I think I'm hate-watching The Newsroom at this point
I never watched The West Wing, I've only seen Aaron Sorkin's movies. I didn't consider myself a Sorkin hater or lover. After the series premiere of The Newsroom, I quickly learned that people really fall into one of these camps. I thought that the pilot was kind of decent though. A bit cheesy and I was surprised to see that they used a real-life event on which to report but whatever, that was fine with me. I wanted to see how the Maggie/Don/Jim love triangle worked out. I thought Jeff Daniels, as grating as his character is, was doing a fantastic acting job. I wasn't super highly vested in how his relationship with Mackenzie would play out, but enough to keep watching the show to see what happens.
There have been five episodes so far. I'm now completely irritated by Sorkin using hind-sight to "properly" report on the news. It's so arrogant - but so blatantly easy and obvious to do so. I get nothing out of the show. I'm not really learning how news is made because it's all too perfect on this show. They fail to show the "surprise" of any big news events because it's all perfectly reported on within 15 minutes. Aaron Sorkin is barely even creating tension to get me nervous about how things will play out regarding how they're going to make important decisions on reporting. I don't feel like I'm going back in time to the moment when the public didn't know what was going to happen (or what had just happened). Then again, the news they're focusing on in episode 5 is up to only a year and a half old. That's just too soon I think.
Alec Nevala-Lee at Salon.com stated this well, comparing it to how Matthew Weiner writes Mad Men:
And we can find sophisticated examples of historical irony even on television. “Mad Men” isn’t entirely above the kind of cute, winking effect we often see elsewhere, as when a character dismisses a politician named Romney as “a clown,” but at its best, it gives us plausible people dealing with history in real time, and it generates authentic suspense from our knowledge of what lies ahead, as when we’re shown the invitation for a wedding scheduled for Nov. 23, 1963. When characters display cultural foresight, it’s usually by accident: Paul Kinsey dates a young black woman mostly to delight in how progressive he is, and he signs up voters in Mississippi to score points with his girlfriend, who dumps him after three days.
As for the Maggie/Don/Jim love triangle, it's going nowhere. I barely believe she has intense feelings for Jim (which I think we're supposed to think?). Everything seems to be going rather peachy with Don right now, so where's the tension in that? Oh, and Lisa barging into the newsroom to yell at Jim for standing her up on Valentine's Day?? Excuse me but really? There's something called security in every building and you can't get up there unannounced - and also, who would be so crazy as to yell at a guy in front of all his colleagues when you've only gone out four times? It's just so lame.
At this point, the only drama I actually am now into is what I didn't care about at all in the series premiere - that is Will McAvoy and Mackenzie MacHale getting together. Sorkin is doing such a crappy job of creating tension and drama overall though so I feel like he may just get them together within an episode or two and leave us feeling "satisfied" with that resolution way too soon. That's the problem with this whole show...everything is resolved way too quickly. Even Will's dating antics and being fodder for tabloid headlines. He doesn't even care about it anymore. Weren't we supposed to worry about his reputation for a while? That lasted one, maybe two, episodes at best.
I read somewhere, whether reliable or not I don't know, that Sorkin is already writing an episode about the tragic shooting in Aurora, Colorado. It nauseates me to no end that he's going to now research for a year, let the police and authorities do all the work and get all the answers and then showcase an episode where Will gets it all right ahead of all the other news networks. It's just too easy - where's the challenge in that?
All this being said, I keep watching. I know I'm going to at least finish out the season. If I really hated it so much, I'd stop watching (like I had to stop watching The Killing after the horrific first season finale. I could only get so far as one episode into season two). I guess I'll just continue to be irritated. I must get some joy out of it. Slate Culture Gabfest recently did a podcast on the culture of "hate-watching" on May 9, 2012 actually. It was interesting...check it out:
http://www.slate.com/articles/podcasts/culturegabfest/2012/05/maurice_sendak_art_market_economics_with_felix_salmon_and_the_phenomenon_of_hate_watching_on_slate_s_culture_gabfest.html