What’s up, internet! Today I’m gonna tell you about a microphone shootout I did in Studio E at Capital University. I had my friend Brianna play my ukulele for me, plucking a melody and then strumming chords, so I can see which microphones sound best on each technique. Brianna is an awesome guitarist and musician who heads up Saltlick, is a member of Bexely Moms, and created/runs Blue Salt Records. Here is the Facebook page for Saltlick, the page for Bexely Moms, and the page for Blue Salt Records if you wanna check those out. Support local artists!
Now that I shamelessly plugged an amazing human being, let’s get down to business (to defeat the huns). After going through the microphone closet in studio E, I chose to compare the Shure KSM 44A, the Blue Kiwi, the Beyerdynamic M160, and the SM 7B. I chose the Blue Kiwi and the SM7B because I love using them for vocals (singing and podcast/voice over respectively), and I wanted to see if they were also as amazing on an acoustic string instruments like the ukulele. When it comes to the KSM 44A and the Beyer, my reasoning is that I don’t normally use those, so I wanted to see how they sounded. I have linked the names with their Sweetwater pages, which has videos and descriptions, as well as additional PDF’s that have polar patterns and frequency response charts and much much more.
The Shure KSM 44A is a large diaphragm condenser microphone with multiple polar patterns. For this project, all microphones with multiple patterns were set to cardioid. It’s known to be one of Shure’s most versatile microphones. The Blue Kiwi is another condenser microphone with multiple polar patterns, and it is described as an excellent microphone for any sound source due to its wide frequency range and pure signal path. The Beyerdynamic M160 is a hypercardioid ribbon microphone that is described to be wonderful for a wide range of acoustic string instruments. The SM7B is the go-to microphone for radio broadcasters, singers, voice-overs, and anything vocal related, as it is dynamic cardioid microphone.
Here is the link to the playlist I put on Soundcloud (because I have no idea how embed the Soundcloud playlist onto a tumblr blog post):
https://soundcloud.com/user-777219964/sets/capital-university-studio-e-microphone-shootout
The Shure KSM 44A picked up the plucked melody very well, as well as the transients for strumming. I got more of the mid-range of the ukulele, the upper range was lost a little bit during the strumming pattern. The Blue Kiwi, in comparison, gave me a brighter upper range in the strummed chords, but a little more body in the plucked melody. The Beyerdynamic picked up the most even distribution of transients and tone color, I felt as though the frequency spectrum was well captured. The SM7B I felt had the warmest tone, and possibly the muddier transients of the set of four (though not in a super bad way, just in comparison to the other microphones.) This is pretty consistent with each respective frequency response and descriptions of best uses, especially because the SM7B is more applicable for human voices than the delicacy of a string instrument.
Based on my research and our shootout, I would probably make my first pick be the Beyerdynamic, followed by the Blue Kiwi, then the Shure KSM 44A, and then the SM7B. I liked how the Beyer was very versatile with different playing techniques and how well it captured the authenticity of the sound. This is the most important reason why I ranked it first, it gives me the most authentic sound. I liked how the Blue Kiwi specifically sounded when Brianna played the plucked melody, the warm tone was very nice, and I also liked how the high end was brought out a little more during the strumming, which is why I ranked it second. If I have a want for a warm melody sound but a higher-resonating strum pattern, I know I’d get it right away with that microphone. I put the Shure next because the lighter tone of the plucked melody was captured very well, but the balance of the strum frequencies was flipped from the Kiwi, which causes me to rank it third. Last I would say is the SM7B. I suspected it might not be a great microphone for the job, but you never know for sure until you try it. That’s not to say I think it’s terrible. I don’t, and in fact, I think if it was all you had, it would work in a pinch and if you used some creative EQ, it would sound amazing. I would also like to say that this list is not to trash any of the microphones, I love all of them, but I’m ranking them based on overall usefulness in my opinion.
Anyways, that’s enough rambling from me. Check out these photos! In order: the KSM 44A, the Blue Kiwi, the Beyerdynamic, and the SM7B