UB Files: Barley's Brewing Company (Alehouse)
When we decided to visit a different central Ohio brewery every month and post our experience, we wanted to primarily focus on the new crop of breweries that have bloomed throughout the area. We assume a majority of the local beer enthusiasts have already visited veteran breweries like Barley’s Brewing Company, Elevator Brewery, and the Columbus Brewing Company. So, in the interest of providing new content for everyone, we were hoping to avoid those establishments for as long as possible. We lasted a couple months, but due to the challenges of scheduling, we find ourselves sitting in a booth at Barley’s about to ask what they have on cask.
With over 21 years of brewing beer in what is now the Arena District, Barley’s Brewing Company has a history of brewing in central Ohio that predates the current craft brew boom by a considerable length of time. This place is the very definition of old-school brewpub. With decorative tiled ceilings and wall paintings celebrating the history of not only Barley's, but the city itself, it's easy to feel some sense of nostalgia even if this is the first time you've stepped foot in this establishment. With the beer scene in central Ohio rapidly changing and growing exponentially in recent years, they haven’t felt the need to re-brand or update how they approach the beers they make or how those beers are produced or distributed, quite the opposite, they wear their age like a badge of honor.
With an entrance on High Street facing the Columbus Convention Center and a door in the back that beckons locals exiting the North Market, the great location of the Alehouse guarantees you’ll probably be dining with a healthy number of patrons at any given time. Fortunately, the abundant number of deep seated booths can still provide an intimate experience. If you find yourself waiting for one of those booths to open up, the large bar located toward the front of the building allows you to grab a pint or two in the meantime. And like the floor plan of Wolf's Ridge, the bar is located right next to windows that overlook the brewing equipment in the basement of the building.
One of the unique aspects of visiting Barley’s Alehouse is their dedication to real ales, which is reflected by the fact they normally have a couple of their beers available on cask. For those unfamiliar with the concept of real ale, they are beers served directly from the same container where they are actively fermenting. Due to the fact that the beer is naturally carbonated, the drinker will notice a little less carbonation than you would expect from a beer from a traditional tap (cask beers are pumped.) In addition, these beers tend to be served at room temperature, which sometimes can be a little off putting if you're not ready for it, but we find the lower temperature allows the flavor of the beer to come through clearer. It's definitely an interesting departure from the normal drinking experience, and although it may not be for everyone, we think beer enthusiasts (or anyone for that matter) should try it at least once.
What you’ll notice from their draft menu is that their selection is very diverse and features a wide range of beer styles and strengths to choose from. You’ll always be able to find some tap regulars such as their Pilsner as well an accessible IPA on the list, but the selection will also be littered with seasonal offerings along with the aforementioned cask selection. Fortunately, their wait staff tends to be fairly knowledgeable and usually willing to help you navigate through their selection according to your palate. But if you can't make up your mind, their sampler is very reasonably priced. As frequent patrons to Barley’s we passed on the sampler experience and went straight to ordering pints from their menu of about 10 in-house brews.
Tasting highlight from our visit:
Barley's Barleywine - (12.0% ABV) When we first got to the table, the server thought this was available on cask and unfortunately it was not. On the plus side it was on tap, but I think the beer would have been a bit smoother if it was aged in a cask. Bordering on the legal alcohol limit of what you can brew in the buckeye state, you could taste all 12% of this malty strong ale. Like many Barleywines, aging is critical because the copious amount of grains, and in some cases hops, added in the brewing process need time to blend, which tempers the boozy taste. Even though Barleywines lend themselves to bottling, I almost always order this type of beer if it is offered on tap. Barleywine's usually provide a complex drinking experience, even if the flavors within aren't quite playing nice with eachother.
Weather you're looking for a place to pregame for an event at Nationwide Arena or trying to immerse yourself in a great beer experience, we would recommend a visit to Barley's Alehouse to almost anyone regardless of their interest in craft beer. It offers an unassuming family friendly atmosphere that makes everyone feel welcome. And if you're hungry for a bite to go with your drinks, the large menu features a nice mix of American and German style food that pairs well with the beers they serve, but you'll have to go to a foodie blog for that review. Prost!











