“Hi, I have a reservation for 3 under the name Honey.”
You blew out a breath of cold air, shoving your hands into the pockets of the coat you had over your jacket. The host, unfamiliar to you as any of Carmy’s family, quickly scanned the list before nodding.
“Ah, yes, for 9:30. I’ll get you seated right this way.”
You shot a quick glance over your shoulder at your two best friends, Sophia and Josh, who were huddled together, grinning like they were in on the best secret in the world. Which, technically, they were.
“This is so exciting,” Sophia whispered, grabbing your arm as you followed the host through the restaurant. “I feel like I’m about to meet the president or something.”
“It’s just a restaurant,” you whispered back, though your heart was already pounding in a way that betrayed your nonchalant tone. “And you’ve met Carmy before. Multiple times.”
“Yeah, but not in his natural habitat,” Josh chimed in, squeezing Sophia’s hand. “This is his domain. His kingdom. We’re witnessing the king in his castle.”
You rolled your eyes, but you couldn’t help the smile that tugged at your lips. They weren’t wrong. This was different. You’d been to The Bear plenty of times—after hours, when the kitchen was quiet and Carmy would make you something simple just for the two of you, or early mornings when he was prepping and you’d sit at the counter with a drink, watching him work. But you’d never been here during actual service.
You’d never seen him in full chef mode.
And you wanted to. You wanted to see the version of him that everyone else saw. The one who was intense and focused and maybe definitely a little terrifying.
You’d heard all the stories from Richie and Syd from how Carmy was beforehand. Before you. You knew Carmy could be a storm in that kitchen. But you also knew the calm after the storm.
The version of him that he liked to reserve just for you.
The host led you through the dining room, which was filled with the low chatter of conversation, the clinking of glasses, the occasional burst of laughter. The lighting was warm, intimate, and the air smelled like garlic and butter and something caramelizing. It was beautiful.
You tried to keep your eyes forward, not wanting to give away your presence too soon. But you couldn’t help sneaking a glance toward the open kitchen, where you could see the flash of white jackets and the glow of the flames.
And then you saw him.
Carmy was at the pass, plating something with a level of concentration that made your stomach flip. His brow was furrowed, his jaw set, and his movements were precise, almost surgical. He looked so serious. So in his element.
You felt a rush of affection so strong it almost made you dizzy.
“Your table, ma’am,” the host said, gesturing to a small, cozy table near the window. “Your server will be with you shortly. Enjoy, and thank you for stopping by The Bear.”
You thanked him and slid into the seat that faced the kitchen, because of course you did. Sophia and Josh sat across from you, still holding hands, still grinning.
“He looked so intense back there,” Sophia murmured, leaning in. “Like, I’m actually a little scared.”
“That’s Carm, he’s in the zone.” you said, laughing softly.
“Should we wave?” Josh asked, already half-raising his hand.
“No!” you hissed, grabbing his wrist. “Not yet.”
They both gave you knowing looks, and you felt your cheeks warm. You’d been so excited about this surprise for weeks.
You’d planned it down to the last detail. The late reservation, the perfect timing so that you’d be here just before closing. You wanted to see his face when he realized you were here.
You wanted to see him break out of that intense focus and stress you know he carried so often and turn into your Carmy, if only for a moment.
You were still smiling to yourself when a familiar voice cut through the air.
“Alright, welcome to The Bear, the best damn restaurant in this city. My name is Richie and I’m—oh.”
Richie stopped mid-sentence, his eyes widening as he looked down at you. He was holding a small notepad and a pen, clad in a pristine tuxedo, clearly all business, but it faltered the second he recognized your face.
“Holy shit,” he said, his voice dropping. “Honey?”
You bit your lip to keep from laughing. “Hi, Richie.”
“What the hell are you doing here?” He leaned down to embrace you, lowering his voice like he was about to spill a state secret. “Does Cousin know you're here?”
“No,” you said, unable to hide your grin. “I wanted it to be a surprise.”
Richie’s face broke into a huge, delighted smile. “Oh, he’s going to lose his shit.”
He looked over at Sophia and Josh, pointing at them with his pen. “And you two! The lovebirds! I remember you from that thing at the—fuck, whatever, doesn’t matter. You’re here. Good to see you.”
“Surprise!” Sophia said, waving her fingers.
“Yeah, no kidding.” Richie was already backing away, his eyes still locked on you. “Hold on. Hold on. Don’t move. Don’t go anywhere. I’m getting him. Shit.”
He turned and practically jogged toward the kitchen, leaving you, Sophia, and Josh alone at the table.
“That was amazing,” Josh said, laughing.
“Yeah, Carmen’s gonna freak out,” Sophia added, practically bouncing in her seat leaning around to try and get a glimpse of the kitchen.
Your heart was definitely racing now. You watched the kitchen door, waiting, your fingers drumming nervously on the table.
It didn’t take long.
The kitchen door swung open so hard it almost hit the wall, and Carmy emerged like a man on a mission. He was still in his chef’s coat, his hair slightly disheveled, his eyes scanning the dining room with an intensity that made a few nearby diners look up.
And then his gaze landed on you.
Everything about him shifted.
His shoulders dropped. His expression softened. The hard, focused lines of his face melted into something open and surprised and so, so tender.
He was at your table in seconds, his hands reaching for yours, pulling you up out of your chair and into a hug that made your entire body feel warm.
“Honey,” he sighed, his voice muffled against your hair. “Fuck, what are you doing here? You didn’t tell me you were coming.”
“I wanted to surprise you,” you said, laughing as you pulled back just enough to look at his face. “Surprise.”
He shook his head, pulling you back into him again, a disbelieving smile spreading across his face. “God, baby, I’m so glad you’re here.”
“Hi, Carmen,” Sophia said, waving from her seat.
He blinked, as if just now noticing your friends were there. “Oh. Hey. Sophia. Josh.” He nodded at them, still holding your hand. “You guys are—yeah. Hi. How are you doing?”
“Good. We’re the surprise witnesses,” Josh said, grinning. “She’s been planning this for weeks.”
“Weeks?” Carmy turned back to you, his eyebrows raised. “You’ve been planning this for weeks and you didn’t say anything?”
“I wanted it to be perfect,” you said, shrugging. “And it is. Look at you. You’re all... chef-y. So handsome, Carm.”
He let out a huff, running his free hand through his hair. “I’m a mess, honey.”
“You’re beautiful,” you said, because you couldn’t help it, and you watched his cheeks flush slightly.
He squeezed your hand and then looked around the dining room, his expression turning serious, his anxiety and perfectionism taking over again. “You should’ve told me, you’re at Table 12. That’s... that’s not the best seat in the house. You should be at—hold on. Let me fix this.”
“Carmy, it’s fine,” you stopped him with a slight tug.
“No. No, it’s not fine. You’re not sitting at the worst table in my restaurant. Give me a second.”
He turned and walked toward the host stand, and you watched as he had a quick, quiet conversation with the host, gesturing toward your table.
You rolled his eyes at his dramatics, turning to see Sophia and Josh giving you impressed, knowing smirks.
“Stop it, guys,” you hushed them, your cheeks heating furiously with blush.
Back at the front, the host nodded, looking slightly flustered, and Carmy was back at your side in less than a minute.
“Okay, we’re moving you,” he said, already pulling you up. “There’s a better table in the back. More privacy. Better view. You’ll like it.”
“Carmy, we’re fine, you didn’t have to move us,” you said, letting him guide you through the dining room.
“You’re not fine. You’re my girl. You deserve the best seat in the house.” He shot a look over his shoulder at Sophia and Josh, who were following with amused expressions. “Both of you. You’re her people. You get the best too.”
He led you to a corner table, tucked away from the main flow of traffic, with a perfect view of the kitchen. It was cozy and intimate, and you realized he’d chosen it because it was close to the pass—close to him.
“This is better,” he said, pulling out your chair for you. “Sit. Stay. I’ll get you drinks.”
“We don’t have a server anymore,” you cheekily pointed out at the fact that he switched your table.
“You have me,” he said simply, and your heart did a little flip.
He disappeared into the kitchen and returned a few moments later with three glasses of wine, setting them down with care.
“On the house,” he said, looking at you. “Actually, everything’s on the house. Don’t even think about paying.”
“Carmy, that’s not why—”
“I’m not taking no for an answer.” He leaned down, pressing a quick kiss to your temple. “You’re here. That’s enough.”
He straightened up and looked over at Sophia and Josh.
“I’ll have them bring my specials out. Tonight we have our 72-hour lamb ragu, served over toasted bread rolls and chives. No allergies right?” Sophia and Josh both shook their heads. “Great, yeah, uh it’ll be right out.”
“Thanks man,” Josh nodded appreciatively while Sophia smiled, already sipping her wine.
Carmy nodded, gave your shoulder one last squeeze, and then headed back toward the kitchen.
But before he went through the doors, he turned back and crouched down to your side of the booth, his hand caressing the back of your head as he planted a soft kiss to your lips. You reciprocated, leaning in with fervor, smiling into the affection.
Carmy pulled away from the kiss hesitatingly, his hand resting on the side of your face. “I’m pretty busy back there, honey, so I’ll probably be in and out a lot.”
“It’s okay, Carmy. Go do your thing,” you nodded in understanding.
“Don’t leave, alright. Stay with me for closing.” His voice pitched up in a way that made you realize it was supposed to be posed as a question.
“Okay,” your face softened.
“Okay,” he repeated back to you, before placing one more lasting peck to your lips and disappearing into the kitchen.
Slightly dazed, and grinning like an idiot you turned towards your friends who couldn’t help but tease and swoon at your lover’s antics.
The rest of the evening was a blur of incredible food, good wine, and laughter. Richie and Syd came out a few times to say hello to you, and have small talk. Meanwhile Carmy sent out course after course—the best things on the menu, things that weren’t even on the menu, things he made up on the spot just because he wanted to see your face when you tried them.
Sophia and Josh were in heaven. They kept telling you how lucky you were, how you’d found the most perfect man on the planet, and you couldn’t argue with them.
Around midnight, the restaurant began to empty out. The last few tables paid their checks and left, and the staff started the slow process of cleaning up. Sophia and Josh finally stood, stretching and yawning, their plates clean and their glasses empty.
“We should go,” Sophia said, pulling you into a hug. “This was amazing, honey. Thank you for bringing us.”
“Thank you for coming,” you said, hugging her back. “I know Carmy was glad to see you guys here.”
“Anytime,” Josh said, clapping you on the shoulder. “Tell Carmy we said thanks. And that he’s a genius. And that we’re definitely coming back.”
“I’ll tell him,” you promised.
You walked them to the door, waving as they climbed into their rideshare, and then you turned back to the restaurant.
It was quiet now. The low music had been turned off, and the only sounds were the distant clatter of dishes and the low murmur of voices from the kitchen.
You made your way back inside, and Carmy was waiting for you at the host stand, his jacket off, his sleeves rolled up, looking tired but happy.
“They leave?” he asked.
“Yeah.” You stepped into his space, looping your arms around his neck, nuzzling your nose against his. “They said to tell you thanks. And that you’re a genius.”
“Yeah? They liked it,” he questioned you, wanting to be sure your friends enjoyed their experience.
“Of course, they loved it. Thank you for tonight, Carmy, it was great.” You say earnestly, easing his ever constant worrisome mind.
“Good, I’m glad,” he said, pulling you closer, pressing his lips to your jaw. “Now. About your surprise.”
“What about it?”
“I wish you would’ve told me you were planning to come.” His voice was soft, but there was a hint of something serious underneath.
“That defeats the purpose of a surprise Carm,” You tease.
“I know, I know. But I would’ve made sure you had the best table. I would’ve been ready. I wanted to see you walk in.”
“But you did see me,” you said, cupping his face in your hands. “And it was perfect. You were perfect.”
He sighed, leaning into your touch. “I just... I want everything to be good for you. Always.”
“It is,” you said. “Because I’m with you.”
He kissed you then, slow and sweet, and you felt the last of the tension leave his body.
“I love you,” he murmured against your lips.
“I love you too.”
You pulled back, grinning up at him. "So. You done for the night?"
"Almost." He glanced toward the kitchen, then back at you, his eyes soft. "Gotta finish closing up. But I have something for you first. A couple people want to say hi."
He took your hand and led you through the dining room, past the empty tables and the dimmed lights, toward the swinging doors of the kitchen. You felt a flutter of excitement as he pushed them open.
The kitchen was quieter than you'd expected, the chaos of service replaced by the methodical cleanup. A few staff members were scrubbing down surfaces, others were putting away ingredients, and Marcus was at the pastry station, carefully arranging something on a small plate.
Carmy cleared his throat, and everyone looked up.
"Hey, everyone," he said, his voice carrying that familiar mix of authority and warmth. "This is my girl, honey. She was at Table 15 tonight."
A chorus of greetings erupted from the staff. Syd waved again from across the kitchen, a tired but genuine smile on her face. Tina gave you a warm nod, wiping her hands on her apron. A couple of line cooks you didn't recognize offered friendly hellos.
And Marcus, ever the sweetheart, picked up the plate he'd been working on and walked over to you.
"Hey, Honey. I heard you were here and I couldn't let you leave without trying this." He held out the plate, revealing a perfect slice of chocolate cake, drizzled with caramel and topped with a delicate tuile. "It's a new recipe I've been working on. Extra for you."
Your eyes widened. "Marcus, this looks incredible. Are you sure?"
"I'm sure." He grinned, glancing at Carmy. "Carmen's been talking about you all night. Figured you deserved something special."
You felt your cheeks warm as you accepted the plate. "Thank you. Seriously, this is so sweet of you."
"Anytime, Honey." He gave you a little wink before heading back to clean his station.
Richie sidled up next to you, a smug grin plastered across his face. "So, how was dinner, huh? Everything to your liking?"
"It was amazing, Richie. Thank you for taking care of us."
"Oh, I didn't do much." He leaned in, lowering his voice conspiratorially. "Good thing, too, because cousin came busting back in here and demanded that you only had the best because his girl was here. Made sure every single person in this kitchen knew who you were and that you get VIP treatment."
You felt the heat creep up your neck, your blush intensifying. "He did not."
"Oh, he absolutely did." Richie laughed, clapping Carmy on the shoulder. "My guy was pacing back here like a nervous wreck, making sure every plate that went out to your table was perfect. Never seen him like that."
"Richie, shut up," Carmy muttered, his arm sliding around your waist.
"It's sweet," Syd called from across the kitchen, a teasing lilt in her voice. "He was like a little puppy. 'Is the lamb ragu good enough? Should I add more chives? Does she even like chives?'"
"Alright, that's enough," Carmy said, but his ears were turning pink, and you couldn't help but laugh, tucking your head into his shoulder to hide your burning cheeks.
"Don't worry, Honey," Tina added, drying her hands on a towel. "We made sure he didn't mess it up. You got the best of the best tonight."
"Thank you, everyone," you managed, your voice muffled against Carmy's coat. "Really. It was perfect."
Carmy squeezed your waist, then gently guided you away from the group. "Okay. Office. Now."
He led you through the back hall and into his small office, closing the door behind you. The room was cluttered but cozy—a desk covered in papers, a few framed photos, a worn-out couch in the corner.
He gestured for you to sit, and you settled onto the couch, the plate of Marcus's cake balanced on your lap.
"Here," he said, grabbing a fork and handing it to you. "Eat. Before it gets cold. Or, uh, room temperature. Whatever."
You laughed and took a bite, a small moan escaping your lips. "Oh my God. This is incredible. Marcus is phenomenal."
"Yeah, he's alright," Carmy said, but he was watching you with such intense fondness that you felt your heart swell.
You took another bite, then held out the fork to him. "Try it."
He leaned in, taking the bite from your fork, his eyes never leaving yours. "Good," he said, his voice low. "Really good."
The air between you shifted, charged and warm. Carmy set the plate aside carefully, his hand coming up to cup your face, thumb brushing across your cheekbone.
"You have no idea how beautiful you look tonight," he murmured, leaning in. "Sitting there, in my restaurant, with my food. Like you belonged there."
"I did belong there," you whispered back. "I belong wherever you are."
He kissed you then, deep and hungry, his free hand sliding into your hair, tilting your head back. You responded eagerly, your hands gripping the front of his coat, pulling him impossibly closer.
The kiss grew heated, his mouth moving against yours with a desperation that made your head spin. He shifted, one knee pressing onto the couch between your thighs, and you let out a soft gasp as his weight settled against you.
"Carmy," you breathed, but it came out more like a plea.
"I know," he murmured against your neck, his lips trailing down your jaw, your throat. "I know, baby. I just—fuck, I've been thinking about you all night. Watching you. Wanting you."
His hips pressed forward, a subtle, instinctive roll against yours, and you felt the hardness of him even through the layers of clothing. Your breath hitched, your hands fisting in his coat as he did it again, a small, desperate grind that sent sparks through your entire body.
"Carmy," you said again, your voice shaky.
He pulled back just enough to look at you, his pupils blown wide, his lips kiss-swollen and parted. "Sorry. I'm sorry. I just—"
"Don't apologize," you cut him off, pulling him back down for another kiss. "Just—don't stop."
He groaned against your mouth, his hips rolling against yours once more, and you arched into him, the friction delicious and maddening. His hand slid down your side, gripping your hip, guiding the rhythm as you both chased the feeling.
It was messy and frantic and so, so good. But all too soon, Carmy pulled back with a ragged breath, his forehead pressed to yours.
"I want you so bad," he admitted, his voice rough. "But I need to finish closing up. And I want to do this right. Take you home. Take my time with you."
You nodded, breathless, your fingers still tangled in his coat. "Okay. Okay. Just—hurry?"
He let out a breathy laugh, pressing one last kiss to your lips. "I'll be as fast as I can. Stay here. Relax. Eat your cake."
He stood, straightening his coat, and you couldn't help but giggle at the sight of him—flustered, disheveled, clearly trying to compose himself.
"What?" he asked, raising an eyebrow.
"Nothing," you said, picking up the fork again. "You're just cute when you're all worked up."
He shook his head, but he was smiling as he opened the door. "I love you."
"I love you too," you said, watching him go.
The door clicked shut behind him, and you sat there in the quiet office, a giddy smile on your face and Marcus's cake in your lap, feeling like the luckiest person in the world.
mae how have i just now realized u write for carmy?? actually, how is this the first time ive read bear fanfiction?
anyway, can you do something soft and sweet with him and a reader who is a little bit softer, quieter, sweeter? i think something about the rough and tumble and the easy and kind getting together trope speaks to me (has nothing to do with personal projection, pinky swear), and i know you would write the best grumpy x sunshine :)
Thank you for requesting angel <3 I hope your the bear fanfic discovery has been fun!
cw: mature themes
Carmy Berzatto x fem!reader ♡ 712 words
You’ve got Carmy sitting in the tub of his own shower. His bare ass is cold, and he’s thinking that the last time he cleaned it was probably when he moved in, though maybe that doesn’t matter if it’s only ever touched by soap and water.
The thing is, he sort of likes it.
He doesn’t particularly want to like it. His ass is cold. Your shampoo is way too nice for his hair. Usually, after sex (or after sex before you), Carmy just went to sleep or got on with whatever else he had to do, but you said you needed a shower like it was implied he’d take one with you, and it’s nicer than he thought it’d be.
“Tilt your head down?” you say, your voice hardly audible over the spray of water.
Carmy complies, and your sudsy fingers work their way down towards his neck.
“It’s gonna get in my eyes,” he mutters. Not even thinking you’ll really hear him, just complaining generally while watching your nice shampoo drip from the hair in front of his face. Mikey used to joke (meanly, Carmy thinks now) that Carmy got that from their mom.
There’s a smile in your voice, the soft kind, when you reply, “Then close them.”
Your fingers trace wide, spiraling circles, like you’re making art on Carmy’s scalp. He’s a little bit in love with you.
Carmy used to think that calm just wasn’t something meant for him. He could fake it, wear it for periods of time, but it didn’t become him. Tension, fear, anger, they felt like the only gravity he had sometimes, like they were all that held him together. If he relaxed for a second, that would be it. He’d fall to pieces, and the pieces would scatter on the wind, and whatever Carmy was wouldn’t be anything anymore.
But then there’s you. The first time Carmy caught himself relaxing with you, he waited to fall apart, and it didn’t happen. The pieces just…loosened, a little. Like Carmy’s gravity found something else to bind it. It’s good in a way he hasn’t figured out how to process yet.
It’s possible he’s a lot in love with you.
You make an amused hum, almost like a laugh, and Carmy realizes he’s tipped his head so far back you’re practically holding him up.
He tips forward again. “Sorry.”
“That’s okay,” you say, chasing him with your fingers. “We should get you a scalp massager. I think you’d like it.”
Carmy makes a noncommittal huffing sound. He will not be doing that. (It wouldn't be the same if it wasn’t you anyway.)
He’s sort of overwhelmed by the need to do something for you. To care for you similarly, maybe wash your body if his hands would be too clumsy in your hair or wrestle you down here with him and go back between your legs. He wants to kiss you behind the soft part of your knee and say C’mere, baby, even though he thinks he’s probably not the kind of guy who can pull off calling someone “baby.” He toys with “sweetheart,” then “honey,” the h a breath on his tongue.
“Hey,” he says, because he’s a chickenshit. Carmy turns his head, kissing the inside of your thigh. Not meaning to be sordid, but he doesn’t hate the startled-then-shy flicker across your expression when he does it. “Hey.”
“Hey,” you say back, playing along but with a question in your tone, while he squeezes at your calf, trying to summon language half worthy of you.
He swallows. “I love you. You know?”
Your cheek apples when you smile. Your cupid’s bow stretches out, and Carmy wishes for a second that he were an artist instead of a cook (which is its own art form, he knows, he can hear Sugar’s voice in his head now, but still) so that he could paint it. You have the sort of smile that deserves that sort of thing.
“I know,” you say, sweet as spun sugar. “I love you too, Carm.”
He tips his head back down so you won’t see the way his mouth tightens on something tender. You push your fingers back into his hair, and he knows you’ll coax it out eventually anyway.
Warnings: smut, car sex, oral (f receiving), handjob, penetration (p in v), public sex (it happens in a parking lot so yeah i guess), no use of y/n, mutual pinning, cursing, kissing, dirty talk, female anatomy, male anatomy.
Word count: 4K (idk how that happened, i swear it's worth it 😅)
There were about a thousand other things Carmen should’ve been doing right now. The restaurant was still made up of tarps and chunks of wood and debris. He needed to call a plumber. And an electrician. And a builder. He needed to figure out the menu. Get the staff. Handle the permits. There were a million other things he should be doing.
But he wasn’t.
In fact, he wasn’t anywhere near the restaurant.
Carmen currently found himself sitting in your car, parked in the middle of a near-empty lot, as you blasted the radio. You hadn’t shut up for the last thirty minutes. You couldn’t. There were too many things to say, too many thoughts to share.
And Carmen listened—not because he needed to, but because he wanted to. Because it mattered to you.
He enjoyed the way your eyes lit up as you spoke about the music. He didn’t understand half the technical terms you used and probably never would, but that didn’t matter. He loved the way your hands moved through the air, describing a specific part of a song like you were conducting it.
He wondered if this was how people felt when he talked about cooking. Did he light up like this? Did his hands move the same way? Did people look at him the way he was looking at you now?
Carmen had been so focused on the way you looked as you talked that he completely lost track of what you were actually saying. You noticed. You always noticed. You snapped your fingers in front of his face to bring him back.
“Yo, Carmy? You still with me?”
“What? Yeah—sorry.”
“I’m boring you with my music talk, huh?”
“No, no—of course not. I was just—”
“Jesus, Carm. I’m joking. You’re all good.”
This happened a lot. Sometimes Carmen got too caught up in the sight of you, in his thoughts about you, that he missed whole pieces of conversation. You never seemed bothered by it. You never held it against him.
But it happened enough for you to notice—how his eyes would glaze over just slightly, or how he’d be so focused on your face that he didn’t compute a single word coming out of your mouth. You’d be lying if you said you didn’t like it. Who wouldn’t want Carmen Berzatto staring at them like they were the only person left on Earth?
“I could play at the restaurant,” you said suddenly.
You surprised him—it was obvious on his face.
“I mean, think about it. You could have live music on, I don’t know, Saturday. Then I could go, and I could play.”
“…Okay. I’d need a stage.”
“No, fuck that. I don’t need a stage to play.”
“Okay. What about payment?”
“Jesus, Carmy—way to spoil the mood.”
You were toying with him. You couldn’t help it. Carmen was an easy target. You loved seeing the way his brows crinkled when he thought he’d actually managed to piss you off.
He never did. Well—maybe if he really tried, he could. But he never had. Not once. And yet every time you teased him, you still got him. Every time.
“You’re a pain in my ass,” Carmen muttered, but he was smiling when he said it.
You leaned back in your seat, kicking your feet up onto the dash like you lived in the car. Like this was your shared little world where nothing outside mattered—not the restaurant, not the bills, not the creeping anxiety that clung to Carmen like grease in his skin.
“Yeah, well,” you said, tilting your head to look at him, “you keep coming back, don’t you?”
He did keep coming back. Not because it mattered. Not because he had to. But because you were a break. A break in the constant anxiety and dread that filled him. A break from the restaurant and its never-ending chores. A break from his mind. Here, in your car, locked away from the rest of the world, Carmen felt like he could breathe again. It didn’t matter that he didn’t understand what you were talking about half the time. The sound of your voice—the simple presence of you—managed to calm him.
So yes, he kept coming back to you.
Even if maybe there were other things he could be doing with his time.
You always made sure he had nothing left on his plate before letting him melt into your passenger seat. You didn’t let him hide here if there was something waiting to be resolved. And even when he said, “I’m good, I’m done for the day,” you still checked with Syd. Not because you didn’t trust him. But because you didn’t want to be a burden.
You didn’t want to be the reason the restaurant fell behind.
Because as much as you selfishly adored your time with Carmen— as much as you wanted to keep him here, tucked away with you forever—you knew what the restaurant meant to him. How much it meant to be building something again. It meant something to him, which meant it meant something to you too. Because he meant something to you.
Carmen’s eyes raked over your face before shifting to the place where your hands thrummed against your thighs. You seemed so at peace here—so angelic against the light of the setting sun. Carmen often thought that, in moments like this. But he never told you.
“You look really pretty.”
You blinked, caught off guard.
It wasn’t like Carmen to say things like that. Not to you. Not to anyone, really.
He was quiet with his feelings—kept them pressed down, folded into corners of himself he rarely let people see. And even though you were close, even though you spent hours like this—just being together—he had never said anything like that before.
Not really.
You glanced over at him, searching his face for a sign that he was joking, or distracted, or thinking about someone else entirely.His brow furrowed slightly, like maybe he was already regretting saying it. Like the words had slipped out before he could shove them back down.
But he didn’t take it back.
You felt your stomach twist, just a little.
“…What?” you asked, not because you didn’t hear him, but because you needed to be sure.
Carmen looked away, jaw tight. His fingers tapped lightly against his thigh—nervous, fidgeting.
“I just…” he started, then stopped. Swallowed.
“I think that sometimes. That you look… you know. Pretty.”
You stared at him for a moment, completely still. Because you’d known he liked being around you—sure. You’d known he cared. But this? This was different.
Your heart beat louder than it should’ve.
You didn’t really know how to respond.Maybe you should thank him, but that felt too superficial, too odd considering the situation. Carmen Berzatto had just told you that he often thought you looked pretty—and that was doing something to you that you hadn’t expected it to.
You’d always had a sort of thing for him. The Berzattos were a handsome family—it was easy to fall for their looks. So yeah, when you were younger, you thought Carmen was cute. But then you started to know him. Started to hang around him. Actually became his friend.
And the thought of him being cute melted into something else.
But he had too much on his plate already, and you didn’t want to just pile on another thing for him to be worried about.
Friends don’t look at friends the way you look at Carmen.And Carmen doesn’t look at you the way he looks at his other friends—the few ones he does have.
So you let yourself sit in silence for a moment, running over a million thoughts at the speed of a second. And then, before you could chicken out,before you could convince yourself that it wasn’t worth it,you removed your feet from the dash and began to lean over the center console so you could reach him.
When your hand touched Carmen’s thigh, his head snapped up from the window to look at you. He hadn’t even realized you’d moved—not until you were practically on top of him.
And you stayed there for a second. Not moving. Not talking. Just letting your breath and his mingle.
His eyes darted from yours to your lips and you took that as your shot.You pressed a gentle kiss to him, backing away softly in an attempt to allow him to take in what had just happened.
But Carmen didn’t need to think. In fact, he’d almost shut off that part of his brain in that moment. Because if he started to think, he would chicken out. And he didn’t want to lose the opportunity you had just granted him. So before his brain could even compute it, he had dragged you onto his lap, hand settling at your waist as he kissed you again.
Carmen’s lips trailed from yours down to the hollow of your neck, soft and searching. You tilted your head, giving him better access, heart pounding in your chest like a drum. His fingers pressed firmly at your sides, pulling you closer until there was no space left between you.
You could feel the heat radiating from him, the subtle shift in his breathing as desire laced every movement. It wasn’t rushed, wasn’t urgent—it was something deeper, slower. Like discovery.
Your hands found their way up, tangling in his hair, feeling the slight roughness beneath your fingers. He responded with a low sound in his throat, pulling you into him again.
The radio hummed somewhere in the background, but it was just noise now—everything else narrowed to the warmth of his skin, the press of his body, the steady beat of your shared breaths.
Carmen’s lips left your neck to meet yours again, more demanding this time, as if he was catching up on all the things he’d been holding back. Your hands slid down, tracing the line of his shirt, feeling the strength beneath, the promise of more.
You ground your hips down onto Carmy’s, causing him to let out a low groan. You smiled against his lips, repeating the action. You could feel the heat radiating from him, the way his body pressed harder into yours, matching the rhythm you set.
And then he pulled his mouth away from yours. You wondered for a moment if he’d changed his mind. Wondered if you were going too fast for poor Carmy. But he surprised you.
“Get in the back.”
You raised your eyebrows at the sudden shift in his voice. Where had the shyness you knew so well gone? Carmen seemed to catch onto your amusement, his hands moving to caress your ass. He smiled as you gasped at his actions.
“You started it.”
“And you’re gonna finish it, Berzatto?”
Carmen smiled at you—full of mischief.
“Get in the back and you’ll find out.”
That was all you needed. You climbed over the center console, sitting in the backseat. Carmen didn’t even need to ask you to take your pants off; you were already stripping them when he managed to get to the backseat. His eyes raked over the newly exposed skin, hands moving to knead it like soft dough.
Carmen’s hands didn’t stop kneading, their touch slow but deliberate, as you adjusted yourself into a more comfortable position. You were practically lying down in the back seat, Carmy hovering above you. The car felt smaller than it had a couple of moments ago, the air charged with a sort of unspoken need.
You let out a soft breath, your fingers trailing down his arms, feeling the strength beneath the fabric.
“Can I see you without the shirt?”
Carmen was surprised by your question. You’d been so prepared to undress yourself before him, but you worried he wouldn’t be as comfortable doing that. Instead of answering, his hands released your body for a moment, tugging his shirt off. Your palms traced his body as he leaned down to kiss your neck again.
His hands moved over your stomach, fingers skimming against the edge of your shirt. You nodded your head at him before he even asked the question, hands moving to help him peel your shirt off. When the shirt slipped over your head, Carmen’s lips met yours again, slower this time, more deliberate. His hands roamed your back, pulling you closer until there was no space left between you.
You could feel the heat pooling low in your stomach, the pressure of his body pressing against yours. His fingers trailed lower, brushing over your ribs, the bare skin beneath your bra.
“Can I?” he murmured against your lips.
Your breath hitched as you nodded, lifting your arms just enough for him to slide your bra straps down your shoulders. His hands cupped your breasts gently, thumbs circling your nipples through the thin fabric. Your head lifted slightly off the seat as Carmen leaned down, taking one of your breasts into his mouth while his hand continued to caress the other.
You could already feel the wet spot forming on your underwear. Carmen wasn’t much better off—his boxers were already stained with precum, his dick twitching with every soft sound that escaped your lips. And every sound did feel like music to him, which felt appropriate, considering your profession.
His lips trailed lower, moving from your breasts to your stomach, and finally to where you needed him most. He hooked his fingers around your waistband, pausing for just a moment to meet your gaze in silent question before tugging the fabric down your legs.
The space was tight, but Carmen was determined. He managed to settle between your thighs, his face mere inches from you.
And then he leaned in.
Your body jolted at the first touch of his tongue. A soft gasp escaped you as your hand found his hair, gripping tightly as he continued working you open with slow, deliberate movements.
Carmen groaned softly against you, the sound vibrating through your core and pulling another breathy moan from your lips. He was taking his time with it, dragging his tongue through your folds, slow and focused—like he was tasting something he’d been craving for a long time.
Your thighs twitched around his shoulders, and he only pressed in deeper. One arm curled beneath your leg to keep you open for him, while the other reached up, hand sliding along your ribs until his thumb brushed over your nipple again. Every point of contact lit you up.
“Fuck, Carmen—” you breathed, voice catching as your hips rocked against his mouth.
He pulled back just enough to glance up at you, lips shiny and eyes heavy.
“Yeah?” he said, voice hoarse. “That feel good?”
The teasing lilt in his voice was new—rough and low, coaxed out by the way you fell apart for him.
You nodded, too far gone for words. Your fingers tightened in his hair as he lowered his head again, tongue circling your clit before sucking softly, rhythmically. You gasped, a sharp, broken sound that made his hips twitch beneath the denim.
You were close, and he knew it. He could feel it in the way you pulsed against his mouth, in the way your thighs tried to close around his head.
He didn’t let up. If anything, he doubled down—sucking harder, tongue flicking in just the right way, fingers now slipping lower, pressing inside you without warning.
Your back arched off the seat, a cry spilling from your mouth as the pleasure hit all at once, wave after wave rolling through you. Carmen didn’t stop until you were twitching under him, your grip in his hair loosening, chest heaving with the force of it. Only then did he lift his head, dragging his mouth across your thigh with a breathless laugh.
“Jesus,” he said, wiping his mouth with the back of his hand. “You’re gonna fucking kill me.”
You were far too breathless to offer a witty quip in response. So instead, you tugged him up by the chin and kissed him, messy and needy. You could taste yourself on his lips, the mixture of you and him almost intoxicating. Your tongue moved over his, hands clinging to his biceps as you tried to keep him close.
It was too much for Carmen to handle. Being this near to you, yet still not close enough, was driving him insane. And you could see it. You could feel it in the way his body trembled as he tried to hold himself up. You could feel it in the bulge straining against his jeans. With every movement of his tongue, he rocked his hips into you—his clothed dick dragging against your thigh, desperate for friction.
You shifted one of your hands from his cheek, palm trailing down his body until you reached his belt. You didn’t know how you’d managed to do it one-handed, but somehow, you got his belt off. You caressed him through his boxers, reveling in the soft moan that escaped his lips at the action.
“Someone’s excited to see me.”
Carmen couldn’t help but laugh at your words, his forehead resting against yours as you smiled. Your hand slipped beneath his boxers, soft fingers wrapping around his dick. Carmen bucked into your hand unconsciously.
“Yeah? Like that?”
He’d gone quiet all of a sudden—just nodding at your words.
“Come on, Carmy. Where’s the loudmouth I know and love?”
“Fuck you.”
You grinned.
“There he is.”
You shifted your grip, fingers moving over his head as you continued your languid strokes. He kissed you again—maybe in an attempt to shut you up. Or maybe to stop himself from groaning out loud. You nipped at his lips, tugging them between your teeth.
“Wanna hear you, Carmy,” you whispered against his lips, your voice low, sultry, commanding.
Carmen groaned — this deep, wrecked sound from somewhere in his chest — and you felt his whole body shudder in response. His hands gripped your hips like he was grounding himself, but his resolve was slipping. Fast.
“You’re gonna be the death of me,” he muttered, almost like a prayer, breath hot against your skin.
“Haven’t even got to the best part yet.”
Your words sent a shiver of desire rushing through him. Yes, he had wanted to keep going—that’s why he’d told you to move to the backseat. But to hear you acknowledge it, to hear those suggestive words slip from your lips, ruined any self-control he had left.
Without warning, he shifted, guiding your body further down the seat. His fingers hooked around the edge of your underwear, tugging them fully off this time and tossing them somewhere behind him. His hands spread over your thighs, pushing them open as he settled between them, his gaze trailing down your body like he was memorizing it.
“You still sure?” he asked, voice rasped and a little wrecked.
You nodded–breathless, aching. “Yeah. Fuck, Carmy—please.”
He lined himself up, pressing the thick head of his cock against you, teasing you with just the tip. He watched the way your body reacted — how your hips lifted toward him, how your breath hitched — and he swore under his breath.
“Fuck, sweetheart,” he murmured, and then he pushed in slow, deep, agonizingly, deliberately.
Your head fell back with a gasp, hands gripping his shoulders as he sank into you inch by inch, filling you completely. The car felt even smaller now, the heat between you overwhelming.
Carmen stilled when he was fully inside, trying to catch his breath, to keep from coming right there.
“Jesus Christ,” he hissed against your neck. “Fuck, you’re warm. Oh god.”
“Carmy,” you whined, biting your lip as you tried to adjust to his size.
He growled — actually growled — and pulled back before thrusting into you again, harder this time. You moaned, nails digging into his skin.
The rhythm started slow, deep, grinding — like he wanted to savor every second — but it didn’t take long before it grew messier, more desperate. You wrapped your legs around him to pull him closer, to let him hit deeper. He bit into your shoulder, hips snapping against yours in a rhythm that had you both panting.
“You feel so good,” he groaned. “Fuck—just—so good.”
Your lips brushed his ear as you whispered, “Don’t stop, Carmy.”
Carmen’s hands gripped your hips tightly, fingers digging in just enough to remind you he was there—anchoring you even as his movements became more urgent, more desperate. Each thrust hit deeper, sending sparks of pleasure bursting through every nerve ending.
Your breath hitched with every collision, a mix of gasps and moans tumbling from your lips, the confined space of the car amplifying every sound. The way he moved—rough yet careful—made you feel cherished and possessed all at once.
He kissed down your jaw, teeth grazing your skin, leaving a trail of fire. Your hands tangled in his hair, tugging him closer as your bodies moved in perfect, heated sync.
You were going to come. You could feel the coil tightening with every thrust. And when Carmen started mumbling words of praise against your neck, you knew you wouldn’t last much longer.
You met his gaze, eyes shimmering with need and something softer—trust, desire, something unspoken that hovered between you.
“Carmy,” you breathed, fingers tracing the line of his jaw, “I want you to come with me.”
His pace faltered for just a moment, but then he nodded, lips brushing against yours in a promise.
The sun was long gone; the only light illuminating the car was a crappy one from the parking lot. You were sure anyone who passed by could tell what was happening inside. With how rough Carmen was moving, you’d be surprised if your beat-up car wasn’t rocking along with the rhythm. But you couldn’t care less. Let them see. Let them watch the show.
The tension coiled tighter, muscles burning, heart pounding. Your world narrowed down to the feel of him, the sound of your joined breaths, the heat that bound you both.
And then, with a shuddering groan, Carmen tipped over the edge, his body trembling as he spilled inside you, every inch of him alive with release.
You clung to him, riding out the waves of your own climax as the world outside faded away.
For a long moment, you just held each other—breathless, tangled, the world outside reduced to distant noise. Your eyes were glued to the ceiling of the car as you tried to catch your breath. You could feel the warmth that still radiated from Carmen's body beside you. Could feel the scratch of his jeans against your bare legs as he shifted into a more comfortable position.
Carmen rested his forehead against yours, voice thick with exhaustion and something softer. “You okay?”
You nodded, fingers tracing lazy patterns across his sweat-dampened skin. “Better than okay.”
A tired smile tugged at his lips. “Damn, you’re something else.”
You laughed softly, the sound warm and genuine. “So are you.”
Neither of you spoke for a while, just breathing in the closeness, the newness of what had shifted between you.He smiled, a slow, genuine smile that made your heart twist.
“I don’t want this to end.”
You blinked, caught off guard by the honesty.
“Stay over,” he said quietly, his voice almost a plea. “Sleep in my apartment tonight. Let me wake up to the sight of you in the morning.”
The smile that broke onto your face could have replaced the sun. You tugged him into a soft kiss.
“Okay… but you’re driving.”
His brows lifted in surprise. “Wait, what?”
“I can’t feel my legs,” you teased, nudging him gently.
Carmen laughed—a low, warm sound—as he shifted closer, wrapping an arm around you. “Alright, alright. I got you.”
After you both got dressed and Carmen settled into the driver’s seat, you made your way to his apartment. You watched the city pass by as you drove, Carmen’s hand resting on your thigh—a soft reminder of what had happened. A silent promise of more to come.
When Luca left four years ago, he took your heart with him and left you with a decision that changed your entire life. When he finally returns, rebuilding what you had is a little harder when you have a daughter he doesn't know about. A daughter who belongs to him.
▸ PAIRING: Chef Luca x F!Reader
▸ WARNINGS: Mature rating mostly due to making out (no explicit sex scenes), hurt/comfort, reader is a big scaredy cat, some angst, amelia's personality inspired by morgan stark (marvel) but race is neutral/ambiguous <3
▸ WORD COUNT: 9.7K
▸ A/N: told myself i wanted to write something small in honor of the bear s4 and luca's sexy return (esp him holding that baby!!) but i clearly have zero self-control. second part which is slightly longer than this one coming in a week :)
↤ main masterlist | part two ↦
You always knew your past would come back to haunt you. All the secrets and vague responses. Deflecting questions like it’s your full-time job. The first year was the roughest. You practically wrote the book on how to avoid FaceTime calls with your best friend.
With Luca, you can imagine how difficult that would be. The man was too kind, too thoughtful, always making time for you despite the timezone difference and the fact that he was being ground down to the bone across the Atlantic.
Now you’re staring at the consequences of your actions.
Luca: Heading to Chicago in two weeks. Do you have time to catch up?
Every expletive you could think of leaves your lips. It shouldn’t be a big deal. It’s been four years since you saw him last. Four years since he left Chicago and never looked back. Maybe he’s only here for a few days. What’s a few days of hiding the biggest secret of your life from a very observant man who cares way too much about you?
“Shit,” you groan as you stare at the blinking line where your reply should be.
“Shit.”
The echo has you jerking up. Amelia stands in the doorway, grinning cheekily up at you.
“You can’t say that word. It’s a bad word.”
“But you said it.”
“Yes, but I’m an adult.”
“So just because you’re older, you can say it but I can’t? That’s not fair. Kids can do anything adults can too.” Her r’s aren’t even fully formed yet so her challenge just sounds endearing. You have a smart kid. Too smart.
Sighing, you scoop her up, which earns you giggles. She knows she’s won the battle. “Maybe when kids start paying taxes, we’ll talk. Ask me again in a few years. I don’t want you getting in trouble with Miss Glinda.”
Amelia grins down at you with those big green eyes. An exact replica of her father’s. She also picked up a lot of his kindness and patience, his tenacity. Thank goodness, because if she picked up any of those from you, you don’t think she would have made any friends. God knows your stubbornness has gotten you into more messes than your parents would like.
Said father is the man whose text you still haven’t responded to. Whose text led you to curse in front of your daughter. Your daughter who said father has zero awareness of.
This is going to be fantastic.
When you tuck Amelia back into bed, she peers up at you curiously. Sometimes, it’s like staring right at Luca. Her inquisitive eyes. The ones that could see right through you.
“Why were you saying a bad word, Mommy?”
You tug the blanket up to her chin as she sinks back into the mattress. “Sometimes, when I feel really strongly about something, I say a bad word. It’s not really a bad thing, but it might not be a good thing either. It’s just when I feel so emotional that I have to use a word that you’re not supposed to use.”
Amelia quietly considers this. You can see the gears turning in her head. “So was it a good thing or a bad thing that made you say it?”
Honestly, you’re still not sure. While you’re more than thrilled at the idea of reconnecting with a good friend and a former co-worker, his arrival in Chicago means that your current situation – in other words, you having a daughter – complicates things. For the duration of time that he is here in the city, you have to figure out how to ensure he never finds out about Amelia. It would be difficult to explain. Even harder now that she’s four.
Plus, it’s not like you have to. He has a life of his own in Copenhagen now, working for the best of the best. He hasn’t been back in Chicago since he left and he likely will leave again to never return. He doesn’t need to know about her. You’ve been just fine on your own.
“A little bit of both,” you smile. “Now, sleep. This is the second time I’m putting you to bed. If I reach a third time, the ogre underneath your bed is going to wake up and eat you.”
She frowns, “There’s no ogre under my bed. You told me this last year.”
Curse your good parenting. “It’s the ogre’s other friend.”
Amelia offers you a sympathetic smile. It’s a sad day when your daughter begins to pity you and your weak attempt to be stern. “Okay. Goodnight.”
“Sleep tight.”
God knows you won’t be doing that tonight.
–
Perhaps the situation merits some context. For starters, Amelia is your four-year-old. She’s bright and optimistic, but she’s also quick and snappy. She’s the type to challenge teachers at school as evidenced by the number of times she – and you – have been summoned to the principal’s office due to a teacher’s bruised ego. However, she’s a good student and she makes friends. She’s never been too much of a handful.
Raising her has been relatively easy, particularly with the help of your parents and Rebecca, your other and current best friend, who adore her.
When you had gotten pregnant, your parents were unsurprisingly upset. They weren’t happy that their only child was knocked up without the father around. No matter how many times they asked who it was, you couldn’t bring yourself to tell them. You dodged the question multiple times, claiming that the father had nothing to do with the baby because it was your call.
It wasn’t Luca’s responsibility. He didn’t know.
Still, Amelia has been winning hearts left and right since the day she was born. With her bright green eyes and mischievous nature, she quickly captured your parents’ love.
With regards to Luca, she does ask about it from time to time. The father she never knew.
It isn’t as if you and Luca ended on bad terms; you clearly didn’t given that you still consider him one of your closest friends. Close friends with a massive secret between you.
It was just – there was nothing between you to begin with.
A drunken one-night stand. That’s all it was. The two of you were tight at Ever, the entire staff knew that. He had been the one to pull you out of your cold shell, introduce you to the rest, and ensured you fit in with the group. Ever wouldn’t have been the same without him.
So after a particularly tough day and a particularly long night of downing two bottles of wine, it happened. The next morning is something your wine-addled brain had really thought about.
“Last night…” he starts.
“I know,” you clear your throat, covering your naked chest with your duvet. The last thing you want is to lose your friendship with him. No matter how much you love this man. “We don’t have to— I mean, I get it. We had both been drinking.”
Luca nods slowly. “Yeah, of course.” He’s still shirtless from waist up as far as you could see. His broad shoulders even more prominent in the daylight. Golden skin through and through. You can see why your brain thought it was a good idea last night.
You’re not blind. You’ve always known your best friend is attractive. You’ve seen the looks some of the servers give him, and even the customers when he takes the occasional step out of the kitchen and into the limelight.
But you can’t lose him. Not to this.
You look up at him. “We’re good right?”
“We’re good.”
And the two of you never spoke of it again. A couple of weeks later, Luca hears that he received the opportunity to stage at Noma. No chef would pass that up. So within a week, he packs his bag and, with tearful goodbyes to the rest of the Ever crew, he is on a flight to Denmark. What was supposed to be a two-month stint turned into four then a full-time gig. Before long, he was bouncing around every fine dining establishment in Copenhagen and making a name for himself as a pastry chef. He eventually returned to Noma to take over pastry work there.
A week after his departure, you land with your face in your toilet to hurl your guts out. Then came the nausea and the odd food cravings. Working at Ever became unbearable with the mix of smells and your constant fatigue. When all the symptoms finally sink in, you decide to take a pregnancy test.
Lo and behold, two pink lines.
The shock electrocutes you. You’re slumped against your bathroom dresser when Rebecca finds you the first time, panicking since you weren’t exactly moving. Or breathing. It took a lot of crying and ginger ale (no more wine for you) on the floor before she managed to help you move to the bed where you proceeded to repeat the cycle.
Telling your parents was the easy part. Getting through the pregnancy was rough. Late nights of being sore all over, the constant trips to the bathroom, fielding concerned calls from your parents.
Some of the worst parts were Luca reaching out. Between calling you at times most convenient for you (he would be up until dawn trying to call you) and sending you check-in texts, you were consumed with guilt. You constantly skipped his calls, claiming you were too busy even as you stared at his name lighting up your phone in the quiet of your room. You told people at Ever that you were leaving to pursue another career path. When your body started to change, you took video calls with him with only the top half of your face visible.
You never told him. You knew what he would’ve done. He would’ve given up his dream and, knowing him, he wouldn’t have even resented you for it. He would have taken responsibility. But that’s not what you wanted for him. Luca was – is – meant to do great things.
His career so far is proof of it.
So you sucked it up. You had the chance to get rid of this unborn, nameless, faceless baby, but it didn’t feel right. You could feel her growing inside you and, once you had that first ultrasound with your mom by your side, it was decided. You were keeping her.
Amelia came in wailing, kicking, and screaming at three in the morning.
The greatest gift you could ever imagine.
She’s been the lighthouse of your life ever since. She is the reason you get up in the morning.
That’s the gist of it. Now, here you are at the age of thirty, staring at your phone dreading typing a mere response.
You look down at yourself. Despite the frumpy clothes being all you find comfortable these days outside of work, you don’t look that much different than you did before, so you could definitely pass as a woman who has never gone through pregnancy. You can do this. One meeting. Then he’ll be back on a plane and gone again for good. No big.
You: Coffee? I could do weekdays afternoon
Luca: Sounds good. I’ll lock in a time with you closer to the date. Looking forward to seeing you again :)
The urge to bang your head against a wall grows stronger by the moment.
Two weeks to prepare for his visit. Two weeks to come up with a believable story for how your life has been going for the past four years as if you never had your beautiful, smart, amazing daughter. You could do that.
Your only concern is whether you’re able to lie to Luca. He’s always been good at making an honest woman out of you. Keeping the truth from him when he’s thousands of miles from you is easy. But when you’re looking into those earnest green eyes, your integrity and skills will be tested.
This will be fun.
The café is busy particularly this time of day. You’ve got office workers making their late afternoon coffee runs, tourists popping in for a midday snack, and regulars trying to shoulder past people to get through to the exit. You manage to put in your order – and his, hoping it’s still the same – and snag a seat in the back corner of the shop. Work is relatively slow today so you called in a half day, which your manager only waves off unconcerned. It also works out because you can pick up Amelia right after this.
You can’t help the way your fingers wring together fearfully. It’s a nervous tic. Your espresso sits steaming across from Luca’s mocha latte. You could use the extra dose of caffeine to get through this conversation.
Hey, how’s it going? What’s new with you? Me? Nothing much, just raising the daughter I’ve been keeping from you and I’m working in a boring office now. How’s the life of your dreams?
A groan escapes your lips. You need to stop throwing this pathetic pity party for yourself. Now that Amelia is four, there’s really no excuse. You could go back to the kitchen and chase that lifelong dream again. There’s nothing stopping you. Your parents are fully retired and would be more than happy to take her off your hands on long days.
But you’re not entirely sure you’re ready. You’re much older than when you left. The stamina of these new and rising chefs is stronger than yours. Then again, you’ve been through hell and back with Amelia’s toddler years – god knows you barely got any sleep and became an expert on multi-tasking.
With Amelia, you also don’t know if being a chef is even your dream anymore. You still cook at home, it gives you a chance to experiment and be creative. There’s no one breathing down your neck on how to properly prepare a plate – aside from your mom who makes sure Amelia gets her main food groups every day.
It’s not as if you spite him for it. It’s not his fault. You just need to hold yourself accountable for your decisions. That includes having your wonderful daughter and keeping her a secret from her father.
The sound of your name rolling off his tongue is all too familiar. It’s almost like a caress. A ghost of a touch. You resist the shiver that snakes up your spine and look up to see him.
Fuck.
All those video calls did not do him justice. It’s been a couple of days since he landed in Chicago and clearly vacation suits him. There is a slight dusting of stubble along his jaw and his hair is a little unruly, far from the poised and elegant styling he usually has in the kitchen. He looks older. Better. You didn’t think it was possible for Luca to grow more into himself but he proves you wrong.
“Luca.” You stand, bumping into the table slightly. Curse your lack of cool.
The smile that spreads across his face is blinding. Familiar. Warm. “God, it’s so good to see you,” he says first, voice dripping with honey. He wraps you in a tight hug. It’s been a while since you’ve been this close to him, since you’ve been able to smell his cologne mixed with that unceasing scent of pastries. “You look… wow. You look amazing.”
“Now you’re just being mean,” you laugh. “Look at you. All grown up. You weren’t scrawny the last time I saw you, but I didn’t think you’d be so… big?”
Something flickers across his eyes, but it’s gone the moment you blink. “Well, all that dough kneading had to go somewhere. Thankfully, that means I don’t really have to hit the gym as much.”
“Life isn’t fair,” you tease. “What are you doing back in Chicago? I thought someone would have to drag you here kicking and screaming.”
While Chicago had been home for Luca for a while, you knew it wasn’t entirely easy. There is a lot of history in the city that he wants to let go, people he chooses to eschew if he can.
Luca looks a little confused by your question. “Ever is closing. Funeral dinner is tomorrow.”
It’s been years since you’ve been involved in the restaurant scene in the city. Admittedly, it’s too painful to be reminded of the past that had once been your dream. So you nod slowly. “Right, of course.”
“Are you not going?”
You hadn’t been invited, which also isn’t surprising. You weren’t a star like Luca or Carmy. You had been a line cook at the time and blended into the other chefs doing menial work in the kitchen. “No, I don’t really talk to anyone there anymore.”
“Oh, where are you working now? You’ve never told me that actually.”
You’re still not entirely sure how you managed to do it but, in the four years since he left, you did not tell him how you pivoted from cooking to an office job. It was more stable, better pay, and the hours were better. God bless company-sponsored healthcare. It was more conducive to raising a child.
“I work a finance role now. Boutique tech firm in the city.”
If anyone else knew Luca as well as you did, they would see the metaphorical jaw drop. “What? Since when?”
“Two, three years.” Four.
He doesn’t miss a beat. “You mean since I left? What happened? Why did you switch?”
The lump in your throat refuses to go down. “I couldn’t handle the hours anymore. I wanted to get home at a good time, make more money.” It isn’t a lie per se. You just had bigger responsibilities that had you prioritizing reality over idealism.
Luca leans back, seeming to appraise you carefully. There are certainly more lines on your face now, weariness clinging to your skin. While life hasn’t been too tough on you, it hasn’t been particularly kind either.
“I didn’t know that,” he mutters, “why didn’t you tell me?”
Your lips quirk up in a small smile. “I didn’t want you to worry. Knowing you, you’d be on the first flight back here to drag me back into a kitchen.”
A charming snort escapes him. You didn’t know snorts could be charming until him. God, it’s stupid how fast your heart still races with him. “You’re not wrong. I just never thought this would happen. I heard that you left Ever but since you didn’t say anything, I didn’t want to touch on a sore subject.”
“Not too sore, I promise. It’s been good. I like it. It’s straightforward and nobody’s constantly yelling at me. There is functioning air conditioning instead of constantly sweating by grills,” you grin.
“That’s definitely appealing.”
“Enough about me. Tell me all about Copenhagen.”
And that gets Luca going. While you’ve heard bits and pieces on your short calls with him, it’s another thing entirely to have him narrate this live in front of you. His hands gesture wildly to describe the chaos of the kitchens he’s been in. He swipes through photographs of menu items he worked on recently. Each piece is more impressive than the next. You truly understand how much he’s grown then. How talented he is.
Somehow, his being here and all these stories reassure you in your decision not to tell him about your pregnancy. This is Luca’s dream. This is what he is meant to do.
“So when are you heading back? Seems like you have a lot in the works,” you ask as you take a sip of your now-cold coffee.
“I’m actually here for a few months.”
Your blood runs cold. If this were a movie, you would do a spit-take. “W-why are you here for a few months? What about Noma? Are you taking a sabbatical? Do they even let you take sabbaticals?”
“I left.”
He says it so simply. Like a thing he does so casually. Leaving Noma of all places – arguably the best restaurant in the world and every chef’s dream. His dream. “You’re going to have to elaborate here. What do you mean you left?”
Luca takes a deep breath and looks at you. Really looks at you. He looks contemplative, his arms crossed over his chest. “I’ve learned a lot there but I think I’m ready to move on.”
One doesn’t just move on. “So what’s your plan now? Are you starting your own place?”
“Someday. I still want to learn. There are a lot of great places here that I can bring my experience to. I’ve started asking around.”
Fuck. Here. “So you’re staying in Chicago?” Your voice comes out as a squeak.
“Yeah,” he smiles. “I’m excited. I mean, there’s a lot I have to do still. I have to find a place to live. And my sister…”
Luca’s relationship with his sister is rocky at best. With his parents divorced – not amicably at that, the two barely interacted. Even when the two were living in the same city, Luca buried himself in his pursuit of becoming a chef. You hear slices of her from him, but you know it’s a painful topic, so you don’t try to push.
“I’m trying to rebuild the relationship there. It’s going to take a while.”
“Right, yeah. I’m glad to hear. I’m sure it’s not easy so I’m proud of you for taking that step.”
“Right,” he clears his throat, eyes dropping to his hand on the table where he fiddles with his napkin. “And you’re here.”
His eyes flick back up to you. Sharp green. Your breath hitches in your throat.
Fuck.
You cannot do this. All that hope that you’ve quashed from your years knowing him, it’s coming back up. It’s engulfing you in this warm, tingly feeling that should definitely not be there. The you that he knows, she’s gone. She has changed so much that you can’t even see her in your reflection anymore.
So no, you can’t start this with Luca. Not when he doesn’t know you. Not anymore, at least. “So Ever funeral, are you excited to see everyone again?”
A brief look of disappointment blankets his features for a moment and you refuse to succumb to the urge to smooth out the creases on his face. “Yes, Carm’s going to be there too so I’m excited to see him. All the greats, of course. Chef Terry is still a legend.”
You hadn’t even thought about Carmy Berzatto in years. The man terrified you back at Ever, and he still terrifies you today. Last you heard, he started his own place. He’s always been intense, so you can imagine that he runs that place with an iron fist.
“Have you been to his new spot, The Bear?”
“No, I haven’t.” You haven’t been anywhere fancy in a while. It’s been a mix of Chuck E. Cheese’s, Cheesecake Factory, and anywhere that has mozzarella sticks. Amelia is a big fan of cheese, apparently.
“We should go,” Luca beams. “I’d love to take you there.”
On a date? You cannot even begin to hope that’s what he meant. Again, you deflect. “What kind of cuisine is it?”
Luca doesn’t miss that attempt, but smartly chooses not to address it. “Contemporary American, I suppose, but you can imagine the Italian and French influences just given where Carmy has been.”
“Sounds delicious.”
“Yeah, shall we go maybe next week? I’m seeing Carm and his CDC Sydney tomorrow, I can ask them for a reservation spot. I heard it’s tough to get. What time works for you?”
Luca is moving incredibly fast for someone who just arrived, and who plans to be there for a long time.
“We don’t have to rush it,” you laugh awkwardly, “you’re going to be here for a while right?”
“Yes, but I have a feeling you’ll try and get out of this dinner with me if I didn’t get you to agree today,” he says, his voice tinged with humor, but the arrow still sticks painfully in you.
He isn’t wrong. You probably would use work as an excuse, despite talking about the better hours. But you have other responsibilities like picking up Amelia from school, feeding her dinner, and making sure she does her homework:
None of which he knows about.
“Weekdays can be a bit tricky with my schedule.”
“The weekend perhaps? How about Saturday?”
Amelia has French lessons in the morning (her request, not yours) and then Rebecca is coming over so the three of you can do a quick painting session. Rebecca is insistent on nurturing her artistic skills from an early age.
The Bear is only open for dinner service which you can’t escape without Amelia asking questions; the girl is too smart for her own good and you haven’t been out with plans that she doesn’t know about. Ever.
The dating scene changes a little for single moms. You haven’t been on a date in a very long time. It’s tough to get into a committed relationship with a child when you've just completed your twenties.
“Let me think about it?”
He studies you for a moment. “Are you seeing anyone?”
You make the mistake of taking a swig of your coffee when you cough, sputtering embarrassingly. Luca flails before offering you a napkin.
“Sorry, shite, I didn’t mean to—”
“No, no, it’s okay,” you wheeze, “it just caught me off guard.”
“Sorry,” he repeats awkwardly, “is that a bad question to ask?”
You shake your head, urging your skyrocketing heart rate to let up. “No, um, it’s fine. I’m not— I’m not seeing anyone.”
“Right, cool.”
The faint pink painted on his cheeks is noticeable but it’s better not to comment.
“I’m not either,” he adds, “seeing anyone, that is.”
You fight the amused smile on your lips. He’s already scratching his cheek, a nervous habit that he hasn’t lost. “Cool.”
“Cool,” Luca echoes in a chuckle.
For a minute, the two of you sit there in silence. All those years apart seem to evaporate, vanishing into the crowd. The comfort that you’ve always felt around him sinks into your bones.
“I should get back to work, can’t have my boss thinking I’ve disappeared on her.”
“Right, of course. No rest for the weary.” Luca smiles. When the two of you are outside, Luca turns to you and immediately pulls you in for another embrace. “It was really good seeing you.”
It’s too easy to burrow your face into his broad chest. That nostalgic ache persists inside your heart. You don’t feel like you’re thirty. You’re twenty-two again in that kitchen, standing next to Luca. Both of you are young and carefree. The aroma of freshly baked goods that clings onto his skin and the sweat that dots his brows.
But when a car honks in the distance, reality settles back into your gut.
“You too,” is all you can muster. “See you around.”
By the look on Rebecca’s face, you can’t exactly pinpoint what emotion she’s feeling. It started off with surprise and then confusion and more surprise. “So he’s just back now?”
“Uh-huh,” you say from your spot in the kitchen as you’re preparing dinner. Mushroom risotto, one of Amelia’s favorites. This one is a labor of love but it’s always rewarding when you see the look on her face when it’s plated in front of her.
Thankfully, she had fallen asleep right after she and Rebecca spent the afternoon playing a game of water tag in the backyard so now it’s just you and Rebecca in the kitchen as you recount The Meeting with Luca.
Rebecca pops another olive into her mouth. “So are you going to hook up with him again?”
“Bec!” You gasp. “Absolutely not.”
“Clearly he was good enough the first time to give you a child.”
An exasperated sigh of disbelief leaves your lips, which only amuses her more than anything. “I will not be hooking up with him again. It was one time. We’re friends now.”
“Honey, friends don’t fuck.”
“Friends can fuck once.”
“If you finish twice in one night, does that count as once still?”
You wave a hand in front of her. “I’m not debating the technicality of this. Point is, I’ve seen him once and I will not be seeing him again.”
“Why not? He’s clearly interested. He asked you if you were single.”
“So?”
“And then he tells you – unprompted – that he’s single too.”
“I get it, maybe he’s interested. But I’m not.”
Even your words sound unconvincing in your ears.
“I’m—” fuck. “—not. I’m not. Anyways, I didn’t make plans and I hope he doesn’t follow up—”
As if on cue, your phone begins vibrating on the table. Both your eyes drop to it as Luca’s face and name pop up on screen. Rebecca’s lips twitch into a smirk. “Superpowers. Good in bed and reading minds.”
“I’m not going to deal with that.”
“You have to.”
“I won’t.”
“Are you five? Why are you avoiding him? You claim he’s your best friend – which I take full offense to by the way – but you can’t even talk to him.”
Groaning, you stare at the device still circling the surface of your counter. “I don’t want to risk him meeting Amelia, especially if he’s going to be here a while.”
“He’s definitely going to meet her eventually. It’s a matter of when. Are you never going to invite him over?”
“What possible reason would I have to invite him over?” Rebecca opens her mouth and you quickly interject, “Don’t answer that.”
Her gaze falls back to the device, then flicks up to you, then back to the device. Before you can stop her, she’s swiping to pick up the call and putting it on speaker. You want to slap the proud grin off her face.
“Hey, hope I’m not interrupting anything.” Luca’s gravelly voice carries over the speakers.
“No, no. Just making dinner,” you respond, ignoring the way Rebecca keeps mouthing at you about his British accent.
“What’s on the menu?”
“Mushroom risotto,” you say as you look over the boiling pan again.
“I remember that one. One of my favorites of yours.” You can practically hear his smile. Your heart skips a little too fast at the thought. “If you’re willing, I’d love to have that again sometime.”
Rebecca mutes it quickly just to say, “Fucking Jesus, he wants in your pants again.” Then unmutes.
With a glare her way, you direct your attention back to Luca. “Yes, maybe.” Noncommittal. Safe.
“Listen, I was with Carm and Syd at Ever and they invited us to come for dinner at The Bear. Wondering what your schedule looks like next week and if you’d be interested.”
“Oh, I don’t know, it’s a little— oh fuck.”
“You okay?”
You shoot Rebecca a dirty look after she launched a fucking olive at your head. “Yeah, fine, sorry.”
“Go,” she whispers.
“Um, I’m not sure about my schedule next week.”
“I can be flexible. I know you said weekdays are a little tough but what about after work? Thursday night?”
Fuck. If Luca is one thing, he’s persistent. And he knows how your bad tendency to avoid things you’re scared of – which in this case is dinner with him, so he’s not letting this one go. “It’s a school night so I’m not sure.”
He chuckles. The sound reverberates straight through your core. “And you can’t go out on school nights, can you?”
Crap. His voice is like a siren’s, luring you in to confess your secrets. The way he says it too – Jesus, the delivery of that question has sparks blowing up inside you. More importantly, you almost let it slip that school nights are usually a no-go because you need to get Amelia ready for the next day. “Still have to work the next day,” you laugh awkwardly.
“Friday then?”
“Friday is better…”
There’s silence on the other end of the line for a moment. You know he’s still there but he’s in deep thought. This happens sometimes. You’ve grown attuned to notice these moments even without seeing his face on the call.
“I just want to say there’s no pressure. If you’re not interested, please feel free to say no. I don’t want to force you to spend time with me if you don’t want to. You’ve got your own life, I completely understand. I apologize, I don’t want to overstep my boundaries.”
Fuck. Of course, he would be a complete gentleman in this situation. It’s not that you don’t want to. Everything is just complicated. Pushing aside those worrying thoughts, you say, “No, I’d love to. Sorry. I just have a lot on my plate right now so I don’t want to make plans I can’t commit to.”
“Do it,” Rebecca mouths. For someone who’s supposed to be a fly on the wall, she is oddly intrusive. “I’ll take Amelia.” You hesitate for a second and she gives you another look before she mutes the call again. “Honey, do it. You deserve to do something nice for yourself okay. And if it’s a nice dinner with a hot British chef, then so be it.”
Sighing, you unmute the call and talk to Luca again. “Friday works. I’ll be coming from work.”
“I’ll pick you up.”
“No, you don’t have to—”
“I insist. Text me the address. I’ll book for 7:30 to be safe.”
“Alright, sounds good,” you reply weakly.
“See you then.”
When the line goes cold, you look up to find Rebecca with a shit-eating grin on her face. “I’m so proud of you,” she exhales dreamily. “It’s like seeing a teenage daughter grow up and plan her first date.”
“Shut up.” You roll your eyes and turn back to the stove. Your cheeks are flushed with warmth.
This is a date. Luca probably considers this a date. Right? It would be embarrassing if he didn’t and you did. Maybe he’s just being nice and taking out an old friend to a restaurant he has been meaning to try.
“I can hear you spiraling,” Rebecca singsongs.
“Why did you let me say yes?”
It is then that Rebecca physically gets up, rounds the counter, and grabs hold of both your arms. “I need to shake some sense into you. You are still a person. You are allowed to go out and have fun. There are people around you who can help you with Amelia. You’re not alone.”
“I know this,” you grumble under your breath.
“But I think sometimes you need a good reminder of it. You’ll have fun at dinner, I just know it. You spent so long pushing away that part of you because you think you’ll never have it again, but – you know what – I think you can. You’ve always loved food and cooking. I can see it in the meals you make for Amelia. Maybe it’s just time for you to go out and explore again.”
Smiling softly, you always knew that Rebecca was your better half. She took you under her wing in college, stood up for you, and gave you the confidence to pursue your dreams. You had graduated with a degree in finance but worried for your life when you had to tell your parents that you were going to be a chef instead. She stood by you through it all.
“Thanks, Bec.”
“Where would you be without me?”
With a laugh, you nudge her away as you turn off the fire. Right on time, Amelia wanders into the room, rubbing her eyes tiredly. “Hungry.”
Classic. She truly is your daughter.
When seven rolls around, you’ve already spent the last thirty minutes fretting over your hair and the state of your makeup. The office has cleared out for the day, but you spent the last working hour playing catch-up. It’s been a busy week for Amelia at Pre-K – who knew they could have so much homework even before reaching kindergarten?
You smooth out the wrinkles on your pale blue dress – work appropriate with the blazer, and chic dinner fit without. Since Amelia, you’ve foregone wearing heels, opting instead for flats or sneakers since you’re constantly on your feet. But you pull out your white, open-toed pumps from your closet for this dinner.
Yes, you can readily admit that you are at least trying to look nice for this dinner non-date.
When you told Amelia earlier this week that you had plans on Friday night to go out for dinner and that she would be staying home with Rebecca, she didn’t blink twice. She only asked what Aunt Rebecca had planned. When she saw you this morning dressed up with a little more blush on your cheeks, she didn’t question it. Instead, she just smiled quietly and complimented you on your dress.
You can’t believe you’re at a stage where she is making space for you. You nearly get teary just thinking about how quickly she’s growing up.
A black sedan pulls up in front of you and Luca is immediately out the door. You’re so used to seeing him in t-shirts, aprons, and sweatshirts that you forgot how delectable he can look when he cleans up. His blonde hair is neatly coiffed and he’s shaved his face clean. You find yourself almost missing that rugged stubble on his face. His navy shirt is freshly pressed with sleeves rolled up close to his elbows to reveal all his tattoos.
God, he looks good. Too good. Tempting even.
“You look fantastic,” Luca beats you to the punch, leaning forward to kiss you on the cheek. His eyes peruse you shamelessly, dragging from the tip of your toes to the top of your head.
It’s a European thing, you remind yourself. “You do too. Almost didn’t recognize you out of your stained tees.”
His mouth curls into a smirk. “Believe it or not, I do have clean laundry these days.” He swings open the door for you and offers a hand to help you slide inside.
Once the two of you are settled in, Luca pulls up the restaurant on the navigation system. He fills the silence with small talk, asking you how your day went and how work is going.
When you finally arrive at The Bear, Luca drops you off at the front and goes to park around the corner. Ever the gentleman. Stepping inside, you’re immediately impressed by how elegant the entire place is. It’s neat with that fine dining touch, but there’s a certain coziness in the air that makes it more welcoming. Luca joins you shortly after, stating his name for the reservation.
A tall man dressed sharply in a black suit comes up and greets Luca first. “Glad you could make it!”
“Thanks for having me,” Luca beams back. He introduces the two of you quickly and you learn that his name is Richie and he is Carmy’s cousin.
“Not real cousin but his brother was my best friend,” Richie corrects easily. “Let me take you to your table.”
The service is impeccable and the ambiance even more so. You’re marveling at how polished everything is. The window strip into the kitchen gives a sneak peek into the work behind the scenes, but your focus is on the main dining room. Beautiful booths against the wall, tables spaced just enough apart. You can’t imagine that this place had been a casual fast food joint just months ago. They’ve truly outdone themselves with the transformation.
“Impressive bunch,” Luca notes your expression. “Not to mention it’s most of their first time working in fine dining. While there have been some inconsistent reviews, the menu is generally delicious overall.”
“Yeah, I don’t recognize it anymore. I remember visiting this shop back then and it was holding on to its last hinges. Now look at this place.”
The tasting menu is even more stunning. The bread is crisp on the outside, fluffy and warm on the inside, paired perfectly well with the option of freshly made butter. Appetizers were light, perfect to get you warmed up for the series of main courses. Desserts – don’t even get you started on the desserts. You’re pretty sure you let out an inappropriate moan at some point.
Your diet these past few years has consisted of whatever is microwavable, preparable with hot water, or whichever dish Amelia is craving. So you’ve had your fair share of ramen, mac and cheese (Amelia’s three-year-old phase), and lunchables (ongoing, on-and-off phase).
It’s been a while since you’ve had a proper sit-down meal at a fancy restaurant. It’s hard to believe that you used to work in these kitchens. You used to be the person creating these meals. While your parents and Amelia let you take your own spin with the dishes you prepare for them, most of the time you’re too exhausted to do anything experimental and stick to what you know – and have in your cupboards.
It’s nice to enjoy this kind of meal again.
You and Luca discuss dinner throughout, talking about the flavor profiles and the potential inspirations, the influences of each dish. Each item was made meticulously with careful thought placed into the flavor. It didn’t feel extremely polished, but that just meant there’s still a lot of heart that went into it.
“That was just… wow.”
“Took the words right out of my mouth,” Luca chuckles as he wipes with a napkin. “I was already expecting to be blown away but that was out of this world. As expected from Carmy. And Syd.”
Richie comes back around and the two of you gush over how wonderful everything is. “Great to hear it, team. Love the enthusiasm. Carmy and Syd have some time right now by the way, if you wanted to go say hi.”
“That would be perfect. Let me just close out and not walk out on my tab.”
“I can definitely get you that.”
When the bill arrives, Luca is quick to swipe it off the table. “Luc—”
Luca immediately shakes his head, dropping his card on top of the receipt and hands it back to the waiter. “My treat. For putting up with me all these years.”
A frown forms on your face as you watch his hands fold on top of the table. “What are you talking about? Don’t be ridiculous. We’ll split. It’s an expensive dinner.”
“Let me do this one thing for you, love,” Luca says. “I wanted to try this place and I invited you so it’s only fair that I cover the bill.”
“Luca, that’s not— come on. I’ll send you the money. This isn’t a—” you bite your tongue, stopping yourself before you can say the word date.
He catches on anyway, lips tugging into a smile. “If I told you this is a date, would you let me pay for it then?”
Warmth creeps up your cheeks again as you wring your fingers on the napkin on your lap.
“Folks, are we ready to meet the chefs?” Richie returns, clapping his hands together.
“Yes, we are.” Luca answers. He’s giving you yet another out. Still the gentleman, he offers a hand to help you to your feet.
Richie leads you towards the kitchen door, drawing curious eyes from surrounding guests over this special treatment you’re getting. When you step in, your senses are immediately overwhelmed.
The kitchen is alive. Not just loud. Alive. A symphony of sizzles rises from the skillets as flames dance around the pans, blues and oranges glowing bright. Metal against metal as hot pans hit the stovetop, the scraping of spatulas against the surface. Another chef yells corner as they appear carrying trays of baked meringues. The chef at expo is reading out orders from her list, her voice slicing steady and clear across the cacophony of sounds.
The light overhead is cold and clinical, sharp fluorescents that bleach the space in blue. But the kitchen burns bright. The heat in this room is significantly higher than the carefully controlled temperature of the dining room.
It’s nostalgic. It reminds you of all those years working alongside Luca. Your fingers wrapped around a cool piping bag, swirling icing on top of tarts. The aroma of pastries baking — golden crusts, caramelized sugars, berries roasting – was consistent in the air. There is a quiet in the chaos. Controlled chaos.
A comfort that you’ve longed for. Your kitchen isn’t the same. The people aren’t the same, but there’s a beauty in the newness. In the challenge.
You’re pulled out of your thoughts when Richie yells, “Yo! Cousin! Chef Syd! Luca’s here.” The brunette woman at expo give him a warning look, which withers him only slightly.
There is a chorus of greetings when people spot Luca. Clearly he’s a fan favorite. When you turn to look at him, he’s already looking back at you. A gentleness to his gaze that catches you off guard.
Before you can attempt to decipher that look, two chefs make their way over to you. One you recognize as Carmy. His intensity is palpable, obvious. If there’s anyone who could put these chefs on edge, it would be him. The other woman is calmer. A friendly face but an equally controlled presence. The two make a terrifying pair.
Carmy’s eyeing you with interest, eyes flicking between you and Luca. “I’ve met you before,” he says simply.
You laugh and Luca rubs his face. “Mate, you guys worked together.”
“We did?” He asks the same time Syd asks, “You did?”
“Yeah, she was my second for pastry.”
“Fuck, I’m sorry,” Syd laughs, crossing her arms over her chest. Carmy still looks completely befuddled, but also distracted by the stream of activity going on behind him. He mutters to give him a second as he deals with the searing steak. “I mean Luca’s great but forgive Carmy, he’s not best at… remembering anything. Or math. Or picking up the phone.”
“Alright, alright, I get it,” Carm calls out, hands still moving quickly and efficiently to turn the steak and then quickly plate it for service. You can’t help but marvel at how speedy he is. He’s always been good but he’s only gotten better. It’s terrifying knowledge. “Hands!” Then he’s back in front of the two of you.
“No, it’s fine. I wasn’t there for very long—”
Luca chuckles. “You were there for at least two years. You definitely overlapped for a while.”
“Shit, sorry, I’m just bad with – well, like Syd said – most things. But yeah, good to meet you again.”
“You too, the food was delicious. As expected,” you shrug with a smile. “Out of this world.” Luca smiles quietly at the echo of his words.
“Thanks, it took a while to get the menu to this place,” Syd nods.
Carmy’s still looking at the two of you. “This is a mess, though. Don’t let us ruin your date.” You see Syd elbow him, leaving him with another look of confusion.
Before you can correct him, Luca is already responding, “No, this is great, mate. I’ve missed the Chicago food scene a lot. Ever was clean, but this feels very lively.”
“Yeah, it’s been great. Budget’s fucking fucked but it’s okay. We’ll figure it out.”
Luca looks at him in concern but the two chefs wave him off. “Well, I don’t want to interrupt too long. I’m just going to say hi to Marcus and head out.” A hand settles on the small of your back and suddenly you’re being directed towards the back corner of the kitchen where a man who is even taller than Luca stands (you note that there are many tall men in this establishment), his hands working away at these delicate little desserts.
“Luca, my man,” the man who you assume to be Marcus grins wide, dapping Luca. You’re more bewildered that Luca knows how to dap than anything. “Heard you were on this side of the pond.”
“Yeah, for a little bit actually.”
“Nice,” he nods slow then looks at you. “Marcus.”
You introduce yourself too and add, “Desserts were perfection by the way. Sundae was inspired, love the olive oil.”
“Thank you. I have to give this man right here his flowers. Learned a lot from my time there.”
Luca laughs, scratching his cheek. “No, it was all you, man. Echoing that desserts were superb.”
“Thanks, man. I actually wanted to run some ideas by you if you’ve got time.”
“Time is all I have.”
Marcus grins. “Perfect, I’ll text you.” He turns to you. “Good to meet you. Never thought Luca would have time for a girlfriend.”
This time, you do jump in. Perhaps a little too fast. “I’m not his girlfriend,” you blurt out, “I’m a… friend.”
Marcus’ gaze darts between Luca and you. Shame sinks quickly into you. The defensiveness in your voice was maybe unnecessary. You can’t see Luca’s face but you can feel his hand shift slightly away from your body. The lack of touch leaves you feeling a little cold in the warm kitchen. “Right, my bad. Anyway, good seeing you both.”
“You too, talk soon,” Luca says.
With a flurry of goodbyes, the two of you are finally out of the restaurant, standing in the slightly brisk evening air. A wind whips by, leaving you shivering slightly. “Are you cold?” Luca asks. “You can wait inside and I’ll pull the car around.”
“No, don’t worry. I’ll just grab an Uber from here.”
“Nonsense, I have a car. I’m happy to drop you off at home.”
“Luca, you’ve done more than enough. Dinner was wonderful. I can get myself home.”
Luca hesitates, gaze drifting into the street.
“There’s no meaning behind it. I really just don’t want to trouble you any more than I already have.”
“You could never trouble me,” he says. It’s almost a promise. You blame the heat on your cheeks on the touch of wind outside. “It’ll make me feel better knowing that you’re getting home safely.”
You don’t think he would drop this. Not to mention, it would save you the money on a long drive back home. Finally, you nod in agreement and he tells you to stay put as he grabs the car.
On the ride home, you quickly shoot a text to Rebecca.
You: Luca’s dropping me off. Can you make sure Amelia’s in bed? Thanks :)
“So you liked dinner?”
You snort, “That’s an understatement. I don’t think I’ve had a meal like that in a long time.”
“I’m surprised. You’ve always been the first to try new restaurants, especially ones by reputable chefs. As intense as Carmy is, he is a fantastic chef. So is Syd, she’s brilliant.”
A weak smile settles on your face as you turn to look out the window. The sparse traffic blurs before you in streaks of red. “Just haven’t had the time, I suppose.”
Luca clears his throat and your glance flies back to him. His grip is tight on the steering wheel, his neck flushed pink. “Well, if you’re interested in exploring more places, I have a lot of catching up to do. We could go together?”
You’ve never been able to tell him no. Not when you want it for yourself as well. “That sounds nice.”
When you get to your home, Luca pulls up along the curb. Just as you’re about to thank him again, he’s already stepping out to get your door. Fuck. “Thank you,” you whisper, slipping your hand into his for the nth time that night. You’re getting used to the feeling. “Thank you again for dinner. I had a great time.”
“Me too,” he smiles. “Hopefully the first of many.”
“I’ll get the bill next time.”
Luca shrugs. “We’ll see.”
When he makes no move to leave, you tilt your head. “Shouldn’t you get going? It’s late.”
“Let me walk you to your door.”
Your heart drops to the ground. You haven’t gotten a response yet from Rebecca which is hopefully a good thing. Maybe they’re both fast asleep, it wouldn’t be the first time. The energy-exerting activities work as well on Rebecca as it does on Amelia.
“You really don’t have to.”
“I insist. It’s the Brit side of me. I want to make sure you get in okay.”
All you can do is nod and walk up the pathway to your door. Your knees feel a little weak. If it’s the nerves or the proximity to Luca, especially since his hand has returned to your lower back, you’re not entirely sure.
When you reach for your keys, Luca shoves his hands into his pants pockets. His hair is a touch mussed up now, a strand falling attractively across his forehead. He’s looking at you with that calm gaze, one that has your body all too aware of his presence.
“You look beautiful tonight.”
“Pretty sure you already said I looked fantastic earlier, beautiful feels like a downgrade.”
Luca laughs, the sound low and familiar. Your chest warms as you look at him.
“Thanks again, I appreciate it.”
“Don’t mention it. I’m just grateful you agreed to go with me.”
“We’re friends, Luca. We can hang out.”
He hums, stroking his chin thoughtfully. Something about the act has your heart rate picking up. “Didn’t seem like you really wanted to.”
“It’s just been a while since I’ve been… out.”
“Well, if you’re not opposed, then I’d be honored to take you out again.”
Oh boy. This is venturing into dangerous territory.
“I should head in,” you say, teeth catching your bottom lip before you can say something stupid like would you like to come in?
However, before Luca can respond, the front door swings open and you hear—
“Mommy!”
Shit.
Amelia stands in the doorway in her purple unicorn pajamas. She’s looking up at you with bright eyes but then her curious gaze wanders over to the blonde man in front of you.
Double shit.
Her hair isn’t an exact replica of Luca’s, but the eyes are unmistakable. All three of you seem to freeze in time.
Amelia is staring at Luca, Luca is staring at Amelia, and you’re trying to figure out how to dig yourself out of this hole. First things first, you crouch down to Amelia’s height. “Baby, why aren’t you sleeping?”
“Aunt Rebecca fell asleep but I wasn’t tired yet.”
You purse your lips. “Let’s get you inside, it’s chilly out.”
“Who’s that?” Amelia peeks around you to look at Luca again.
The thought of even looking at him right now is terrifying. “He is my friend.”
“You’re not going to introduce me?” Amelia asks, eyes widening. You know exactly what she’s doing. Manipulative. The guilt-trip, puppy-dog eyes.
So you grit your teeth and plaster on a smile as you straighten back up and turn to Luca. He’s still rooted to your porch, mouth pressed into a thin line and his brows puckered in confusion. “Luca, this is Amelia. Amelia, Luca.”
“Hi, Uncle Luca.”
Polite, you taught her well.
It is then that Luca seems to snap out of it, clearing his throat awkwardly as he crouches to her level. He sticks out a hand, which she immediately accepts. “Hi, Amelia. It’s very nice to meet you. Though, it seems like it’s way past your bedtime.”
Amelia disregards his comment and instead responds with “You have a cool accent. Where are you from?”
“I grew up in London but I’ve lived here in Chicago and also spent the last few years in Copenhagen. In Denmark.”
“That’s so cool, I’ve never been,” Amelia beams, eyes sparkling in delight.
“Well, if you ever decide to go, I could take you around.”
“Do you live there now?”
His eyes snap up to you briefly, the movement surprising you, before they return to the little girl before him. “No, I’m moving back here to Chicago.”
“Why?”
Luca is quiet as he pulls together his words. “Because there are a lot of people I care about here.”
“Is my mommy one of them?”
The lump in your throat has only grown. The word mommy usually warms your heart but you can feel it stuttering instead. Your mind is running awry, wondering if he’s connected the dots yet, what answers you should give him if he asks. He doesn’t need to know, you remind yourself. He’ll be here a few months and then he’ll be gone again – and you and Amelia can go back to the life you’ve always lived. Just the two of you.
“Yes, your mum is definitely one of them,” Luca softly says, “Speaking of, she’s very sleepy. Maybe it’s best that you tuck her in for the night.”
Amelia giggles, “That’s a great idea. She always tucks me in so it’s my turn.”
“Mhmm, then you can go to sleep knowing your mum’s tucked away safely in bed.” Luca reaches out to ruffle her hair, which pleases her as she preens to the touch. His eyes widen for a second before they melt again and he strokes her head. “Have a good night, Amelia.”
Amelia remains by the door when he finally turns to you. There’s a storm clouding his usually bright eyes as he looks at you. You’re not even sure what words are caught on the tip of your tongue, but they never come out.
“Have a good night, love,” Luca murmurs and leans forward to press a kiss on your cheek. Your eyes slide shut. God, you’ve missed this intimacy with someone. Nothing could compare to his touch. The loneliness that has ebbed and flowed over the years seeps back into your lungs.
But your heart is still rattled by what just happened. You can barely move, let alone respond.
Then he’s gone, the roar of his engine echoing down the quiet street as he drives away.
Your mind is numb as you prepare Amelia for bed. She’s chattering about how nice Luca seems to be and how she’s excited to see you making friends again. The only thing you can offer her is a weak smile as you press a kiss to her temple. She slides under the covers and is out cold in minutes. You leave her room quietly to drape a blanket over Rebecca, who’s sleeping on the couch.
Only then do you head to your own room, weary from a long day.
The last thing you see before sleep pulls you under is your phone lighting up.
Tags: not proofread, p in v sex, Dennis isn’t having sex with yall this time unfortunately, Carmys secretly a freak
a/n: this is basically just set up, but don’t worry bc Dennis WILL be joining yall next time, and part 2 will be even longer!!!
The ER smells like antiseptic and misery.
Carmen’s jaw is tight, shoulders tense, his right hand wrapped in a dirty kitchen towel. He’s pacing instead of sitting and waiting like the nurse told him to.
“You’re gonna make it worse” you say, arms crossed as you watch him.
“I’m fine.” he snaps, then softer, annoyed at himself “I’m fine...”
“You dumped boiling oil on your hand, Carm. You’re not fine!”
Before he can argue, the curtain pulls back.
“Alright” a calm voice cuts in, careful and gentle in a way that almost doesn’t belong to the ER. “Let’s take a look.”
You freeze.
Dennis Whitaker stands there in black scrubs, badge clipped to the bottom of his top. Same soft blue eyes.
For a second no one speaks.
Then Dennis’s eyes flick to you before he quickly looks away.
“…hey” he says quietly, in that god awful shy tone that’s just too sweet.
Carmen turns to you, instantly feeling the shift in the room. “You know him?”
Dennis blinks, clearly not expecting Carmen to be that sharp. “Oh, Uh—College.”
You nod. “Yeah, he’s also from Broken bow.”
Dennis gives a small, but awkward smile. “Haven’t seen you in a long time.”
“Yeah…” you say. “You kinda disappeared.”
Something flickers behind his eyes, but he just gestures to Carmen’s hand instead. “Let’s focus on you.”
Carmen holds his hand out like it’s an offering and a challenge at the same time.
“How’d this happen?” Dennis asks, carefully unwrapping it.
“I’m a chef. Spilled some oil.” He says flatly.
Dennis hums. “That explains the burn pattern.”
Carmen watches him work, eyes sharp, assessing. Then, casual but pointed
“So what, you two study together or something?”
Dennis hesitates. “We were…close.”
You feel it instantly. The way Carmen’s shoulders stiffen.
“Close?” Carmen asks.
“We dated. Briefly.” You murmured softly.
The silence that follows is heavy.
Carmen lets out a short scoff. “Huh.”
Dennis cleans the wound, fingers precise and gentle. He doesn’t rush. Doesn’t try to challenge any unspoken rules. He asks permission before touching, apologizes when Carmen flinches.
“Didn’t expect you to pivot from theology medicine.” you say quietly.
“Didn’t really know who I was back then.” He chuckles softly
“You do now?” you ask.
His eyes meet yours. “More than I did before.”
Carmen doesn’t miss it.
The car ride home is silent. Not the calm kind of silence. The dangerous kind.
Carmen’s driving one handed, the other, now properly bandaged, resting stiffly on his thigh.
You can feel the question practically bubbling inside him.
Finally, he says it.
“So” he starts, eyes still on the road, voice almost casual. “You fuck him?”
Your head snaps towards him. “What!?”
“Back then” he adds quickly. “College. Broken Bow.”
You hesitate.
That’s enough of an answer for him.
He exhales sharply through his nose. “Jesus.”
“I-I didn’t think it mattered, we were just teens…” you say.
“I didn’t say it did matter.” he replies, jaw clenched. “Just—whatever. I don’t wanna know.”
He doesn’t yell or pry like you expect him to. The rest of the ride passes in tense silence.
He’s rougher than usual tonight.
Not aggressive or anything you’re not comfortable with—but intense. Focused. Like he’s trying to work something out through his body.
He’s above you, weight braced solely on his forearms, breathing uneven. He hasn’t kissed you in a bit which is odd for him.
He’s just staring, like he’s trying to decide if he should say something.
“Can’t stop thinking about it” he admits quietly.
You’re breathless but slightly confused. “About what?”
“Him.” His grip tightens. “You with him.”
Your breath stutters. “Carm–”
“I hate it.” he says, breath ragged, tension flowing through his words. “Still do.”
Then, quieter. “But it’s fucking me up with how much it’s turning me on.”
The confession hangs between you, heavy and electric.
He presses his forehead to yours. “Tell me.”
Your breath catches. “Carmen—”
“Tell me.” he repeats, firmer this time. Not loud. Not angry. But sure. “About you and him.”
He kisses you like he’s claiming something, his movements possessive and desperate. The jealousy is there, but so is something else. Curiosity. Control slipping just enough to feel dangerous.
You swallow. He watches your throat bobs.
“It-It was college…” you start, voice shaky due to the fact his pace wasn’t faltering at all. Fucking you within an inch of your life.
“We were stupid…Lonely. He was gentle, Always asking if I was okay.”
Carmen’s hand slides under your thigh, bringing it to rest on his shoulder. This new angel. “You liked that?”
“Sometimes.” you admit.
His thumb presses hard into the meat of your thigh. “Yeah? Go on.”
You close your eyes, letting yourself remember.
Also maybe embarrassed that you’re telling your boyfriend about how your collage boyfriend fucked you.
Or maybe it’s because you’re embarrassed that it’s getting you off.
“He used to get shy. Like he couldn’t believe I would want to fuck him. Like touching me was…a privilege.”
Carmen exhales sharply through his nose.
“Fuck...” he mutters.
You open your eyes, and this time his are shut tight.
“You picturing it?” you ask softly, accompanied by a small whimper.
His mouth twitches. “Trying not to.”
You’re in a daze, mumbling as your arms lock around the back of his neck. Your legs around his torso. “I was always on top. He wouldn’t touched unless I asked him to.”
“I n-never got to suck him off, wouldn’t let me… but god, did he eat pussy like it was his last meal…”
That does it.
The image of you riding that poor pathetic country boy.
The image of him nose deep in your cunt, face wet and wrecked.
Carmen leans down, forehead pressing into the side of your neck. “Jesus Christ.”
Your hands slide into his hair. “You asked.”
“I know…” he says, voice rough. “And I fucking hate how much I needed to hear it.”
He kisses you—deep, claiming, like he’s erasing something. His movements are sharper now, more possessive, like he’s reminding you both of who’s cock your on right now.
When he pulls back, his voice is barely steady.
“Say my name.”
You do.
And he doesn’t ask about Dennis again—not tonight.
Even by the time you collapse together, it’s clear that whatever this is isn’t over.
Not even close.
Tag list: @deansdeer @str4wbsstuff @yeschefcarm @yeschefcarmy @chrys-lism @lactosesocks @cafe-of-insomnaics @friendly-neighborhood-boricua @whenisthefall @lilpeachyyyyy @annie-panda @aphroditeincarnated @peachyfckingkeen @latenightreadingpdf @sapiensecrets @captkrks @mayisbae @abbotitts @whoreforlupin @bmo-bri @robinavitchabbotslut @fawns-filed @mewmew222 @nicksolemnlyswears (if you where not tagged when u asked to be that means I can’t tag u bc of ur mentions settings!!)
summary — being home for summer break means finding a bit of odd and steamy comfort within the chef who catered your younger brother’s baseball banquet.
word count — 24.4k
warnings — 18+ MDNI, porn w/plot (f&m oral, protected&unprotected pinv sex, public sex, naughty texts), age gap (reader 20, mikey 50-51), pet names (hon, lil’ thing, pretty thing, etc.), no use of y/n, very vague prior suicide attempt mentioned, mention of opioid addiction, na meetings, social drinking, terrible banter & jokes, questionable decisions/bad communication, natural bodies, rude & vulgar language
author’s note — no, this did not trigger a vague memory for myself…i say unconvinced
chicago summertime, the air was maybe still a little musty and thick, but the wind whipped enough to diminish the smell that usually made your nose scrunch. hot, earthy air with a mix of preteen boys wearing entirely too much salt and pepper body spray was not ideal, but you still stood smiling, urging your brother and his friends to squish together for a picture. you were thankful that the body spray was masking some of the musk from the few teammates who clearly had a hard time remembering their deodorant.
they seemed grown up in their little suits and knock-off baseball chains, each one sporting their number. thirteen hung around your little brother’s neck; most thought it was unlucky, but he made it his own proudly. they didn’t have on mucky cleats or red clay stains in their britches; they were little gentlemen standing on a faux red carpet. of course, their acne-ridden faces, crooked ties, and suit jackets that sat a little too large on their shoulders were a little laughable. no one attending this banquet would deny how happy the team looked together. they were all acting like they were major league players, and no one was going to halt their excitement.
they were halfway through their season, and the coach was exceptionally proud—he had to be proud because he was your dad. maybe even more proud because your little brother, cameron, was showing an overwhelming amount of potential, especially when he would start attending high school the year after next. if your brother continued on this uphill climb, his college would be paid for much like your own. although an athletic scholarship didn't send you to live out of state, you weren't nagging the “free” money from the academic successes you were reaping the benefits from.
in contrast to the team’s peak attire, the family and friends that were in attendance had toned down their appearance. you were in a two-day-old pair of ripped jeans and a “go cubbies” shirt because that was the cleanest laundry out of your overpacked suitcase that was sitting on the floor of your childhood bedroom. you had only been in town for a day, feeling too tired from the packing and traveling to do anything with the mess you had brought home to even attempt to organize it.
the interior of the gymnasium had cheap streamers and a balloon arch to make the banquet seem like more than it really was, but no one seemed to mind because of the hilariously awkward cue cards the local commentator, benny amato, from the sports park was reading that your father and assistant coach had written.
you were brought a plate of food by your mother as you swiped through the group photos you had taken, trying to find at least one “serious” one that all their mothers wanted. your eyes widened seeing the overfilled plate, large meatballs smothered in some well-seasoned pasta sauce, and the noodles seemed to be handmade, none of that overcooked, soggy dining hall food you managed to choke back when attending school. your father was right behind her with bowls of caesar salad that she couldn't manage to carry for you both; even the salad had a healthy slab of garlic bread on top, so buttery and fragrant.
you slid your phone into your pocket as mr. amato was finally getting to the awards portion of the banquet after he had passed his long and draining introductions. people loved a good meal and entertainment to go with it because this wasn't some fancy event; this was high class. this was the dundies from the office, but adding adolescence in a crumby gymnasium and taking away the ability to overdrink in a chili's.
‘eye on the ball’ was the first golden bat trophy to be awarded. it wasn't given to jace kowak for his exquisite ability to catch a multitude of plays, it was for the three black eyes he'd acquired so far this season. and even with this first crumby joke out of the way, you knew you'd be sitting through twelve more while stuffing your face with food that you planned to eat cold while standing in the light of the fridge later tonight.
the dorm room meals you managed to cook in the shared kitchen weren’t anything fancy, but they were tasty. however, you were sitting here thinking you’d receive some subpar food like at every other community event you’ve ever attended, but no, this—this was something remarkable. this wasn't watered-down pasta sauce, gummy noodles, and tough, questionably sourced meatballs—this was so good. you were looking forward to your mother’s cooking after you’d been away, but even her home-cooked meals would be hard to top this.
you looked up from your plate to see another player proudly collecting his golden bat for “true grit.” imagine that—the kid was awarded for getting a mouthful of sand on his latest slide from last week’s game. benny amato’s voice was grating. you were managing to only filter out some of it, and the other half was causing you to stifle any eye roll that was surfacing. you had to remind yourself that you were being a good sister and that you loved your brother.
luckily, your brother was next, walking to the stage with his head held high. he had to anyway. he just was given high honors on the “ball buster” trophy. oh yeah, the week before last he took one right to the sack…and still kept running. you didn't expect to receive that call when you were drunkenly eating sushi beside your roommate as you scrolled on tinder. fortunately, the emergency room cleared him as quickly as he came in.
“never seen cam look so proud,” your mom laughed as she nudged you. you were continuously snapping pictures for her as your dad cheered as if he was oblivious to the fact that his son was getting an award. maybe his yelling was just a little more obnoxious than needed, or maybe it was only obnoxious because of your tiredness.
when your brother returned to his seat, you were slinking out of your chair. “i’m going to the bathroom,” you mumbled, excusing yourself from the table.
you made your way outside for a breath of fresh air. you had barely a moment of peace since returning home. the ride home from the airport was deafening. everyone was crammed into the car, speaking at you rather than to you. each one of them with a new set of questions from last time. your father was prodding about the storage unit you were renting, your mom was wondering why your friend lizzie wasn't in your final day pictures, and cameron was digging through your school bag, questioning every item.
the street lights had not yet turned on. the summer sun was taking its time setting. cars were buzzing along the road carelessly. the ‘l’ added that extra sound that made it home. it was the moment you needed because you did miss chicago, but not enough to stay. this three-month venture would be the longest you've been home since you graduated from high school. last summer, you visited for two weeks because you crashed in your friend’s apartment until you were able to move into a new dormitory. you were stuck at home this year because the leasing arrangement with your new apartment fell through until two months into the new school year. so, you lugged your things into a storage unit and flew back home.
“sorry, didn't know somebody was moping out here.”
you turned your head, straightening your posture. “i'm not moping,” you responded to the caterer, only able to recognize his job by his navy shirt with thick white writing on the pocket—“the bear–berzatto owned.”
“sure as hell looks like moping,” he chuckled, lighting a cigarette. “upset you didn't get a trophy for fighting the ump?” he leaned against the wall next to you. the siding of the gymnasium was warm and oddly comforting. he had his apron thrown over his shoulder. he had tanned italian skin a in similar fashion to lots of locals in the area, broad shoulders, a crooked nose that seemed to have seen a fight or two before, and that smug smile that seemed to draw you in to look for more.
a smile began to flicker against the corner of your mouth, taking more of this man’s appearance in as he took a drag of his cigarette. “no, just annoyed that i’m home,” you shrugged, pausing to look ahead rather than at this stranger that your eyes had been giving far too much attention to. the silver in his dark hair came in streaks, and his beard had those same shiny flecks in them that were definitely not exiting your mind as you looked ahead to the roadway. “i think i'm going to kill my entire family before the summer is over.”
a laugh came from the caterer. “i’m going to act like i didn't hear a premeditation to murder, but what i can do is give you a little peace,” he offered his cigarette to you.
you gave a nod of appreciation, taking the smoke between your fingers and inhaling steadily before handing it back.
“what’s got you so worked up that you're willing to take a life sentence?” the caterer questioned after a lull of silence. you finished exhaling as he began inhaling.
“summer off from college, and i can't stand being here,” you were finally looking at him again. “this is home, but i'm not living here,” you gestured loosely as the older man forked over the cigarette again. he knew you needed it. his arms were tattooed; the line work seemed like it was time for a touch-up. “now i'm dropping all my complaints on you, and i don't even know you.”
“michael berzatto,” he didn't wait to introduce himself because it seemed like he didn’t mind listening.
he said he preferred mikey over michael. when you gave your name, it seemed like he’d never say it because he had a multitude of pet names at his disposal that would be easier.
you shared names and cigarettes. you shared blown smoke and some weird, unspoken mutual decision to silently flirt back with your eyes. both of you thought nothing bad could happen from a little camaraderie.
“i was gone a while too,” mikey confessed, vaguely with very little explanation. “but i’m back now.”
“i feel like i can't breathe here. i don't know how you came back,” you retorted, letting your newfound confidant have the final smoke of his cigarette. it wasn't long after he stamped it out that he lit another one. maybe it was to keep you talking, or maybe it was because he wasn't satisfied after the first one.
mikey wasn’t a polished guy, but you’d be lying if you said you weren't still looking, but the strange part was that he was looking back. not looking past you or even afraid to make eye contact. he had his focus set. he was soft around the middle, a slight wrinkle in his forehead and around his eyes when he made any face other than his resting one, and his hands had seen work—scarring, burns, cuts, all of it.
“still can't breathe, not on some days, but better than where i was,” mikey concluded. the cigarette rested between his fingers for a minute before passing it to you to take the first inhale of the burning tobacco.
he's gentle, and you didn't know how gentle he was in reality, but the version you were receiving right now seemed peaceful and likable. he wasn't agreeing with everything you said or pushing you to speak. words fell out of your mouth because they seemed easy to spill with him. it was silent again between the two of you, but that seemed to be loud enough while the cigarette moved back and forth again.
“you guys did good with the food and all,” you added when it got just a bit too quiet, especially when you found yourself standing a bit too close. you didn't move away when you noticed.
“i think if we woulda brought any more food coach woulda been rolling his players outta here,” mikey chuckled, flicking the ash to the side of him. his last name matched the one on his shirt. you cracked a smile.
“you own it? the restaurant, i mean,” you shook your head when he offered the cigarette back. you had enough to calm your nerves already.
“me and my brother, the short one, not the lunatic who was handing out drinks,” mikey rubbed the underside of his nose with his index knuckle, watching as you tugged up the waistband of your jeans. “we renovated a few years ago, still got the original beef window on the side, but it's nicer on the inside.”
“nothing fancy?”
“hell no, kids are knockin’ their juice over in their pasta, it doesn’t have a dress code, and the kitchen is still good at yellin’ at each other,” he stamped the cigarette out. “but that’s what's good about it.” what mikey meant to say was that it wasn’t a shit hole anymore because he had his head screwed on the right way around.
“glad i got to try it,” you looked back towards the door. you knew you had to return soon to avoid questioning from your mother. “i guess my dad can get on my nerves, but he knows how to pick good food.”
“coach’s daughter? i’'m goin’ to hell,” mikey let out a breathy exhale, no longer leaning on the wall. connecting those dots fully seemed to make his eyes widen.
mikey casually smoked with some little college hottie that just so happened to also be the daughter of the man that was paying him tonight. shit always seemed to follow him, yet there he was still enjoying your presence.
“nah, you’re going to hell because you smoked two cigarettes with a twenty-year-old,” you took a step towards the entrance. “and you liked it,” you put your fingers into a cross and teasingly rubbed “shame” in his direction. you heard a chuckle as you walked back into the gymnasium.
“you sure you don't want me to wait until you come out?” your father pestered again, looking at you about to reenter the empty gymnasium. the banquet was a success. the entire team went home happy and fed. most of them were toting plates of leftover food, including you. you couldn't let it go to waste, especially not after your appetite was curbed from smoking. you handed the plate to your mother as she walked by, knowing your late-night snack would be safe in her hands since they were going straight home.
“dad, i'll be fine. i just forgot my phone,” you assured him as he gave that skeptical glance about not being able to watch you safely leave in the sedan you were borrowing from your mother. “i need to stop by walgreens anyway and get another charger; mine is busted,” you explained, hope that would be enough to allow him to leave.
forgetting your phone may not have been an accident. after being on the cleanup crew with your family, you may have strategically placed the device on the table nearest the catering station.
the car keys were hanging loosely in your hand as your father looked back at his single-cab truck. cameron and your mother were piling inside.
“alright, be safe tonight, baby girl,” he placed a gentle hand on your shoulder, squeezing it lightly.
as you re-entered the gym, you saw mikey counting the fold-out tables he had stacked against the wall. his final task for the night was to load all the tables and chairs into the restaurant’s van and bring them back. richie, his best friend and drink slinger for the night, had already gone back with carmen, the shorter caterer, to clean all the serving equipment.
“left somethin’?” he asked, pulling your phone out of his pocket when he heard the door close. his head was slightly cocked when he looked at you. as he handed it over a picture of you and your friend from your university semi-formal lit up with the time. he didn’t have a hard time knowing it was yours.
“yeah, thanks,” you mumbled, not understanding why you had now become so nervous. the lights in the open room were buzzing. the commotion of the families caused you not to notice how much the white noise had been drowned out.
you looked around, playing with the phone in your hand, letting it clack against the key ring.
“did you forget somethin’ else?” he asked, reading off a checklist.
“your number,” you blurted out quickly as if you were ripping off a band-aid. the keyring slipped into your back pocket with your phone.
“my number?” mikey’s thick eyebrows furrowed. “you fuckin’ with me?” he asked, his voice lighter as he was about to laugh. he wasn’t taking you seriously at all.
“no,” you assured him, looking around again. that twinge in the back of your mind was pressing, saying ‘what the hell am i doing?’ this was a moment of realization, getting yourself into something that might haunt you for the rest of your nights. potential rejection was scary, but what was more horrifying was the fact that you were asking a man who clearly had the upper hand on your age. “just needed something to get through the summer.”
“they all left,” mikey uttered, knowing you were scoping out the area, but his statement seemed like permission. his lips were slightly parted as if he wanted to say something else, but you didn't give him a chance. your hand was resting on his forearm. his hand flexed, only able to grab the closest thing to him to bring you closer—the hem of your cubs shirt. he preferred the red sox, but the cubbies were bringing home the win tonight.
god, you reminded him of his younger self—desperate, hungry, hard to control, but easy to talk.
it was a split second before your hands scrambled to the back of his neck. mikey leaned down, pressing his lips to yours. you were sharing those cigarettes again—more intimately than before—adding a touch of desperation to them. you could taste the stale menthol, somehow it was surprisingly refreshing, knowing you might have possibly been making the biggest mistake of your life.
this wasn't another bar crawl with your shitty fake id, picking up some asshole from a fraternity; this was older and bolder. you didn't feel nervous outside of illinois in the local college bars as you inspected your potential prospects while sipping a vodka cran, but michael berzatto haphazardly walking backwards with you in an empty gymnasium as you sloppily made out with him was anxiety-inducing.
you gripped the back of his shirt. your fingers grazed the back of his neck. your mouth opened to catch a partial breath, and another clumsy step backward sent both of you knocking into a stack of chairs. your eyes opened. your cheeks were flush, and your heart rate spiked as you pulled yourself into mikey's chest to try and protect your sneaker-cladded feet from the domino effect of the chairs.
mikey licked his right canine tooth. he was just shy of the clear portion of the wall where he meant to back you into, unable to successfully do it moments ago. his attention had been focused on you while deepening the kiss and guiding you blindly backward.
“christ, i haven't—” mikey tugged you to the side of the fallen chairs. your head softly thudded on the wall behind you. he was placing quick kisses against your jawline. his scruffy beard was brushing against your cheek. “—done this in a long fuckin’ time,” he finished, resting his hand between your thighs and running his thumb across the light-washed denim.
“i think you're doing fine.” it was possibly the quickest you felt any type of growing arousal, especially as he captured your lips again. this was clumsy and unorganized, but not unlikeable. it was wonderfully awkward, and somehow knowing a stack of chairs crashed down was comforting because it felt natural and carefree. mikey’s confession also helped, settling some of the tension that you felt on your shoulders.
one of your hands trailed to the waistband of his jeans. your fingers were hooked into the top of his cotton boxers. his fingers are gently stroking higher on your inner thigh. the softest touches held the heaviest meaning behind them. this time, it was him pulling away from the kiss.
“wait,” he held your wrist, though your fingers didn’t retract. “you got—y’know a condom or somethin’?” he asked, though you laughed.
“no, i brought my phone and keys that aren’t even mine.” you bit your lip, quickly apologizing for laughing and for your lack of preparation.
he started laughing too. he couldn’t help himself. he didn’t bother looking through his pocket when he knew he didn't have anything useful. “i’m fifty. the most protection i have is a roll of tums to prevent heartburn,” he looked up at the ceiling. his laughter increased only because otherwise he would begin thinking far too much about how risky this situation was.
“i-i’m on the pill,” you cleared your throat, though more giggles were peeking through as he swatted your hand away from his pants.
“jesus,” mikey sighed as he began cracking up again. “bad idea waitin’ to happen.” his hand was still between your thighs. he wasn’t backing off, and neither were you. you were looking up at him. the hand that was on his boxers was now resting on his chest.
“you’re right,” you swallowed hard, but you didn’t move. you didn't want to admit it, but he was right. your eyes darted from his soft eyes to his lips. he wasn’t pressing or rushing. you were staring, and he was too.
his laughter faded, dipping his head again. you met his lips. even after the laughter and moment of cognizance, the excitement was still there. he was focused on tasting the remnants of your chapstick—a flavor he couldn’t quite place—it was cherry, but something deeper than just the fruit. maybe something nutty.
his hand slipped from your thighs and began to unbutton your jeans. he was toying with your zipper. his fingers grazing your panties—the funky floral ones that came in every basic four-pack of underwear—you were wishing you had made a better decision when digging through your suitcase.
“listen to me, i’m too old for that leg lockin’ bullshit,” mikey muttered against your mouth, working down his own pants. trusting within the age-old pull-out method was something mikey hadn't done since he was your age, but in this moment, he needed to believe in something.
“got it,” you mumbled, stepping out of your sneakers to tug down your jeans. you understood where his nervousness was stemming from, much like him, you didn't want a pregnancy scare at the end of this little excursion for pleasure.
mikey’s hands were grasping at your thighs. you were palming the front of his jeans, his semi-hard erection was growing by the second. neither of you wanted to stop. if anything, the touches only grew more hasty and hungry.
with your jeans discarded and your horrendous floral underwear on display. your legs were spread and his fingers were toying with the wet splotch you had created on your panties just from a few simple times of mikey’s fingers grazing you. you were unfastening the button to his jeans.
mikey was kissing your neck, a soft sigh coming from his mouth as he felt your hand move past his boxers. your heart was pounding as his fingers slipped past the seam of the gusset of your panties and applied the slightest bit of pressure. your legs were already trembling.
his thumb grazed past your clit after one affirming touch to signify he was capable. two of his fingers then slipped inside like they were meant to be there. there you were dripping into the palm of his hand with your eyes closed, feeling the outline of his thick cock through his pants.
your underwear was bunched to the inner crease of your right thigh. they were moved over just enough so mikey’s fingers could coat themselves in the sweet arousal you produced.
you had your other hand gripping the dark curls that graced mikey’s neck. with your lips slightly parted, you were pushing against his hand, trying to collect more sensation than he was allowing you to have.
the hollow gymnasium only embraced the sound of the smallest whine you uttered, echoing loudly off all the walls. mikey brought his head up to rest on yours.
you rocked against his middle and ring finger as he thrust them inside of you, falling into him as your jeans gripped the midsection of your thighs. he just had to be sure that you were ready, and a small part of him was enjoying the fact that someone was already falling apart for him.
there was no way he could keep you against that wall without his hip or back making a noise that would be embarrassing and even more telling of his age. he already had on a knee brace under his jeans after he had to single-handedly rearrange the walk-in after having to perform maintenance on one of the cooling fans when fak the handyman wasn't available. he could save himself from another hint of embarrassment because he wasn't walking around with a salonpas patch across his lower back today.
the gym floor it was. if you didn't think about it too hard the scuff marks would be less noticeable and the faint smell of wax would be concealed by the overwhelming sensation of him hovering over you, helping you drag off your bottoms and letting your panties hang around one ankle so they wouldn't be hard to track down when you needed to make your leave.
you gave your jeans a final kick. you looked wide-eyed at your mismatched no-show socks. one was neon pink and the other was a basic white; that was the least of your concerns compared to the full tent in mikey’s jeans.
his apron over his shoulder had been shrugged off into the same pile as your jeans. mikey was wasting no time, mostly because the longer he would wait would mean, the less likely he was to get antsy.
his pants were soon bundled at his knees, cock sprung outward freely instead of being contained by his pants and underwear. he gave his cock a generic stroke using the remainder of your wetness and a palm full of spit to coat his shaft. he gripped the base of his shaft and balls for a little support.
the tops of his meaty thighs were hairy as well as his pubic region. his wiry hair was wild and unkempt—a full bush—but that meant one thing: he was a real locally grown man. he had nothing to be embarrassed by, as seen by your surprised face, but he couldn't help feeling a little vulnerable. you had to feel that way, too; the only easy part about this situation was that you both had no strings attached. even if there would be a repeat a few days from now, you both didn't know each other enough to care.
him entering made you dig your nails into the back of his biceps as your back arched off the ground. your wet pussy was already clenching around him, unable to fully comprehend the amount of his dick you were taking.
you realized you weren't breathing when mikey was lightly patting your cheek with his free hand. “hey, hon,” he mumbled. “y’with me, lil’ thing?” he asked as his eyes raked over your expression.
“y-yeah, fuck, just give me a second,” you swallowed, feeling that stretch from some girthy italian dick wasn't what you were accommodated to. the last guy who got lucky with you was average—that was the nicest way to say it anyway.
mikey was slowly rocking his hips into you as he pulled one of your legs over his shoulder, trying to help you adjust to his size further.
this was like a porno with some clickbait title like: COLLEGE GIRL GETS FUCKED RAW BY OLDER MAN **IT DOESN'T FIT!!**
time was of the essence, mikey had to return to the restaurant, and you still had to do the walk of shame into a chain convenience store to get a new phone charger and a plan b just to be safe before your parents suspected you were gone too long.
he ran one hand under your shirt to rub circles into your waist. every touch he placed was intentional, however, it was somewhat hurried.
mikey was rocking his hips gradually, an uneven exhale left his mouth. his jaw was slack, hearing the soft whines of pleasure slip from your lips. your stomach would tighten and release, only gripping him inside of you further. he had said not to lock your legs, but you were completely out of control with the way your pussy was clenching his shaft.
“fuckin’ hell,” he muttered, tightening his hold on your elevated leg. every time he thrust, your body was rocking back from the sheer amount of force he was exuding. he couldn't stop, not with the pretty little sounds that were so determined to keep him going. he couldn't understand how tightly your pulsing cunt was begging him to keep him inside.
mikey's shirt began to bunch. the mild annoyance was enough to take his hand off your hip and slip just the hem of it into his mouth. his pudgy, wooly stomach was meeting you each time he pushed his throbbing cock into, each time just a bit further than before, his swollen tip just barely kissing your cervix. his balls were slapping against you.
shame was beyond recognition at this moment. it was the two of you having deep, quick, naughty, and highly inappropriate sex. this was somehow the most comfort either of you had experienced for a long time. your peers from college in their five-inch inseam shorts wouldn't ever fuck you like this. even in its quick nature, it didn’t take away from your partner's attention to detail. mikey's last romp was with some crazy-eyed single mom that he totally dodged a bullet with over half a year prior. it was decent sex that got his rocks off, but he had never blocked a number so fast in his goddamn life.
mikey rested his head on your calf as he continued to engulf his rock-hard cock in your needy pussy. his soft grunts and moans were now muffled by the bit of shirt fabric in his mouth. you, on the other hand, only got louder, especially when mikey managed to adjust your hips upward.
he didn't know you, but he knew your body. he was lusting over that sweet squelching noise as he railed you. he was involved in every ounce of you, anchoring his hand firmly into your waist to keep you in place.
right there, where he has you sprawled out on the gym floor, yeah, that was the closest to heaven—maybe it was closer to hell—you had ever been. hitting it just right, opening you up just a bit more, trying to visualize the soaking cunt at his disposal.
your wet folds spread so pretty as his tanned dick slid so easily between your legs. he reached the hand he had over your thigh to your clit.
you tried to moan but were taken aback by the sudden increase in pleasure as mikey circled over your swollen and desperate clit.
what you thought was exceedingly pleasant before was now elevated. which was good for mikey because he didn’t know how much longer he could trust the load he was holding back.
“mikey,” you whined, your nails etching deep half-moon patterns into his forearm as he continued to stimulate the spot you needed most. “m-my god.”
his sweaty temple pressed further into your calf. he could tell you were unwinding, his dick stuffing you so full in some unconventional spot on the gym floor while thumbing at your clit, your echoing moans and pleads bounding off the walls.
“c’mon, pretty thing,” he muttered, letting the shirt between his teeth go. “y’gotta let go. gotta let me see you finish,” he encouraged with a bit of determination behind his voice to finish what he started.
he placed a couple of sloppy kisses on your calf, trying to hold off the ache in his cock. he had you right where he wanted you, writhing against his shaft with a slight flush on your face with your mouth agape, releasing a breathy and sharp gasp.
your head was back for only a moment, picking it back up to watch his thumb flick against your clit. you were leaning on your elbows, closer to him than before, still grasping the hell out of his arm. your breathing was uneven as the teary look in your eyes began.
“uh-uh, there y’go,” mikey praised, watching you unwind in front of him. his rocky thrusts were getting more uneven, feeling your unrelenting pulsing pussy wrapping him so tight.
you were riding that faithful high of satisfaction. mikey was pushing your leg into your chest, getting the final and deepest fuck he could before the heaviness in his balls was too much to bare.
a quick pull out, and he was spilling into his hand and into the apron he gathered from the ground. it was like your body was on fire now, the moment he felt his release, he was letting go and pulling away.
with his hand wiped, he was tugging up his boxers, trying to steady himself while also offering a hand to you, though you declined it. stepping into your panties uneasily, you fished for your jeans.
you were pulling back on your clothes, pushing back your hair, trying to straighten out what little dignity you had left as if you hadn't been obnoxiously moaning for a man who was as old as your dad. the wobble in your legs was noticeable. you'd be taking a couple of extra laps around the store just to sort your bearings out again.
you had snagged his number, which only solidified the fact that this encounter wouldn't be the only one you were destined to have with mikey.
there were a couple of final moments glancing back and forth while mikey tossed his soiled apron in the garbage can. he was still trying to catch his breath and attempting to fix the knee brace under his jeans.
mikey’s night wasn't close to over.
he half-assed cleaned himself before leaving the gym, loaded the rest of the restaurant's equipment in the van, and locked the venue.
he played his music a little too loudly, drumming his fingers against the wheel as he drove, trying to shove down the smile he had creeping onto his face.
stupid. it was really fucking stupid, but god, did it feel good to do something that felt a little wrong.
at the bear, mikey lugged all the rental tables and chairs into the basement, the only non-renovated spot of the entire restaurant.
he and carmen had taken another loan from their late father’s friend, jimmy, to begin redesigning the basement storage space. it wasn’t a bad idea, the dusty and cluttered room needed a revamp, but each time carmen would look into contractors, mikey would become nervous.
the entire restaurant had already changed, and it looked better, ran better, hell, it even smelled better, but the final room was hard to part with. mikey saw too much of himself in his father to completely tear the entire place apart. maybe the basement would be completed another day.
“where the hell you been, man?” richie heard mikey clattering around as he pushed the final table into place.
he pretended like he didn't hear richie, pulling the corner of the table even with the others he had previously stacked against the wall.
“mike,” richie called as his friend tapped the banister to the stairs as he began walking upwards. “where you been?” he questioned again.
mikey couldn't admit that he was balls deep in some college girl because that was stupid. that was immature and maybe a little damning. he'd be open to more criticism than he wanted after a long day, but even thinking back to you sprawled out on the gym floor made him want to laugh. it was eye-opening, heart-stopping sex that made him not feel so old.
he was halfway up the stairs, shrugging off richie’s question. he was looking at his feet as he trekked up the stairs, knowing he wouldn't be able to look at his friend with a straight face.
“had to recount, thought i was missin’ something when i loaded everything.” that was a blatant lie, and richie knew it by the twitch on mikey’s lip when he said it. mikey was trying to push away the smirk he had formed.
“cousin, what the fuck is that look?” richie questioned as mikey made it to the top of the stairs.
“nothin’, just happy we’re done with that shit so we can go home,” mikey waved him off, flicking the lights off as he walked in the hallway. richie was trailing him.
carmen had heard the two talking, slumping as he walked out of the newly cleaned kitchen. he was leaning against the hallway door frame with his eyebrows furrowed. he had told the rest of the staff to leave for the night when they were halfway done cleaning. he wanted to finish the rest himself anyway.
“what did you do?” carmen wasn't trying to dodge the question that needed to be asked. his brother wasn't exactly being subtle. that shit-eating grin was threatening to spread across his brother’s face and his tone of voice was faltering.
“nothin’. damn, what is it with you two?” mikey played the game of avoidance again, an awkward laugh leaving his mouth as he attempted to push past the two.
“you look like someone fed you and let you finish,” richie chirped back, earning a gag from mikey.
mikey pointed his finger at his friend, now unable to stifle a laugh and smirk that was forming. “you're a fuckin’ animal, man,” he chuckled, itching the back of his neck.
“oh yeah, got laid. i called it. i was right. you see that, carm?” richie pestered, taking mikey by the shoulders and jiggling him a bit. “he didn't deny it!”
“mikey, what the hell?” carmen’s expression fell. he realized richie was right, and knowing his older brother was banging someone at a catering event wasn't exactly endearing.
“stop, i’m just in a good mood,” mikey cracked another grin.
“you bitch about gettin’ those tables up and down the stairs every time we cater, and now you're grinning stupid,” carmen retorted, pressing a little further. he had to hear mikey say it for himself, and not base it off of richie’s factoid—correction—suspicion.
richie dismissed carmen, turning his attention to mikey, looking directly into his eyes. “where? and how hard?” he did a mocking whistle after.
“you're a goddamn dog,” mikey pointed at his friend, being jostled around a bit more.
“don't tell me it was on the tables. we'd have to throw ‘em out and get more,” carmen accused, hoping that mikey had some sense of respect in his questionable decision making.
“not on the tables,” mikey waved off his brother and then turned his head. “not sayin’ it was anywhere else either,” he corrected himself, hearing richie’s laugh grow louder.
“jesus fuckin’ christ,” carmen muttered, holding the bridge of his nose. “let’s go the fuck home.”
mikey’s morning narcotics anonymous meeting went as expected. a refresher, if anything, a reminder that he was sober. a reminder that he was still an addict even after seven years of sobriety. a mental reset to start the day on a fresh note after tossing and turning the entire night thinking about you.
that post-nut-clarity hit differently when he finally realized that sleeping with a client’s daughter probably wasn’t the smartest move. the client’s daughter who was thirty years younger than him, with whom he barely second-guessed dropping to the gym floor with.
he had that little black key ring to remind himself that he was “clean and serene for multiple years of recovery,” but that still didn’t stop him from attending two meetings a week to keep himself in line. it was routine at this point. one at the beginning of the week and one at the end.
he could go without them; he really could, but there was something about sitting with a group of people with the same problems. he didn’t always talk, but on days that he really felt shoddy, he spilled.
mikey had his life put together in a certain way; what used to be unevenly stacked bullshit that always came crumbling down was now a science. he had to rebuild everything. it was like gaining a second life on top of the old one. he was the same person, only now able to make clear and conscious decisions about fixing everything his addiction had once broken. he was still paying money to the irs in back taxes and penalties because he was prepared to leave the world and his mess for someone else to clean up. that wasn't mentioning all of his credit cards, loans separate from jimmy's 300,000 dollars he had stored away, and the endless number of people he said he would pay back. his life was better now, steadier. the income from the restaurant was now worth it. carmen helped him make something safe.
seven years later and he was still wary of taking tylenol or over-the-counter cold and flu medication because he was worried it might trigger him. he didn't drink because his mother, donna, who still hadn't received help for her suspicious drinking habits, made it seem like an easy vice to become hooked on.
he had his head above water, treading carefully but with purpose.
but you. you were new and unexpected, and delightfully terrifying. because why the hell was he staring at a picture of your tits at ten o'clock on a sunday monday morning. he was standing in his office overlooking the invoices natalie, his sister, had finalized when his phone buzzed in his pocket.
you had no shame, not even a little. you were sitting in your childhood bedroom, procrastinating the need to unpack because living out of a suitcase seemed easier than committing to fully being back in chicago. your discarded sleep shirt was sitting in your lap, one hand bundled your cleavage together as you snapped a picture.
10:03 AM
you: think you missed something last night
you: *attached an image*
10:05 AM
mikey: didn't have time
mikey was sitting back in his chair, palms sweating ever so slightly as he looked over the photo again. your sheets lay over your lap, sitting up, not showing your face. imagine breaking in a new contact like that, sending a ridiculously scandalous picture of your breasts to a man who had priorities and real responsibilities.
10:05 AM
mikey: willing to try harder when i see u again
eesh, he knew this would happen. absolutely no shame within himself to so easily send that message.
10:10 AM
you: *attached a video*
you: promise?
not safe for work at all. your hand had dropped, and you were on display on his cellphone when he was supposed to be double-checking that all the invoices were lining up with the monthly budget.
not safe for work at all. your hand had dropped, and you were on display on his cellphone when he was supposed to be double-checking that all the invoices were lining up with the expected income from the client list. his open documents on his office computer had gone dim. his attention was fully on the technology in his hand.
mikey had watched the short clip a couple of times. watching your hand drop so effortlessly to let your breasts fall and then you giving an assist to jiggle them. if his pants weren't tightening before they sure as hell were right now. he pulled the crotch of his jeans down to find more comfort in his sitting position.
10:12 AM
mikey: i know what i’m getting into now
mikey: my place tonight?
10:12 AM
you: lucky for you my schedule is very open
you: but you owe me $51.13 for hitting it raw
you: *sent a payment request for $52*
10:13 AM
mikey: i'm going to be out 87 cents
10:13 AM
you: i know my worth
10:14 AM
mikey: i’ll be showered by midnight
mikey: *shared an address pin*
mikey was bouncing his foot anxiously, though he was dawning that signature smirk that he was wearing the night before as he was heckled by richie and carmen.
10:23 AM
you: see you later
you: buy condoms thx
read at 10:23 AM
mikey was staring blankly at his phone screen, knowing today would seem like the longest day of his life because he had to wait to see you again.
“hey, you good?” carmen knocked on the doorframe of mikey's office. with a single click mikey's messaging screen snapped to black. he cleared his throat, tossing his phone next to the invoices. his hand on his lap quickly, like he had been caught in something.
carmen seemed to be asking more than just how his day was going, but not wanting to fully commit to his questioning, last night was enough. without richie in the room, it seemed harder.
“yeah,” he assured his youngest sibling. “just finishing this up.” he gathered the printed papers in his hand and nudged his computer mouse with his hand so the virtual spreadsheet would reappear.
“alright, you're on beef with ebra today. church down the street did a fundraiser and i jus’ know he's gonna be slammed after service lets out,” carmen explained as his eyes darted around mikey's office.
“good call,” mikey nodded. he was like the floater and didn't mind it. it allowed carmen to keep the level of control he liked, and it allowed mikey to be where he was needed, keeping busy all the time, whether it was front of house, main kitchen, beef window, or maintenance.
“alright,” the shorter nodded, drumming his fingers against the door frame.
“alright,” mikey agreed, the rolling chair underneath him giving a slight squeak as he moved his shoulder blades back.
“yeah,” carmen mumbled, patting the door frame one last time, backing into the hallway.
“carm, ‘m good.” mikey knew his brother was lingering. he couldn't blame him too much. he had every right to question his well-being after putting him through hell for so many years prior.
“thirty-five minutes ‘till we're bustin’ our asses again,” carmen cleared his throat as he called out the final warning on time before service began. he couldn't say much else. he had to take mikey's word for it, and whatever weird impulsive decision he had made last night was nothing to be concerned about.
carmen was always nagging natalie for her incessant ability to ask how people were, and now he always saw himself doing it with mikey because he wasn't around when his brother was struggling the most.
“heard,” mikey gestured loosely, facing his desk again to find his focus again. he had to check just a bit of the documents before he slid himself into the kitchen for the tail end of prep.
it was just past midnight and there you were, standing in your bright blue and orange university sweatshirt and free people shorts, in the middle of mikey's living room, letting him pull you into his chest. he was pushing back your hair, making sure not to let it snag on your earrings. your fabric purse was still hanging off your shoulder.
small talk occurred for less than five minutes, mostly him making sure you had arrived safely. you didn't ask how his day was until he asked about yours.
mikey’s apartment was clean for the most part. he had a laundry pile stacked on a chair that seemed to never be used other than for that purpose. the curtains were a little crooked as well. his shoes were nestled by the door, and keys were thrown on the counter next to his cigarettes and wallet. his clutter was mostly on his coffee table, mail, loose pens, sharpies, and cups that hadn't made it to the sink. his knee brace was also there. he had no use for it right now, although he thought that he might regret not having a little extra support later.
he had many pictures, all of which had some sort of rae dunn frame. you assumed they were gifts, although you didn't know mikey well he didn't seem like the person to pick stark white frames saying things like “live, laugh, love,” or “family,” in that signature thin, black capitalized font.
he had one hand on your cheek, caressing his thumb against it. he had the opportunity to actually take his time with you now. he was appreciated every bit of you. this didn't have to be quick tonight seeing as you were both safely in the confines of his own home.
he smelled clean, his outgrown hair was still a little damp. he seemed like he had at least taken the time to trim his beard before you came, lining up more evenly with sharper angles.
mikey didn't know where to begin because his hand was still resting on your cheek, trying to gauge your expression. you weren't trying to hurry him, but you were certainly not waiting. you were on his turf, but claiming just a bit of it for yourself by leaning in to kiss him.
it felt right to live in this moment, feeling him take the subtle kiss you started and turn it into a more developed moment. your bottom lip quivered against his, drinking in the desire he had for you in one simple motion. he parted your mouth, edging his tongue inside of your mouth. his thumb was still resting against your cheek.
he guided your waist closer with his other hand, two of his fingers were hooked inside the thick band of your athletic shorts. you were flush against him, angling your head more to allow his tongue to inch further.
you were running your hands underneath his shirt, feeling chill bumps appear as you touched him.
“y'wanna take this somewhere more comfortable?” he mumbled, kissing your cheek. he had a conventional spot that was far more pleasant than the gymnasium floor.
you agreed, being led back to his bedroom, which was more bare than the den. his closet door was slightly cracked open. there was a clothes hamper in the corner that wasn't overly full. a candle he had never used was sitting on his dresser. the condoms you had told him to buy were unopened on his nightstand. his bed frame was metal, and squeaky. when you sat down you slightly cringed from the noise.
“sorry ‘bout that, i got it second hand a few years ago because my sister told me i couldn't be forty-five with my mattress on the floor,” he was standing in front of you, watching you reach over and put your purse next to the box of condoms.
“she sounds like a smart woman,” you had a faint smile on your face. mikey had his hand resting between your thighs, beginning to crawl over you, replacing his hand with his knee, dividing your legs.
you laid back as he was inching his way on top of you, helping him tug off his shirt. the faint hum of the window unit kicking on could be heard as he helped you out of your collegiate sweater and lacy bralette.
you spent entirely too long pulling apart your suitcase to find that bralette and matching panties and he pulled it off of you without a second thought. it showed how much he truly cared about those floral panties and mismatched socks from last night.
his knee was firmly placed at your crotch, feeling that small bit of pressure was enough to send you spiraling. his lips were dragging across your chest, the tip of his crooked nose was nudging the side of your breast. a bulge in his gym shorts was as things were only escalating by the second.
he was nipping at your skin, adding another layer to this entire experience, littering your skin with twinges of pleasurable pain. he always stopped right before your erect nipples, only ever giving them enough stimulation from his breath and nothing more.
you were biting into your bottom lip as if it would save you from his teasing. his knee only further pressing into you. you were pushing yourself into him, both your clothed bottom half and your exposed top half arching ever so slightly off the bed.
mikey pushed your chest down, holding one finger to your sternum once you were lying flat on the bed. “lil’ thing, you gotta let me enjoy you for a bit.”
a whine left your mouth as his lips grazed past again. his top lip rested on your skin and his bottom lip was on the band of your shorts.
“couldn't get enough'a you last night,” he mumbled into your stomach, giving it one final kiss. “and right now you're tryin’ to rush me when i'm tryin’ to take my time.” he picked up his head, a loose silver curl falling from his bangs.
“you're not being nice about it,” your fingers were running through his full chest of hair, still grinding against his kneecap until he grabbed your thigh.
mikey chuckled, watching you grab his wrist in protest. “i’m not tryin’ to be nice, i’m tryin’ to enjoy myself before i start thinkin’ with my dick.” he took your hand off his wrist, kissing it gently, smirking against your skin for a split second before dropping it on the bed and giving some much-needed attention to your nipples.
you couldn’t expect him not to do it after your teasing video from this morning. he was partially distracted the entire day, having to switch with ebraheim to wrap and bag rather than talk to customers.
he was lightly thumbing at your right nipple as used his tongue to toy with your left. you were arching upwards again. mikey was finding it amusing with how easily you could fall apart, continuing to suckle on your protruding bud.
you were holding his head in place, aching for more as his tongue curled around more. he wasn’t letting up because the moment he switched to your other breast you were in the midst of expressing a breathy gasp.
there wasn’t a good reason for mikey to make you like this. hormones coursing through you knowing if you had any ounce of self-control you probably wouldn’t be reacting like you were.
then came the soft bites at the sides of your breasts and sides, burying further into your skin, purposely now forcing his knee further between your legs.
you sighed with relief shimming down further to meet his leg. mikey’s large hands had a tight hold on your upper body, letting both of his thumbs rub the curve of your breast.
he was staring, really staring. he was watching your eyes close instinctively as you found the right spot on his knee to grind your clit against.
it was a short fleeting feeling. your shorts and underwear were digging into you adding just a bit too much padding to keep generating the correct balance for your pleasure.
you ran your hands up to his face. the moment you opened your eyes was the moment mikey stopped looking, staring at your chest instead.
“what?” you mumbled, snaking out of his hold partially. the rough texture of his facial hair felt jagged against your palms.
“decidin’ how i wanna fuck that lil’ pussy.” mikey wasn't shy about it, dragging your shorts off only to see the same lace pattern on your underwear that he hadn’t acknowledged on your bra in the first place. he tilted his head, beginning to slide off your panties. he glanced over the side of the bed briefly trying to locate your bra but was unable. “‘cause i think you already got an idea on how y’want this night to go—”
“—‘cause you came prepared,” he teased, stepping off the edge of the bed to finish removing your panties and his gym shorts. he had a kind of patience that drove you crazy, watching his hands drag down your legs with certainty in mind.
“not really,” you fibbed, following his lips that dragged from the tip of your right toe, and up the curve of the inner portion of your leg.
“y’show up to my place in matching lingerie the second time you see me, and you're tellin’ me you're not ready?” he was now nipping at your inner thigh with the same aggressive tenderness that he showed your chest.
“i know y’know what y'want,” he continued trying to coax it out of you. he was right, but you didn't expect him to call you out on it. “y'knew what y'wanted last night pretty fast, lookin’ at me with those fuck me eyes before y'even came back for your phone,” he pressed the conversation, letting his chin rest in the crease of your leg. “so, how’d you expect this to go?”
you raised yourself on your elbows, both of you fully exposed, trying to share another moment together if you’d pull yourself together and answer him.
he was looking up at you awaiting a response, halting even his smallest touches to give you his full attention.
“i wanna ride.”
you didn't want to give an explanation, and luckily he wasn't looking for one because you couldn't admit you enjoyed looking at the way he reacted to being inside of you. you had just about killed him the night before, all sweaty, trying to pace himself because although he was feeling younger he really wasn't.
“there it is,” mikey praised, crawling his way past you to reach the box of condoms on the nightstand. you pulled yourself to your knees, scooching out of the way so he could fit comfortably on the bed.
mikey was rolling on a rubber, you were caressing his chest hair as you swung your leg over him to efficiently straddle him. he had a firm hold under your bottom. his throat was getting tight as you fished for his protected cock, anticipating what was coming next.
you were sinking down, your palms flat against his wooly biceps. he moved one of his hands to grip your wrist as you were letting all of your natural lubrication immerse his manhood.
you could feel him wholly inside of your stomach, nestling yourself onto his center shakily. he was rubbing at the slight hump of your wrist bone, helping you settle into that stretch you had yet to forget.
he was looking at you with that same expression of a mixture between worried and needy with his inherently sad brown eyes that seemed to carry more weight than you knew about.
“y’good?” mikey wanted to clarify as he licked over his bottom lip, not daring to inch into you this time, seeing as you had such a determined glint in your eye.
“mhm,” it was almost like you weren't trying to break concentration as you had now known what to prepare for.
that ache between his legs was being satiated the moment you started to find a rhythm within your bounce, lowering your chest to meet his and spreading your knees a bit further apart to get the full length of his substantial shaft.
there was a soft squelch every few moments from repeatedly sliding up and down. you were so wet, and mikey was loving every second of it, not daring to move your positioning especially since you were moaning directly by his ear. he was cupping the curve of your ass feeling the supple skin as your bouncing turned into more of a twerking motion. the squeaking bed frame only became louder by the second.
the fat of your ass jiggling against his lap and hand as you continued to throw your pussy back. mikey was choking back a slurry of groans, burying his forehead into your shoulder while your breast knocked into him.
your legs began to cramp after the multiple minutes of repetitive fucking, and mikey could sense it. your once-calculated motions were slowing and you began trying to find your pattern again by leaning on one leg more than the other.
mikey brought you closer, both of his hands steadying your thighs to gain even an ounce of control. he pulled you flush against his chest as he leaned back, lifting his hips upwards to get a feel for you in the modified position. of course, it felt fucking good with your pussy still wrapped around his cock. his balls already began slapping against you as his upward thrusts fiend for more of your tight, wet cunt.
you gasped softly, turning our face away from him to not accidentally scream into his ear. your entire body tightened.
“right there.” your tone was halfway praise halfway forceful, not wanting whatever spot mikey had found and taken over to stop.
your sweaty bodies were pressed together in his bed creating sweet, dangerously addicting sex. he gave a low breathy chuckle that was almost helpless in a way, nipping your arm as he pounded upwards trying to give you the satisfaction you had just found.
mikey could feel you tightening around him, only continuing to find that spurts of squirt were now beginning to exit your pussy. his head was dizzy, giving into every bit of unadulterated lust within him. you were a mess with your eyes closed tight and frizzy hair, grasping him for dear life.
you were helpless against him only baring your hips down further to contain yourself as you reached your high, panting hard and whining as it coursed through your entire being.
a second film was added to the franchise: AMATUER COCK RIDE LEADS TO SQUIRTING *!WET & MESSY!*
mikey was unraveling as you were, and a final gush of fluid began coating his thigh with his final upward thrust, trying to reach further than was possible with his cock to release. you were whimpering a string of curses as the control he took over your body only became rougher. he was holding the small of your back essentially using you as a toy to finish his orgasm.
penetration alone causing you to climax was surprising, to say the least, and the pool of liquid you coated his chest and lap in was not unheard of, but very uncommon in their occurrence and mikey had single-handedly done both in the two days he had known you.
he released his hold, settling his body back into the mattress. you unsteadily pulled off of his cock, catching your breath momentarily.
mikey let his head hit the pillow as he felt you crawl off of him. his chest was sweaty and heaving. his eyes were closed until he felt the bed even out from your lack of weight on top of the mattress.
“you leavin’?” he asked breathlessly, raising onto one elbow, now pulling the sheets to his waist. he felt exposed now with your quick exit strategy. last night was different, you were both in public. he didn’t know what he expected from you, but it wasn’t to act like nothing just happened.
he wasn't upset about his soaked sheets or the fact that he would be up for another half an hour to change them before he showered; his ego felt slightly deflated knowing you could so easily gather yourself and head out the door, but even that took time for you to perfect.
“well, yeah,” you stated as though it was obvious. your face was still flushed as you were searching for your discarded sports bra. you quickly scooped up your florida gators sweatshirt hand and guarded your chest—as if it was some private sector—not like the man on the bed didn't just take his time kissing and licking your entire body.
“do y'always leave like that?” mikey rephrased his question, watching you pull your bralette out from under the rickety bed frame.
you shrugged. “i don't sleep in strangers’ beds.”
that made mikey not want to be so much of a stranger.
“y'need me to walk you out?”
“i can open the door, mikey,” it wasn't rude, just true. you said it with a smile like you were old friends.
“no, i know,” he nodded, sitting up a little further. “just be safe, y’know?”
you were tugging on your sneakers, seemingly unfazed by the sex and more concerned about taking your leave. “i’ll lock the bottom.” you purse off the nightstand and then did just as you said you would as you left his apartment.
a month had passed, yet there had barely been a day that mikey wasn't making time for you. he seemed to be committed to making your summer as bearable as possible. you weren't staying the night. you were barely talking in person when you were showing up at his apartment. he was giving you an ungodly amount of unholy sex that his neighbors probably despised him for.
this saturday you were at the ballpark, watching your brother in a quick weekend tournament because he had begged you to watch a couple of his games. you had nothing better to do this summer. other than your nightly rendezvous with mikey the days were open other than the occasional rekindle with your friends from high school.
you were sitting in a camping chair, phone in one cup holder, a sweating diet coke in the other. your father's scorebook notebook was in your lap, filling it in for him as the game continued. you were wearing one of his jerseys that you modified to fit better with a hair tie, the team hat, and a pair of denim shorts with stars embroidered on the pockets. the chicago five points was the team your father coached. white jerseys with yellow writing graffitied across the fabric with the addition of bright stars. there was smudged eye black on your cheek from having cameron attempt to take his number off your cheek. there wasn't a chance in hell that you could let him attend a game without letting him get teased just a little bit by his fellow teammates.
the game was wrapping up and you were adding the final scores to the booklet. there would be about an hour and a half until the next game because your brother's team was advancing. if they won the majority of their games today they would be playing at a park further away next weekend.
you looked up from the booklet to see mikey leaning over the fence, waiting for a lull to grab your father's attention. you sunk back in your chair, dragging the capped pen over the scoresheet. after settling his team and telling them what field to return to, he sighed when he saw mikey, already beginning to explain how sorry he was for his outstanding balance from the banquet.
“damn michael, i'm so sorry,” your father apologized again for what seemed to be the umpteenth time in the conversation.
the entire time you were trying to stay focused on the booklet in your hand, trying to replay the plays the team made in your mind rather than honing in on your summer situation talking to your father.
“hey, it's all good coach reggie,” mikey shrugged, sliding the folded check into his pocket. “i know you aren't trying to skip out on a balance.”
“i really did try and pay online, but it wasn't working the same way from when i did the deposit. i called, hell, i don't remember her name, at the restaurant, and she tried to walk me through it but it still wasn't working,” your dad explained, trying not to seem like a total asshole for withholding money he wasn't meaning to withhold in the first place.
“that was probably my sister nat,” mikey was being casual. “like i said it's not a big deal, but if this check bounces you better be prayin’ that i don't start swingin’ one of these bats on you, coach,” he teased, making your father return his humor with a firm pat on his back.
“thanks so much for stopping to get the check by the way, we're living at the park this weekend,” your father joked.
“ain’t a problem, we're even now,” mikey then bid his goodbye. you were trailing up to the fence right behind where mikey was once standing.
“dad, i'm getting a bite to eat from the concession stand, you want anything?” you called out, mikey's head turned as he walked. he heard you, and suddenly he was hungry too.
“no, baby girl, i'm alright,” your father concluded, watching his players exit the diamond.
you had a boat of nachos, nothing fancy, just that thick neon artificial cheese piled on round, salty tortilla chips. leaning against a post near the covered and crowded picnic area, you had napkins under the red and white boat watching mikey come closer with two drinks in his hand.
“stalking me while i'm with my family?” you quipped, taking a bite of one of the cheese-loaded chips. you were extending the tray to him, and with a quick adjustment of the drinks he took a chip.
“your dad is the one who asked me to come over here and pick up his check, thank you, miss smart ass,” mikey covered his mouth as he swallowed the concession stand food. he knew it was going to be bad. “you can have those, i think i've gotten too old for the artery-clogging fluorescent cheese.” he offered a soda to you, as he twisted the top off.
“and you can keep that because i only drink diet,” you ate another chip from the boat like it was nothing.
“so you'll shove down a tray of fake nachos, but get your panties inna twist over full sugar soda?” mikey laughed, taking a long drink of his soda to rid the aftertaste from his mouth.
“i never said i made any sense,” you acknowledged his truth. you may not have made any sense but you knew what you liked.
“don't worry, i know you don't,” mikey retorted, taking a drink of his soda. “but y’know if y’want some real food you can come get some hot italian beef, right?”
you both paused, staring at each other wondering who was going to break the silence by laughing first. it was you, holding your knuckle to your mouth, trying not to choke on the food you were chewing.
“jesus, do you hear yourself?” you questioned through a laugh, wiping your fingers on the napkin under the food tray.
“no, you made it weird. i just asked if y’wanted a sandwich.” mikey was still chuckling.
it was that refreshing silence again, where you were just enjoying each other.
“i gotta bounce, lil’ thing,” mikey held his gaze a little longer. “brother bear's gonna start textin’ in all caps, and then i'm screwed for the rest of the day,” he kissed the top of your cap which made you tense up. “try not to make too many kids cry.”
“no promises,” you itched the side of your arm while looking at the picked-apart nachos in your hand. “gotta keep them humble somehow.”
it wasn’t long before you helped your dad move all of the equipment to the next diamond. the assistant coach was helping the players warm up. your dad was checking over the roster.
“you know that guy i was talking to?” your father asked, watching you line up the batting bags in the dugout in a neater fashion.
“what guy?” you knew what guy, but you had to play stupid.
“the one i was talking to after the last game? you were sitting right there.”
“oh, the one you paid for the banquet,” you mentioned earning a nod from your father.
“yeah, michael—he turned his life around, not many people get that chance.” your father had unknowingly walked into a minefield. you didn't know where this conversation was going when it first began, but this wasn't what you expected at all. you knew you enjoyed what mikey was providing you with, but you didn't know him. your father was just trying to make conversation.
“i don't know him that well, but i know that he was on drugs pretty bad, his brother had to take over the restaurant while he was recovering,” he continued while sipping on a cup of gatorade that was mixed in the nearby cooler. “we ran in different circles, but he’s always been a nice guy, just got a little unfocused for a bit.”
it all felt a little too personal and too real. you had gathered the score booklet again, wanting to take your seat in the camping chair again to comprehend what your dad was really saying.
“that had to be almost ten years ago, give or take, i don't know if other people still like him, but i respect that. he took initiative to get back where he needed to be.”
that left a sinking feeling in your chest. you were volunteered information and now you didn't know what to do with it.
“sounds like he got it figured out.” those were the only words you could muster as you exited the dugout to begin setting your chair up for the next game.
later that night you were lying on your stomach in bed with aloe vera slathered across your cheeks to minimize the sting from the hot sun. you knew you needed a break from mikey, just until you could figure out if you wanted to continue seeing him.
10:10 PM
you: got to wrap up a few things this week. busy sry
11:50 PM
mikey: lmk when ur free
mikey hadn't expected a full week to pass with no contact. he knew you said you were busy, but it was a little unsettling to know you could so easily brush him aside. he knew it would eventually end, but didn't know it would be so soon. he wanted to text and see what you were doing, but he knew better than to try and chase after someone who didn't want him.
“fak, wait,” mikey grumbled, setting down his end of the shelving that needed to be moved so they could put in new wall anchors.
“why am i waiting? you have to actually try to pick it up,” the handyman said defensively, adjusting his backward cap.
“i am pickin’ it up, but you're not turnin’” mikey groaned, knocking his hand against the metal with an eye roll.
fak held his hands up, attempting to offer peace, giving a tilt with his head. “on three?” he offered to try to defuse the situation, knowing his employer was more than a little agitated.
that didn't seem to work at all because the shelf went crashing down, causing mikey to throw the towel he had off of his shoulder. it was hot enough in the kitchen without something going wrong.
“watch it,” carmen spouted from his station, hearing the loud bang against the floor. mikey shot him a glare.
“thank you baby bear for addin’ that wonderful insight to this shitty situation,” mikey was holding his temples as richie stepped in to help them pick the shelving up to the standing position. “the fuckin’ floor is goddamn cracked,” he added, bending down to look at the tile.
carmen didn’t look up, only shooting brother the middle finger.
“cousin, bring it down about half an inch from dick to slightly less of an asshole,” richie suggested, walking backward as he and fak efficiently moved the shelf out of the way.
“don't worry about him, he's only mad because his summer situation benched him,” richie’s snarky comment made mikey throw his hands up. “she probably got sick of his ugly mug and traded up.”
“shut up, rich,” mikey warned, collecting his stud finder and measuring tape to begin the process of installing the l-brackets.
“bro, that's an easy fix,” fak claimed, his face lighting up as he had learned of the new information.
“we are not talkin’ about this,” mikey grunted, not looking away from his handy work on the wall, ensuring both sides were even.
“you gotta schmooze her,” fak claimed.
carmen, although at his station, was muttering a jesus christ, under his breath because the last person anyone would want dating advice from was fak. that burly tattooed maintenance man had ideas, but so did every other living soul on the planet—it didn't mean you took them.
“get her one of those edible arrangements. bitches love fruit,” fak pointed his finger certainly before he got another idea. “or–oh! what about you get her one of those big stuffed animals? all cuddly and shit, yeah she’d want that.”
mikey let fak go on his tangent, half-mindedly paying attention while he got out the drill.
“and boom! romance! works every time,” fak insisted as if he had just solved a world crisis.
monday night—technically tuesday tuesday according to the time—full nine days since you last talked to mikey.
you hadn't warned him that you were coming. you just showed, giving a soft knock on his door and waiting patiently. you didn't even expect him to open the door, but he did, shirtless and in a pair of sweats.
he let you in without much hesitation. he was happy to know you were okay.
“this is weird and i’m sorry,” you apologized, setting your keys on his coffee table. “i should’ve texted you first.”
“it’s okay,” he assured you.
his half-made peanut butter and jelly was waiting on the counter. he wasn’t very concerned with it right now, knowing you were standing in front of him.
“am i screwing with your sobriety?” you asked abruptly.
“next time start with foreplay,” he suggested with a laugh.
“mikey,” you mumbled. “really?”
“first off, i’m a grown man you don’t needa start worryin’ about where my head is. second, i know what i’m doin’ with you.” he was more serious this time, walking back into the kitchen as he spoke.
he put the bread in the toaster and then casually popped the lid off the jam jar.
“i don’t want to be the reason that pulls you back down.” you were standing on the opposite side of the counter watching him.
“i have made worse decisions than you, pretty thing, and plenty of ‘em,” he took the toasted bread out of the toaster and laid it on the paper plate in front of him. his knife was pointed at you before it dipped into the opened peanut butter. “but you and whatever the hell we have goin’ isn’t gonna screw with my sobriety.”
after smearing in the jelly, he cut the sandwich into two triangles taking his side off the plate and then sliding the other half to you. “you know what you’re doin’ though? fuckin’ with my sleep schedule. hard.”
you smirked, looking down at the freshly made sandwich. he was leaning on his hand as he took a bite.
“i’ll blame you forever for that,” he teased.
that night was calm for once. you didn’t end up in his bedroom or even naked for that matter. you sat on the couch with him enjoying the half a sandwich he had made.
you were leaning into his chest watching some low-budget movie on amazon prime. you weren’t fleeting away at any little touch; you were accepting all of them.
you had eaten and your arms were folded over on your chest and your knees were curled up. you were comfortable. you looked at him, really looked at him. the screen would occasionally brighten and you could see that worn tired expression that he wore so well. the wrinkles by his eyes that made him squint just a little when he smiled.
“i’m sorry about earlier.”
mikey shrugged, leaning down to kiss your temple. “don’t apologize for askin’ questions you didn’t know the answer to.” he knew you only asked because it was coming from a good place. you had him in mind and you barely knew him.
“i don’t want to be the reason i mess up what’s working because you have it figured out, and i’m all impulsive and junk…” you trailed off awkwardly.
“pretty girl, you’re supposed to be like that. you’re twenty,” he reminded you, meeting your gaze.
“yeah, but i just don’t want to be somebody’s relapse,” you mumbled, letting the tension soak in the air for just a moment.
“eesh, way to kill the mood,” mikey did a faux shiver, bringing you closer. his back dug into the couch, knowing your words had weight to them. he knew he had to shed a little light on the situation.
“i’m seven years into this, and like you said, i know what works for me and i know what doesn’t. if i knew you were screwin’ me up i’d say something,” mikey admitted, watching your eyes go wide with surprise.
“i mean it—i’ve made enough mistakes to get where i’m at right now.” he held your chin gently. “you’re not even close to ruinin’ me, hon.”
it was oddly comforting to know that you weren’t ruining mikey’s chances at a better life. he had real issues, the kind that had some grit to them. it wasn’t scaring you off knowing he had them.
“but now, it’s my turn to ask questions,” he turned your face to the side to place a kiss right under your ear lobe. it was like he was trying to butter you up to get the answer he wanted. “what makes you hate bein’ home' so bad?”
you hummed slightly in thought, closing your eyes. “i feel like i’m wasting time… like i'm forced to stall my life,” you were now staring at his ceiling watching the fan spin with the occasional sound of the wobble from the blades. you didn't know how to pull your thoughts together fully. “i left because i wanted some freedom,” you cleared your throat, now realizing that you were fidgeting with your hands. “it's cliche, i know, but i needed to find myself and not be smothered.”
mikey was nodding slowly, taking your hand apart from each other, rubbing his thumb over the top of your hand instead. “so since you've been gone have y’found anything worthwhile?”
you nodded though not fully convinced of yourself. “a few things, but i'm still getting where i need to be.”
those words said enough. you weren't fully settled in your new life although you had been living there because your current moment was just a stepping stone for something larger and more important that you wished to achieve. although coming home felt like regression mikey had been doing a great job to keep you from dwelling on that feeling.
you stayed the night. a sexless night of him waking up slumped over on the sofa with you. the entire night he had his arm draped over your side. you weren't use to sleeping in anyone else's home, much less the man you had been religiously letting plow you, but somehow it felt right to spend extra time with him.
the next morning you both woke up to his alarm blaring in the next room over.
your mom was at the kitchen sink, sipping her coffee while she read the back of a boxed cake mix, trying to take an early jump on the pineapple upside-down cake she was bringing to a work potluck the next day. your father had already left for the day for his job in building inspection, coaching was a side gig.
“you didn't come last night,” she commented, glancing at your tired appearance. “daddy said you've been going out late almost every night.”
it was a little unnerving to know that your parents had been paying that much attention to your whereabouts. you thought that you were being quiet, going in and out of the house at odd hours. neither of them had said anything to you. they didn’t want to rock the boat because you were finally home, but they were observant of your actions—for the most part.
cameron was smirking at you from his bowl of cereal, knowing you were in a bit of trouble.
“just out with friends,” you shrugged, taking a drink of your own coffee. you had spent the entire night tossing and turning on mikey's sofa because there wasn't much room for the both of you.
“you could've texted,” she mentioned, taking out a mixing bowl.
“i will next time,” you nodded slowly, avoiding the gaze she brought as she began dumping the contents of the mix into the glass bowl. “just lost track of time.”
“alright,” she squinted her eyes slightly, just enough to make sure you knew she was aware that she knew something was different.
a heartthrob walking up to the beef window wasn't uncommon and it wasn't overlooked, and you were no exception. wearing some little ribbed low-cut baby tee with a dewy face, sunglasses pushing your hair back, and the summer sun was sticking to your skin like you were a walking advertisement for hot girls near you.
richie has his head halfway out the window, looking down at you. he was hitting his pen against his receipt pad. ebraheim was glancing out the window, wrapping a few to-go orders that were about to be picked up. he like richie knew there was nothing good to come out of anyone that was carrying themselves the way you were. you seemed determined in a way like it wasn't only lunch you needed.
“and what can i get for the smoke show?” richie asked, unknowing of who you were and where you came from. all he knew was that you looked good and had that look of trouble glinting in your eyes.
you gave him a playful smile, leaning in a little closer, your hands resting on the bar of the window. “mikey promised me a sandwich when he wasn't busy.” it was sweet and innocent, but it had such a loaded meaning.
ebra was glancing at richie with a look that said did you just hear her. and yes, erba, richie did, loud and clear because now he was putting together the pieces of this very suspicious puzzle.
“did he now?” richie asked, backing into the window a bit.
“mhm, said i could swing by whenever,” you confirmed.
“hold on sweetheart,” richie smiled, dropping his pen onto the counter. “lemme go get your daddy for you.” his voice was laced with a thick veil of sarcasm.
richie disappeared into the kitchen, not able to wipe the look of surprise off of his face.
“hey, cousin,” he was close to mikey’s station, watching him wipe away vegetable scraps into a clear container to be used as broth for later on. “someone is here for you,” he cleared his throat, earning a shrug from mikey. plenty of people came by needing to see him and in this moment he was doing something.
“i'm almost done with this, just gimme a second,” mikey was wiping the edge of his knife on a clean kitchen towel.
“she asked for you by name and is practically flashing’ the entirety of river north.”
mikey set his knife down, elbowing richie as he began progressing towards the beef window. “coulda started with that you, jackass.”
“that's the girl? mikey, the fuck?” richie groaned. he was looking too, but actually knowing his friend was engaging with the trouble on two feet was worrisome.
mikey was shushing him as he entered the beef area. he glanced out the window, seeing that you seated yourself at a table under an umbrella. he was too far gone the moment he saw you. he wasn't paying any mind to richie now that he knew you had taken his offer for a sandwich seriously.
mikey had slid past ebra, wrapping a quick sandwich, tray and all lined with parchment, an addition of extra napkins and he wasn’t forgetting the drink. the soda that dribbled down the side of the cup was wiped up like it really mattered—it didn't but it needed to look nice for you.
ebra although he was occupied with his work was still watching through the window covered in decal stickers at you. it was silent judging, but not towards you or your outfit—towards mikey.
“ebra, shut it,” mikey warned when he was halfway out the door.
“i did not say anything, michael.” ebra paused before opening the sandwich window to give out the to-go orders in brown paper bags.
“you didn’t have to with that face.”
ebraheim shut the window, a kind of helpless glance towards richie who was standing towards the back of the beef kitchen.
mikey walked the completed tray out to you, and your face lit up when you saw him.
“didn't know you were comin’ today,” mikey carefully set the tray down, letting you excitedly unwrap the parchment on your sandwich.
“i was hungry and in the neighborhood,” you shrugged, taking a bite, a content expression washed over you.
“well eat, lil’ thing,” mikey set the napkins under your cup so they wouldn't fly away. “diet coke this time—’cause i remember shit,” he bragged on himself a little.
“look at you being a gentleman,” you teased, leaning in to take a sip of your drink.
“the one and only,” he plucked his work shirt like he was a big shot.
“i should’ve texted,” you admitted after taking another bite of the hot sandwich, having a hint of embarrassment scratching at your brain. “i think your cashier was a little surprised to meet me.”
“i woulda been too if someone so fine asked for him,” mikey jested from his seat, resting his hands on his knuckles to look at you with his full attention.
meanwhile, richie had disturbed carmen because he needed to know what his brother was doing; that was their duty after mikey's rehab in which they would both be responsible for him. it had been a while since they had to call on each other, but there they were staring out the beef window watching you make mikey laugh, which was somehow more disturbing than if it were him trying to make you laugh.
“do you see why this is more important than the fuckin’ sausage and peppers?” richie asked, gesturing loosely out the window. carmen had handed his station over to sydney for the time being. “i mean do you really fuckin’ see it.”
“jesus, okay, i get it,” carmen was still looking out the window.
“he wiped her drink,” ebra chimed in, earning a slow head tilt from carmen. ebra held his hands up in defense. “in my country we called that expensive.”
“that's not helpin’,” carmen slightly shivered. “it’s already bad ‘nough without all the extra.”
“we gotta talk some sense into him,” richie groaned, peering out the window to see mikey holding the soda straw to your lips so you wouldn’t have to pick it up while you held your sandwich.
the moment you left carmen and richie practically picked mikey up by the scruff of his neck to drag him into the alleyway. richie brought out a pack of cigarettes and carmen scooted three crates next to each other with his foot.
“alright,” richie clasped his hands together. “what the fuck are you doing?”
“startin’ with a subtle approach i see,” mikey took a cigarette from his friend and a seat in the middle.
“mikey, you didn't say that she’s younger than me,” carmen was popping a couple of pieces of nicorette gum, itching at the scar on his hand. your youth had been the first thing that anyone would notice, especially when placed next to mikey.
“i didn't say anything,” mikey reminded them, flicking the ash from his cigarette. “are we really having an intervention in the middle of lunch?”
richie had his foot placed on top of his crate, looking down on mikey. he didn't find it very funny, so unfunny that he was staring at his lit lighter, unable to even light his cigarette.
“no, we aren't doin’ this not now, not later,” mikey leaned back some, his back hitting the concrete wall of the restaurant.
“yeah we are,” carmen interjected. “because richie’s picked you up too many times for you to walk out right now.”
richie gave an appreciative nod towards the younger brother. “dude, you got past the rocky shit and you think bangin’ some chick is the right answer?” he asked, playing with the igniter wheel.
“i feel like you guys are comin’ on a little strong.” mikey was playing the game of avoidance again, not wanting to reveal too much about anything.
“you’re too involved—”
“y’can’t tell me how involved i am when you don't know how it is,” mikey had his elbows on his knees looking at the mural on the building across the street through the chain link fence.
“i think we saw how it was,” carmen rolled his eyes, a slight scoff leaving his mouth.
“bear, don't start that passive-aggressive bullshit with me when you—”
“me? we aren't talkin’ about me right now—we're talkin’ about you bein’ balls deep in some chick actin’ like your bullshit has gone away.”
mikey whipped his head around to look at his younger brother. “oh-ho, look at carmy gettin’ pissy again about shit that doesn’t pertain to him.”
carmen inhaled sharply, only nodding his head. “you wanna be like that, right now? because i didn’t have to leave new york when your psychotic ass was going through withdrawals. i didn’t want to keep findin’ pills in your desk when i was cleanin’ this shithole up. i didn’t have to keep watchin’ you fall apart a thousand times before you finally pulled it together. so yeah, it's not my shit but i keep steppin’ in it because you put yourself in it.” carmen's tone was low and snappy. it was lethal in a way, making both mikey and richie shift uncomfortably.
“and as for richie he’s dealt with your shit a fuck ton longer than i have and i'm your own goddamn brother. so let him fuckin’ talk,” carmen concluded, chewing his gum with a little extra agitation.
richie took a moment before speaking. carmen had just unloaded enough. “we're not tryin’ to judge,” he uncomfortably took a seat. “it's just that we know you worked hard to get where you are now.”
mikey flicked his cigarette to the center of the pavement then ran his hands over his face. it felt like he was having the same version of the conversation he had with you, although the difference was that richie and carmen knew all of his struggles and not just the vague understanding of his past with drugs.
“it's some stupid summer bullshit. she’s goin’ back out of state soon anyway. that's all this is; that’s it,” mikey was still in his spot, not willing to look at either of them now.
“what happens when she’s gone?” richie pressed, looking at the smoking cigarette on the ground.
“i show up. i do my work. i go to meetings,” mikey recited quickly like he had done it many times before. that was his normal routine, though his current routine was to show up, do work, go to meetings, and enjoy you he knew he'd be at a loss without you.
carmen wiped his sweating palms on his knees. he was still annoyed. “don't let this get outta hand or i'm tellin’ sug,” the younger brother warned.
mikey grumbled under his breath as he watched carmen stand. “low blow, carm.”
natalie, sugar, was the last line of defense because carmen knew mikey couldn’t be the reason for getting her wound up with those sad puppy-dog eyes she wore so well. he couldn't cause her any more pain. she had enough to worry about without starting to worry about him again.
she had given mikey more help than anyone, more than he would like to admit.
2:10 PM
mikey: r u busy?
2:15 PM
you: not for you
2:15 PM
mikey: slip in my office and help me out?
2:16 PM
you: please?
2:17 PM
mikey: u don’t have to beg
2:17 PM
you: *eye roll emoji* *middle finger emoji*
you: be there in a few
planning for an impromptu fourth of july barbeque to be held in the parking lot of the bear was one of the biggest headaches that mikey had encountered in a long time. between that and a lunch rush from hell, he needed a pick-me-up before dinner prep because the stale coffee wasn't working anymore.
it wasn't long before you arrived, nestled secretly under his desk after a couple of playful kisses.
mikey was sitting back in his office chair, his fingers curled around the armrests while he watched you wrangle his erect cock.
you were slurping on the curvature of his cock with glossy eyes, a bit of salvia falling out of your mouth. your cheeks were hollow, following part of his shaft down as you used your tongue to attempt to reach a little further.
one of your hands was cradling his balls; it occasionally slipped up to stroke the base of his manhood that you were unable to fit in your mouth.
you began to brush back your hair although mikey took notice of this, taking the liberty of holding it back for you. there you were, working up and down his girth like you owned it, choking lightly when you went too far.
spit was dribbling out of your mouth and onto the office chair where he was manspread. your swollen lips taking the liberty of working at his tip; his salty precum flooding your oral senses.
with his fingers intertwined securely in your hair he took his free hand to caress your cheek, a small bit of praise for your much-appreciated work. you were very expecting of this, trying to force your throat a little further each time even if it meant your eyes only got more watery.
mikey was gentle. he wasn't pushing your head and making you take every inch of his well-endowed tool. he was letting you enjoy yourself and in turn, was enjoying himself.
you knew you had him wrapped around your finger when his stomach would cave ever so slightly. your eyes were meeting his.
you began to bob your head a little faster, watching him exhale shakily as the combination of your strokes and mouth seemed to make his erection extra stiff, especially when you pointed your tongue to place extra pressure on the prominent vein of his cock.
that's when the door rattled, making mikey jump. you couldn't pull your head back fast enough, and even with mikey fishing for his pants, it was too late. the door certainly wasn't locked. this could've been avoided.
“michael—” jimmy, as in the jimmy that had given him and his brother hundreds of thousands of dollars, as in the jimmy kalinowski that had long been a family friend with the berzattos had entered. his eyes were darting around the room frantically, like a bad car wreck he was unable to look away from.
and in this rendition of the pornos, it is titled: HOT CHICK SUCKS THICK OLDER COCK UNDER DESK **CAUGHT**
“mother of fuck!” jimmy roared as he stumbled out of the room and down the hallway.
mikey was trying to get his bearings together while also checking on you, which wasn't great because his heart was pounding out of his chest.
“i am so fucked,” mikey groaned, tugging up his pants the rest of the way with part of his shirt stuck in the waistband. “jimmy—fuckin’ a’, man,” he was talking to himself in a panicked manner.
“hey, hey,” you tried to calm him, adjusting your shirt and wiping the corners of your mouth.
“you gotta go,” mikey was rushing. he was right. you really did need to leave. he was dragging you by the wrist, down the hallway. you were also appreciative of mikey's quickness to get you to the door.
the kitchen doors were rushed open. it was like jimmy was on a war path.
“somebody put a leash on michael before he catches a fuckin’ statutory!” jimmy barked, suddenly the entire kitchen fell silent. no pots were clattering, no talk of their day, no squeak of the required non-slip shoes. everything stopped.
“yo, what the fuck?” richie was the first one to speak up.
jimmy’s announcement wasn't exactly subtle. it was painful and embarrassing and gross.
“your friend’s stripped down to his skivvies in his damn office getting a mid-day treat from some floosie, rick.” jimmy threw his hands up angrily.
oh fuck—nothing about jimmy's outburst was beneficial to busy kitchen.
carmen didn't leave his station; he was urging everyone to keep working as an uproar of comments were being made. he had too much to do other than entertain the chaos. he and richie knew exactly what this was about based on jimmy’s comment even before he had to explain himself.
the rest of the kitchen was stunned, immediately blabbering back and forth before richie struck two skillets together urging them to be quiet.
jimmy then saw mikey leading you out, pausing his kitchen outburst to catch the imbecile who had started this whole saga.
“what the fuck are you doin’?” jimmy confronted mikey harshly. he then looked at you with his head tilted. his glasses a little crooked. “and sweetheart what the fuck are you doin’ with him?”
you swallowed hard. jimmy’s tone had changed drastically when he had spoken to you. “do i need to call him a lawyer?” he pressed a little further.
“no, what? no, i’m twenty. i go to school. i have a license,” you rambled though none of it provided any solid proof unless you were to pull out your cardholder you were nervous. your hands were shaking and mikey was still edging you to the door.
“alright, wonderful, so you have a fuckin’ brain then why are you using it to be with him?” jimmy prodded. your shoulders were still tense, staring at him wide-eyed.
“unc, let her go,” mikey sighed, looking at the exit sign above the door. jimmy was practically blocking the hallway. “then you can keep yellin’ but don't let her be mixed up in it.”
“i spend all this goddamn money for you go have a co-ed under your desk? be like your fuckin’ brother for god’s sake and throw a goddamn knife or scream in the fuckin’ walk-in,” jimmy spat one last time before scooting out the the way.
“i’ll take that note,” mikey grumbled, ushering you out the back door.
walking into the kitchen seemed like the right thing to do at the moment, but immediately regretted it once he was in there. he had heard jimmy’s outburst and already knew the staff was talking.
it was silent when mikey came in, all the conversation halted immediately. if that wasn't a sure sign that people were conversing about the sudden drama then he didn't know what else was. there was never a dull day at the bear.
“this has really gotten outta hand,” mikey announced from the hand washing station, lathering his hands and forearms up. “and i didn't mean for it to get this far, but it did,” he groaned trying to phrase his words correctly.
“baby, you can't be doin’ that,” tina responded. “like some shit you just don't do.”
“unprofessional,” sydney added softly, her round eyes darting around. “really inappropriate—and like—gross, right? we’re a whole restaurant.” she gestured loosely.
mikey was drying his hands, staring at the blinding lights on the ceiling. “alright, i fucked up, we got that, thank you,” he was leaning against the wall, knowing if he even began kitchen duty his head would be too jumbled to achieve anything.
“told you it was a bad idea,” richie coughed, having to add the ‘i told you so at the worst moment.’
“you knew? and you let him keep doing it?” sydney pressed further, unable to look at anyone other than tina who was also shaking her head.
“he wouldn't have stopped anyway…college chick has initiative,” richie shrugged. it earned a couple of groans of disapproval. everyone was rightfully awkward and wary of the situation.
“sis looks like she’s committed her thesis study to daddy issues,” marcus tried to lighten the situation, and a couple of chuckles were heard.
“no, no, she's pledged to tri delta and her philanthropy mission is to support recovering addicts,” sweeps butted in, carrying a basket of unfolded napkins.
mikey stood with his arms crossed trying not to laugh. he deserved the heckling. not everyone found it amusing, but it was definitely helping mikey recover from the initial shock and surprise of being walked in on.
“mystery baby was just trying to use the last points on her campus dining plan, cut her some slack,” marcus hit a witty rebuttal.
“mystery baby is her new name, fuckin’ brand that shit,” richie called out.
“okay okay, have we had enough fun?” mikey asked with a fading chuckle. “maybe we should get the hell back to work before carmen blows a gasket,” he offered, knowing their slow hands wouldn't be helpful by the time service started.
“yeah, probably for the best because i texted sugar,” carmen didn't even look up.
“motherfucker.”
natalie had been at the hardware store attempting to pick up a list of supplies from their morning meeting about the barbeque carmen had proposed. though the moment carmen’s 911 mikey text came through she dropped everything.
they were sitting in her office. pictures of her daughter and husband littered her desk, and it was more organized than mikey’s office by far. color-coded tabs and coordinating pens to highlighters along with an actual color scheme. carmen had briefed her on the entire situation before she even sat down with her oldest brother.
mikey was tapping his foot anxiously. he didn't know where she was going to start. with the fact that she had plucked mikey off the state street bridge night so many years ago when he was half conscious and at rock bottom, maybe the night she bailed him out of jail for petty theft, or when she had given him a place to stay after he couldn't stay at their mother's house in the early stages of recovery, or even maybe the fact that she had helped him find the meetings he so regularly attended. he could go on and on about what his sister had done for him.
“bear, what’s goin’ on with you?” she asked softly. worry filled her eyes.
“nothin’,” mikey shrugged. he felt like he was in the damn principal’s office.
“do you think carmy texted because it was nothing?” she had a point, but he didn't expect their youngest sibling to actually go through with his threat.
“no, jeez, sug, i'm grown. i have my head on straight now. i participate in my meetings. i’m clean—”
“mikey,” natalie stopped him. “i know you're good. you’ve been good. i’m proud of you, but i’m not proud of this girl.”
that stung. mikey furrowed his brows as his arms crossed over his chest. sugar had a million things she could've brought up and she chose the one that mattered.
“i know you’re grown, but she isn't. she’s still somebody’s kid,” natalie was taking this in a different perspective, different than what carmen had to say and everyone else. she wasn't touching on his sobriety, not now at least. mikey was expecting her to want to kill him.
“she’s two and a half times younger than you. when we were twenty our family didn't care, but her’s might.” she was thinking about it like it was her own daughter years into the future.
“no one was supposed to find out and then—”
“then you started thinking with your dick, bear,” natalie sighed, wrapping her brother in a hug that he didn't reciprocate. “that was reckless and really fucking stupid, and now i want to hit your head against the wall.” she had such a serious tone that mikey couldn't help but chuckle. he patted his sister’s back.
“i probably deserve it,” mikey agreed. this was more gentle than he thought it would go. natalie wasn't crying or making those big guilt tripping eyes. but what else could she do other than say something? she wasn't tracking anyone down and giving them a lesson. mikey was responsible for his own doings...even if they were ridiculous.
“no probably about it,” natalie flicked his forehead before pulling away.
jimmy was sitting in the furthest booth from the door, mindlessly eating his lunch with no complaints to be had, seeing as he was sitting by himself. he was occasionally looking up at the door in between bites, just a little peace to separate himself from the chaotic week.
“hell, is that jimmy k?” your father asked, a tray of food in his hand from the deli, but had yet to set it down at a seating arrangement.
“oh shit, that's reggie,” jimmy perked up a bit, a welcoming smile gracing his face. “you wanna take a seat?” he offered the opposite side of the booth to reggie.
years back jimmy had given reggie extra work when he needed it. they had rarely kept up with each other besides the occasional run in, but they always seemed to chat like old friends that had never forgotten where they once left off from previously.
“long time no see, man,” reggie greeted, unwrapping his sandwich. “same old, same old?” he questioned, breaking into conversation easily.
“little of everything, you know me,” jimmy mentioned casually.
it was all normal until the conversation shifted from family to work. reggie was mentioning he was still married, one kid about to start high school, the other in college, and was still coaching. jimmy mentioned his son and some other odds and ends, but then he turned to money. jimmy seemed a little annoyed to be mentioning how much money he loaned his “nephews” to redo their sandwich shop into an actual restaurant, and how even after all their renovations, they were still fucking up.
“you're talking about the bear, right?” reggie was now placing all the pieces together, remembering how jimmy was friends with michael and carmen’s father. “they catered my kid’s banquet a few months ago.”
“yeah, yeah, the fuckin’ bear,” jimmy groaned. “let me pick your ear about somethin’ okay, reg?” he wasn't really asking. he was going to talk anyway. “mikey is the most lovable fuck up, but right now i could kill him. how would you feel knowing you spent a bunch of goddamn money and then walk in his office and catch him with some college kid?”
“what?” reggie repeated, the conversation having shifted heavily. he put down his sandwich. those words seemed to hit a little too close to home because his twenty-year-old daughter hadn’t been present practically the whole summer, coming home late every night, and being oddly secretive.
“not kiddin’ you, walked into his office about a week ago and he had some twenty-year-old gettin’ down on her knees in the middle of the work day,” jimmy repeated, not noticing how still reggie had become.
jimmy was just blabbing because he was annoyed, not knowing that he was inciting a panic in his old employee.
“you know anything else?” reggie swallowed hard. his hands were shaking under the table. his dad sense was screaming at him that it was his daughter making some stupid mistake.
“no—oh, reg, no—” jimmy finally caught on to reggie’s face that had seemingly lost a little color.
“hey, you know, i gotta get back to work, but i’ll see you around,” reggie cleared his throat. he had barely eaten on his lunch break. he was going to sit in his truck and use the rest of his time to call his daughter.
the staff alternated days off. this week it was mikey’s monday off, and there was no place better to spend it than with you, grasping the meat of your thighs. his elbows help to keep you spread wide, absorbing himself in his own world between your legs. even after the scare with jimmy the two of you had an inability to keep your hands off of each other. it was like you both knew that the summer was soon going to end in just three short weeks.
he had no other care in the world than to be with you. he was lapping at your cunt. his flattened tongue easily maneuvering over your folds. he had a certain technique that you thought would never be able to be replicated by anyone else.
your hands were laced in his loose curls while you crossed your toes from the sheer pleasure you were on the receiving end of. you gasped as his mouth opened a bit more, sucking your outer layers and the dripping arousal that fell from your pussy.
he was looking up at you, knowing good and well what he was doing as he spread your folds further apart with his oversized fingers. he had a direct contact with your clit in moments, beginning with a soft suckle which transpired into a greedy moment of his beard being buried into your soaking pussy and his aquiline nose brushing against your pubes all while staring at you.
his elbows dug into you although it was worth it because of the instinctual want to close your legs as the stimulation began to become more overwhelming. you might have been tugging at his hair too harshly, but he didn't say anything, only continuing to show your cunt the utmost respect as he ravaged it with his mouth.
soon his fingers dipped inside of you, fully and easily being coated with everything you had produced. you gave an unsuspecting whimper looking down at mikey still directing his oral attention to your clit and his digits curled upwards to satisfy you even more.
he had to breathe. his forehead was sweaty and he was a bit breathless as his fingers worked in and out of you.
his jaw was aching ever so slightly which caused his determination for his fingers to become more direct with their targeted movements. his other hand was toying with his dick trying to coax his erection to stay up fully. he had been concentrating fully causing his once rock hard erection to soften just a bit.
“need ya to turn over, lil’ thing,” he directed, the wet splotches on his beard were noticeable as the light filtered through his thin bedroom curtains. mikey has taken his fingers out, licking the reminits of your sweet slick off of them.
you began shifting to get on your knees, mikey helped rotate your hips. he grabbed your ankle to situate your positioning, giving his cock final a hearty stroke as he did. he gave your pussy one final long, dragged out lick from your hole your ass, which caused a shiver to run down your spine.
his balls were hanging heavily as he reached over you to grab a condom wrapper.
you felt his covered tip prod at your entrance. mikey held apart one of your asscheeks to oversee the full entry. it was the perfect fit, he was absolutely drowning in that blissful feeling. his eyes rolled back a little as you shimmied your ass back ever so slightly.
the smutty saga continued with: SALT N’ PEPPER MAN EATS PUSSY AND FUCKS PRETTY BABE *HOT* *YOUNG*
instead of mikey's hair your fingers were now pawing at his sheets trying to find a good grip. the bedframe would never not be squeaky, but it had upgraded slightly, with a pillow between the headboard and the wall.
“y'feel so good,” he praised, gradually increasing the pace of his rocking hips.
“so do you,” you murmured halfway between talking and moaning.
“don't think y'get what i’m sayin'” he mentioned, taking his hand off of your ass and the other off your hip to bring his tattooed arms under your armpits. he hooked his hands to the front of your chest, leaning over you to feel closer. his pudgy stomach brushed against the small of your back. “you're drivin’ me fuckin’ crazy today.”
you released a small grunt only for it to be suppressed by an increase in moans as his humps increased in effort, rocking into you with vigor and need.
you brought your head back some, feeling his wiry beard hair brush against your ear. his palms were sweaty, having to adjust his grip on you to keep you against him. he was pressing soft kisses to your hair that smelled of dry shampoo and his downy detergent after being so comfortable in his bed.
“i’m serious…y’gotta hold on me today,” mikey rasped, his knees buckling slightly as he felt your pussy pulsing. he nipped at the shell of your ear, his breath lingering. “fuckin’ hell,” he sighed, feeling another twinge from your lethal grip.
“i-i can't help it when you’re talking to me like that,” you stuttered, hanging your head low into the bed, though he followed you, resting his cheek on the back of your head gently. his thrusts were unsteady and deep.
he had already tortured you by eating you out, overly prepared to take his cock, and you were still on the receiving end of pleasure—overstimulated was the most simple way to put it. you and mikey were both belting sounds of pleasure.
you had your eyes shut tightly unable to speak or give any warning that you were close to climax. he was pressed against your back engulfing your body in warmth and ecstasy as his rigid thrusts only became more heightened. your cunt was doing a quick squeeze and release. he knew he had you close in more ways than one.
“oh—” you dug your fingers tightly into the sheet. you were uncoiling while he was still so deep inside. he was edging against your cervix over and over.
“pretty girl,” his voice was husky in your ear. he pressed his body into you further muffling your moans and pleads into the bed. “this pussy gonna make me cum?”
“y-yeah, y-yeah,” you sounded a little dumb and a little whiny but you could barely think straight, especially with his ridiculously mind-boggling movements. he was chasing those final moments.
“pussy is unreal,” he huffed, though seconds later his jaw went slack. that same hazy feeling you were experiencing. if it was humanly possible he would've been closer as he fucked out his peak, only able to continue his final few thrusts with the rest of his energy briefly.
he laid on you for a while, conscious enough not to squish you, but still not letting you go anywhere, nuzzling his nose into the crook of your neck.
you were then showered and redressed, and currently, happily perched on mikey’s kitchen countertop. you were watching him prepare thinly fried zucchini battered in an italian breadcrumb which was going to be served with parmesan cheese sprinkled over the top.
mikey was whisking his egg and milk together, already having his separate dish of breadcrumbs prepared. the oil in the skillet was heating up, the convection fan was already circulating.
and your job? that was to sit and look pretty or so he said. you gave yourself an extra task which was occasionally stealing some of the freshly grated cheese out of the bowl.
watching mikey cook was sexy. he knew what he was doing, knew how he wanted it to come out, and knew that it was going to be delicious.
he was standing at the stove watching the breaded zucchini in the bubbling oil, tongs in his hand ready to take them off the heat when the shallow fry had completed its task at getting them crispy and golden brown.
“alright, hopefully, you’re not full on cheese so you can actually eat,” he offered one of the almost paper-thin spears to your lips.
you nodded as you chewed. perfection, all of it. every single crunchy bite. “holy shit,” you mumbled, a sort of warmness spreading through your chest.
“good, huh?” he was back at the stove pulling the last few pieces of zucchini out of the oil and placing them on a paper towel.
“yeah, almost like you’re a chef or something.”
mikey laughed, setting the tray next to you on the counter, offering you another piece. one hand was on your thighs, looking into your eyes as he let you have another bite.
your phone started ringing, making you snap out of the trance you were in caused by mikey and his delicious food. mikey saw the contact name, as soon as you did. he scooted to the side some. you hopped off the counter and answered in one swift motion.
“hey dad.”
“hey, baby girl.” he didn’t sound happy although you didn’t expect a call mid day to be any good. he was supposed to be at work. “you busy?”
“um, a little,” you replied, glancing at mikey in the kitchen, trying to put a little space between you and him as you talked to your father. “what’s up?”
reggie didn’t know how to answer that. he still hadn’t fully decided on what to say. he just knew he needed to call you.
“i ran into someone i used to work with, been a few years since i’ve seen him,” he explained. your gaze never left mikey, who was cleaning up the kitchen.
you had every reason to be nervous because your father was never the man that would call in the middle of a work day.
“how was that?” you questioned, knowing that your dad was taking longer to get to his point than normal.
“i don’t know,” your father sighed. “but he told me something—something you might know about.”
you were fidgeting with the end of your shirt, phone pressed against your ear and shoulder.
“he said he’s sorta family to the owners of a restaurant,” your dad was stalling which was only making you squirm more. you swallowed, the sides of your throat burning a little.
“when he was there last week he said there was a college girl under the owner’s desk.” it made reggie sick to say that outloud. having to say those exact words to his daughter should’ve been punishment enough.
“dad—”
“he didn’t know your name. he didn’t even say it was you, not like he picked you out of a lineup or something, but jesus—kid, you’re acting like you did it without me even having to ask…”
mikey is now staring because you look ill, standing in the middle of his living room looking so guilty. he knew what this is about without having to eavesdrop.
“what are you doing, baby girl?” he sounded exhausted. it sounded like he had just had too much. “what did you decide to get yourself into?”
you felt meek. “it’s not like that.”
“don’t tell me that because it is exactly like that.”
you wanted to crawl into a hole and never come out again. the lull of silence was too much right now. that once tasty platter of zucchini now looked inedible.
“you think you’re grown up, but you’re not. you’re twenty and you’re going after some guy like you don’t think is going to ruin your life, but he will.”
you couldn’t say anything because if you did you’d be breaking down.
“baby girl, come on. you’re so much smarter than that,” he pressed a little further, digging that knife a little deeper.
“i’m worried about you,” he finally expressed.
“okay,” that’s all you could manage.
“okay?” he asked, wondering if that’s all you had to say.
“i’ll be home later,” you choked out. your thumb nail was digging into your leg. you hung up.
mikey put down the cloth he was using to wipe the counter. he joined you in the den, hoping he didn’t have to be the first one to say anything but he was.
“…he knows?”
“mhm,” you mumbled. “knows jimmy, used to work with him…isn’t that something?”
mikey was walking slowly as if any sudden movements would send you running. he stopped at the coffee table, taking a seat to look at you. he tried to grab your hand but you wouldn’t let him.
“that tracks,” mikey coughed a bit, trying to pull his words together. he was speaking very gently. “look—if I would’ve known they knew each other i wouldn’t have—”
“—wouldn’t have let me suck you off at work?” you completed his sentence earning a sigh from him.
“no, come on, if it wouldn’t have gotten back to your dad then—”
“the only thing that matters right now is who we got caught by?” you wouldn’t let him get a word in not right now. “not that we got caught at all?”
“i shoulda known better,” mikey was uncomfortably running his hand through his hair. “i didn’t mean to screw this up.”
“do you think you’re screwing me up?”
“that’s not what i said,” mikey said pointedly.
“that’s what my dad said,” you retorted, though your voice wasn’t very loud. it was painful and quiet. “that you’re gonna ruin my life.”
mikey tilted his head. his hand fell in his lap.
“are you going to ruin my life?” you tried to coax out an answer from mikey. you didn’t want to believe he could, but unfortunately this illicit secret was out and spirling out of control.
he didn’t really like that question.
“i don’t wanna…” mikey was searching for more words. “but i worry about it because i’m older than you—you have your entire life ahead of you. you can probably screw up three good times from now until you're my age and be better off than me. but me? i‘ve fucked up enough. i’m outta chances, pretty girl,” he was resting his head in his hands. he wasn’t going to give you a minute to respond now, so he continued. “i don’t regret a single thing, i really don’t—but i can’t be the reason your life is screwed up. i like you a helluva lot, and if i knew i was the reason i screwed you up i don’t think i could forgive myself.”
you looked like he had punched you in the gut, breathless, not making a noise as you cried. just silent tears falling, looking at each other trying to convince each other that any feeling you had was fake.
“you gotta say something,” mikey urged.
you didn’t, not right away. your mouth was closed in a tight line, trying to hold your crying self together. you grabbed your purse next to where mikey was sitting. he knew you’d be gone in an instant. your mind was already somewhere else. you weren’t mentally still in mikey’s apartment.
“hey, please don’t go, not just yet,” mikey swallowed, standing as you started walking for the door.
“i really need to go.”
“i can walk you out,” he stood up, going to follow you, but you stopped him.
“i got it,” you choked out.
and like that, you were gone and mikey was alone.
this was the last weekend before you returned to school. keeping your distance from mikey was so difficult, but your father wasn't exactly thrilled to learn of your summer affair. you were trying to lay low so that embarrassment would stop eating at you, but in all actuality you could barely stand to make eye contact with either of your parents.
you were trying to be on your best behavior because after all your parents did let you stay with them all summer, paid for your gas, and flights to and from school, among countless other things.
that was the hardest part for them, knowing you were grown, having to see you leave, and now watching you make one of the stupidest decisions of your life while still trying to remain proud of you because your success in school wasn't nothing.
the disappointment was rough because you had proved over and over again that they could trust you to be a responsible adult away from home, but your lustful tailspin had them questioning where they went wrong as parents.
they never yelled at you. not once. the moment your dad called he wanted to vomit because he had that inkling that you were doing something—someone—that you weren’t supposed to. they knew you knew better. you knew you knew better.
you kept trying to downplay how bad it was, but every time you thought about mikey it only got worse. you wanted something to keep you occupied, and it did, but at what cost?
your childhood friends knew your final moments in chicago were coming to an end. they wanted to see you and you thought it would be a good way to take your mind off of the clusterfuck you had helped create. they suggested a party, an end of the summer rager at someone’s parents' lakeside rental property.
it was loud, the house was so hot from the movement of people combined with the door from outside being constantly opened and closed. even outside you couldn't escape the heat, but it was probably your burning face from the drinks you had so easily thrown back.
you were chatting—more like drunkenly rambling—with one of your old girlfriends about the courses you decided to register for at the edge of the lake. only your feet were resting in the water because you already pulled your shorts back over your damp bathing suit bottoms. you had your jacket half zipped over your top, unsure of where the shirt you originally had over your bikini went.
you began to feel too dizzy for your own good, peering uncomfortably into the solo cup of a badly mixed drink. you excused yourself from your friend after she was unable to answer what time the designated driver was bringing you all back to your corresponding homes.
“when are we leaving?” seemed to be the question of the night that no one could give you a straight answer to. you felt like garbage. you wanted to leave. you had your sneakers in one hand, walking around aimlessly trying to get a direct answer from your final friend in your group after ditching your solo cup on a random counter.
you were regretting coming at all when all of your drunk friends and even the singular sober one were unable to coordinate a time to leave. you were sitting on the steps of the porch the faint sound of another megan thee stallion song blaring even through the closed door. your stomach was churning and you had a pained expression on your face while you stared at the lawn.
you couldn't call your parents. you had already screwed up too much to make them unhappy for another moment this summer. you only had one more option. it was approaching half past one in the morning and there you were calling mikey, ruining his sleep schedule yet again.
it didn’t ring for long.
“hello?” he murmured, almost shocking you to your core to hear his voice again, especially all groggy from sleep.
“hey,” you paused, shutting your eyes for a brief second as if you were working up the courage to ask him a favor. “can you come pick me up?” you slurred, holding your temples trying to keep your focus.
“you okay?” you could hear some rustling coming from his end, knowing he was already attempting to pull himself together to rescue you.
“yeah, uh, my friends invited me out but i really wanna leave, and i couldn't call my dad,” you were plucking at the grass on the bottom of the steps.
“i'm comin’, hon,” mikey assured you like it was nothing out of the ordinary. “just text me the address.”
you felt small. you had so easily left him, ran out, and avoided conflict and now he was helping you without a second thought. “thanks, mikey.”
within the hour you were seated in mikey's car, pulling your knees into your chest. you had dropped your sneakers to the ground. you were leaning your head against your seatbelt.
“you answered,” you noted, staring at the radio in mikey’s car—more specifically the time.
mikey didn't look much different than normal, other than that he had let his beard become a little more unruly than normal. he always looked a little tired and a little sad.
“of course, i did,” he didn't look at you, but he meant what he said.
“i'm sorry for waking you up.” you sounded like a child who didn't want to be scolded, trying to soften the blow by buttering up their guardian.
“i'm glad y’did.”
you were staring out the windshield unsure if you should thank him again or not.
“y’made the safe choice,” he added, flicking on his blinker that seemed louder in the dark of the late night.
“i missed you.”
mikey was unsure of what to say. you were drunk and clearly spaced out all while still being conscious. he drummed his fingers against the wheel. “missed you too, pretty girl.”
you looked up for a brief second and then back at the road, time seemed to be moving a little too slowly.
“can we talk?”
“we're talkin’ right now.” he held the wheel a little tighter, unsure of what your drunken state was trying to express.
“you're not looking at me.” it was true, not once since you had gotten in his car had he even glanced at you.
“i'm drivin’,” he reminded you, though it wasn't very fast and it didn't seem like he was rushing to get you home.
“you can pull over,” you suggested, so he did.
mikey had taken his time to turn his head, knowing if he saw you he would be able to forgive you leaving within a second, and he did. his gaze was softened as one hand rested on the shifter.
“you're like what i needed,” you unbuckled your seatbelt, stretching out in the front seat. you were picking up the hair from the back of your neck and tossing it just to get a breeze of air. you were leaning into the air vents soaking in the chill. “like you're just so hot and you like really got me, you know?”
mikey didn't know—well—he did to an extent. he was silently staring at you, watching you unzip your jacket to let the air con hit your chest.
“and like i really missed you,” you were now sitting to face mikey.
“yeah.”
“you didn’t miss me?” you were offended. you were resting your hands on the center console.
“you walked out,” he reminded you. “you left.”
“now, i’m back,” you mumbled uncomfortably.
“who picked you up, lil’ thing?” mikey questioned, clearing his throat. “who’s takin’ y’back home?”
“you.”
“uh-huh, i answered. i gave you space. i’m the one tryin’ not to lose you when i know i’m gonna lose you anyway.”
you leaned a little closer, bridging the gap between you and mikey. your palms laying against his silver-specked beard, letting the hair scrape your soft skin. he didn’t react much, only watching. your forehead rested against his, stunning him for a moment.
your dizzy head was stabilized for a moment, pressing your lips against his. it wasn’t nearly as sweet as you’d thought it would be when you noticed he wasn’t reciprocating.
he was gently pulling your hands off his face, and moving his head back. it was one of the hardest things he had to do after not seeing you. you were practically halfway over the center console.
“no, you’re drunk and we’re not doin’ that,” mikey said firmly, kissing the tips of your fingers instead. he helped you get situated in your seat again.
“i know what i want,” you mumbled defensively, looking down at your lap.
“pretty girl,” mikey began, clearing his throat. “i’m not gonna be that guy.”
you were mildly sulking and on the verge of tears. the alcohol was really settling in and all of your thoughts that had come with it.
“y’don’t think i don’t want to? i haven’t stopped thinking about you since you left.” mikey was trying to be consoling but it didn’t help when you were left defeated. “i’m not makin’ this worse between us.”
“i fucked it all up…you wouldn’t be able to make it any worse,” you confessed guilty.
“this wasn’t ever goin’ to work,” mikey stated with his chest tightening. he held his index knuckle to his lips.
“you said you were okay with this.”
the entire situation was conflicting.
“i know what i said, but it doesn’t mean it was gonna work,” mikey cleared his throat harshly. you could’ve sworn you saw a tear drip down his face. “i gotta stay and y’gotta go back to school.”
mikey had pulled off of the street, continuing down the road. he had to get you home before he was past a solitary tear.
you were fidgeting with your fingers with an uncomfortable churning in your stomach. you didn’t know how you were managing to keep yourself together; maybe it was because you had already embarrassed yourself around him enough.
you were practically gagging yourself to keep your tears down, knowing you’d never be able to listen to “the scientist” by coldplay again without thinking of this very moment when the silence was trying to take over but chris martin’s voice over the late night radio was peeking through like daggers in ballistic gel.
“this was supposed to be fun,” your voice wavered uncomfortably. you were finally starting to realize how far everything had come. it all came around, all at once, completing the circle with a deathly kill.
“it was,” mikey’s knuckles were white because of the sheer force he was using to grip the wheel. “but this is the part that wasn’t ever goin’ to be fun.” his jaw twitched slightly.
“i didn’t think i’d like you so much,” you confessed, watching as your street came into view. you were rubbing your thumb over your right temple to soothe your impending headache. your other sleeve was wiping your tears as they spilled, hoping mikey wasn’t paying too much attention.
mikey felt like a bullet had ripped through his chest, trying to convince himself that you were drunk enough that you didn’t know what you were saying, but even that didn’t help. it just hurt.
he parked in your driveway, watching your gather your shoes. he was taking initiative this time, not letting another time when he could have chased you be wasted. he was walking you to the door. one of his large hands at the small of your back guiding your drunken self to the door.
“i’m always gonna be around.” he shouldn’t have said that but he did. you only gave a shaky nod.
he could see your empty eyes and puffy face in the motion-activated light of the doorway. he gave your head one final kiss and returned to his car. he watched the door to your house shut.
it never got cold in florida, not like the illinois cold anyway. exams were coming close before the sweet relief of winter break would start. you were studying or trying to at least.
it had gotten lonely and that was probably due to the fact that since starting another undergraduate year at uf you had distanced yourself from practically everyone.
lizzie, who was your closest friend at university, had tried everything in her power to pull you out of this weird lull you were trapped in. she knew something was wrong based on your demeanor and the sad girl playlist you had put on repeat. you kept in touch while you had gone home for the summer, but you hadn’t said anything about mikey. that would be far too hard to explain. when you returned you said you regretted the summer, but that simply wasn't true. you regretted being too young, too naive, and too involved with someone you knew you shouldn't have been. you were impulsive and dumb and it was hard to admit that to anyone other than yourself.
you had gotten in far too deep with mikey and that was a fact. you wouldn't have been thinking about him so much if you hadn't gotten attached.
the final title to the erotic summer films would be: FEELINGS FUCKED HARD *SHE CRIES* LEFT WITH GAPING HOLE
you moved into your new apartment when you returned from chicago, having lizzie and a few others from your study groups help pile everything from your storage unit into the space. all your decor that was once in your dorm room was hardly enough to cover all the blank walls. it was too sterile. so when your stipend from your scholarship hit your bank account, you spent far too much money trying to clutter the walls and console your aching heart.
you felt like your social life was in the gutter. the last party you attended before school had to do with your embarrassingly drunk confession to mikey. mixers, frat ragers, and the post-karaoke bar crawls would land you feeling even worse than you initially went out. it didn't feel right receiving drinks from other guys, much less drinking at all.
halloween had been one of your most favorite times of the year, especially when attending college, but this year's activities were basically halted. you were dolled up like the sluttiest cowgirl to match with lizzie. you had only gone out for an hour. you interacted with your lyft driver more than anyone in the bar and immediately had to tell him that you were sorry for crying.
your social media which was once buzzing with photos from everything had also taken a turn for the worst. everything from the end of may to the beginning of august was just reminders of mikey, although he was in none of the photos. lounging by the pool? yeah, that was the swimsuit he had liked the most. pictures at the ballpark with your brother? it only made you think about mikey having heartburn from concession station nachos. that dumb picture you had taken of your half-eaten beef sandwich? that one hurt the most because mikey had made it. you tried to cover those posts in your feed with updated ones of your apartment decor, your work on the school communications page, and your paid internship with a local news station, but it never felt like enough.
your family visited for the weekend before thanksgiving to see the apartment. your father was being himself, picking at every little thing about how awful college apartments could be. he had walked through the entire place, asking if you had seen the cracking on the molding or the uneven flooring in the bathroom. you didn't care because anything was better than the dorms. your mother brought a set of embroidered dish towels and a carry-on suitcase full of cleaning supplies. your brother had weaseled his way into staying one night in your apartment rather than at the hotel, which was fine because you stayed up late watching a rented movie and eating an overpriced doordash delivery. it was refreshing to have some sense of normality because no one dared to mention the summer; not like they would speak of it anyway. you had taken enough pain and embarrassment away from it for them to discuss it with you present.
so no, the end of august to mid-december had not been going entirely “well” for you. the only thing you could think to do was return home so you wouldn't be alone for the holidays. you knew your family wouldn't turn you away even if you wanted to turn them away most days. when you called your mom and told her that you wanted to be home, she was ecstatic. within the next hour, she called you back explaining that she had booked your flight for three days after your exams were completed.
in your current studying session, you had been picking up your phone in between making flash cards. your hand was cramping and you were unable to stay completely focused. you leaned back in your desk chair glancing between your computer screen, notebooks, and the index cards sprawled on your desk. you rubbed your cramping hand uncomfortably, massaging your inner palm.
it wouldn't be long until you'd be back in chicago, but right now you are stuck in your apartment with upcoming deadlines and tests to prepare for. you couldn't explain why you were reaching for your phone again. you had just checked a random notification from a video lizzie had sent to you on your social media. you paused the music that was playing, staring blankly at your phone screen before inching your fingers to your messages.
11:11 PM
you: i'll be home for christmas if you're still around
your heart was racing, thinking that unsending it might have been easier, but it was too late. the deed was done. you were hastily putting your phone down with the screen facing the wood of your desk.
you stood from your desk, hitting your palm against your forehead with a groan. your leg began to bounce anxiously, trying to rationalize the decision you had just made. the bear didn't close until ten, mikey always said it took at least an hour or an hour and a half to get everyone out and everything cleaned, so no, he wasn’t going to respond right away. he had priorities. he had a business to run. he was fifty with a goddamn life, probably doing a lot better than you were right now—he wasn't. he wasn't doing any better because if he was he wouldn't have responded.
I really love your writing and I had an idea and thought you ould write it really well (no pressure ofc) 💕 I was thinking about Carmy and f!reader in a weird situationship/fwb situation. they both like each other and have feelings for the other but they aren't together, but reader gets pregnant
𝐀 𝐋𝐢𝐭𝐭𝐥𝐞 𝐌𝐨𝐫𝐞 𝐓𝐡𝐚𝐧 𝐍𝐨𝐭𝐡𝐢𝐧𝐠 ♡
Thank you for the request! I hope this captured the vibe 💕
Carmen Berzatto x reader || Carmy playlist || Main masterlist
summary: On an unexpected morning with Carmy, your world quietly, irrevocably shifts.
word count: 4.2k
tags/warnings: Afab!reader. Throwing up. Pregnancy. Hurt/comfort. Fwb/complicated situastionship to lovers. Carmy is bad at feelings, but he has them and he's trying his best.
You wake before the sun, the room still blue-gray and quiet except for Carmy’s breathing. He’s curled toward you, one arm slung loosely over your waist like he forgot in sleep that you’re not really his. Just like he isn’t yours. You are not even sure what to call what the two of you are.
You’re just… whatever this thing between you is. Friends, but not. Something easy and complicated all at once.
You slip out of his bed as carefully as you can, but even half-asleep he notices the loss of your warmth like it’s instinct. His brow furrows, a quiet sound leaving his throat as his hand reaches out blindly, fingers brushing the sheet where you were.
“Mm, where you going?” he mutters into the pillow, voice gravel-soft.
“Bathroom,” you whisper.
He hums, already drifting back under.
Your stomach has been wrong for days. Weeks. Enough that the faint morning queasiness doesn’t surprise you anymore, though you’ve been pretending not to notice. But today it’s stronger.
You make it just in time.
The nausea hits like a wave you’ve been trying to outrun, knees hitting tile, palm braced on the edge of the tub. You breathe through it, eyes stinging, throat burning.
It’s fine, you tell yourself. It’s stress. Just stress. Work, life, this… thing with Carmen that shouldn’t mean so much. It has to be stress. Except your period is late. Really late.
When you’re sure your stomach has settled and you have nothing more to throw up, you get up, slowly pulling yourself up, one hand gripping the porcelain like it might slip away if you let go. Your legs feel weak, hollowed out, and you have to stand there for a moment with your head bowed, breathing through your nose until the room stops tilting.
The bathroom smells faintly like Carmy’s soap. Clean, sharp and familiar.
You rinse your mouth, trying to get the worst of the acidy taste washed away, but it clings to the back of your throat like a bitter pill.
You splash cool water on your face, watching it bead and drip down the sink. You press your chilled fingers to your cheeks, trying to breathe normally. Maybe he didn’t hear.
The door creaks. Of course he heard.
“Hey,” Carmy says, his voice suddenly sounding wide awake, sharp with worry. “You okay?”
You straighten too fast. “Yeah. Yeah, I’m fine.”
He stands in the doorway in sweatpants and a white tee, wrinkled and stretched from sleep, hair a mess, loose curls flattened on one side, sticking up on the other, brow pulled tight in concern that looks carved into him. He’s always ready for emergencies, they are something he has started to expect from life, he’s just not used to you being one.
“You’re not fine,” he says softly. “You were throwing up.”
You open your mouth, close it. The acidic taste burns at the length of your gorge. You don’t want to say it. Because saying it makes it real, and real is way, way too scary.
He steps closer, slow and careful, like he is sure if he is allowed to. Like one wrong move might send you retreating back behind that careful, practiced distance you keep between the two of you when things get too real.
“Is there something I can do?” he asks quietly.
The question is so simple it almost breaks you. Not what’s wrong, not why didn’t you tell me, just that. An offer, an opening, the want to help.
You shake your head, a small, useless motion. Your throat tightens around the words before they ever make it out. You turn back to the sink, fingers curling around the edge like it might anchor you.
“I don’t know,” you say finally. Your voice sounds thin to your own ears. “I don’t think so.”
You know how he likes his coffee. He knows exactly how you take your eggs. You’ve seen him at his worst, panic tight in his chest, hands shaking, voice breaking. He’s seen you quiet and careful, the way you tuck pieces of yourself away so neatly it almost looks like strength. You know each other in these intimate, unspoken ways that don’t have a name, that don’t fit neatly into something but are so, so far from nothing.
That’s the thing that scares you most.
You swallow. “It’s not… it’s probably nothing,” you say. “I’ve just been… feeling off.”
“Okay… How long?”
You hesitate. Then almost inaudibly: “A few weeks.”
He rubs a hand over his mouth, a habit you’ve seen a hundred times when he doesn’t know what to say yet.
“You been sick the whole time?”
“Not… like this,” you say. “Just tired. Nauseous sometimes. I thought I was just run down.”
He hums, low and thoughtful. Then he takes a step closer, his eyes searching your face like he is looking for something. “You could have told me.”
“I know,” you say. “I just… didn’t think it was important.”
Carmy exhales slowly through his nose, like he’s counting without meaning to. Like he’s replaying every moment over the past few weeks in his head, looking for the signs he missed. “You being sick is important.”
You look down at the sink, at the tiny chip in the porcelain you’ve stared at many times before, because meeting his eyes right now feels like too much.
“I don’t think I’m sick,” you say quietly.
His breath catches. It’s subtle, almost imperceptible, but you feel it anyway, the shift in the air, the way the room seems to narrow around the two of you.
“My period’s late,” you whisper.
Silence. Not empty, but heavy. He swallows, his body tightening, but he doesn’t step away.
“How late?” he asks, voice rougher now, like he’s bracing for impact without quite knowing what that impact is.
“Late enough that I’m thinking about it.” You swallow, the words tasting metallic and sharp in your mouth, bracing yourself for what you know you have to say out loud. “I think I might be pregnant.”
There it is. The words hang between you, heavy and fragile and terrifyingly real.
Carmy goes very still.
For a heartbeat, you can’t read him at all. Not panic, not anger, not relief, just shock, like his brain is rebooting under the weight of it. Then he swallows hard, Adam’s apple bobbing, and he drags a hand down his face.
“Okay,” he says again, quieter this time. “Okay.”
You watch him, trying to read the slight twitch of his jaw, the way his fingers flex against his face. His chest rises and falls, steadying himself, but there’s an almost imperceptible tremor in his shoulders.
“Do you want me to…” His words falter, and he runs a hand through his messy curls, unsure. “Do you want me to go get a test?”
You nod, feeling the sting of tears pressing at the corners of your eyes. “Yeah,” you whisper, voice small, “I… I think I need to know.”
He nods, slow and deliberate. “Okay. We’ll do that. I’ll go. Or we can go together. Whatever you want.”
You hesitate, then nod again. “Together,” you murmur, you don’t want to be alone right now.
He exhales, a breath you feel more than hear, and steps closer, letting you lean into him. His arms wrap around you with a steadiness that feels like gravity, anchoring you even as your stomach twists with nerves.
You move in silence after that, just the quiet choreography of two people trying not to break something fragile between them. Carmy grabs his jacket, slipping it on over the white tee.
You grab a sweater from a chair, his, obviously, and pull it on. It smells like him, warm and familiar. Carmy watches you do it, lips pressing together like he wants to say something and doesn’t know how yet. You slip your shoes on by the door, fingers fumbling a little with the laces. He notices. Of course he does.
“You sure you wanna go now?”
You nod. “If I wait, I’ll spiral.”
“Yeah,” he says quietly. “Okay. Yeah, that tracks.”
The street outside is quiet, washed in early morning light. The city hasn’t fully woken up yet, no horns, no crowds, just the low hum of distant traffic and the whisper of wind between buildings.
You walk side by side, his palm on your back, after half a block, his hand slips down and finds yours instead, tentative for half a second before you squeeze back. He exhales, relieved, like that small contact steadies him as much as it does you.
The pharmacy is open, fluorescent lights humming overhead. Everything feels too bright, too normal. A woman at the counter yawns behind a coffee cup. A rack of candy bars gleams obnoxiously cheerful.
Carmy disappears down an aisle and comes back with not just one, but three tests.
“You don’t need,” you start.
“I know,” he says quickly, already a little flustered. “I just… I wanna make sure. In case one’s busted or, I don’t know.” He rubs the back of his neck. “Sorry.”
“It’s okay,” you say, and you mean it.
At the checkout, he insists on paying, swiping his card with hands that are steadier than you expect them to be. When the cashier slides the bag across the counter, Carmy grabs it like it’s something precious instead of a thin plastic sack holding your entire world.
The walk back is even quieter. He keeps glancing at you, like he’s afraid you might disappear if he looks away too long. Back inside his apartment, the door clicks shut behind you, sealing you into the small, familiar space.
He sets the bag down on the counter and looks at you. Really looks at you.
“Bathroom’s yours,” he says gently. “I’ll… I’ll be right here. Okay?”
Your throat tightens. “Okay.”
The bathroom feels smaller than before. Too quiet. You close the door and lean against it for a second, pressing your palm flat to your stomach. Nothing feels different, yet everything does.
You open the box of one of the tests and follow the instructions, placing the little plastic stick at the side of the tub before washing your hands. You leave the bathroom, finding Carmy sitting just outside the door, leaning against the wall, hands on his knees. He looks up as you step out, eyes soft but alert.
“Have you?”
“Yeah,” you say with a small nod. “We have to wait a few minutes for it to develop.”
You sit down next to him, letting yourself lean into him, letting your head rest on his shoulder. He leans back, letting his cheek rest lightly against the top of your head. Neither of you says anything for a while, the quiet stretching around you like a fragile bubble, both of you holding your breaths in tandem, hearts thudding in that peculiar, synchronized rhythm that comes from knowing someone this intimately.
Then, after a few minutes, he moves, just slightly, to leave a gentle kiss to the top of your head. It almost breaks you, but you don’t move, don’t pull back. You just let it land, soft and grounding.
His cheek finds your hair again, you almost can’t take it. You want him so bad, you have known it for a while now, that you are in love with him, but you have not let yourself admit it. You tried to convince yourself that you were content with the way things were. Now you feel like you will never have the chance of having him. Because whatever waits in that bathroom feels like it could take that possibility away before you ever get the nerve to reach for it.
“You’re shaking,” he murmurs, so softly it barely disturbs the air.
You hadn’t noticed. Or maybe you had and didn’t want to name it. You tuck your hands closer to yourself, but he catches one, warm fingers wrapping around yours without hesitation this time. No question. No pause.
“Hey,” he says, and you feel it in your chest more than you hear it. “I got you. Okay?”
The words hit harder than anything else has.
“You don’t have to do this,” you whisper. “You know that, right?”
His brows knit together. “Do what?”
“Be here like this. Be… involved.”
He lets out a soft breath, almost a laugh, but there’s no humor in it. “Yeah. I kinda do.”
You blink. “Why?”
“Why,” he repeats quietly, tasting the word. “Because I did this to you.”
“I don’t want you to,” you start, then falter. The words pile up too fast, tripping over each other. “I don’t want you to feel like you’re stuck. Or obligated. Or like this,” you gesture weakly toward the bathroom door, the waiting, the fear, “is something you have to carry just because you feel guilty, or trapped, or whatever.”
He shifts so he’s facing you fully then. “I’m not trapped,” he replies, firmer this time, like he needs you to hear it all the way through.
You shake your head, eyes burning. “You don’t know that yet.”
“Yeah,” he admits. “Maybe I don’t. But I know this.” He swallows, jaw flexing. “I know my first instinct wasn’t to run or pretend this isn’t happening. It was to stay right here. When you said you might be pregnant, the only thing I could think was…” He swallowed again, jaw tightening for just a second. “I don’t want you going through that without me…” He trails off, breath hitching like the rest of the sentence is too big to fit through his throat all at once.
Something in your chest cracks at that, not a clean break, but a splintering, the careful structure you’ve built around yourself giving way under the weight of how sincerely he means it.
“I think the five minutes are up,” you say softly.
The words feel unreal in your mouth, like you’re narrating something that’s happening to someone else. Your gaze flicks toward the bathroom door, like it might suddenly swing open on its own and spare you from having to make the choice to look.
“Okay,” he says quietly. “Do you wanna… do you wanna do it together?”
You nod. You don’t trust your voice.
You stand slowly, knees unsteady, and he rises with you like it’s instinct, like his body has already decided it’s not letting you do this alone. You walk the few steps to the bathroom side by side, shoulders brushing, the light inside still on, too bright, too honest.
The test is exactly where you left it.
Your stomach twists as you pick it up, the small plastic stick suddenly impossibly heavy in your hand. Carmy’s presence is a pressure you both lean into and lean against, grounding and terrifying at once.
You look down and your breath gets caught in your chest. One clear vibrant line. But next to it is another. Faint, but unmistakably there.
“It’s… positive,” you whisper, voice breaking before you can stop it.
Carmy exhales, slow and measured, though his chest rises and falls a fraction too fast to be completely calm. “Okay,” he says, soft, almost to himself, and then he reaches out, fingers brushing yours.
“Yeah,” you whisper, barely louder than a breath.
“Scared?” he murmurs, voice low, careful.
You nod again, whispering it this time: “Yeah. Terrified.”
He doesn’t flinch. He doesn’t look away. “Me too,” he admits.
Tears sting your eyes. “You don’t have to—”
“Don’t,” he interrupts, fast. Desperate. “Please don’t. I don’t know how to do this, but I know I want to do it with you,” he says, voice breaking just enough to make your chest tighten. “Whatever it is you want. And if later you tell me you want space, or you wanna do this differently, or you don’t want me hovering, then okay. I’ll listen. But don’t decide for me right now.”
He swallows hard after that, like he’s said something that cost him, like he’s bracing for you to pull away anyway.
You don’t. Instead, you break.
Not loudly. Not dramatically. It’s quieter than that, your shoulders caving in, breath hitching, tears spilling over before you can stop them. You press your face into his chest, fists curling in the fabric of his shirt like you’re afraid he’ll vanish if you let go.
“I don’t know what I want,” you admit, words muffled, raw. “I don’t know what I’m supposed to feel. I just…” You inhale shakily. Tears start coming faster now.
His arms come around you immediately, firmer this time, no hesitation at all. He presses his cheek into your hair, breath warm against your scalp. You shake against him, a quiet, helpless sound leaving your throat.
Carmy tightens his arms around you instinctively, like your fear has weight and he’s trying to hold all of it for you. One hand presses firm and steady against your back, the other sliding up to cradle the back of your head.
His thumb rubs slow, grounding circles at the base of your skull, like he’s trying to remind your body that he’s there and you aren’t alone,
“That’s okay. You don’t have to know,” he murmurs, softer this time, voice rough around the edges.
You pull back just enough to look at him, eyes burning, lashes wet. “You won’t hate me is I choose to keep it?” The question slips out before you can stop it, small and terrified and painfully honest.
His eyes flicker, not away from you, but inward, like he’s checking himself before he speaks. He shakes his head once, slow and sure. “No,” he says, too fast to be anything but true. “No, I wouldn’t hate you.” His voice is steady in that way you know means he says what he really feels. “I can’t hate you. I, uhm, I think I love you.”
He doesn’t finish the sentence cleanly. He doesn’t even seem to realize he’s said it until the words are already hanging there between you, fragile and incandescent.
“I…” He exhales, shaky, a hand lifting like he might take it back and then dropping again. “I don’t know why I said that,” he cuts himself off, brow creasing like he’s bracing for impact. “I know I love you.” The words land this time without hesitation.
You freeze for half a heartbeat.
“I love you.” He says it quieter, steadier, not because it’s less terrifying, but because he’s stopped trying to outrun it. He closes his eyes like saying it any louder might shatter something delicate between you.
Your chest aches in a way that’s almost unbearable. Relief and fear crash together, leaving you breathless.
“Carm…”
“I know,” he says quickly, opening his eyes again, earnest and scared and impossibly sincere. “I know this is… a lot. And the timing’s shit. And I’m not saying this fixes anything or makes it easy. Fuck no. But I couldn’t not say it. Not right now. Sorry.”
A sob slips out of you, half-laugh, half-relief, breath shaking.“God, you’re such an asshole.”
He lets out a breath that might almost be a laugh. “Yeah,” he agrees. “I’ve been told.”
“You don’t have to say anything,” he rushes, immediately, voice low and rough. “I’m not— I’m not saying it because of this. Or because I think it fixes anything. I just…” He swallows. “I just needed you to know.”
Your breath catches. You can feel the sincerity radiating off him, anchoring you even as your stomach twists and your heart threatens to burst.
“Carm…” You try to speak, but your voice falters, so thick with emotion it comes out as nothing more than a choked whisper. He tightens his arms around you, gentle but unyielding.
“You don’t have to say anything right now,” he says quickly. “I’m sorry, I’m so shit at this. It’s a fucked up timing, sorry…” His words are rough, jagged with emotion, but steady underneath.
“Can we cuddle?” you don’t know what else to say, your body needs the closeness, your thoughts won’t form into anything coherent.
“Yeah,” he says immediately, voice low, rough around the edges but steady. “Yeah, of course.”
You follow him back to his bed, letting him guide you. The sheets smell faintly of him, clean, comforting, familiar, and it’s enough to ground you in the moment.
You sink down beside him, and he immediately wraps an arm around you, pulling you close. Your body presses into his side, fitting like it’s meant to, even though your mind is still spinning. He drapes the other arm across your back, holding you with a quiet, unshakable steadiness.
You inhale shakily, letting the warmth of him anchor the panic and fear twisting in your chest. His presence is a weight and a support all at once, grounding you without words.
You lean fully into him, resting your head on his chest. The steady rise and fall of him beneath your ear, the soft brush of his fingers on your back, the faint warmth of his skin, it’s all grounding. You let yourself tremble, let the tears fall freely now, and he doesn’t flinch. He only holds you tighter.
Minutes pass, or maybe even hours, time has lost meaning. The tears stop, you bury yourself in him, letting his heartbeat, strong and deliberate beneath your ear, ground you.
“You love me,” you murmur, voice small and trembling.
“Yeah,” he murmurs back, voice rough, steady, and certain. “I do.”
You press your face closer to his chest, letting the words settle in your chest like a fragile warmth. “I love you too,” you whisper, voice breaking.
He tightens his arms instinctively. You lay like this for a while like the world has shrunk to just the two of you, the hum of the city outside fading into irrelevance.
“Are you hungry…?” he asks softly, voice low, almost hesitant, like he doesn’t want to shatter the fragile cocoon you’re both wrapped in.
You can’t help but laugh, soft and shaky, a small, breathless sound that surprises even you.
“You’re such a fucking chef,” you say
He lets out a small, rough chuckle, the kind that starts deep in his chest and shakes him a little. “Yeah,” he says, shaking his head, “sorry.”
You nuzzle closer, letting the humor thread its way through the fear still coiled in your chest. “Don’t apologize. I am hungry.”
He smiles faintly, just the corner of his lips lifting, and it’s warm, quiet, gentle. “Yeah?” he murmurs, a little surprised, like he’s relieved to be useful in a way he understands. His hand rubs slow circles into your back, grounding. “Okay. Uh… I can make something light. Toast? Eggs? Soup? I’ve got—”
“Carm,” you interrupt gently, tilting your head to look up at him. His eyes are soft, a little red-rimmed, still holding all that fear and tenderness at once. “Eggs sound good.”
He blinks, like the simplicity of it catches him off guard. “Yeah?” he says again, quieter this time, a little smile breaking through for real now. “Okay. Eggs. I can do eggs.”
He presses a quick, careful kiss to your forehead, like sealing a promise he’s afraid to say out loud, and gently shifts out from under you.
“I’ll be right back,” he murmurs, softer than usual, like loudness might scare the moment away.
You stay curled in his bed, wrapped in sheets that smell like him—soap and coffee and something warm you can never quite name. You listen to him move around the kitchen: the low click of the burner, the scrape of a pan pulled from the rack, the quiet curse under his breath when something clatters a little too loud. Normal sounds. Ordinary sounds. They ground you in a way nothing else has all morning.
Your hand drifts to your stomach without you thinking about it, before you can stop yourself. There’s nothing to feel yet. No change, just you and fear. And something fragile and new and terrifyingly flimsy.
From the kitchen, you hear him clear his throat. “Scrambled okay?” he calls, trying and failing to sound casual.
You smile despite yourself. “Perfect.”
There’s a pause. Then a soft, almost relieved, “Okay.”
When he comes back, he moves carefully, like the room has turned sacred. He sets the plate down on the nightstand, scrambled eggs, still steaming, toast cut diagonally because of course it is. A mug of tea follows, placed just close enough that you won’t have to reach too far.
“There,” he says quietly. “Didn’t overdo it. Should be easy.”
You push yourself up, pillows tucked behind your back. Before you can even thank him, he’s already climbing back onto the bed, settling beside you like that’s where he belongs.
You take a bite. Your stomach settles, just a little, and you let out a breath you didn’t realize you were holding.
“Hey,” he murmurs, noticing immediately. “Okay?”
You nod. “Yeah. Better.”
His shoulders loosen at that, tension bleeding out of him in a way that feels almost physical. He watches you eat for a second too long, then catches himself and looks away, rubbing at the back of his neck.
“Good,” he says quietly, almost to himself. “That’s… good.”
He hesitates, then reaches for your hand anyway, threading his fingers through yours like it’s the most natural thing in the world.
You lean into his shoulder, warm and full and still scared, but steadier now. Outside, the city keeps moving, cars, sirens, lives continuing on, despite your world just having quietly, irrevocably shifted.