2017 Honorable Mentions
Hereâs a bunch of records I liked a whole heckuva lot, but didnât love. In alphabetical order.
Blaenavon-Thatâs Your Lot Like a mixture of a sad Hippo Campus and late-2000â˛s british guitar bands. Thereâs a lot of potential here, but they havenât learned how to edit themselves yet as thereâs a good 15 minutes that could be done away with here. Still, a very promising debut.
Converge-The Dusk in Us Not a whole lot of heavy bands are worth your time these days. Converge is one of them.
Father John Misty-Pure Comedy Perhaps the schtick is going a bit too far now. He hit the happy medium on 2015â˛s I Love You, Honeybear, but now thereâs about a third of a record that veers dangerously close to unintentional self-parody.
Hippo Campus-Landmark Really solid full-length debut from Minnesotaâs favorite boy band, but it drags a bit in the mid-section. Fortunately, they understand the art of sequencing and start and end strong.
Homeless Gospel Choir-Presents: Normal A loose concept album about that pesky thing called âgrowing up.â The songs are great but suffer from the production pathology that afflicts so many solo punks: cheap sounding full band arrangements. Having seen the dude live, heâd be better off leaving the songs to his guitar and voice alone.
Japandroids-Near to the Wild Heart of Life There are some great singles here, but also some pretty horrific duds, not least of which includes the onanistic 8-minute centerpiece âArc of Bar.â When your album is only 8 songs, you canât really afford any hiccups. Not bad, but easily the least good release of their career.
Joan of Arc-Heâs Got the Whole This Land is Your Land in His Hands Latest from the Kinsella sibling whoâs not in American Football. One of the choruses is âI know how the nicest guy in ISIS feels.â Alrighty.
Kesha-Rainbow âPrayingâ is a great single, and the rest of the album is fun enough for the most part, but Kesha has no identity of her own on this project. This doesnât play like eclectic genre-experimentation in pursuit of a coherent whole, but rather, it seems like someone low on ideas throwing everything against the wall to see what sticks. The production is also dreadful with clipping throughout and absolutely no sense of dynamics or subtlety. Kesha had a great chance to define a moment here, but it seems like circumstances have ended up defining her. Bummer. We were all rooting for her.
LCD Soundsystem-American Dream Same deal as Japandroids. Not bad, but easily their weakest work to date.
Lil Peep-Come Over When Youâre Sober Pt. 1 On its own merits this record doesnât totally live up to the hype, but it functions as an unfortunate reminder of what he might have accomplished had his time on earth been longer. Lil Peep was on to something genuinely innovative, and frankly, was the only buzzy soundcloud rapper worth a fuck.Â
The Menzingers-After the Party Are you noticing a theme yet? Brilliant singles. âTellin Lies,â âMidwestern States,â âBad Catholics,â the title track, all bangers. Too bad every other song sounds like an early draft of the others. Again, shouldâve been an EP.
Mountain Goats-Goths A guitar-less ode to the cool parts of the 80â˛s. Just too many god-dang filler tracks. That said, I need to need to crank Siouxsie in LA on a 90F+ day before I die. If you have have an interest in gothy new wave bands that arenât named The Smiths or The Cure, this is required listening.
Propagandhi-Victory Lap Still the only political punk band that matters. Ok, thatâs a lie, but this record was worth the wait. Canadaâs finest continue to push themselves with every release, and this one might be the closest to an accessible radio rock album theyâve ever made. Fortunately, thereâs no coinciding loss of verve.
Q-Pup-Ancient Agriculture and What it Means Quite possibly the most fussed-over local release of the last year, this is clearly the work of a perfectionist. Literate and labyrinthine without descending into pretension, it drastically improves upon the template laid out by Q-Pupâs closest sonic forebear, Neutral Milk Hotel.
Rostam-Half-Light Hot take: Better than the last Vampire Weekend album. Hot take: Rostam was the talent and the new VW album is gonna blow.
Shout Out Louds-Ease My Mind It smells like 2007 in here and thatâs a good thing. Indie-pop was perfected on Our Ill Wills and Shout Out Louds are smart enough not to mess with a winning formula.
Slowdive-S/T Hot take: Itâs better than Souvlaki.
Thurston Moore-Rock ân Roll Consciousness It sounds like Sonic Youth, but listening to this shows that they were filthy hippies the whole time. They just couldnât play the blues.
U2-Songs of Experience Iâm a scene dad, so I should probably like some dad rock. U2 have kept pushing themselves their entire career, and this is no exception. Whether or not they succeeded is up for debate.
Vagabon-Infinite Worlds A completely unnecessary and incongruous 6-minute interlude kills all the momentum on this already brief slab of 2000â˛s indie revivalism. A 25-minute album canât afford to give up 20% of its runtime to filler. Just release 20 minutes of perfection instead.
Weezer-Pacific Daydream Stop whining that it isnât Pinkerton. Weezer is a pop band, and always wanted to be. Put on some shades and have fun or go cry to Modern Baseball.










