What’s your opinion on theories that all is not well when it comes to OT4 and the band is effectively broken up
I don’t know what people are specifically theorising. And I also don’t know what expectations people have - what would ‘all being well’ between Harry, Liam, Niall and Louis look like?
I think their relationships are likely to be really messy. They share a very important past, they’re tied together in people’s minds in a way that means that they can make a different to each others lives. But (Harry and Louis excepted - if I’m right about their relationship) they’re not the most important people in each others’ lives any more. And there are so many reasons relationships between any two of them, or the group, could be difficult at any time.
As for the idea that the band is effectively broken up - I don’t really know what people think that means. The only difference between an inactive band and a broken up band is the label that the people involved in the band choose to put on it.
And the way people choose to present themselves matters, but it’s also temporary. Lots of bands have broken up and got back together, other bands have been inactive for ages - and never done anything together again.