“My family would kill me if they found out about us. Not to mention what they might do to you.” You’re not avoiding his gaze anymore, which makes it perfectly easy to see the worry in your eyes. He fights the urge to touch you, tries to use his words to soothe you instead.
“Listen, they don’t have to find out. Hell, no one does. We’ll just go on one date. We’ll get to know each other, like you said, see if this works. And, hey, if it doesn’t? We just stop. No harm, no foul.”
The foul would be that Eddie would lose the girl of his dreams after just one date, but a man only has to drink from the Holy Grail once to be changed forever.
“And if it does work?”
“Then, I die happy.”
Pairing: Eddie Munson x F!Reader
Summary: The Princess of Hawkins High gets swept away in a secret romance with local freak Eddie Munson.
Genre: Fluff, Angst, Hurt/Comfort
Content: no Y/N, dual POV, secret relationship, mutual pining, opposites attract, Golden Girl!Reader, 24814 words
You have a confession. You’ve sort of always had a weird, perverted interest in The Freak. Something about his long hair and dark aesthetic and tarnished reputation really turns you on in a way your usual palate of meatheads doesn’t, although you would never, emphasis on never, let anybody know that. You’ll sooner die than let word get out that you have the hots for The Freak King.
But, Eddie’s nothing like you’d thought he’d be: aggressive, hateful, maybe a little cartoonish in his villainry. He’s human. He’s a boy that gets flustered when a girl comes onto him, who refuses to mess around when drinks are involved, who posts himself at the door to keep anyone from taking that wasted chance for their own.
This Eddie, the real Eddie, is nothing like you fantasized about, and you’re not sure what that means.
Pairing: Eddie Munson x F!Reader
Summary: A one-time attempt to scratch an itch turns into something you aren’t prepared for when you realize that Eddie “The Freak” Munson is more than he seems.
Genre: Fluff, Angst, Smut, Hurt/Comfort
Content: no Y/N, Dual POV, opposites attract, secret relationship, friends with benefits to lovers, Bitch!Reader, 17415 words
Chapters:
1 - Feel the Rush - You - 1951 words
2 - Something There - You - 1445 words
3 - Dangerous Territory - You - 1820 words smut
4 - My Strange Addiction - Eddie - 4804 words smut
5 - Turn It Off - You - 1297 words
6 - Knocking on Heaven's Door - You - 1352 words smut
“Oh, so you get to sit around and do nothing while we freeze our asses off in some cabin and pretend to be madly in love? Yeah, right.”
Pretend. The words hurt against your will. It would be pretend for him.
Dean sighs, taking a moment to grovel internally before he perks back up, slinging his arm around you. “Well, maybe with you as my wife, it won’t be so bad, will it, honey?”
“Great, ‘cause your check-in time is tomorrow at four, Mr. and Mrs. Smith.”
Pairing: Dean Winchester x F!Reader
Summary: You and Dean pretend to be a couple to investigate a case, but what happens when things start to get a bit too real?
"Never gonna happen."
"Why the hell not?" Sam is exasperated by this game of yours at this point. He'd figured you out almost a year ago, which is kind of an achievement for you considering how long you've been pining after the older Winchester brother. And how goddamn nosy the younger one is.
"Cause I don't do casual. And Dean only does casual."
Pairing: Dean Winchester x F!Reader
Summary: You’ll never tell Dean how you feel because he’ll never settle for you. That is, until he realizes he’s just as desperately in love as you are.
Genre: Fluff, Light Angst, Hurt/Comfort
Content: no Y/N, friends to lovers, mutual pining, canon-typical violence, 8418 words
Dean’s an idiot. He knows it. Sam knows it. Everybody knows it.
So, it shouldn’t be a surprise to anyone that he’s somehow missing you when he’s the one that fucking left.
At first, he pretended he didn’t care. He filed you away with all the other girls he’d fooled around with and never saw again. But they didn’t stick in his head like you did. He wasn’t haunted by echoes of their voices or glimpses of their smiles. Just yours. He couldn’t get you out of his head, no matter how hard he tried. And he fucking tried.
“What the fuck is wrong with me?”
Pairing: Dean Winchester x F!Reader
Summary: A one night stand has Dean Winchester considering becoming an honest man.
Genre: Fluff, Self-Inflicted Angst, Smut
Content: no Y/N, Dean POV, one night stands, strangers to lovers, Reluctant Wingman!Sam, canon-typical violence, 9432 words
“A resort, huh? I could use a good vacation,” Dean says before gulping down most of his beer.
“An all-couples resort,” Sam emphasizes. “We can’t all go.”
Dean just shrugs and turns to you. “Well, princess, looks like you and I have a date with the ocean.”
“I actually think you should sit this one out, Dean. We’ll go,” Sam says, gesturing between the two of you. You try not to perk up too much at the idea. A romantic getaway with Sam?
It seems almost too good to be true.
Pairing: Sam Winchester x F!Reader
Summary: You’ve had a longtime crush on Sam, and when a siren starts attacking a couples resort, maybe you’ll finally get the chance to tell him. As long as you can both make it out alive.
Genre: Fluff, Minimal Angst (like abysmal)
Content: no Y/N, fake relationship, friends to lovers, canon-typical violence, 6740 words
“Seven years and four months. That’s how long my mate’s been gone, and that’s how long I’ve been waiting to get revenge on Dean Winchester,” she starts, and you have to refrain from rolling your eyes.
“I’ve been waiting for the day that I get to repay the favor. Seven years,” she scoffs. “That little manwhore took seven years to finally settle down with someone, but here you are. And sweeter still, you’re a hunter, too. Two birds, one stone.”
“When he finds you, he’ll have to kill you himself. What sweeter revenge is there than that? To have him not only witness what his love has become but to also have him put you down himself. He’ll have to live with that for the rest of his sorry life. And I, I can die happy.”
“One problem,” you jut in. “Dean doesn’t love me. Sure, he’ll be sad to see me go, but he’s not going to waste seven years lamenting over my death, unlike some people.”
To that, she only laughs.
“We’ll see, won’t we?”
Pairing: Dean Winchester x F!Reader
Summary: What do you do when you become the thing your lover hates most in the world?
Genre: Hurt/Comfort, Angst (for angst's sake), Angst with a Hopeful Ending
Content: no Y/N, established relationship, vampire turning,, self-hatred as a result of vampire turning, bittersweet ending, canon-typical violence, 5171 words
Sam needs you.
You’re good together, and Sam would take care of you. He’d nurse the hurt he can’t see, and you’d heal that broken thing inside him.
Sam needs you, and Dean doesn’t want you.
Looking at him now, with his pleading puppy dog eyes, you know it’s true and you know you can’t hurt him.
So, you squeeze the hand that feels so out of place in yours, and you say,
"Okay."
Pairing: Dean Winchester x F!Reader
Summary: You've always loved Dean, but Sam might need you more.
Genre: Angst, Hurt/Comfort
Content: no Y/N, alternating POVs, childhood friends to lovers, mutual pining, (eventual) emotional infidelity, 24000+ words
Chapters: (tentative) updates on Wednesdays and Saturdays
