2018 update
I haven’t added to this blog since my trip to the Western Front in 2014 but i have continued to research the activities of William’s battalion through out the duration of the war in an attempt to pin down where and when he died. At the beginning I had theories based upon some on-line information from a website. However, this website hasn't been completely accurate and has led me to reach some conclusions incorrectly. since 2014 there have been many more resources available on-line and in publications. Archives have released many more records that were previously not digitised. As a result I have had access to some primary resources. The most revealing of these have been the battalion war diaries which give a daily account of where the battalion has been and the action it has seen. The accounts can vary depending on the officer recording the information. Some officers do not give too much away and others provide very detailed accounts.
The one thing that confused me was that the notification of death (seen earlier in the blog) is signed by Lieut Colonel Lumsden of the 2nd Btn Royal Scots. The 13 Btn Royal Scots was sent off the line for the whole of September, yet his registered date of death was 29th September 1917. Therefore, I had to read the war diaries of the 2nd Btn Royal Scots. It took me a few years to gain access to all of these resources and part of that was that I had to retrace my steps research wise and try and undo some of my perceptions regarding what happened to William. Also, gaps in the information I had previously located meant that important facts had been missed. I had been misled as to the locations of the battalion on certain dates. I had been confused by his date of death when the battalion had been on R&R. I had eventually discovered that the battalion was on the Frezenberg Ridge both in July and August 1917 and that the action had been so fierce that the battalion had huge losses and that the R&R in Arras was actually to enable the replenishment of the battalion to bring it back to strength. Beck House, a ruined farm house with a huge pill box built within it.
William’s Battalion was engaged in a battle to take the German garrisoned Pill Box on the 31st July. This resulted in disastrous losses for the battalion. By the 1st August 1917 the 13th RS had taken Beck House after an entrenched battle. That night the rain came and there was no moon. The relief battalion, the 10th Scottish Rifles, was stood down as it was unsafe to send the men in without being able to see. When dawn came the Germans had regrouped for a counter offensive and had surrounded the 13th RS on 3 sides. The German’s hit hard and when it was over the RS had sustained considerable casualties. By the the morning of the 2nd August 1917 the battalion had a strength of just 11 officers and 126 other ranks. The rest of the battalion was either dead, missing or taken prisoner. Although the battalion also saw action in August, this night was by far the most devastating to their strength and the likelihood of William surviving it was pretty slim.
Although William’s name is carved on the memorial wall in Arras, the effects register puts his death in Belgium, which is where Beck House is. By the 26th September the area was securely in Allied hands. By the 1st September the 13th RS had gone to Arras to rebuild the battalion and the 2nd RS had moved into the Frezenberg area near Beck House. With the enemy driven back for a time, the task of clearing the battlefield and identifying the dead had begun. I believe this is why the 2nd RS commanding officer is the one who signed the death notification.
At the end of September I will be making a trip to Ypres to take in the memorial ceremony and after that i will visit the Scottish Memorial to lay a wreath.
#Lestweforget








