices where your attention is and smiles knowingly.
“You must be very proud of her.”
You are. Impossibly so.
“Always,” you answer quietly.
Something thoughtful flickers across Elaine’s face.
“She talks about you a lot, you know.”
Your chest tightens.
“She does?”
“Oh yes.” Elaine sounds amused.
Then she sighs lightly, swirling her champagne glass.
“She’s becoming the face of investigative journalism whether she wants to or not,” she says. “It’s remarkable to watch.”
Something about her tone makes your stomach tense slightly.
“She’ll keep rising,” Elaine continues. “Five years ago I would've said national syndication was ambitious."
Elaine smiles faintly.
"Now I'd be surprised if she stopped there."
Onstage, Nancy smiles softly at something written in her notes.
Your heart twists.
“She deserves all of it,” you murmur.
“She does.”
Elaine’s agreement comes easily.
Then—
“Public life can be difficult on relationships, though.”
Your grip tightens subtly around your champagne flute.
Elaine continues watching the stage as she speaks, seemingly unaware of the damage each word causes.
“At Nancy’s level, image starts becoming part of the career whether you like it or not.” She glances toward you then, expression still perfectly pleasant. “The people beside you matter almost as much as the work itself.”
Heat creeps slowly up your neck.
“I suppose,” you say carefully.
Elaine hums softly. “It’s unfortunate, really. Nancy’s happiest when she’s allowed to just be herself.”
Something sharp lodges itself beneath your ribs.
Onstage, Nancy laughs softly at her own joke and the entire room laughs with her.
“She clearly adores you,” Elaine adds.
The words hit so suddenly your chest actually hurt.
Because you know that.
That’s the horrible part.
You know Nancy loves you.
You have never doubted that.
Not for a second.
That's what makes tonight so unbearable.
Because love isn't the thing you're afraid of losing anymore.
Elaine smiles faintly. “But eventually people at her level usually need partners who can move comfortably through these spaces with them. Public scrutiny gets exhausting otherwise.”
Elaine swirls her drink thoughtfully.
"The interviews. The events. The constant attention."
She shrugs.
"Not everyone wants that life."
The words aren’t cruel. Aren’t intentionally vicious.
Just honest.
Honest enough to destroy you.
Your pulse roars suddenly in your ears.
Every insecurity from tonight crashes together at once — the hallway conversation, Jordan, the awkwardness, the isolation, the feeling of constantly lagging one step behind Nancy’s world.
Onstage, Nancy looks out into the crowd again.
Searching.
For you.
Her gaze passes over dozens of people before finding yours.
The moment it does, she smiles.
Small.
Immediate.
Unthinking.
Like you're the person she was looking for all along.
And somehow that makes everything worse.
Because even now — even loving you, even choosing you, even looking for you first in a room full of people — a small, awful part of you can't stop thinking: she still deserves better.
Applause suddenly erupts around the ballroom. You startle slightly, realizing Nancy finished speaking. People rise to their feet around you.
A standing ovation.
Nancy’s eyes immediately find yours across the crowd.
The second they do, her entire face softens. Like your reaction matters more than the hundreds of people applauding around her.
Your vision blurs instantly. You stand too quickly.
You need air.
You need space.
You need five minutes to stop feeling like you’re about to fall apart in the middle of Nancy’s biggest night.
“Excuse me,” you manage quietly.
Elaine looks startled. “Oh— are you alright?”
You nod automatically even as your throat tightens painfully.
“Just overwhelmed.”
It isn’t even a lie.
Then, before Nancy can make her way back through the crowd and see the tears gathering in your eyes—
Because if she sees you, she'll abandon every congratulations, every interview, every person trying to get her attention.
And, god, you couldn’t ruin this for her.
Not tonight.
Not when this moment belonged to her.
So while the ballroom erupts around Nancy’s in celebration
—you turn and walk out before she can see you breaking apart.
If you want to be a part of my tag list, please submit an ask specifying series, fandom, or all and I will happily add you (If you don’t specify, I’ll just assume you want to be on the general list)!
Taglist: @paradoxicalconundrum
Cold Sheets, Warm Hands
Pairing: Nancy Wheeler x Fem!Reader
Summary: You wake to an empty bed and a silence that feels wrong. You follow it until you find Nancy alone in the night and learn the nightmares haven’t left her — not really. Sleep is something she’s learned to fear, but this time, she doesn’t have to face it alone.
Warnings: Soft Angst (I went easy on you guys), Hurt/Comfort, Mentions of Nightmares and Insomnia, Trauma Aftermath. Let Me Know If I Forgot Something
Word Count: 1.6k
A/N: New Nancy fic just dropped!!! I literally just wrote this today. Fastest I've ever cranked out a fic in my life, I think. There's not even really a plot to this. Just feelings, but, like, good feelings (I think). I don't know. I just wanted something really soft with Nancy. Oh! This takes place post-epilogue btw. Thank you so much for reading. I hope you enjoy and that you have a wonderful remainder of your day!
- Nebula
Masterlist | Stranger Things Masterlist
You don’t wake up all at once.
It happens slowly, the way it always does when something isn’t right — your body noticing before your mind catches up.
The room is still dark, the early hours of morning not quite ready to give way to light. Everything is quiet in that heavy, almost unnatural way that makes your chest feel tight before you even know why.
You instinctively curl inward, chasing warmth that isn’t there. Your hand drifts across the sheets, searching without thinking—
And finds nothing.
Just empty sheets.
The mattress beside you is flat. Undisturbed.
Cold.
That wakes you up.
Your eyes open, blinking against the dark as your hand presses more firmly into the space beside you, like maybe you’re wrong. Like maybe she just rolled away, or—
No.
It’s too cold for that.
Nancy’s been gone for a while.
For a second, you don’t move. You just lie there, staring into the dark, your thoughts sluggish and heavy with sleep, trying to piece together something that makes sense.
She’s probably just in the bathroom.
The thought comes easily. Automatically. Something familiar to hold onto.
You push yourself up onto your elbows, glancing toward the closed bathroom door.
“...Nance?” you call softly.
Nothing.
You listen, holding your breath.
No running water. No light bleeding under the door. No quiet rustle that says I’m right here, just give me a second.
Your stomach tightens.
Okay. Maybe she went to get water.
You swing your legs over the side of the bed, the floor cool beneath your feet as you stand. The apartment feels different at this hour — too still, like it’s missing something.
Like it’s missing her.
The air is cooler than it should be. The hallway is dark when you step out into it, eyes adjusting as you look toward the kitchen.
Dark.
Living Room.
Dark.
No soft lamp light. No TV left on low. No sign of her anywhere.
Your heartbeat picks up, just a little.
“Nancy?” you try again, a bit louder this time.
Still nothing.
Now it’s not just concern.
Now it’s that familiar, creeping edge of fear. The kind that fills in the silence with worst-case scenarios before you can stop it.
You swallow hard, forcing yourself to keep moving. You step further into the living room and stop when you see it.
There’s movement.
The curtain by the sliding glass door shifts, slow and soft, billowing inward with the faintest breath of night air.
It’s a small movement. Easy to miss.
But it’s enough.
Relief hits you so suddenly it almost makes you dizzy.
You let out a breath you didn’t realize you’d been holding, your shoulders dropping as you press a hand briefly to your chest.
“Of course,” you whisper.
The balcony.
You cross the room more quickly now, quieter somehow, like you don’t want to startle her. The curtain brushes against your arm as your hand finds the handle, hesitating for just a second before you slide the door further open.
Cool air greets you immediately.
And there she is.
Curled into the chair near the railing, blanket wrapped tightly around her shoulders, a mug cradled between her hands like it’s the only thing grounding her. She’s smaller than she would ever allow herself to be in the day.
She doesn’t notice you right away.
She’s staring out into the dark, distant and unfocused, like her mind is somewhere else entirely.
“Nance?” you say, gentle this time.
She doesn’t startle.
She glances over, eyes a little unfocused at first, like she’s still halfway somewhere else. Then she blinks, and you see her come back — see the exact moment she realizes you’re real.
“Hey, baby,” she murmurs, voice rough. “I didn’t mean to wake you.”
“You didn’t,” you lie, stepping closer. The cold from outside seeps through your thin sleep shirt, but you barely notice. “Something else did.”
There’s the faintest hint of a smile at that, but it doesn’t last.
You lean against the railing beside her. “How long have you been out here?”
Nancy shrugs, eyes drifting back out into the dark. “I don’t know. Couldn’t sleep.”
That’s not new. Not lately.
You glance at the mug. “Tea didn’t help?”
She glances down at the mug in her hands like she forgot it was there. Her fingers shift around it, adjusting, grounding.
“It did,” she says after a beat. “Just… not with the part that matters.”
You don’t push right away. You’ve learned that much — she’ll get there on her own, or she won’t at all.
Silence stretches between you, thinner now. Taut.
You reach for the edge of the blanket draped over her lap, tugging it lightly in a quiet question.
She hesitates.
Then shifts, just enough to make room.
That’s your answer.
You sit beside her, the chair not quite big enough for both of you, your thigh pressed against hers, your shoulder brushing hers now with every small movement. Up close, you can feel it — something off in the rhythm of her breathing. Too shallow. Too measured, like she’s thinking about every inhale.
You carefully take the mug from her hands, setting it aside. Then you reach back for her fingers instead, rubbing warmth back into them with your thumbs.
“They’re freezing,” you murmur.
Nancy huffs quietly. “Didn’t notice.”
“Yeah,” you say softly. “I figured.”
There’s a pause. The kind that isn’t empty — just full of things she hasn’t said yet.
You don’t rush her.
Instead, you lift her hand and press a soft kiss to her knuckles, lingering just a second longer than necessary.
Her breath catches — barely there, but you feel it.
You pull the blanket back over yourselves, trapping your warmth between you.
The night hums softly around you. Distant. Unimportant.
“I had another dream,” she says after a moment, voice quieter now.
You glance up at her. “Do you want to tell me?”
Nancy exhales slowly through her nose, her gaze finally dropping from the darkness to somewhere unfocused in her lap.
“It’s the same thing,” she says finally. “Over and over.”
Her voice is quieter now. Thinner.
“I fall asleep and I’m back there.”
You don’t interrupt.
“You’d think it would be… different, or blurry, or something,” she continues, a faint, humorless huff escaping her. “But it’s not. It’s exactly the same.”
You keep your touch steady — thumb tracing slow, absent patterns against her skin.
“I can smell it,” she says. “That— rotting, wet—” She cuts herself off, jaw tightening. You squeeze her hand gently.
“I can hear the vines. See them slithering and pulsing. See that monster—”
Her voice breaks, shoulders tense under the blanket, like she’s trying to hold it all in.
“And I know I’m dreaming,” she adds quickly, like that part matters. “I know I am. But it doesn’t change anything. I still—” Her breath catches. “I still feel like I’m stuck.”
There’s a beat.
“I can’t get out,” she finishes, barely audible.
The words settle heavy between you.
You shift slightly, turning more toward her, your knee nudging against hers.
“Nance…” you say, thumb resuming its abstract circles on the back of her hand.
She shakes her head immediately. “It’s fine. I just— I wake up before it gets—” She stops. Swallows. “Before it gets worse.”
Your chest tightens.
She lets out a shaky breath, her forehead dipping forward until it almost rests against yours.
You close the distance the rest of the way.
For a second, neither of you move — just breathe the same air, share the same space.
Then you lift your free hand and gently tuck a strand of hair behind her ear, your fingers lingering against her cheek.
“You don’t have to sit out here by yourself,” you say.
“I’m not by myself,” she replies automatically. “You’re here now.”
“That’s not what I meant.”
Another quiet stretch.
Then, softer, “I hate feeling like this.”
“I hate that I can’t just…” she gestures vaguely, frustrated. “Sleep. Like a normal person.”
“You went through something not even remotely close to normal,” you reply. “Your brain’s just trying to catch up.”
Nancy huffs a quiet, humorless laugh. “Feels like it’s doing a terrible job.”
“Maybe,” you say, squeezing her hand, “or maybe it just needs a little help.”
She looks at you again. “Yeah? Like what?”
You tilt your head toward the door. “Like not doing this alone at three in the morning.”
She lets out a small, tired laugh.
You smile faintly, bumping your shoulder against hers. A moment passes before your tone shifts again.
“I’m serious, Nance. I’m here,” you say quietly. “You can wake me up next time.”
She huffs softly. “It’s the middle of the night.”
“I don’t care.”
A small pause.
“…You say that now.”
“I’ll say it then, too.”
That earns a real reaction — a faint, tired smile you can feel more than see.
You shift, gently pulling the blanket wider before wrapping it around both of you, tucking it snugly over her shoulders and then your own. Your arms follow naturally, settling around her, drawing her in.
Nancy stiffens for half a second — out of habit more than anything.
Then she melts.
Her head finds its way to your shoulder, body folding into you like she’s letting herself stop holding everything up on her own for a moment. Her hand slips from yours just to curl into the fabric of your shirt, like she needs something solid to hold onto.
You press a gentle kiss to the top of her head before resting your cheek lightly against her hair.
The night stretches on around you, no longer sharp or empty but softened by shared warmth.
After a while, her breathing starts to even out against your shoulder. Not asleep — just calmer. Looser.
Safer.
You don’t rush her.
Don’t push her back inside.
You just sit there with her, under the blanket, in the cool night air—
Until she’s ready to try again.
If you want to be a part of my tag list, please submit an ask specifying series, fandom, or all and I will happily add you (If you don’t specify, I’ll just assume you want to be on the general list)!
JEALOUS NANCY JEALOUS NANCY JEALOUS NANCY
Perfectly Rational
Pairing: Nancy Wheeler x Fem!Reader
Summary: Nancy Wheeler tells herself she is perfectly rational — that the sharp pull in her chest has nothing to do with the way you with someone else, nothing to do with the space she feels slipping from her grasp. But when you get hurt and she isn't the one you turn to, she can no longer explain away what was has been brewing inside of her.
Warnings: Jealousy, Slight Possessiveness (but not toxic), Emotional Repression, Minor Injury, Mentions Blood and Bleeding, Very Light References to the Upside Down Trauma. Let Me Know If I Forgot Something
Word Count: 4.3k
A/N: Hi Anon! Thank you so much for this request. I was so excited to see this in my inbox!!! This was so fun to write and I really hope you enjoy. Thank you so much for reading and I hope you have a wonderful remainder of your day!
- Nebula
Masterlist | Stranger Things Masterlist
Nancy Wheeler doesn’t get jealous.
She simply isn’t the jealous type. At least that’s what she tells herself.
She is observant. Rational. Grounded.
Jealousy is reckless. Illogical. She doesn’t indulge in things she cannot prove.
So when she looks across the room and sees you laughing — not the polite kind you use when someone tells a bad joke, but the real one — at something Vickie whispers into your ear, she does not call the sharp pull in her chest jealousy.
She calls it distraction.
Distraction from the board game playing out before her — dice clattering across the table, Mike groaning dramatically as his character takes damage, Steve saying something loudly about how he definitely understood the rules this time, and Dustin immediately calling him out on it.
Your laugh cuts through all of it.
It bubbles out of you — light, unguarded—pitching higher at the end, catching slightly on the inhale like you’re surprised by your own happiness. It’s a sound Nancy knows well. It usually ends with your forehead pressed to her shoulder — close enough that she can feel it in her collarbone.
This time, it ends with your hand on Vickie’s arm.
Someone cheers at the table — Lucas, maybe — but Nancy doesn’t look. Her eyes narrow, jaw tightening as she watches you sit cross-legged on the couch beside Vickie. The redhead leans closer to finish whatever she’s saying and you meet her halfway, knees brushing. You don’t bother to move them apart.
You laugh again, softer this time.
“Shut up,” you say, but you’re smiling.
A cushion hits the floor somewhere behind Nancy. Lucas complains. Max laughs.
Nancy’s fingers tighten around her soda can and the aluminum gives with a soft, sharp crack.
She stills — looking down at the dent her fingers have pressed into the metal.
She’s being ridiculous.
You’re allowed to have friends.
Vickie Dunne is harmless. Sweet. Nervous. Still slightly overwhelmed by everything that’s happened to Hawkins.
And technically, so are you.
It made sense you would latch to each other. You were both pulled into this mess later than the rest of them — absorbed through proximity, through circumstance… through love.
Of course you’d cling to each other a little.
It’s natural. Healthy, even.
“Hey, Wheeler, you’re up.”
Nancy doesn’t respond.
“Nancy?”
She blinks, glancing up just long enough to see Dustin gesturing impatiently toward the board. She nods absently, like she’s listening — like she cares — then looks right past it again.
Back to you.
You whisper something in Vickie’s ear and her face goes pink. You both dissolve into giggles.
Something hot and sharp flares in Nancy’s chest.
She doesn’t like that she didn’t hear the joke. Doesn’t like that she wasn’t meant to.
You’re allowed to laugh, she reminds herself. Allowed to sit close to someone without it meaning something else.
Her stomach twists anyway.
She watches you grab Vickie’s wrist, stopping her from standing fully.
It’s casual. Thoughtless.
Intimate.
The kind of touch she has to think about before she makes.
Because when Nancy touches you, it is measured. Brief. Hidden in the space between glances. Something that can be explained away if anyone looks too closely.
A brush of fingers when handing something over. A knee bump that lingers just a second too long under the table. Late-night conversations where your shoulders press together in the dark, close enough to mean something, far enough to deny it.
This—
This isn’t that.
Nancy’s throat feels tight.
Steve laughs loudly and the sound grates against her nerves.
She tells herself it’s because the basement is stuffy. Too many people. Not enough air.
She knows it’s because she’s watching the way your hand lingers around Vickie’s.
You say something Nancy can’t hear. Close. Quiet. Your mouth near her ear.
Vickie smiles, nods, then slips free, heading for the stairs. The basement door creaks open, spilling brighter light down for a moment before it swings shut again.
You watch her go.
And for a moment — just a moment — you don’t look anywhere else.
Steve says something beside her that Nancy doesn’t catch. Because, for what feels like the first time all afternoon, your eyes finally meet hers.
Your expression softens instantly.
You smile at her.
And God, that smile is still hers. She knows it is.
You mouth, You okay?
Nancy nods once.
Of course she is.
She is not jealous.
She is simply watching.
And she will keep watching.
Because if there is something to see, she will be the first to notice.
A die skitters off the table and onto the floor finally bringing Nancy’s attention back to the game she was supposed to be playing.
Dustin groans dramatically as he scrambles after it, accusing someone — Lucas, probably — of sabotage. Max laughs, kicking her feet up onto the couch, while Steve leans back in his chair, balancing it precariously on two legs like he has something to prove.
The door creaks open again as Vickie returns, a soda already cracked open in her hand. She hands it to you without asking.
You thank her automatically. Like it’s expected.
Nancy’s stomach twists as she watches the condensation bead along the aluminum, a droplet slipping down over your fingers before you wipe it absently against your jeans.
It’s ridiculous. It’s a soda.
She has bigger things to worry about than who brings you a drink.
But she likes getting things for you.
Likes the quiet way you lean into her shoulder and murmur, “Can you grab that for me?”
Likes knowing she’ll notice before you even ask. The way your eyes flick to her first when you need something. The way you don’t even look around the room.
It makes her feel… needed.
Chosen.
Now she’s watching someone else step into that space like it’s nothing.
Like anyone could do it.
Nancy feels it then.
Not anger.
Not quite.
Something sharper.
Possessive.
Her spine straightens immediately, like she’s been caught doing something wrong — like the feeling itself is something she has to hide.
She is not jealous.
She is observant.
There’s a difference.
Across the room, Steve watches Vickie nudge your knee with her own. He’s half-paying attention to the game, half to everything else — as usual.
He smirks.
“Are you two, like, attached at the hip now?” he asks, gesturing lazily between you. “Seriously. I don’t think I’ve seen one of you without the other in, like, a week.”
Robin snorts from the couch, not even looking up as she flips through a magazine. “He’s not wrong.”
It’s light. Teasing.
The boys snicker.
Vickie goes pink, ducking her head as she tucks a piece of hair behind her ear.
You roll your eyes. “Oh my god.”
But you’re smiling.
Nancy isn’t.
Attached.
The word lands heavier than it should.
You don’t deny it.
You don’t correct it.
You just bump Vickie’s shoulder with your own, easy and unthinking, like it’s second nature.
Like it doesn’t mean anything at all.
Steve laughs, pointing between you again. “I’m just saying. It’s kind of adorable.”
“Steve,” Robin groans, finally looking up. “You call everything adorable.”
“Yeah, because everything is adorable,” he shoots back.
Adorable.
The word lands wrong.
Too soft. Too easy.
Nancy’s stomach tightens.
It’s ridiculous. It’s nothing. A joke.
But her chest feels hot.
Because she’s not the only one who sees it.
She’s not imagining it.
This — whatever this is between you and Vickie — it’s visible. Obvious enough to be named. Teased. Laughed about.
Adorable.
Nancy’s jaw tightens.
She doesn’t like that word on you.
Doesn’t like it attached to something that isn’t—
She cuts the thought off before it can finish.
You’re still smiling.
Still close.
Still not looking at her.
Something inside her shifts.
Not loud.
Not explosive.
Just a quiet, decisive click.
Before she can stop herself, she’s already moving toward you.
She tells herself she’s just… joining the conversation.
That’s normal. Healthy. Girlfriends join conversations.
But when she reaches you, she doesn’t look at Vickie.
She looks directly at you.
“Hey,” she says — and it comes out sharper than she means it to.
You blink at her, smile softening instantly.
There it is.
That look.
The one that’s hers.
Her shoulders ease before she can stop them.
“Hey,” you echo.
She lowers herself to the floor beside you.
Close.
Close enough that your knee has to move or press against hers.
She doesn’t give you the option.
Her thigh settles firmly against yours. Solid. Intentional.
Vickie pauses mid-sentence for half a beat — just enough to notice the shift — before her smile returns, a little smaller this time.
“What did I miss?” Nancy asks, voice even as she threads her fingers through yours, resting your joined hands openly against her leg.
Visible.
Undeniable.
It’s more than she should do.
She knows that.
Knows it the second she does it.
But she doesn’t pull away.
Robin, sprawled sideways on the couch, stills for just a second as she watches it happen—eyes flicking from your joined hands to Nancy’s face.
She doesn’t say anything.
Just presses her lips together and looks back down at her magazine, turning the page a little too deliberately.
You turn toward Nancy without thinking, your body following the contact like it always does, and Vickie shifts back an inch.
The movement is subtle. Automatic.
She tucks a strand of hair behind her ear, glancing briefly toward Robin like she’s checking something — then back to you, expression carefully neutral.
Relief floods Nancy so fast it almost embarrasses her.
She swallows it down.
See? This is fine.
You chose her.
You always do.
So why does it still feel like something is slipping?
-*-
The rhythm of the afternoon continues around Nancy like nothing ever shifted at all.
But it did.
She can still feel it.
The weight of your hand in hers. The way your thumb brushes once, absentminded, against her knuckles.
Grounding.
Familiar.
Hers.
You shift closer to Nancy, angling your body toward her fully like it’s the most natural thing in the world.
Like it always has been.
“So,” you say, glancing between her and the rest of the room, “are we still pretending I didn’t just win that argument?”
“You absolutely did not win that argument,” Dustin shoots back immediately, indignant as ever.
The room swells again — voices overlapping, the argument picking back up like nothing ever paused.
Across from you, Vickie laughs at something Robin says, but it’s quieter now. Less directed at you. Her posture angled just slightly away, like she’s giving space without making it obvious.
Robin nudges her with her shoulder again, murmuring something under her breath. Vickie rolls her eyes, but she’s smiling — easy, fond.
Normal.
Everything is normal.
Nancy exhales slowly through her nose.
This is what she wanted.
You’re here.
You’re close.
You’re looking at her again.
You glance down at your empty soda can, turning it idly between your fingers.
“I’m gonna grab another drink,” you say, starting to pull your hand from hers.
Nancy’s grip tightens instinctively.
Just for a second.
Enough that you notice.
“I can—” she starts.
You pause, looking at her.
And for a moment, it’s right there again — that quiet, familiar rhythm. The unspoken offer. The way she usually takes care of things before you even have to ask.
But then you smile, soft, easy. “It’s okay. I’ve got it.”
You squeeze her hand once before letting go.
The absence is immediate.
Colder than it should be.
Nancy watches you stand, brushing your hands against your jeans before heading toward the stairs.
Vickie glances up as you pass.“Hey, can you grab me one too?” she asks, almost absentminded.
You nod without stopping. “Yeah, sure.”
Nancy’s jaw tightens.
Of course.
Of course you do.
Robin’s gaze flicks briefly toward Nancy again — quick, unreadable — before she leans back into the couch.
The room keeps moving, but Nancy doesn’t hear any of it.
Her eyes stay fixed on the doorway long after you disappear through it.
She tells herself it’s nothing.
You’re just getting a drink.
You’ll be right back.
This is fine.
It is.
But then the sharp crack of shattering glass captures everyone's attention.
Nancy moves before she thinks, running to the kitchen where the sound came from.
Everyone follows — chairs scraping, Dustin yelping something unintelligible — but Nancy is faster.
Nancy’s heart is already in her throat by the time she reaches you.
Too fast.
Too familiar.
Her mind is already running ahead — cataloging outcomes, worst-case scenarios, the things she’s seen before. Blood that didn’t stop. Hands she couldn’t steady. The way panic makes people sloppy.
Not you.
Not again—
You’re standing near the counter, staring down at your hand.
“Shit,” you hiss under your breath.
Blood beads bright against your palm.
It isn’t a lot.
But it’s enough.
Nancy’s vision tunnels.
You’re bleeding and you’re hurt.
And she wasn’t there.
The thought hits sharper than it should.
She should have been here.
“I’m fine,” you say quickly, breath catching just slightly.
Steve swears loudly about his mom’s hardwood floors.
“Oh my God. Okay, don’t move,” Vickie says, voice snapping into something steadier than Nancy has ever heard it. Not nervous. Not flustered. Just sure.
Nancy stops.
It’s subtle. Almost invisible. That half-second hesitation.
But it’s enough.
Because Vickie is already doing what Nancy was about to do.
Already assessing. Already taking control.
She takes your wrist gently but firmly.
“I’ve got it,” Vickie says, already guiding you toward the sink. “It’s probably just a surface cut. Let me see.”
You let her.
Of course you do.
Because she sounds like she knows what she’s doing.
Because she does.
And Nancy stands there, hands hovering uselessly at her sides.
She knows what to do too.
Rinse first. Clear the blood. Check depth. Apply pressure if the bleeding continues.
But Nancy is a step too far away while someone else takes care of her girlfriend.
Everyone crowds in, peering over shoulders.
“Is it bad?”
“Do you need stitches?”
“Steve, do you even have a first-aid kit?”
“It’s fine,” Vickie says calmly. “Seriously. It’s not deep.”
Not deep.
Nancy already knew that.
She knew it the second she saw it.
That doesn’t stop the tightness in her chest. Doesn’t stop the way her pulse refuses to slow.
Nancy hasn’t moved.
She’s still close enough to see the thin line across your palm. Close enough to see the way your mouth presses tight, pretending it doesn’t sting.
But she isn’t the one holding you steady.
Vickie rinses the cut carefully, thumb braced against the inside of your wrist. Her touch is efficient. Clinical.
Nancy swallows.
She knows how to do this.
She does.
She’s cleaned worse than this. Stitched worse than this. Held pressure on wounds that didn’t stop bleeding so easily — hands slick with it, breath steady anyway. No hesitation.
She knows how to take control when it matters.
So why isn’t she moving now?
Because she’s not the one you’re looking at.
Your focus stays fixed on Vickie, following her instructions without question.
“Hold still,” she murmurs.
You do.
Immediately.
Nancy’s chest tightens.
It’s not the injury.
It’s this.
This space she should be in.
This moment she should be part of.
And instead, she’s watching it happen from the outside.
Again.
Nancy feels something ugly flicker low in her stomach.
It makes no sense.
This is practical. Necessary. Good.
Vickie reaches for a towel. “Just keep pressure on it, okay?”
Your fingers curl around the fabric she offers without hesitation.
You smile at her — soft, grateful.
“Thanks.”
It’s automatic.
Nancy’s jaw tightens.
Around her, the energy shifts. The crisis dissolves.
Dustin loses interest first, already asking if they can go back downstairs. Steve mutters something about sweeping up glass, grabbing a dustpan from the corner. The others scatter once it’s clear you’re not bleeding out on his floor.
Relief, collective and careless.
But Nancy doesn’t move.
She stays rooted exactly where she is.
Watching.
Vickie dabs gently at your palm, checking for more glass. Her touch is light now, less urgent but no less sure.
“You’re good,” she says after a moment. “Promise. It just looks dramatic.”
You huff a quiet laugh.
That laugh.
It bubbles up — higher at the end, catching on the inhale.
And once again, you lean toward Vickie when you do it.
Nancy feels it like a physical shift in gravity. Like something tilting just slightly out of place.
Robin is standing on the other side of the counter.
Watching.
Not you.
Not the blood.
Nancy.
Her head tilts slightly.
Nancy steps forward then. Finally.
“Let me see.”
The words come out sharper than she intends — too quick. Too controlled.
Vickie glances up, a flicker of surprise crossing her face.
For a second, she doesn’t move.
Then, carefully, “It’s really not—”
“I know,” Nancy cuts in.
Not loud.
But firm.
Certain.
Vickie stills.
Then steps back.
Just a fraction.
Just enough.
Nancy moves into the space immediately. Like if she hesitates, she’ll lose it again.
Her fingers wrap around your wrist, almost mirroring the way Vickie held you seconds ago, but tighter. More deliberate.
Your skin is warm.
Familiar.
Nancy examines the cut like she’s searching for something Vickie missed.
Something she can fix.
Something that makes this necessary.
Her thumb presses just a little too close to the cut.
Not enough to hurt.
But enough that you feel it.
She doesn’t find anything.
It’s exactly what Vickie said.
Surface-level.
Fine.
Her grip tightens anyway.
“You need to be more careful,” she murmurs.
It sounds steadier than she feels.
Controlled. Measured.
Like nothing is wrong. Like this isn’t about anything except the cut.
You soften instantly at the tone.
“I know.”
You squeeze her wrist lightly with your uninjured hand.
And there it is again — that grounding warmth.
That look.
Like she’s the one you’re tuned to. Like the room fades a little when she’s this close.
Relief spreads through her, slow and humiliating.
Because it shouldn’t matter this much.
Because she shouldn’t need this.
And yet, she can’t deny how it feels knowing you chose her.
You’re leaning into her now.
Not Vickie.
Her thumb presses, almost unconsciously, against the inside of your wrist.
Feeling your pulse.
Steady.
There.
Robin is still watching.
And there’s something knowing in her expression.
Nancy lets go of your wrist a second too late. Your skin slips from her fingers, warmth lingering where she held on.
Her pulse is still racing.
It was a small cut.
A stupid accident.
Nothing worth unraveling over.
So why did it feel like she was being replaced in real time?
She tells herself it was adrenaline.
She tells herself it was protective instinct.
She tells herself it was love.
But as Vickie tosses the blood-spotted paper towel into the trash and says lightly, “You’re lucky I was here, huh?”
Nancy’s stomach twists.
Her gaze snaps to the redhead before she can stop it.
Something sharp flickers across her face.
Gone almost instantly, but not fast enough.
Not anger exactly.
Something tighter.
Territorial.
Her eyes narrow just slightly. Her mouth presses thin.
Lucky.
The word lodges under her ribs.
Because she was here too.
She’s always here.
She would have handled it.
She does handle things like this.
The silence lasts less than a second. But it stretches — enough to notice.
Vickie falters almost imperceptibly — her smile wavering, eyes flicking between you and Nancy like she’s trying to place something she doesn’t quite understand.
And across the counter, Robin definitely notices.
Her gaze sharpens, just slightly.
Confirming her theory.
You don’t catch it — you’re smiling sheepishly, still holding the towel to your palm, shoulders a little hunched like you’re bracing for a lecture more than anything else.
Nancy forces a small, polite smile.
“Yeah,” she says evenly. “Good thing.”
The words taste wrong.
Because what she means is:
You didn’t need to be.
The thought is immediate.
Ugly.
Unfair.
Nancy feels it settle in her chest anyway, heavy and unwelcome.
Because Vickie didn’t do anything wrong.
Because you’re fine.
Because this shouldn’t matter.
And yet—
It does.
Robin clears her throat lightly.
“Hey, Vick, can you help me find the rest of the bandages? I think Steve’s bathroom is missing half its inventory.”
It’s casual. Offhand.
But her hand settles gently at the small of Vickie’s back as she guides her toward the hallway.
Vickie glances between you and Nancy for half a second — uncertain — before letting herself be steered away.
The kitchen grows quieter.
Just the low hum of the refrigerator.
The faint sound of Steve arguing with Dustin in the living room.
And you.
Still perched on the edge of the counter, towel wrapped loosely around your palm.
Nancy doesn’t waste the opening.
She steps closer.
Not sharp this time.
Not territorial.
Just… drawn.
“Let me see it again,” she murmurs.
You smile, a little sheepish. “Nance, it’s fine.”
“I know.” Her voice is softer now. Almost apologetic. “I just want to.”
You hold your hand out to her.
Trusting.
Nancy takes it carefully, turning your palm upward.
The cut is thin. Already slowing.
She traces just beside it with the pad of her thumb, not touching the wound — just close enough to feel the warmth of your skin.
“You scared me,” she admits quietly.
Your expression shifts immediately.
“I did?”
“When the glass broke, I thought— ” She swallows, unable to voice her true fear, but you don't need her to. You understand exactly.
“I didn’t know how bad it was,” she finally says.
You smile up at her, cupping her face with your uninjured hand. “Nancy, I’m okay. I promise.”
“Yeah,” she says. But she doesn’t sound entirely convinced.
She lifts your hand instead, pressing a small, absent kiss just below your knuckles — nowhere near the cut.
Protective.
Reverent.
Yours.
“You have to be more careful,” she whispers, but there’s no edge to it now. Just warmth.
You smile at her the way you always do when she gets like this — soft, indulgent, a little fond.
“Yes, ma’am.”
She huffs a quiet laugh despite herself.
Her free hand settles at your hip, grounding. Familiar.
“I just…” She hesitates.
This is where Nancy Wheeler usually doesn’t hesitate.
But with you, she does.
“I like taking care of you,” she finishes, barely above a whisper.
It’s not accusatory.
Not even pointed.
Just honest.
Your eyes soften.
“Nance.”
You say her name softly, like you already know there’s more she’s not saying.
Your thumb brushes just under her jaw, grounding, patient.
Nancy exhales slowly, like she’s bracing herself for something she doesn’t quite know how to say.
Her hand is still wrapped around yours.
Still holding on.
“I know it’s stupid,” she murmurs, eyes dropping briefly to your hand instead of your face. “It’s just—”
She hesitates.
That careful, measured instinct kicking in again. The one that edits. That filters. That keeps her from saying too much.
You wait her out.
You always do.
“I didn’t like…” she starts, then stops, jaw tightening slightly.
She’s frustrated now because she doesn’t have proof. Because she never says something she can’t defend.
So she pivots.
Safer.
Controlled.
“You and Vickie seem to be really close,” she finishes instead, quieter.
Not an accusation.
But not nothing, either.
You tilt your head slightly, studying her — trying to understand what she’s really saying.
“Yeah,” you say slowly. “We are.”
Nancy nods once.
You shift slightly in her hold.
“Okay,” you say carefully. “Where is this coming from?”
Nancy exhales through her nose.
“Nowhere.”
That’s a lie. You both know it.
“Nancy.”
She hates how gentle you sound. How easy you make this. Like this isn’t something sharp. Like this isn’t something she can barely hold onto.
Your gaze lingers on her for a second longer — taking in the tightness in her jaw, the way her grip hasn’t loosened, the careful way she’s choosing every word.
And something in your expression shifts.
Understanding.
You smile softly up at Nancy.
“You know how you and me are friends?” you say gently.
Nancy’s eyes flick up to yours immediately.
Sharp.
Searching.
“Yeah,” she says.
Careful.
You nod slightly toward the hallway, where Robin and Vickie disappeared.
“Robin and Vickie are friends the same way.”
It takes a second. But you can see it when it lands.
The shift.
The way Nancy’s shoulders loosen, just slightly — like something she didn’t even realize she was bracing against finally gives.
“Oh.”
Soft.
Quiet.
Relief, creeping in before she can stop it.
A giggle slips out of you before you can stop it.
You squeeze Nancy’s hand lightly. “I like Vickie,” you say, honest, easy. “She’s… easy to be around. She gets it.”
Nancy nods once.
She understands that.
Of course she does.
“But she’s not—” you start, then stop yourself, glancing briefly toward the doorway.
Careful.
Always careful.
Your voice drops instead.
Softer.
“She’s not you.”
Nancy’s breath catches.
Barely there.
But you feel it.
Her grip on your hand tightens just slightly, like she’s grounding herself in something real.
Certain.
“You’re—” you hesitate, searching for something safe. Something that won’t give too much away.
Your thumb brushes over her knuckles.
“You’re mine,” you finish quietly.
It’s subtle.
Could mean anything.
But it doesn’t.
Not to her.
Nancy exhales, something in her finally unclenching.
“Good,” she says, a little too quickly.
Then, softer, more honest, “Because you’re mine too.”
The words slip out before she can stop them.
And for once—
She doesn’t take them back.
There’s a flicker of something like surprise in her own expression… and then a small, almost embarrassed huff of breath.
But she doesn’t look away.
You smile.
Soft.
Fond.
Like this is exactly what you were waiting for.
“I know,” you murmur.
Your forehead nudges lightly against hers — quick, subtle, easy to miss if anyone walked in.
But it lingers just long enough to mean something.
Nancy’s hand tightens at your hip, grounding herself in the contact.
In you.
The jealousy, the sharp edges, the tightness in her chest — it all settles into something quieter now.
Not gone.
But understood.
From the hallway, there’s the faint sound of Robin laughing, followed by Vickie’s softer voice.
Normal.
Everything is normal again.
Nancy glances briefly toward the sound… then back to you.
And this time, she doesn’t feel like she’s losing anything.
If you want to be a part of my tag list, please submit an ask specifying series, fandom, or all and I will happily add you (If you don’t specify, I’ll just assume you want to be on the general list)!
nancy's a 10/10 with a slight problem




