Cherry
Pairing: dad’s archnemesis!Jack Abbot x Reader
Summary: Fucking your dad’s biggest enemy has consequences, whether you want to admit it or not.
Warnings: 18+. EVERYONE SHUT UP I HAVE AN ERECTION. Protected-turned-unprotected p-in-v (with consent). Sex on the hood of your father’s ‘75 Aston Martin V8. Improper disposal of a condom. Creampie. C*mplay.
Note: I’m on Instagram now (kinda), come say hi :-)
Word count: 2.2k
And the Worst Daughter of the Year Award goes to…
“You,” with gritted teeth, you bit out, “motherfucker.”
It was almost annoying how good Jack Abbot was.
More infuriating was the fact that he was your father’s sworn enemy, and somehow, you’d let him slide nine inches inside you today, the day before, and the day before that—going all the way back to last Halloween.
No more than two or three weeks ever passed where you weren’t sucking, fucking, or tonguing the sick bastard, and when you did, he always gave you rounds.
Occasionally, you felt a pang of remorse.
After all, you were your father’s favorite kid.
But that didn’t change the fact that you had needs, and Jack was an easy target; he’d been living next door to your family the last several years, and for as long as you could remember, you’d had a crush on the man. You just could never act on it until now, when you were already out of college, no longer living at home, and almost wholly free of the…dicier ethical considerations.
Was it wrong? Absolutely.
Were you often in the habit of thinking about that when Jack had you bent over a table and was hammering you senselessly, in secret? Hell no.
“Oh, fuckfuckfuckfuckfuck,” you whimpered in a low, broken refrain. You clamped your legs tighter together.
And behind you, probably grinning from ear-to-ear, Jack squeezed your hips in either hand and chuckled.
Then, shortly, he ordered, “Get up. Now.”
The orgasm that had been growing and coiling and swelling inside you for the last five minutes—and what had very nearly come to fruition a moment ago—was stolen from you just as fast. Jack pulled out, and he turned from the old, rickety table he’d just been plowing you on. He strode in the other direction.
You were holed up in your garage. Fifteen minutes ago, you’d told your mom you would go and grab the cake—your dad’s birthday cake, for his 50th celebration. About five minutes after that, Jack had announced he was going to get more refreshments for the party.
This was meant to be a mid-event quickie, and now your neighbor was walking over to one of your family’s cars. Patting the hood affectionately and beckoning.
“No fucking shot, Abbot.” You shook your head, resolute. “We are not fucking anywhere close to that.”
The man must’ve had scrambled eggs for brains if he thought you’d even consider having sex on your dad’s 1975 Aston Martin V8. The thing was a classic in mint condition and your father’s prized possession. His baby. Frankly, aside from your mother and your siblings and you, that vehicle was his pride and joy. If someone so much as breathed too hard next to it, he’d have a meltdown. And that wasn’t an exaggeration.
Now Jack was stroking the hood underneath his palm.
Inwardly, you winced and wished you made better decisions in life. Maybe, someday soon, you would.
But that day was not today, apparently.
“Get your cute ass over here, sweetheart.”
Like clockwork, you took your cute ass over there. You only grimaced twice when your backside hit the bright, unblemished, blindingly cherry-red surface of the car and when Jack dragged you by your legs to the edge.
You spread yourself wide, let him flip the hem of your gingham dress over your hips, and shit—he felt good.
Twice as nice as when he was hitting it from the back. Now, gliding in until the firm, round globes of his balls kissed your rear, and the thatch of mostly gray hairs at the base of him tickled your skin, he felt like a dream.
Jack knew it.
He communicated as much when he planted a hand beside your hip on the hood of the car and started thrusting relentlessly. When he plunged in so deep the tip of his cock hit your cervix and you couldn’t keep a loud, shuddering cry from slipping out between your lips and he leaned in and kissed you, mouth smiling.
Between the breakneck speed of his thrusts and the wet, sloppy kissing, the man somehow managed it:
“Whose pussy is this?”
At first, you pretended not to hear him.
The arrogant prick already had an ego the size of Alaska and didn’t need any further encouragement. Plus, you were about to come, and you needed this.
So you let your head loll back a little, and you stopped kissing. You closed your eyes. Rolled your lower half furiously, feverishly in time with each maddening stroke, and you grabbed Jack’s shoulder for leverage.
In return, you felt him grip your chin abruptly.
He tilted up, forcing you to snap your gaze back open.
Your ankles had just crossed behind his back. He was canting his hips even harder than before, plunging to the furthest depths of your body and scraping your insides with an unspeakable, near-dizzying pleasure. Each thrust hit straight through to your core, and you could feel your warmth leaking out from where he stuffed you. Sweet essence trickled down his cock.
He tightened his hold on your face, “Whose is it?”
At the same time, a knot constricted in your stomach. Your toes curled, your breath hitched, and by the feeling that had started up from the base of your spine, you sensed your climax was as near as it ever was.
Fuck it.
With your eyes locked on his, you parted your lips.
Still bouncing on his cock, now reaching for his other shoulder with your free hand and then lifting yourself slightly off of the car, you held tighter onto Jack, too.
And you couldn’t help it: you had to smile a little when you said it, body all but bursting at the seams with your pleasure, “It’s yours, Jack. This pussy is yours.”
“All mine?”
“All yours.”
“Then let me come inside her.”
Fuck, if that didn’t take you by surprise.
Leave it to Jack to propose the most batshit thing.
You’d never let any man inside you without a condom. Never wanted to take that risk. It would be incredibly stupid for you to do it now, with your next door neighbor who was as old as your father—and was hated by your father, only invited to this party because your mother had made you ask—between your legs.
Again, you didn’t think. You made the bad decision.
You mumbled, ‘OK, whatever’ and then watched Jack Abbott withdraw, take off the condom, sling it somewhere over your shoulder, and push back in.
Your body welcomed him gratefully. Shaking when his cock made contact with your velvety walls and there was nothing in between you but the warmth and your own shared, sticky fluids, you almost couldn’t breathe.
He sawed in and out, again and again. Went mindless with it, apparently, as his brows drew in closer, and his whole expression tightened. The next groan strained.
“Aw, baby,” Jack said, almost mournfully. “Pussy’s fuckin’…chokin’ me. I’m gonna lose it in a second.”
You were, too.
You didn’t give him—or yourself—the chance to second-guess this braindead move and simply let him rut deeper inside. Kissed him messily and moaned.
Strokes went quicker, harder, wet and loud and frantic.
You felt him twitch; that was when you hit your end.
Your climax landed with a force you didn’t expect, and half your body seized at once. You shrieked. Your cunt spasmed around Jack, effectively milking his own release from his now-throbbing cock, and you felt every rope spit thick and heavy and warm through your walls. He coated your insides with his seed, and then he kept right on fucking you like the only awareness he might have possessed was in the tip of his member.
Jack grunted, and he fucked his spend deeper.
“That’s my girl,” he said softly. Kissed your forehead.
Still floating somewhere in the ether, you nodded back.
It went without saying another word that you were his.
“You ever let one of them…stuck-up, dick-for-brain boys your own age blow a load inside you like this…” And as if to emphasize his point, he pulled out and let a little white trail of semen spill out from where he’d been. “You and me are gonna have a talk, young lady.”
You wanted to roll your eyes, but you were too tired.
When Jack told you to push more of it out, you did.
Five, six, seven slow pulses of your walls, and his seed came oozing out, trickling from a spent and sated hole.
Straight onto the fresh red paint of your father’s car.
You knew you had every reason to be humiliated at that, so you moved to stand, shortly. Tried to shake the thought out of your head. Smoothed the skirt of your dress down, then looked around, momentarily forgetting where the refrigerator in the garage was at.
Right.
There.
“You know,” Jack called as you started the other way. Yanking his jeans and his boxers back up, the buckle of his belt jingling as he did. “This car’s just as old as me.”
Mid-stride, you had to fight to keep from wrinkling your nose. You stopped in front of the fridge, swung it open, and grabbed the cake. Kicked the door shut.
“1975,” Jack stretched the sound of the number, grinning when he met your gaze and you drew closer.
Don’t make me kick your teeth in, Abbot.
You’d barely made it within spitting distance of the vehicle again before the man was pulling you to him, arm looping around your waist. You held back the cake.
“You’re gonna make me drop it,” you warned him.
Jack’s grin stretched wider. “Hate to see that.”
Just like your father would surely despise knowing what you and his archnemesis had done to sully his car. The look on his face, the raw, unmitigated ang—
“Hey.”
You meant to stop Jack with that word.
It didn’t work—he was already prying the lid off the cake’s container. Taking it off and flinging it sideways.
“Jack, that’s Dad’s fucking birthday cake!”
“Just taking a little off the top, OK? Relax.”
Before you could try and stop him, it was too late. The man dragged his middle finger through a big, thick, ivory-colored corner of the buttercream-frosted cake. Thankfully, the whole thing was so large, and the icing’s pattern so ornately, crazily drawn, that you really couldn’t tell where Jack had snagged from.
Still, you shot him a look that could kill.
“Are you crazy?!” you hissed. “Trying to get us cau—”
“Open.”
At Jack’s voice, your eyes widened a bit.
You didn’t notice it at first, but now you saw it plain as anything: your neighbor had lowered his hand to the hood of your father’s car. Swiped the finger loaded with icing through the mess of his cum still sitting on it, then lifted that hand again. Up toward your mouth.
“Ew, Jack, get the fuck out—”
You wanted to be grossed out by it.
“Open wide, sweetheart.”
You really, really, did.
“C’mon. That’s it.”
Your lips parted.
“Right there.”
You let it in.
“Good girl.” Jack grinned, seeing your mouth close around his finger coated with frosting and his come.
You swallowed and swore you’d start making smarter choices tomorrow. Seriously, no more fucking around.
The two of you started back for the party.
Right before you made it out, Jack pivoted.
“Shit. Almost forgot.” Jogging back to the car.
And, as if this afternoon couldn’t get any more depraved and disgusting, you watched your neighbor peel the condom you and him had used off the windshield of your father’s car. He waved it a second, taunting, before resuming his path back to you.
Out of habit, you jumped a little.
“Don’t even think about it, Abbot.”
But, luckily for you, Jack stopped short.
Instead of offering you another coital-flavored refreshment, the man paused at the car’s gas cap.
You groaned as soon as you saw him do it.
Smirking, Jack flipped open the metal door, and, without hesitating a second, he threw the used rubber in the place where a gas pump was supposed to go.
He shut it again.
You called him a lunatic.
As you strolled outside, back into the party and all of the noise, Jack took the cake so you wouldn’t have to carry it. Ever the gentleman and a strictly platonic friend who was trying his damndest to hide the fact that he’d just come inside his enemy’s daughter and had her eat it, he wrapped a casual arm around you.
He squeezed your shoulder. Leaned in close, once. And, as quietly as he could manage it, he whispered:
“Between you and that precious car of your dad’s, it looks like I’ve popped both of his cherries now, huh?”