Stay With Me
In a world tearing itself apart, a guarded medic lets herself finally fall—only to find Babe Heffron already waiting, steady and soft, willing to stay through every broken piece.
Pairing: Babe Heffron x Reader
Prompt: "I can’t fix you. But I’ll sit with you while you fall apart.”
Word Count: ~2,500
Genre: Hurt/comfort slight angst because why the fuck not
Setting: Zell am See, Austria
Warning: idk is there even any?
Note || I'm well aware that Chuck didn't really die but for the sake of the one shot please roll with it and enjoy 😭 Also please please PLEASE send in some requests I’m running out of ideas 🥲
gotxpenny's masterlistband of brothers masterlist
The sky was the same dull gray it always was these days. Smoke curled from the end of my cigarette as I sat on the low stone wall, boots scuffed and numb from the cold. My fingers shook, not from the chill—but from everything else.
Chuck was gone. Shot through the head in a town whose name I barely remembered. My best friend. My only real friend, if I was being honest. One second we were talking about chocolate rations, the next he was bleeding out on cobblestones, and I hadn’t even had time to say goodbye.
Now, I just sat here. Smoked. Didn’t cry. Couldn’t.
I was the black cat, after all.
The hard-ass. The woman who didn’t flinch, didn’t break, didn’t let anyone get close. I’d earned that reputation from day one. Other companies pushed me around, treated me like I didn’t belong. Hell, some of the men in Easy did too—at first. But they stopped when they realised I wouldn’t take it. Winters had my back. Lip gave hell to anyone who mouthed off. Even Liebgott—who barely liked anyone—left me alone.
But then Babe Heffron came along.
Kind. Open. Soft in a world that demanded sharp edges. He looked at me like I was something human. Not a burden. Not an anomaly.
Just me.
The first time we met, it was in a muddy clearing just outside Eindhoven. I was patching up one of the new replacements, hands stained red, boots sunk in the muck. He offered me a canteen. I didn’t take it.
I’d been expecting the usual—side glances, whispers, someone calling me sweetheart or nurse like I wasn’t wearing the same uniform they were. I’d braced for it, like always.
But he didn’t do any of that. He just stood there, calm and patient, as if he had all the time in the world for someone like me.
“You okay?” he’d asked, voice gentle but unafraid.
I remember blinking at him like he’d asked if the sky was blue. No one ever asked if I was okay. Not seriously. Not without some agenda behind it.
“I’m fine,” I had said, curt. Cold. Automatic.
He just nodded, like he believed me. But he didn’t leave.
Instead, he crouched beside the replacement I’d just bandaged and struck up a conversation—low and kind, meant to distract from the pain. Me, I was already halfway gone, mind on the next thing, the next wound, the next job.
But he stayed in my periphery. And the next day, and the next, I started noticing the same thing.
He was present. With everyone. Not just the officers or the loudmouths. Not just his friends. With the guy who couldn’t stop shaking. With the medic who didn’t want to be seen. With me.
He didn’t treat me like I was something strange to figure out. Didn’t walk on eggshells, didn’t try to force small talk just to see if I’d bite. He was easy in his silence, comfortable in the gaps most people couldn’t stand.
And somewhere in those first few weeks, something shifted.
I started to wait for his voice in the mornings. Started to listen for his laugh across camp. Started to wonder what he’d say if I ever let down my guard long enough to tell him how scared I was. How angry. How lonely.
I didn’t let him in. Not yet. But he was there anyway.
Patient. Quiet. Constant.
And that was what undid me the most.
Because Edward Heffron didn’t try to break down my walls.
He just stood outside them, waiting, until I opened the damn door myself.
Then I heard the crunch of gravel behind me but didn’t turn my head. I knew the sound of his footsteps now. He never walked too loud, never approached like the others did—like I’d snap if they got too close.
“Didn’t think you smoked,” Babe said gently, settling down beside me without asking.
“Only when everything’s fucked,” I muttered.
He nodded like he understood. Maybe he did. Babe had always felt things too deeply for this war. It showed in his face, in the way he never looked away from the wounded, in the way he saw people.
Babe remembered the first time he saw her.
Not just noticed her—saw her.
She was knee-deep in mud and blood, sleeves rolled past her elbows, hands working fast and sure over some poor kid who couldn’t stop screaming. There was no panic in her, no wasted movement. Just focus. Tension. Grit.
She didn’t look up when he offered the canteen. Just gave him a glance sharp enough to cut and a curt, “I’m fine.”
He believed her, but he also didn’t. Not in the way that mattered.
Because beneath the hardened look and the stiff posture, he saw something else—a kind of ache that had nowhere to go. She wore it like a second skin, like she’d gotten used to the world asking everything from her but giving nothing back.
Everyone knew her by then—the woman in Easy. Tough as hell, didn’t take shit from anyone. Guys in other companies called her all sorts of things when they thought she couldn’t hear. Black cat. Ice queen. Bad luck.
Babe didn’t buy any of it.
He saw the way she stayed long after everyone else moved on. The way she checked on the wounded even after Doc Roe said they were stable. The way her eyes flicked to the horizon like she was waiting for the next thing to go wrong. Like it always did.
She wasn’t cold. She was guarded.
And he got that.
Maybe it was the Philly in him. Maybe it was because he’d never liked bullies, never liked the kind of guys who needed to tear someone down to feel strong. Or maybe it was just her. The way she didn’t flinch when things got ugly. The way she carried herself like she didn’t need anyone—but looked so damn tired of that weight.
He didn’t know when exactly he started falling for her. Maybe it was the way she never sugarcoated anything, not even comfort. Maybe it was how she looked at people like their pain mattered—even if she didn’t think hers did. Maybe it was because she didn’t try to be soft for anyone, and somehow that made her feel even more human.
He kept his distance, at first. She had that kind of presence that warned people off without saying a word.
But he stayed close enough. Close enough that when she needed quiet, he gave it. When she needed someone to sit with her and say nothing, he was there.
And the truth was—he’d never seen anyone like her.
She didn’t just survive the war. She stared it down. Every day.
And he’d made a quiet promise to himself, somewhere in those broken towns and long marches. He couldn’t fix her. He wouldn’t try.
But he’d stay. Every time she came undone, every time the cracks showed, he’d be there. Quiet, steady, and hers—if she ever wanted him.
The silence stretched and I didn’t offer him the cigarette. He wouldn’t have taken it either way. Instead, he folded his hands between his knees, elbows resting on them as he looked straight ahead at the empty road.
“I heard about Chuck," I didn’t answer. My jaw was locked too tight, “I liked him,” he added after a pause, “He always snuck you extra socks when they came in.”
That almost made me smile. Almost.
Instead, I exhaled a shaky breath and said, “I don’t know what the hell I’m doing, Heffron. I don’t know how to do this without people I trust,” I paused, swallowing the lump in my throat, “Or if I even know how to be someone worth trusting anymore.”
Silence danced between us. But not the uncomfortable kind. Babe’s quiet was the kind that made space, not pressure.
“I don’t think you’re supposed to know,” he said eventually, “I think you just get up. Keep going. Let people in, little by little, even when it scares the shit out of you.”
I glanced at him then—really looked at him.
Because that voice, those words…they didn’t feel real. Not in this world. Not for someone like me. So I searched his face for the tell. A smirk. A twitch. Some stupid joke waiting to follow, some sign that this was just another setup for disappointment. Another reason to wish I’d kept my walls higher.
But there was nothing.
No smirk. No shift in his eyes. No punchline waiting in the wings.
Just Babe. Still. Steady. His brows pulled together in that way he got when he meant something. When he wasn’t just talking, but offering pieces of himself.
And it scared the hell out of me.
Because for once, I wasn’t bracing for the fall. I was falling already.
And he was still there.
I blinked, shaking off the odd feeling rising in my chest, “You make it sound easy.”
“It’s not,” he said, turning to look at me for the first time. His eyes were soft but steady, “But it’s worth it.”
I looked away, the cigarette burning down between my fingers.
The words slipped out like they’d been hiding just beneath the surface, waiting for the quiet to let them breathe. I didn’t mean to say them—not like that, not so bare. But once I did, I couldn’t take them back.
“I’m a mess, Babe,” I whispered, “You don’t get it. I push people away for a reason. I don’t know how to let anyone—you—care about me. I don’t even know if I can be loved the right way.”
And that was the truth. Not sharp, not defensive. Just tired.
I didn’t cry. Not yet. But something inside me shifted, like the first crack in ice when spring comes too early. My hands shook. My chest felt tight in that dangerous, aching way. The walls I’d built so carefully—out of silence, sarcasm, and sheer necessity—were starting to tremble under the weight of honesty.
And Babe saw it.
He didn’t move. Didn’t push. He didn’t offer some perfect fix or try to patch me up with empty comfort. He just watched me, eyes soft and steady, like he was seeing every piece of me start to come apart. Like he knew this was the moment I needed to crumble, and that trying to stop it would only make it worse.
He waited.
Waited for permission.
Waited for me to say it was okay—for him to reach out, to hold me, to be that quiet force I didn’t know how to ask for. He didn’t reach too soon. He didn’t flinch at my mess.
He just stayed, patient as ever, like he’d already decided I was worth it—walls and all.
Babe didn’t flinch. He didn’t reach for me, didn’t crowd me. He just spoke, low and certain, “I can’t fix you,” he said, “But I’ll sit with you while you fall apart.”
That’s what undid me. Not some grand gesture. Not a kiss. Not a confession.
Just that.
I felt the tears finally sting behind my eyes. And Babe just sat there beside me—silent, warm, steady. The only thing that didn’t feel like it might disappear.
And for the first time since the war began, I let someone see me fall apart.
And he didn’t look away.
My breath hitched, chest rising too fast, too tight. The cigarette burned down to the filter between my fingers, forgotten. I didn’t look away from him. Not this time.
As the tears welled up and finally spilled, I stared straight into Babe’s eyes—soft blue and unbearably open. He wasn’t scared of what he saw. He didn’t try to look past it or pretend it wasn’t there.
He held it. Like it meant something. Like I did.
And I didn’t mean to say it. God, I didn’t even think before the words tumbled out in a broken breath—
“Ed…”
It was barely more than a whisper, but I felt the shift the second it left my mouth. Felt it in him.
Something in his expression cracked wide open.
He blinked like he hadn’t heard it right at first—because no one called him that. Not here. Not in this place where everything had to be nicknames and armor and half-truths.
But I’d said it.
Ed.
His real name. The name I’d tucked away in the back of my mind, too personal to use, too intimate to say aloud. Until now.
His lips parted like he wanted to speak, but nothing came. Just a long breath. His hand moved—slowly, deliberately—reaching up like he couldn’t help it anymore, fingers brushing the side of my face, featherlight and trembling.
“You’ve never called me that,” he said, voice raw and quiet, like he was afraid if he spoke too loud the moment might break.
“I know,” I whispered, tears slipping over my cheeks now, steady and silent, “I just…I needed you to know this isn’t about Babe Heffron in, Easy Company. This is you. You, Ed. You stayed.”
His eyes glossed over then, and I could see it—how the name undid him the same way his kindness had undone me.
His name.
Ed.
It wasn’t loud. It wasn’t dramatic. It was quiet—so quiet he almost thought he imagined it. But it hit him harder than any shell ever could.
Babe Heffron had been called a lot of things since joining the war—Heffron, Babe, Philly, soldier, even hero once or twice. But never Ed. Not here. Not in this mud-soaked hell where real names felt like a luxury, like something you left behind with your old life.
But when she said it—when she said it—it was like someone pulled the air straight from his lungs.
Because it wasn’t just a name. It was trust. It was her letting him see the raw part, the real part, the part no one else got close enough to touch.
He stared at her, throat tight, and for the first time in a long while, he felt like he might break.
She was crumbling right in front of him, and all he could think was how desperately he wanted to gather her up, keep her safe, wrap his arms around every cracked, bruised part and whisper, You’re not too much. Not for me.
The war had taken so much from him—friends, innocence, sleep, peace. But this? Her trust? Her saying his name like it meant something?
That was a gift he didn’t know how to carry.
But he would.
God, he would.
He didn’t kiss me. Not yet.
But he leaned in, resting his forehead gently against mine, eyes closed like he was anchoring himself to the sound of his own name in my mouth.
“I’m not going anywhere,” he whispered back, “Not now. Not ever, if you’ll let me stay.”
And in that war-torn silence, with the smoke curling around us and everything broken at our feet, I let him hold me.
And I let myself be held.