Alan was quiet as he picked up the picture inside the glass shattered frame. It was himself and Polly having coffee in the Castle Rock Diner. They were smiling as they looked at each other. It was quite the candid shot; one he hadn’t been aware of at the time or after. Rare that they were both smiling. Though he had been to Polly’s home many times, stayed over, thought he was familiar with everything she had hanging around, this was new to him.
“What did you find?” Her voice startled him and he looked up from the picture before handing it over. “I’m surprised I’ve never seen it before.” He shrugged as he glanced around the room. The destruction didn’t end with the picture frame. The windows had also been shattered, Polly’s belongings were strewn around the room, furniture was broken. I was rather devastating and he was proud of Polly for taking this attempted retrieval of her surviving things so well. Proud and a little concerned, but he wouldn’t push her. He never did. His own home was in the same shape. Just as many in town were.
This happened when half the town was literally blown sky high by dynamite planted by two of its own residents.
Polly smiled a little and looked down at the photo. She made no attempt to stroke it or anything like that. Not only was the glass shattered and injury capable, but the arthritis had returned to her hands – though not as severe as either of them had expected – and holding it alone was becoming difficult. “It wasn’t out for everyone. It was…kept for me. Made me happy.” She glanced up at him and her smile, small as it had been, faded, sadness rising in her eyes. “Netty took it. Thought I would like it.”
Netty was one of the many people who had lost their lives in the last week. She had worked for Polly and become a good friend. It was one of the losses that hit Polly the hardest and Alan could see it plainly. “I’ll assume she was right.” He said simply. “And it’s okay.” He gestured to the photo and the fact that he was in it but had never seen it. “Everyone has their secrets.”
Polly’s expression darkened even more at the last words. “Yes.” She spoke almost hesitantly, as if she were trying to make some kind of important decision. “They do.” Whatever it was, she didn’t immediately lean one way or the other. She didn’t tell him, but she didn’t…not tell him. She didn’t move on.
He debated doing just that. Letting it go as he always did when she almost but not quite told him something, the secret of all secrets that she held so deeply inside that he sometimes wondered if she would ever reveal it. Other times he knew she eventually would because they loved each other and she would trust him enough to do so…someday.
“Polly?” He asked after a long moment, meeting her eyes, slightly hesitant himself. “Why were you mad at me? You know…when you called before…” He trailed off and gestured vaguely outside. Before everything in Castle Rock had literally gone to Hell and back. “Exactly what is it that you think I did?” At the time she hadn’t given him a chance to defend himself or even to ask for any kind of clarification. She had been angrier and more betrayed than he had ever heard and it was directed at him. He couldn’t imagine what would make her feel that way.
For an instant he saw the guilt surface in her eyes. Guilt, confusion, fear…but no anger. Whatever it had been, she wasn’t mad about it anymore. “I thought…” She trailed off herself and set the picture down before making her way to the living room, not looking to see if he followed. He did.
Stopping beside the coffee table, which was somehow in almost perfect condition despite the rest of the house, she picked up what looked like an official document and handed it to him silently. Maybe she couldn’t say what she had thought, but she could show him.
It was addressed to him in his official capacity; Sheriff Alan Pangborn of Castle Rock, Maine. But it was CCed to Miss Patricia Chalmers. The return address was San Francisco, California. A quick scan of the document showed him immediately why she was so upset and he looked up in some combination of confusion, disbelief and sadness himself. Yet, he didn’t feel the anger she had projected on him before. “You thought I was investigating you behind your back?” He didn’t add ‘you thought I would stoop so low to learn your secrets? that I cared for you so little that I wouldn’t wait for you to be ready to reveal them yourself?’
“It looks official.” She was almost whispering now, shame coloring her words. “I didn’t see it until later, but he made a mistake.”
He didn’t have to ask who ‘he’ was. Leland Gaunt. The demon who had destroyed their town and taken so many of his people. Even if he hadn’t managed to keep their souls. He didn’t say anything at all, allowing her to continue at her own pace.
Sighing, she shoved some debris off the couch and dropped down onto it, her gaze dropping to the floor as she gathered herself to tell him – finally – what had been eating at her for so long. “He addressed it to ‘Patricia Chalmers.’” She started. “I wasn’t Patricia in California. I was Polly.” A hesitation. “To everyone. To child services. They would never call me Patricia because Patricia didn’t exist there.”
Alan nodded, but she wasn’t looking at him, wasn’t really looking at the floor either. She was looking inward, into the past and he didn’t want to pull her out because he knew she needed to get this out.
“I believed it because I thought…you knew that I wasn’t telling you everything. You know that Kelton wasn’t adopted or whatever other stories are swirling around. You know there’s more.”
This was true. All of Castle Rock knew the story. Or thought they did. But none knew the details. Polly Chalmers had gotten pregnant at a young age and instead of settling down and marrying the father like a proper young lady should do, she had left. She had run off to California to do who knew what. And when she had returned there was no baby with her. She had said that she had given up the child for adoption, which had been her original plan upon arriving in California. It wasn’t what had happened.
He hadn’t known that the child hadn’t really been adopted, but he had had a feeling. He had just been waiting for her to decide when it was right to let him in. “I knew something wasn’t clicking.” He murmured in acknowledgement.
Polly nodded, but didn’t look up for another long moment. When she did there were tears in her eyes. “I didn’t put the baby up for adoption. I couldn’t. I kept him, I named Kelton and I loved him so much…” She swallowed hard and Alan nodded in understanding. He was a parent as well. A parent who had lost a child.
“It was hard. So hard. Making a life there. But, I did it. I worked as a waitress and I applied and applied for assistance, but I kept getting turned down or told to wait…” She shook her head. “I had to work and couldn’t leave Kelton alone, so I hired a girl to watch him while I was away.”
She started shaking now and Alan moved closer, kneeling down before her. He started to reach for her hands reminiscent of an equally important conversation they had had once before, but paused because with her arthritis he would just cause another kind of pain if he touched her hands. Instead, he placed his own hands on her arms just above hers in a show of support. He would wrap his arms around her to give the comfort she so greatly needed, but she needed to finish, needed to tell him how this secret had ended and she needed to see his face when she did so. He knew that as much as he knew anything else.
He didn’t prompt and after another shudder she continued. “I had finally been approved for assistance, but…there was a fire. While I was at work…” She took a deep breath, seemingly unaware of the tears rolling down her cheeks now. “I can remember the call so vividly. I can hear it when I try to.” Her voice dropped, almost silent. “Even or especially when I don’t want to.” She shook her head. “Kelton…well, he was gone. The babysitter, too.” She paused for a long moment. “He wasn’t adopted, he’s dead. And it’s my fault.”
Alan met her eyes, silent for his own time. “Do you remember how you got me to look at Annie and Todd’s death in a completely different way? Pulled me out of that debilitating guilt –“ That he still felt more often than he would like, but needed so badly at the time. “Well, the same goes for you. Kelton’s death isn’t your fault, Polly. You loved him, you did what you could for him. It’s just…sometimes love isn’t enough.” He spoke softly himself; her pain echoed in his eyes before he moved to sit next to her, to allow her to lean in if she chose to.
“I’m sorry.” He had been thinking the words, knew they were stupid and wouldn’t help anyone, but it was Polly who spoke them. “For thinking you would betray me like that. I knew…deep down. But –“ She shrugged in his arms a little. It had been very convincing. She shifted just enough to look at him again. “And I’m sorry it took me until it was almost too late to tell you.”
She cut him off. “Especially after you told me about your secret, about Annie and Todd, both at the beginning and…after we were together.” It was clear in both her expression and tone how much that meant to her. That he had opened himself wide for her. Even if he didn’t always tell her how much he still suffered over it.
Alan arched an eyebrow at that. “That wasn’t exactly a secret.” He tried his best to keep his own expression neutral at best. “The Rock is a small town and a car accident that took the life of the town Sheriff’s wife and son is pretty big news.”
Polly frowned at that and then shook her head. “But you told me.” He had told her more than just about the accident, more than the basics. He had told her his feelings, let her see his obsessive guilt, his depression. “You trusted me with all of you and I…I wanted to do the same, but just couldn’t do it.”
Alan’s neutral expression faded almost immediately and he reached out to brush her hair from her forehead. “But you did.” He told her. “It took you a little longer, but I’m a patient man. And it was your secret to reveal or not. You have the right to have your private things, Polly.” He looked at her for a long moment. “But I’m glad you told me.” For her sake even more than his.
Polly considered that. “Me, too.” She admitted. “I’m –“ This time he cut her off instead of the other way around. “No more apologies.” He told her firmly. “None are needed.”
A smile, small but grateful, graced Polly’s features. “I love you, Alan.”
“I love you, too, Pretty Lady.” He had known all along how he felt and told her before, but he was never surer. “I love you, too.”
Polly laid her head on his shoulder for what seemed like forever but wasn’t nearly so long. “Alan?” She asked after the quiet had gone on almost too long.
“Yeah?” He didn’t shift to look at her, just kept his arm around her as she spoke. He was in no hurry to continue their mission to save what they could of her belongings before moving onto his own.
She didn’t continue, didn’t ask her question right away and then she finally spoke again. “Are you going to stay?” He did almost look at her then, but let her clarify. “To help rebuild and…” She trailed off, sounding unsure and he couldn’t blame her. Neither knew what was going to happen to Castle Rock and its survivors now.
Alan hadn’t really thought about it, but he already knew the answer. “No.” He drew the word out slightly, not quite hesitantly, more like he was thinking about it as he said it. “I don’t think I am. I think I’m done here.”
Polly considered that. “What will you do?”
Alan shrugged slightly, feeling her head on his shoulder shift slightly as he did so. “Move on, I guess. To where, I don’t know. I think I did what I was supposed to here.”
Alan tensed slightly at that. “I just made the bad guy leave. I didn’t save anything.” The town had still been practically destroyed, so very many people had been lost. He hadn’t acted soon enough; hadn’t done nearly enough for those he was sworn to protect.
“You did.” Polly didn’t point out the souls he had literally stolen from the demon or devil that had been Leland Gaunt. The souls that, even with their destination unknown, were no longer in the hands that had stolen them and would give them a much worse fate. She didn’t point out that no one else had been able to drive the evil away. “You did.”
She didn’t allow him to protest again. “Wherever you go, I would like to go with you.” She told him, now shifting to look at him again and he couldn’t hide the surprise at her words. They had just confessed their love once more, she had revealed her greatest secret, they had survived what could have been the end of their world and yet this surprised him. “I think, I did what I was supposed to do here, too.” She continued and then she managed a tiny but genuine smile. “I think I was supposed to meet you.”
Polly shook her head at that. “To save each other.”