Gay cuckold story from Reddit
It started innocently enough: a craigslist couple looking for a third. The Top is 28, 5'10", 150 with a 7" dick. The bottom is 26, 5'7", 135, and smooth. Both white dudes. I respond back: 31, 6 foot, 165, athletic with a 8" dick. Scruffy, and looking for now. After a few messages and an exchanging of pics, I show up to their house. They offer a drink and want to get comfortable; I just want to fuck but why not. They’ve been together for the last three years, and have just started opening up; they only look for Tops, and always play safe.
Halfway through my beer, I’m getting bored with the small talk, so I start feeling up the Top, and go in for a kiss. This disarms them, I find…I’m about to fuck a Top’s man, and including him at the beginning always seems to make it go better. We start making out, and I can feel the bottom going for my fly. Within seconds, he has my cock out and is sucking it, while he is fumbling with his boyfriend’s pants to get to his cock too. I pinch the Top’s right nipple while making out, and hear him moan through my mouth, still ignoring the bottom boy as he is now going back and forth between sucking my dick and sucking his partners.
After a few minutes, I stand up, take off the remainder of my clothes, kiss the bottom, and bend him over the couch. I feel his ass: perky with a light dusting of hair. I rub my finger down his crack and onto his rosebud, and he jumps. I kiss the Top again, smile, and start rimming the bottom, pulling the Top’s face in and dueling our tongues over his hole. I put the top on rimming duty as I go around to the front and have the bottom suck me: he’s real good. Cute, innocent face with slightly shaggy blonde hair, light layer of scruff, right amount of suction. I see the Top lubing up his ass, and I go to the back. The Top breaks out a condom, puts it on me, and guides my dick in. I go slowly, and the Top just sits back on the couch and watches me fuck his boyfriend.
I assume we’re going to trade off, but the Top is just content sitting there. I motion him over to kiss me, and he says he just wants to watch. Okay–one of these–not a problem. I flip his boyfriend over so he is facing me as I fuck him missionary. It’s a standard fuck: a good ten minutes or so with good chemistry and lots of making out. As I’m getting close I ask him where he wants me to cum, and he whispers that his boyfriend likes watching it, so on his chest. I pull out, rip the condom off, and shoot on his chest. The Top cums when he seems me shoot, and jerks his load out over his body, which then sets off the bottom.
We all get cleaned up, I turn down another drink, and I head out.
A couple days later, the bottom sends me a text saying they want a repeat. I text back that I am a bit confused by what happened, and that normally threesomes involve more contact between the parties instead of one watching. He confides that his boyfriend is getting into being a cuckold, and gets off on watching him get fucked by “real men”. This is interesting–I start googling. Dan Savage has a recent article that gay cuckolding seems to have started a couple of years ago (right around when gay marriage started), and has picked up all the terms and behavoirs of straight cuckolding. Cool–so it’s not about the other top; he wants to see his boy get used by a real man. I always aim to please.
I start texting the bottom to find out what he is into, and the bottom likes dominant guys that use him. He likes throat fucking and hard fucks. While I would normally never abuse a guy like that with his boyfriend watching, if the Top is into this, I’m always game. I ask him where he likes cum. He takes a few minutes to respond, and then says that he loves cum in him. He corrects himself, and says that he likes cum in his mouth. I press, and he admit that he loves being bred, but his boyfriend would never let him get barebacked and that they always play safe.
We set up another meet-up for that Thursday night. I tell the bottom not to tell his Top that he told me all this.
I show up to their house at 8, and the Bottom offers to grab all three of us drinks. I kiss the bottom, hard, and look at the Top.
“Go get me and your boyfriend a beer.”
The Top seems confused as last time I was focused on him, but turns and goes to the kitchen. I take the Bottom’s shirt off, whispers in his ear that we’re going to put on a show for his Top tonight, and start making out with him. The boyfriend comes back from the kitchen, and stops when he sees the two of us making out intimately. I look over, tell him to bring my beer. I push his boyfriend down to his knees, and his boyfriend gets the hint and immediately unzips my jeans to get to my cock.
I grab it from him, and take a few swigs. The Top tries to kiss me, and I stop him, and instead push his bottom’s face on my dick so he starts gagging. I hand the Top my half-empty beer, and tell him to go sit on the couch and watch a real man please his boyfriend. I can see his face get read in a combination of shame and lust, and he does what he is told and goes and sits down. I face fuck his boyfriend for awhile, taking my dick out periodically and slapping it on his face. The bottom keeps looking up with his scruffy blonde hair and innocent green eyes.
I look over at the Top periodically to see how he is responding: it’s one thing to watch porn and fantasize and it’s another to watch the person you love participate in it. He has a face full of lust, and is solely focused on my dick. He has his cock out and is jerking himself. I tell him to stop. He does.
I stop the bottom, and pull my jeans completely off. I pull the dude up to his feet, and make out with him. Even though I just have an inch in dick size on his boyfriend, I start to whisper loudly in his ear while pulling him close to me so his top can hear, “your man doesn’t fill you up, does he? You need a real guy to fuck you with a real dick, instead of his small, pathetic one.”
I look over on the couch, where the Top is pinching his nipples with a rock hard erection. I can tell he is getting flustered: I don’t think anyone has ever talked to his boyfriend like this.
I put the Bottom on all fours, and get down behind him and dig my face into his ass. He can feel my scruff caressing the inside of his cheeks, with my tongue finding his hole repeatedly. He is moaning loudly, and I talk directly to him.
“You like that, don’t you? Your boyfriend doesn’t treat your ass like it should. You need a real guy to fuck you and give you pleasure.”
After a few minutes, I look over at the Top on the couch, and tell him to get the lube and come over. He grabs the lube and a couple of condoms. The top reaches for my chest, and I pull away:
“Lube up your boy’s ass. He needs a real man to fuck him.”
Still on all fours, the bottom gets lubed up from his boyfriend, whose cock I don’t think can get harder. I lift the bottom to just on his knees, and while looking down on him I make out with him.
“Get on your back on the floor. I’m going to fuck you here on the rug.”
His boyfriend is fumbling with opening the condom as I lift the bottom’s legs.
“Lube up my dick,” I tell the Top.
“But….” he stammers. “We only play safe with other guys.”
I just look the Top up and down. I can see him thinking, and watch his dick get even harder. With a bright red face, he breathlessly lubes up the head of my dick. I see the Top look at his boyfriend, and see his boyfriend nodding.
“Just stick the tip in. Then you need a condom.”
I look over at the Top, and make eye contact.
I see him blush even harder, and he lubes up my entire dick. I look down at his bottom, who is on his back leaking copious amounts of pre-cum, and stick my raw dick against his hole. I pull his legs up farther against me, and I slide the tip in. The bottom starts to moan, and is looking over at the Top to make sure it is okay. I look too, and see the Top nodding his head.
I tell the Top to get on all fours, and to watch as my dick goes in and out of his boy’s hole. He does. I go back to the bottom and start to making out with him, stopping periodically to check in.
“You like this dick in you? You like what it likes to have a real man in your ass, instead of that small cock that your boyfriend has? I bet he can’t even get it up to fuck you right, can he?”
The bottom just moans. The top goes to touch his own dick, and I tell him to stop: I know that if he cums this is going to be over.
“Get back on the couch and watch me fuck your boyfriend.”
His face gets red again, but he does. He sits there rockhard and watches.
I fuck his boyfriend. Missionary. Doggy. On his side. Bent over the couch armrest. I always position his boy so the Top can see my raw dick going in and out, and I can see the pre-cum flowing directly out of his dick and onto him. I’m getting close.
“I’m getting close. I’m on prep, clean, and just got tested. Where is my cum going?”
The top blushes again. He stammers.
I look down at the bottom, who looks back up at me as he is getting plowed while bent over the armrest.
“Do it.” He says. “Breed me.”
I’ve pushed this couple far enough tonight that I know they are going to have awkward conversations tomorrow. It’s enough for me to know that they both have gone far over what they thought they would be comfortable with. I pull out.
“Get on your knees.” I tell the bottom.
I open his mouth with my left hand as I jerk off with my right, and put a giant load in his mouth. He looks up at me, a cute face with innocent green eyes, and I can see my cum coating his tongue and all over his scruff.
I look over at his Top, and rotate the bottom’s face so the Top can see the cum all over him. He is jerking off rapidly.
“Next time this load is in your boy’s ass.”
I grab a towel, wipe my dick off, get dressed, and leave.
