Whatâs Mine â.Ë PART 1
Pairing: Spencer Reid x fem!BAUreader
Description: You fall for Spencer Reid slowly, quietly, and all at once. Then prison takes him away. When he comes back, so do all the questions you never stopped asking.
Gener: Angst/Hurt-Comfort/Slow burn
Warnings: Angst, hurt/comfort, prison/incarceration themes, emotional distress, miscommunication/emotional misunderstanding, slow burn/unresolved romantic tension
A/N: NEW SERIES đ€ Expect angst and smut in future parts đ
The first time I heard Spencer Reid speak, I knew I was in trouble. It wasnât the content - a rapid-fire dissertation on the statistical improbability of the crime pattern we were reviewing - but the delivery. The cadence of his voice, the way his mind seemed to operate on a plane just above everyone elseâs, yet he was trying so earnestly to bring us along. I joined the BAU a year before his arrest, a fresh-faced 27-year-old trying to prove I belonged among these legends. He was 36, a genius, a veteran. The age gap felt like a canyon. But within five months, listening to his rambles about Fibonacci sequences in art history or the chemical composition of tears, I realized the canyon wasnât about age or intellect. It was about the terrifying, quiet realization that I was falling for him.
The year before his arrest was a blur of learning and longing. I got used to him. Used to the way heâd hover by my desk when he had a new fact to share, used to the slight, shy smile heâd offer when I asked a question that genuinely intrigued him. We saw eye to eye on cases, on analyses. There was a silent understanding, a rhythm. I thought, maybe, given enough time, that rhythm could become something more.
Then the world shattered.
His arrest wasnât just a professional shock; it was a personal earthquake. Watching him being handcuffed, his face pale and confused, felt like a violation of every natural law I believed in. The team mobilized. Emily became a force of nature, her phone permanently attached to her ear, her eyes burning with a furious determination to prove his innocence. JJâs worry was a constant, palpable presence - sheâd stare at empty chairs during briefings, her mind clearly in that detention center. Rossi carried a heavier silence, his paternal concern manifesting in relentless background checks and legal consultations. Garciaâs brightness dimmed, replaced by a frantic, digital sleuthing. Matt and Luke, the newer additions like me, worked with a grim, focused energy, trying to hold the unit together.
But my feeling was a private, consuming storm. I performed my duties. I analyzed profiles, went on raids, wrote reports. But at night, in hotel rooms on cases or in my own apartment, the storm broke. Iâd lie in bed, the darkness pressing down, and cry. Not just tears of sympathy or professional outrage, but tears of a specific, aching fear. What was happening to him in there? Was he scared? Was he cold? Was anyone hurting him? The image of Spencer - my Spencer, with his books and his kindness and his awkward brilliance - in a prison cell was a cognitive dissonance that ripped at my sanity.
The sentence announcement was a collective blow. We stood in the court room, the news echoing through the room. A stunned silence, then a surge of disbelief. Emilyâs jaw tightened so hard I thought it might crack. JJ turned away, a hand over her mouth. Rossi muttered a curse in Italian. But inside me, something fractured. It felt physical, a sharp pain behind my ribs. The formal, legal confirmation of his imprisonment made the nightmare real and permanent.
Garcia, in her infinite, loving wisdom, created a visitation schedule. For one and a half months, it was my anchor. Every scheduled visit was a beacon. Preparing for it was a ritual: choosing clothes that were professional but not intimidating, rehearsing things to talk about - case developments, new books, harmless team gossip. Seeing him was both a relief and a new kind of pain. He was thinner. Paler. A haunted shadow lingered in his eyes, though he tried to hide it with facts and forced smiles. Our conversations were careful, dancing around the horror of his reality. Iâd leave each visit with a renewed determination and a heavier heart.
Then, without warning, the anchor was ripped away.
Emily approached me in the hallway one afternoon, her expression unreadable. âHe took you off the list,â she said, her voice flat.
I stared at her. âWhat? Why?â
âI donât know,â Emily replied, and the genuine confusion in her eyes was worse than any bad news.Â
Emily Prentiss usually knew everything. âI asked. He just said it was his decision. He didnât explain.â
The confusion curdled into a hot, sickening hurt. âHe didnât⊠he didnât say anything to me? No message?â
âNo. Just the instruction to the facility.â
I walked away, my vision blurring. It felt like a betrayal. Not just a professional snub, but a deep, personal rejection. We had always seen eye to eye. We had a connection, a trust. Had I misread it all? Did he see me as just another colleague, one so disposable he could cut me off without a word? The questions tormented me. Does he not like me? Does he not want me on the team? The heartbreak was quiet and constant, a dull ache that throbbed behind every work task, every empty chair in the briefing room.
1,5 months later, he was released. The celebration was muted but profound. We got the call, and a collective breath, held for so long, was finally exhaled. But he didnât come back. Emily wisely begged him to take time, to decompress, to relearn the feeling of freedom. I understood, but the absence now felt different. He was out, but he wasnât here. And the silence between us - the unanswered question of the visitation list - hung in that absence, unresolved.
Life at the BAU resumed its brutal, demanding rhythm. Cases came and went. We saved lives, we lost some. The machine functioned, but with a ghost limb.
Then, on a Wednesday morning, everything changed.
The bullpen was buzzing with the usual pre-case energy. Matt and Luke were discussing a sports game. Rossi was sipping his coffee, reading a file. JJ and Garcia were sharing a quiet laugh.Â
Around an hour into the new workday, I was the last to enter the briefing room, carrying a fresh stack of case preliminaries from my desk. As I looked up to find my seat, my heart performed a skipping beat.Â
Spencer Reid. Standing near Emily, being enveloped in a hug by JJ. Garcia was next, squeezing him tightly, tears in her eyes. Rossi gave him a firm, heartfelt pat on the back. Matt and Luke offered warm, welcoming smiles.
He looked⊠like Spencer. Not the pale, haunted version from the visits, but our Spencer. He was dressed in dark gray trousers and a pink shirt - a color so unexpectedly soft it made my throat tighten. His hair was neat, his posture straight, though a new wariness lived in the set of his shoulders.
His eyes found me across the room. He gave me a small, tentative smile. Then he calmly walked over, navigating the space between us as if crossing a bridge heâd long studied.
âHi,â he said, his voice a familiar, gentle sound Iâd missed so desperately.
âHi,â I managed, my own voice thin.
We hugged. It was brief, professional, but the contact was electric. I felt the solidity of his frame, the warmth through his shirt. âWelcome back,â I whispered into the space near his ear.
âThank you,â he murmured back.
The team settled into their chairs. I took my usual seat, but my focus was shattered. I kept sneaking glances at him. He was listening to Emily, nodding occasionally. The pink shirt against his skin, the way his hands rested on the table - they were details I drank in greedily. He was just as handsome as always, but the handsomeness was now layered with a harder, more complex texture. Prison had changed him, but it hadnât broken the core. That core was still brilliantly, attractively there.
Emily began the briefing formally. âFirst, itâs my great pleasure to officially welcome Dr. Spencer Reid back to the BAU.â A round of genuine, warm applause echoed in the room. Spencer ducked his head slightly, a humble gesture. âAs part of his reintegration,â Emily continued, âthere will be a modified schedule. For every hundred days in the field, Spencer will take a mandatory thirty-day leave. This is non-negotiable, for his well-being and the teamâs long-term health.â
Spencer nodded. âI understand. And while I wish I could come back at one hundred percent capacity immediately, Iâm⊠Iâm really happy to be here. Thank you, all of you, for everything.â
His gratitude was sincere, heavy. We all felt its weight.
Then Emily pivoted. âNow, we have a new case. A series of abductions in Cleveland, Ohio. The pattern suggests a highly organized, ritualistic offender.â She distributed files. I took mine, my eyes scanning the text, but my mind was only half-present. The other half was anchored to the man in the pink shirt across the table.
The briefing concluded with logistics. Wheels up in forty minutes. We all stood, the room filling with the movement of bodies gathering files, tablets, and gear.
I needed a moment. The emotional whiplash of seeing him, the residual hurt from the visitation list, the sheer intensity of his presence - it all coalesced into a need for a few seconds of solitude. I headed for the bathroom down the hall.
I was almost at the door when a hand closed gently but firmly around my arm.
I turned, and it was Spencer.
Without a word, he guided me, not with force but with undeniable intent, away from the bathroom and toward a forgotten side corridor. He pushed open a door Iâd rarely noticed - an old, empty office used for storage years ago, now largely ignored by everyone.
He pulled me inside and closed the door. The room was dim, lit only by the daylight filtering through a dusty window. Boxes were stacked against one wall. The air was still and cool.
I was stunned. âSpencer, what are you doing? We have to get to the plane.â
He stood before me, his expression serious, his eyes intense. âHow have you been holding up?â he asked, his voice low.
Something in me, something that had been simmering for months - the worry, the fear, the heartbreak, the confusion - bubbled up violently. The calm professionalism Iâd maintained shattered.
âHow have I been holding up?â I echoed, my tone sharp. âIâve been working. Iâve been analyzing crime scenes. Iâve been trying not to think about you in a cell every night. Iâve been fine, Reid. Just fine.â
He opened his mouth to respond, but I didnât let him.
âAnd then,â I continued, the words rushing out like a flood, âall of a sudden you take me off the visitation list? Like, seriously, Reid? Iâve known you for way more than a year now. How the fuck do you think that feels for me? Not being able to visit you in there? Knowing you were suffering? And then I had to hear it from Emily? I didnât even get an explanation? It makes me feel like you donât like me. Like you donât want me as a colleague. Like you donât even want me on the team!â
I was breathing heavily, my hands clenched at my sides. The confession of my deeper fear - that his action meant he rejected my very presence - hung in the dusty air.
Spencer stared at me. His eyes, usually so bright with intelligence, were dark, clouded with something I couldnât name. He didnât look angry. He looked⊠hurt.
âOh,â he said slowly, his voice a low rasp. âYou want to know why I suddenly took you off the list?â
The irritation in my voice was pure, unfiltered. âGo on, Reid. Tell me.â
He took a deep breath, as if steeling himself. âI didnât want you to see me like that,â he began, each word deliberate. âNot in there. Not⊠diminished. Not suffering. Every time you visited, I saw the look in your eyes. The pity. The worry. It was⊠it was a mirror of my own degradation, and I couldnât stand you holding that mirror.â
He stepped closer, his breathing becoming heavier, his voice growing more raspy. âAnd I didnât want⊠the other inmates⊠looking at you.â A muscle in his jaw tightened. âYou walk in there, and youâre⊠youâre light. Youâre life. Youâre everything that place isnât. They look at women who come in, and they donât see colleagues or friends. They see⊠objects. Possibilities. I didnât want their eyes on you. I didnât want you to be a kind of meat in their world.â
I shook my head, the anger still fueling me. âIt wouldnât be my first time in a prison, Spencer. Iâve been to dozens for interviews, for transfers. I can handle inmatesâ stares. I have handled them.â
I stared right into his eyes, challenging him.
His response was not verbal at first. He took two long, sudden steps towards me. The movement was so swift and purposeful that I instinctively backed up until my shoulders met the cold wall of the old office. He raised his hand, not to touch me, but to place it flat against the wall beside my head, caging me in his space. He leaned in, his body close, his gaze locking onto mine from a mere foot away.
He was breathing heavily, the air from his lungs warm against my face. Then he leaned in even closer, his voice dropping to a whisper so low it was almost a vibration. âOh, I know you can handle that,â he whispered. âI know youâre capable. But if I had caught them staring at you⊠with want in their eyesâŠâ He paused, his dark eyes burning. âI wouldnât have held back.â
My heart was hammering against my ribs. The proximity, the intensity, the raw confession in his words - it was overwhelming. I tilted my head up further, resting it back against the wall, squinting my eyes as I stared up at him. The challenge remained in my voice, but it was now mixed with a desperate curiosity. âWhy? Youâve seen inmates stare before, Reid. At JJ, at Emily, at Garcia when she visits. Why wouldnât you hold back now?â
He leaned in closer still. His lips were near my ear now, his whisper so low it felt like a secret being etched into my soul. âBecause, darling,â he breathed, the word âdarlingâ hitting me with a force that stole my breath. âPrison changes a man. It strips away the⊠the civilized layers. It exposes the raw core. And in that raw core, I found something I didnât know was so possessive, so violent.â
He pulled back just enough to look directly into my eyes again, his own gaze blazing with a fierce, unprotected truth. âI wouldnât have held back,â he repeated, âbecause I donât want them looking at whatâs mine.â
The words hung in the silent, dusty room.
They werenât a question. They werenât a speculation. They were a declaration, forged in the darkness of his incarceration, brought into the light now against this wall.
All the anger, the hurt, the confusion - it melted, not into nothing, but into a new, terrifying, exhilarating understanding. The removal from the list wasnât rejection. It was a brutal, flawed, desperate form of protection. A protection born from a feeling he hadnât named before, a feeling that prison had crystallized into a stark, possessive certainty.
I stared at him, my mouth slightly open, no words forming.
He watched me process it. The fierce intensity in his eyes softened slightly, replaced by a vulnerable uncertainty. He had laid something bare that he could not retract.
The sound of distant voices and footsteps in the hall broke the spell. The team was mobilizing for the plane.
Spencer slowly lowered his hand from the wall. He didnât step back, but his posture relaxed a fraction. âWe have to go,â he said quietly, his voice now just its normal, gentle rasp.
I nodded, still speechless.
He turned and opened the door, allowing the brighter light from the hallway to flood in. He looked back at me, waiting.
I moved, my legs feeling unsteady. I walked past him into the hall, and we joined the flow of our team heading towards the elevator and the waiting jet.