Learning from the Masters
Read as much from those that you admire and learn from them.
This is a paraphrase I read somewhere. The article talked about how some famous writers in the 20th century had similar descriptions of their female protagonists. It wasn’t zeitgeist but a deliberate action by the fan-authors as tribute to the more famous author. Similar to celebrity fans. I don’t remember the authors mentioned but that got me thinking. Copying, someone said, is the best form of flattery. Many would disagree.
I grew up reading romance books among others. My first book was a Mills and Boon paperback lent to me by my Aunt who got annoyed when I kept bugging her to give me something to read. From Mills and Boon, I moved on to Harlequin before venturing to Sweet Valley High teen romance. Yeah, my romance reading books went backwards. I interspersed that with Stephen King, Robert Ludlum and John Grisham.
Since I was a voracious reader of romance books, I noticed similar themes among the books. Mills and Boon seemed to prefer openly hostile first meetings between the protagonists before they fall in live or the heroine gets pregnant and hides it from the hero or the heroine was the secretary/assistant/is of a lower station in society and the guy is this domineering boss/lord of the manor/millionaire (before billionaires became popular). The plots were so predictable, I needed to read Vale of the Vole by Piers Anthony and stumbled across the Book of Three by Lloyd Alexander to give my reading a bit of spice.
Years later, I realized these similarities were called tropes or hooks and writers use them because readers expect them. The most common tropes according to Tahra Seplowin (@calixofcoffe) in her article http://www.soyouthinkyoucanwrite.com/2015/06/plot-102-romance-tropes-fab-or-drab/ were: girl next door, virgin heroine, marriage of convenience, alpha male.
There were romance writers who were able to write original and compelling stories using those hooks. And there were those who simply wrote without originality. Rumors and accusation of plagiarism emerged, the one I was most surprised to find was the accusation that Janet Dailey plagiarized Nora Roberts . I was surprised because Janet Dailey was - is - popular in her own rights; however, this is an illustration that even great writers suffer from lack of inspiration.
With the rise of self-publishing and the ease with which readers and writers can download e-books, it has become relatively easy to just copy off from others. I don’t mean “be inspired by”, rather literal copying of someone’s work. Read about the Becky McGraw vs Laura Harner case.
In my case, I am inspired by the works of Kresley Cole, Larissa Ione, AW Exley, Ilona Andrews, Nalini Singh, specifically the romance fantasy series. As a first time novelist, I am dissecting their works and trying to figure out what makes their books engaging, exciting, and enjoyable. One commonality among these authors is their ability to make their characters relatable and memorable. Their protagonists and their supporting characters are not one-dimensional. They have their own voices and their own personalities. That’s what I’m trying to incorporate in my novel.
If only other writers would take the time to study the techniques of the Masters instead of just copying and passing off other writer’s work as theirs, there wouldn’t be plagiarism cases.