Doll Morality?
Someone posted in the N@zi Doll Discourse post a while back, "Having a doll represent anything feels inherently glorifying, for lack of better word. What I mean is, you wouldn’t have a doll of something you hate. You make dolls to represent beloved characters, maybe real individuals you admire- wether it be partners, actors, pets even."
And oh boy. Oh boyyyy I have realized in this moment why so many people get so feral over fictional bullshit, and also that apparently my doll-having experience is not like the experience others are having. And no shade to this person or anyone else who feels this way, but man... I do not at all make dolls based on things I love and support, not like, intentionally or exclusively. I have dolls for reasons like "that looks cool" and "that's cute" -- but I also have some character dolls in a fictional setting, and they include both a protagonist, an antagonist, and a morally-grey third-party. And I don't... give it that much thought, you know?
I don't condone bad actions, literally just "character x did thing for reason. plot moves forward" is about the sum of that thought process because I don't... consider that actions of some fictional people to be reflective of my stand on basically anything? That's like saying Mads Mikkelsen is pro-cannibalism because he played Hannibal Lecter, to me. Like it's just. It's just a role on a TV show; it's just a doll on my shelf.
It's just some characters in a fictional story that won't even see the light of day, and I'm just an anon sitting on my bed star-struck by how different our experiences can be across the hobby- in a nonjudgmental, positive manner, mind. Literally I made these (negative) characters into dolls because I saw some sculpts that worked over the years and said to myself "oh, well damn, that works. that'd be a cool doll."
I don't really tie morality into it at all, for me. Fiction is fiction at the end of the day, isn't it? But it was very interesting to see someone else's take on the matter, and it provided some insight to me, at least, on why people have become so incredibly morally aggrandized over the behavior of fictional characters and "proper" representation and everything else (saying this as a person from a a societally disadvantaged background for the record; I'm not saying I don't get why people want to see more representation, I'm saying I'm baffled by the rise in the belief that only "positive, morally wholesome" representation is acceptable when I, personally, would prefer to see a diversity in narratives about people from my background, good and bad, because I feel only allowing one perspective is just as hollow as only showing negative portrayals; but I digress.)
It makes sense to me that people would be upset by things that are morally dubious or objectively bad if they feel that those producing such content are inherently supportive of it. On the other hand, the knowledge that some people feel this way actively fills me with dread and has further filled me with resolve to never publish anything, anywhere, because even my relatively milquetoast neo-noir bullshit probably won't past muster under that kind of scrutiny. As a final note, I will say that despite all this, I still would find it fucky to make a N@zi doll, even if there is at least one out there released by a prominent Dollmaker. I'd be open to hearing why someone else got one (if you like the sculpt and burned the outfit, sure, why not) but me personally, no thank you.