I think the whole history about Paige was perfect If you consider the circumstances. Actually I always thought everything was perfect, like it was meant to happen. The affair with Sam and why he tied his wings, the rule against witches and whitelighters having a relationship ... everything just fits for the history. And for the person who asked you, Paige was the exception, she was always a Charmed One but the prophecy only needed three sisters, so they were complete before Paige born.
I think they explained it as best they could without having people over-think it too much because as I said before, would cause a headache analyzing it.
Personally, I don’t think she was a Charmed One from the beginning, the prophecy stated that it would be only three powers (mind, time & foresight) and the Triquetra symbolizes exactly this. Therefore, when Prue died, Paige would become a Charmed one, she wasn’t one to begin with. Just a normal witch, a powerful witch at that because of her family line and she was a hybrid, the first hybrid.
The Sam and Patty affair was a good touch, seeing as why the Elders were so against Leo and Piper being together, but Paige, there was still some holes.
Like for one thing, I know for sure, Grams and Patty would NOT give a baby away to mortals without binding it’s powers. So, how in the heck did Paige orb out on her own during the car accident that killed her parents?
And on the subject of her powers falling in line, they MUST have binded her powers because like I said before, she didn’t have Prue’s ability of moving things with her mind, so it would entail that she must have had some other power, where did it go? If Paige’s white-lighter power wasn’t binded, her original witch power mustn’t have either, it doesn’t make any logical sense.
So in all, yeah they made sense of it all in a nutshell but when broken down, they didn’t really think it through to not have any sort of plot holes or fall through with the entire story of Paige.
Had they put a bit more thought into it, things would be clearer, but with the time frame of things, I don’t think they had the time~ to lol








