What I love about them:The sheer amount of development she’s had since her original appearance is delightful. Even by New Mutants she was getting more exploration and nuance, and her initial redemption arc in the nineties made perfect sense. Generation X had its flaws, but I deeply appreciate it for running with that and exploring her in new ways.
Then there’s Genosha, which compounds her traumatic guilt by like a thousand, and it was so poignant and fascinating to see her, well, not deal with that. I love how symbolic her diamond form is in that way.
Becoming a part of the core X-Men wasn’t simple or easy for her, which made it really interesting and satisfying. It was also really refreshing that becoming an Official Superhero didn’t make her any less sharp or arrogant or pragmatic. She makes a great foil to a lot of other X-Men, Jean and Charles most of all.
What I hate about them:Writers’ refusal to let her have positive relationships with other women, or to remember the development that was previously made.
Favorite Moment/Quote:I’ve got a two posts full of those so far, which makes it even harder to choose! But if I had to pick the quintessential Emma panel, I think it’s this one:
What I would like to see more focus on:Emma being a teacher. It’s such a huge part of her character, but we haven’t seen much of it for a long time.
What I would like to see less focus on:Scott. I enjoyed their relationship a lot, but it had a tendency to overwhelm her narrative. (And as a consequence her relationship with Jean was reduced to romantic jealousy.) Then after they broke up, well, she was written by Bendis.
I thought it could be really interesting to see Emma in a world without Scott, aaand then IVX happened. (From what I’ve seen she’s being written well again in Jean Grey, so...fingers crossed.)
Favorite pairing with: Jean! Frenemies always get me, along with opposites attracting. Rheir history is so intensely fraught and their feelings about each other are so complicated, and they have to potential to complement each other really well when they aren’t bring out the worse in each other.
Jean/Emma/Scott is also great.
Favorite friendship:Hank. They were so unexpectedly sweet in New X-Men.
I also enjoyed her dynamic with Erik in the eighties a lot, btu that was less of a friendship than a pragmatic partnership with wary respect.
Speaking of not-quite-friendships, Ororo. She has an even more bitter history with Emma than Jean, but seeing her come to trust Emma as a fellow X-Man in X-Treme X-Men felt earned. Ideally, their respect for each other is clear even though they don’t get along.
Then there’s Kitty. I have my issues with how Whedon wrote her in Astonishing, but her dynamic with Emma was so fascinating and poignant and I’m mad that later writers flattened it into petty sniping.
Favorite headcanon:She keeps every present her students have ever given her. Or she tries, at least.