The Gay Underworld of Late-Victorian London: Theo Aronson’s Book is a Landmark Study of Private Spaces at the Time of Oscar Wilde
In 1885, England criminalized all sexual relations between consenting adult males, no matter how private or quiet. So if you want a picture of London’s gay life around the 1895 trial of Oscar Wilde, you must descend into a shadowy underworld of protected spaces and passwords. This is where Theo Aronson guides us in his landmark study Prince Eddy and the Homosexual Underworld (Barnes and Noble, 1994).
The Prince Eddy of the title is one of history’s great might-have-beens. Prince Albert Victor, Duke of Clarence, was the handsome, dashing eldest son of Edward VII–the gay eldest son. Prince Eddy had all the skirt-chasing habits of his father, only for guys. When he died suddenly of typhus at age 29, the entire Royal establishment heaved a sigh of relief–and then destroyed all his papers. Prince Eddy was no more controllable than his father had been at that age, and had he lived he would have been, literally, the first openly gay Prince of Wales in English history.
So where did Prince Eddy go for fun? That’s the subject of this book. We start with telegraph boys. Victorians sent and received telegrams with the ease of emails, except that pickup and delivery came by means of comely young men who often didn’t mind a little extra income having sex with their male customers. Memoirs and letters of the period are full of affairs with such boys; Wilde’s boyfriend Lord Alfred Douglas practically specialized in collecting telegraph boys, and many of his friends followed suit.
The practice finally hit the fan in 1889 when one such, Charlie Swinscow, was seen carrying far more money than he was making at work. Officials were astonished at his frank answer: he and his buddies Henry Newlove and Charles Thickbroom doubled their income most nights at a male brothel at 19 Cleveland Street, one that specialized in bringing men together with delectable telegraph boys. Clients named went right to the top of society, most notably Lord Arthur Somerset, a friend of Prince Eddy. These toffs were discreetly allowed to escape to the Continent during the resulting furor; less prominent customers were less lucky.
Besides telegraph boys, there were The Guards, often mentioned in popular literature, plays, and films made later about this period. Between low pay and the relaxed attitudes of working class boys toward homosexuality, soldiers made very good prostitutes, and the fact that both parties in the transaction had something to lose helped keep a lid on blackmail. “Of course we all do it for money,” Aronson quotes one such. “We also do it because we really like it, and if gentlemen gave us no money, we should do it all the same.” Big, muscular, uniformed, clean, virile, and friendly–no wonder they were popular! The Horse Guards, barracked near Hyde Park, were the most famous unit participating in this trade. “One could hardly move among certain densely wooded areas of Hyde Park for soliciting Guardsmen…their weapons…in their hands,” Aronson quotes one contemporary.
Another place of resort was the Hundred Guineas Club off Portland Place, managed by a certain Mr. Inslip. For an annual membership of nearly $10,000 in today’s money, the well-to-do gay man was given a dreamlike play space for his double life. Members, guests, and staff rent-boys all dressed in drag and adopted women’s names. For much of the evening, gentlemen sipped champagne, eyed the staff choices, and engaged in decorous hand-holding, dancing, and small talk. At 2am, the lights were doused. “On no account, staff were warned, were they to reject any advance.” Until time was called at 6am, everyone paired off upstairs in gay oblivion. One rent boy who worked there “was careful…to appear at the club only two evenings a week for fear of being used up too soon.”
Although Aronson gets bogged down elsewhere in the book with theories that Prince Eddy was actually Jack the Ripper (still an unproved but popular hobbyhorse), where he sticks to the substance of the title, his book becomes an essential addition to the social history of the late Victorian period, and a great read as well.