Ok, I'm just gonna come out and say it: making DEKU a villain is almost as fundamentally bad as making superman evil, yea, in-shit-stice? This is almost as bad as that, because your taking away quite literally everything that makes izuku midoryia, izuku midoryia. Inko? Gone. Katsuki? Gone. All-might, who is also at the very center of his soul, GONE.
Your retroactively changing what makes my hero academia itself. Just like how you have to take away every thing that makes superman, superman, in order for him to be believably evil: his love for humanity? Gone. His colours that make him an icon? Gone. Ma and Pa Kent? Gone. And finally; Lois, GONE.
This why injustice superman, is so disliked by the community because, the general populace thinks that " you either die a hero, or you live long enough to see yourself become the villain". This quote ,this very DAMNED quote, that has was said by a corruptable being, and been used by the entire internet, has been misconstrued, as "heroes don't stay good", and over and over and OVER again, comics wrighters have constantly proved it wrong, heroes, such as supes are the very definition of imperfect purity, and are quite literally the definition of a superhero, spiderman, captain america, the man himself who has been taken to hell and back, and walked right back himself, with a ironclad, unwavering will attached to his GODAMN chest, Batman, and now... DEKU, izuku midoryia, the symbol of peace, perseverance, and passion, the man with an ironclad will attached to his chest, reinforced by the love and care of everyone that he loves and holds dear to his soul, inko, katsuki, all might, 1-a.
He is the definition of a hero, and to take that away from him, to strip it from him, is to make an entirely new character, who only shares the same name, not the unwavering will, the boundless passion, the colors, the soul which could, if not be more warm, than the surface of the the sun.
He is the symbol of peace, of passion, of strength, and perseverance. He is DEKU
