A Safe Place
Album Review #15: Bush - Black And White Rainbows
Three years after Man On The Run, alternative rockers Bush return with their seventh album, and third with their new lineup. On Black And White Rainbows mastermind Gavin Rossdale leads the quartet through 15 songs, each one polished with fat, lush production, and each one powered by explosive choruses that feel as though the music and lyrics were plugged into a mathematical formula. Full of grandeur, the blueprint the band works with here feels surfeit in the end.
Since Sixteen Stone (the British band’s 1994 debut), Rossdale has remained the driving force, and main songwriter. It’s a crown he’s worn well considering that it’s his tunes that helped sell 10 million records in the United States alone. But sales aside, the secret weapon that made older albums exciting is now evident with the release of this one. He’s always collaborated. Whether Steve Albini, Bob Rock, Page Hamilton (for the short lived, but great Institute), or the team of Clive Langer and Alan Winstanley (who I think brought out the best in Bush), it was these producers (though Albini prefers “recording engineer”) that added texture, and variation to each effort.
On Rainbows Rossdale assumes all responsibility. He’s credited as writer, producer, and even mixer. This is clearly a personal effort. Even without the tabloid fodder of his recent divorce from singer Gwen Stefani, the record’s lyrics and mellow vibe promulgate that this is a record about a man trying to find the color and vitality in his life. “Mad Love,” with its double entendre title, is an infectiously great ballad, and defines the pace and mood of the album. “I was feeling a prisoner,” Rossdale sings, and as past tense suggests, he no longer does, but I can’t help but feel that the music says otherwise.
The band has stripped Black And White Rainbows of any abruptness, of any surprises. Every song is boxed in by similar progressions (verse, pre chorus, chorus, rinse and repeat) that impede the expanse the band roams in. There are moments of excitement, but they’re few and far between. Perhaps Rossdale is a prisoner of apprehension, of what audiences have come to expect from him as an artist, and him assuming what they’d want to hear.
Inside the sleeve, even before we get any music, we get an excerpt from Thus Spoke Zarathustra, a text written by German philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche. The book deals with the concepts of eternal return, and will to power, among other heavy themes. One would think that the soul searching quote, one that depicts “bold adventurers embarking on dreadful seas,” to paraphrase Nietzsche, would be examined profoundly, rather than executed with lines like “hang onto yourself babe.” And when Rossdale does escape his marital woes, he skims the surface of “people at war,” and “polar bears weeping over melting ice caps,” analyzing these social issues merely as a bystander, an announcer without rumination, without a personal point of view.
Much like Neil Krug’s photos for this album (blurs of light and landscape, a woman’s neck and chest, obscured shots of flowers, oversaturated colors), we get snippets of goodness, snippets of depth. Unfortunately, it never coheres.
There’s the orchestration of the Dave Stewart co-penned “Lost In You,” with its gorgeous harmonies; the alpine guitar arpeggios on the “sister rose” segment of “Nurse” helps the track soar; drummer Robin Goodridge pounding his way through the gloom of stand out track “Ravens” is visceral; the melancholic interplay between bassist Corey Britz and the ever fabulous guitarist Chris Traynor on the verses of “The Edge of Love” lifts Rossdale’s vocals.
Speaking of singing, I loved Rossdale’s instinctive surrender on the second verse of “Sky Turns Day Glo,” full of stretched notes, and gasps for air. It’s a moment of humanity on a record that feels drained of it. “Water” with its trip-hop groove, and chiming guitars shimmer against the “kaleidoscope of emotions,” and proves that Traynor can dredge more from sustained, harmonizing notes than the formulated staccato riffs that plague the rest of this album. Even the verses of “The Beat of Your Heart” showcase a band in perfect synch with one another. But then that chorus hits.
Overall, it’s not enough. From the awkward “Peace-s,” with its title turned into an acronym cheerleader chant, to the Rihanna tinged “Dystopia,” to the synths on “Ray of Light,” I can’t help but wonder what would happen if Rossdale stripped down the production a bit, if he took some left turns. It’s all on point, the harmonies, the tones, but there’s no variety. What if “Toma Mi Corazon,” was slowed to a reggae groove, something more fun to fit the sexiness of the track, and the Spanish singing, something more “beautiful and bizarre.” Oh well.
As Rossdale sings on “Lost In You,” “I’ve seen the red of the sun, but it’s dull compared to what I have done,” I hope that he lives up to this line next time around. Bush. Thank you.
SMOOCH-O-METER:







