Hi there, hope this is okay to ask. I’m going to give some background if that’s okay.
I’ve had a close friend for years. She’s unlike any other person I’ve known. I get close with friends, but she’s by far my closest. She’s demi-pansexual, I’m also demi and I Think pansexual (at least panromantic. Idk. My sexuality wavers a lot). We have extremely open, honest communication and we’ve talked about living together for years (im in east coast US, she’s west) and each time we see each other we struggle to part and miss each other terribly afterward. We’ve wondered if it’s a QPR type thing - but we do enjoy some arguably romantic stuff together like holding hands and cuddling and sharing a bed. We’ve debated doing more (kissing) but don’t want to ruin anything or make it awkward.
Here’s the problem. I really want to start dating soon and I really want a partner I’m sexually attracted to. I think my friend is very attractive, but I don’t think I feel anything sexual necessarily. I love the idea of cuddling sweetly but I have lots of kinks I don’t think she’d enjoy engaging in, and I don’t know if I’d want her in that position.
Today I remarked “I wish I could just have a spouse and a girlfriend (her)” and she had apparently thought similarly. We love each other so dearly and want to know each other for the rest of our lives, we love sharing a bed and we love being close. We don’t mind at all when people think we’re dating; it’s kind of exciting tbh. But I don’t know if she’s someone I’d want to marry - and I Really want to be married someday.
I kind of like the idea, again, of being in some sort of relationship with her but also having a spouse. I don’t know if others would be okay with that though.
Is this … an option? Idk. I’ve never thought I might be poly. But I guess I do have fantasies of having multiple partners, and when I’ve heard examples of poly (“they’re my sun, you’re my moon, she’s my stars”) it made sense to me. I just always figured I was monogamous because I’ve never met a man I want to date and I don’t want an open relationship. I don’t know if I’m in denial of being in love with my friend, if this is just the demi part of me talking, or if being poly would solve this tension. :(
Hi anon! The short version of my answer is, Yes, that's totally an option and if you both feel good about it you should give it a shot!
First, and this is probably my own personal opinions and experience talking, but I think it could be really helpful for you guys to worry less about defining the relationship. My opinion on labels is, whether you're labeling a relationship or an orientation or a gender, etc., a label should serve you, not the other way around. That is to say, it's better to use a label to describe something or someone that already exists, than to use a label to prescribe a way that something or someone should behave. Relationships often become a lot less tense when you stop trying to fit them in a box and just allow your dynamic to become what it wants to be.
It's obvious that you both care a lot about each other, and you enjoy spending time together and enjoying physical contact together. Placing a label on your relationship could be an important milestone when the time is right, but if you're not sure what you two "are" right now that's totally okay. And if you never figure out what you "are", that's also totally fine and valid. Undefined relationships can be just as significant, deep, and passionate as relationships with clear labels and roles.
Talk with your friend about how you want your relationship to be, not just what you want it to be called. Example questions: How often do we want to see each other? Do we want to make major life changes to see each other more often - if so, what's the timeline? When we're together, what kind of physical contact do we want to have? If we were to escalate our physical contact (ie. kissing, sex, etc), how will we communicate how we feel before, during, and afterwards? If we initiate a committed relationship with each other, will we both feel comfortable seeing other people simultaneously? What does "committed" look like for us? How will we communicate with each other and with our other partners about our desires and expectations? (It's TOTALLY OKAY if you don't have answers to all of these questions immediately! They're good things to reflect on individually and talk through together over time; don't feel like you have to rush it or have it all figured out right off the bat.)
The most important thing is to communicate with each other openly and consistently, and each of you do the same thing with any future partners you may have. If you do decide to have a non-monogamous relationship, going into it with your wants and needs laid out on the table will make things go so much more smoothly.
All that being said, I still haven't addressed the crux of your ask directly. Yes, it's absolutely an option to be in a long-term relationship with someone you're not married to and to marry someone else. You mentioned that you don't want an open relationship; it sounds like you might be describing something called polyfidelity, or a closed poly relationship. This means that you are in a relationship with more than one person, but the relationship isn't open for more folks to join. I know I said labels aren't the end-all be-all, but having that vocabulary will hopefully serve as a good jumping-off point for you to do your own research and reading.
Things to consider moving forward, if you both decide that that type of relationship would work for you: How would you feel about your future spouse also having another partner(s)? There are monogamous people out there who would definitely be willing to enter a relationship with a polyamorous person (these are called mono-poly relationships), but just like any relationship structure, this one comes with its own challenges. On the other hand, if your future spouse is also polyamorous, you would need to discuss having a closed relationship with them and determine that that's something everyone is comfortable with. Lots of polyamorous people would be open to a closed relationship, so don't feel discouraged by that statement! But lots of other polyamorous people prefer open polyamory, so it's important to make sure that everyone is on the same page going into the relationship.
I know I've just thrown a lot of information and long-winded advice at you, so don't feel overwhelmed. You don't have to make all of these decisions or come up with all the answers right this second! These are just things to reflect on, and a starting point for conversations with your friend and with yourself. I highly recommend journaling, or doing any other activity that helps you process your emotions like mindfulness, art, exercise, etc. while you think these things over.
Good luck, anon! I wish you and your friend the very best! <3 My ask box is always open if you have any other questions or want to talk things through! I can't promise to be an expert or a therapist but I'm happy to give you more of my thoughts or resources I can find on these topics.