Characters: Reader x Theo
A/N: theo’s character genuinely frustrates me bc i should hate him but he’s just so flipping beautiful, like why?
You stared angrily at Theo, why did he have to be so hot. With his stupid smile and stupid hair, any girl would find him irresistible, and he knew it.
From the moment he'd showed up in Beacon Hills you had taken Stiles' side, believing he was up to no good. But, neither you or Stiles could manage to prove he was guilty of anything, so, Scott being the 'see the good in everyone' type of guy he is, immediately trusted him.
Scott was determined to change your opinion of Theo, so when the pack needed someone to go and do more research on the dread doctors, he suggested the two of you go together. When your complaints and whining were ignored by Scott, you had no choice besides riding in Theo's truck to the school library.
You stared grumpily out the window, trying to ignore Theo's gorgeous smile. After a few minutes of uncomfortable silence, Theo spoke up. "Look, all I want is to be a part of the pack. I'm not a bad guy, Y/N,"
"I didn't believe you the first five times you've said that, I'm not changing my mind now," you stated bluntly.
You turned toward him, scowling, "Look, Theo, Scott paired me up with you because he thinks I should trust you, but you know what? I don't care what Scott thinks, the bottom line is I don't trust you and I don't like you. So let's just get this over with,"
Theo only stared at you with a small smirk playing on his lips, as he shrugged, "Whatever you say Y/N,"
You snapped your head back toward the window, the truck soon resuming in its unnerving silence.
You and Theo climbed out of the truck, Theo leading the way to the library. He paused in front of the doors, turning to face you so quickly that you almost ran into him.
"What the hell Theo!" You snapped, "Go inside-"
Theo ignored you, "I know you like me," he blurted out.
"W-what?" You stuttered, surprised by his statement.
"I said, I know you like me," Theo took a step towards you and you stepped backward, "I know this hatred against me is all an act,"
He continued to come closer to you and you continued to retreat away from him, "It's not an act," Your heartbeat quickened as he got closer, "You're not a good person," your voice came out in a whisper and it sounded more like you were trying to convince yourself than make a statement.
"Who told you that?" He chuckled softly, "Stiles? He doesn't like me because I’m a threat to him. He’s afraid I'm gonna get too close to Scott. He thinks I'm trying to take his place,"
Thud. You gulped as your back hit a wall, you had no where to go.
"Y/N, I might not be a werewolf, but I can hear your heartbeat," He was inches away from you now, "You do like me, and you can't lie about it,"
You looked away from him, trying to ignore your burning cheeks, "I don't-"
"And your heartbeat is telling me I'm not the only one who wants me to kiss you right now,"
You held your breath as Theo gently grabbed your chin and brought his lips to yours. Why did something so wrong feel so right?
