do you have any thoughts on memory loss coming out of the CoL? if this is a possibility for the finale and (dare i say it) clarke or lexa come out of it with amnesia because idk ALIE got upgraded to super AI if she manages to get the code...i mean we've seen jaha forget wells but under different circumstances in that he was a source of pain and grief for him but it makes me wonder...
I actually wrote about this quite a while ago in my second ALIE Update after Episode 2 when i was trying to figure out how you could live in the City of Light forever. I haven’t put much else thought into this ‘theory’ so here is the sections on that along with some of the van leaks:
Death in the real reality & still alive in the City of Light
The best explanation I have for this phenomenon is that the longer you stay in The City of Light and ‘accept’ it, your brain is downloaded onto ALIE’s server. There are theoretical scientific studies that talk about how if humans could download their brain on to a computer, they could live forever. Your brain functions by sending electrical impulses, so if you could replicate that, theoretically you could replicate someone’s consciousness. Therefore, if your ‘real body’ dies in the ‘real reality’ your consciousness has been downloaded and you can live forever in the City of Light. But, the catch is that you have to say ‘yes’ to entering the City of Light. So, Gideon’s brain and consciousness was downloaded onto ALIE’s servers that allows his consciousness to live forever ‘digitally’ in the City of Light. However, is that really being alive?
Maybe when you enter the City of Light, and ALIE starts to download your consciousness, it also erases your brain. Maybe this is the build up to the finale. Maybe they are about to destroy ALIE but then the epiphany hits that if they destroy her; everyone that is inside the City of Light might lose their memories/who they are. A person is more than just then their body.
Vancouver Leaks – why is Clarke in pain while she is in the City of Light? Isn’t there supposed to not be pain there?
ALIE says that there is no pain in the City of Light….but that is A LIE.
As mentioned, ALIE controls your body while your mind is in the City of Light. She might create pain as some sort of ‘conditioning therapy’ to train and teach the humans inside the City of Light to behave. I’m not sure what her plans are once she gets the people inside the City of Light, but her claims that the city of light is this Utopia is A LIE.
Moving on, you see Lexa grab Clarke and ask “Are you hurt?” meaning that in the ‘real reality’ Clarke’s body is fine, but Clarke believes that she has been stabbed or somehow injured. ALIE is making Clarke believe she is hurt when she isn’t. I wrote HERE, that I think Clarke is in the City of Light against her will and that is why she is in her season 1 clothes and not modern ones. I think that ALIE is trying to convince Clarke to say ‘yes’ to the City of Light. In order for the City of Light to work, you have to say ‘Yes’ – you have to be willing and wanting. But, I think that ALIE will have somehow been able to get Clarke to enter the City of Light by using people Clarke loves (hurting them possibly – think of Raven banging her head against the wall) to get her to say ‘yes’ which isn’t a free-will choice; it was a choice made under duress. But, the act of Clarke saying ‘yes’ and wanting the suffering of her friends to end was enough to send her mind into the City of Light.
Some more biblical parallels: God created humans in his image. And like their Creator, they have free-will. So, to be human is to have free-will. In order for ALIE’s plan to work she has to have the human choose – without choosing under duress – to enter the City of Light for the connection to take complete hold. Clarke enters the City of Light, but not completely because it was under duress. I think that ALIE then temps Clarke to say ‘yes’ (of her own free-will) while she is in the City of Light; tempting her like Eve in the Garden of Eden to eat the forbidden fruit. ALIE shows her a time where she was free of burdens and had no blood on her hands, which was in season 1. Remember what Clarke said in 1x01 “The ground — that’s the dream. This is reality. Reality sucks.” ALIE is giving her what she wants – to be on the Ground but not in reality because “reality sucks”. Also, it looks like the people are feeling rain on their faces with the same expression Raven had when she felt rain on her face. ALIE is using things from Clarke’s own dreams that she has to convince her to accept the lie. This isn’t Clarke’s full dream though, she wants “I see trees all around me, the scent of wildflowers on a breeze” this modern metropolis from the past is not what she wants.
Lexa is able to reach Clarke due to their ‘real human connection’, and Clarke’s entrance into the City of Light not being ‘complete’. ALIE doesn’t have complete control over Clarke’s mind or body. Clarke is able to somewhat see/feel Lexa while she is in the City of Light. Clarke is holding onto Lexa for dear life in the Vancouver leaks – I think she can’t fully see Lexa yet. There is a moment when they are on the steps where Clarke says something to Lexa and Lexa smiles and grabs her face. We think that Lexa is saying, “Your mind is already changing” or something along those lines. I think that Clarke was telling Lexa that she can see Lexa’s face; Lexa is probably a blurry figure that Clarke can barely see, but due to their ‘real human connection’ and love – she can sense her. Lexa is slowly able to draw Clarke’s mind out of the City of Light and back into her body that is in the real reality. Lexa and Clarke are each other’s anchors to the real reality.
[Side note: You might be asking why Otan wasn’t able to resist ALIE when she used his body to hold a knife against Emori’s throat. I think there are two parts to this, 1) he willingly said ‘yes’ to go into the City of Light, and 2) Otan and Emori have a brother/sister connection rather than a ‘real human’ romantic one. I see this being paralleled with Bellamy/Octavia or Bellamy/Clarke or other friends. We see in transcript that Octavia, Bellamy, and Clarke have a real band-of-brothers moment.
This is not a moment of ‘real human connection’ but a familial one – like Otan and Emori. Therefore, I think that romantic love is the only thing that can anchor a person. Love might be the thing that is able to destroy ALIE because love can’t be explained or replicated digitally. Love is a weapon and shield.]
Finale theory and Lexa being trapped in the City of Light.
Now, if we are going with this theory – which is a far stretch and I’m not sure I even believe it anymore – there are many MANY questions that arise that I simply don’t have the answers to. So, the plan is to kill ALIE and free everyone ‘trapped’ inside the City of Light. For me, I think there are three things that could happen if ALIE is destroyed:
ALIE is destroyed the connection breaks and people’s minds return to their bodies in the real reality.
The people whose minds were in the City of Light are trapped there while their bodies are alive in the real reality. So they are in a coma like state since ALIE isn’t controlling their minds
ALIE is killed and all the data downloaded for them to live forever in the City of Light is wiped from their memory; giving everyone amnesia or totally wiping away who the person is.
Now, there might be even more repercussions for killing ALIE. I could see an ‘OH SHIT’ moment arise when they find out that destroying ALIE would also be destroying a person. A person is the summation of their memories and experiences as well as DNA and certain genetic factors. If you get rid of those memories, you are essentially ‘killing’ the person; you are saving the human body but you are killing the human inside of it. So, Lexa might not be trapped inside the City of Light…she might have her memories erased. This would also fall in line with the ‘its complicated’ surrounding Lexa’s survival as well as Clexa. Lexa is her mind and her experiences, take those away….and is she still ‘Lexa’? This might be another ending to the finale that fits in with the ‘it’s complicated’ scenario. BUT!!! If Lexa was chosen to be the Commander due to her being able to resist ALIE’s mind control…idk how this would work.