[yas3m1t3]

The Host

[yas3m1t3]

The Substance 2024 (Movie Analysis) - II

Movie analysis hashtag: fruit for thought ys

Mother-Daughter dynamic: Elisabeth, representing the mother, projects her unfulfilled dreams onto Sue and sending her into entertainment industry, example beauty pagents, acting but in Sue's case Fitness. This leads to jealousy when Sue begins to garner admiration and praise. The jealousy Elisabeth feels mirrors the complex and sometimes painful relationships some mothers have with their daughters—seeing them as extensions of themselves while simultaneously resenting the youth and opportunities they no longer possess. Sue, in turn, begins to internalize the insecurities - need for validation Elisabeth has passed onto her, fueling her own insecurities about her body. Her body in this scene also represent how older woman who've undergone post partum transformation. Elisabeth’s coping mechanisms, like binge eating and self-isolation, are stark manifestations of her internalized shame and self-loathing, behaviors that Sue learns and reinforces. The dark room symbolizes not just Elisabeth’s withdrawal but how she’s taught Sue to compartmentalize and suppress anything deemed “ugly” or “unworthy.” Elisabeth who eventually tries to terminate Sue is a perfect example of what jealousy does to a mother daughter relationship, it leads to some mothers sabotaging their daughters.

Destruction of the Female Body: The violence toward Elisabeth's body by Sue, especially when Sue physically hurts Elisabeth in a specific area of her body (the breasts, the face, the midsection), symbolizes the destruction of what society values in women—youthful, perky breasts, flat stomach and defined face. In Elisabeth's case, what she now lacks. This violence is also a symbolic act of self-loathing, as Sue is attacking what she fears she will gain in the future.

Transformation and the "Monster" Moment: Sue's & Elisabeth's final form—where they becomes a grotesque, dehumanized version of herself—represents how aging and societal rejection turn women into "monsters" in their own eyes. They doesn't see themsleves as a person anymore—they sees themself as a collection of body parts, or worse, as something broken and monstrous. The scene at the New Year's show, where a youthful, perky breast pops out, is an act of mutilation to fit society's expectations. The breast itself becomes a symbol of the idealized body—something that is "acceptable" and "prized." It's a tragic moment where both Elisabeth and Sue offer their perfect, youthful feature of themselves to the industry. The Industry which has objectified and often selects women for having such idealistic features like perky breasts. Elisasue laugh because they are offering these men exactly what they seek a woman's youthful features (just mutilated) yet they don't want it anymore.

The Final Scene: Elisabeth, reduced to a lump of mashed flesh, clings to the cracked star, representing her desperate attempt to hold on to her value in a society that has discarded her. The film ends with Elisabeth’s face intact, but her body is unrecognizable, symbolizing how society reduces women to their physical appearances, just a pretty face but with a lumpy body. Elisabeth's final act of clinging to the star is a desperate plea for validation—a validation that, in the end, will never come, because society has already moved on to the next youthful, idealized image.

[yas3m1t3]

The Substance 2024 (Movie Analysis) - I

Movie analysis hashtag: fruit for thought ys

Objectification of Women & Societal Pressure: The film explores how society values women primarily for their physical appearance, particularly their youth. Elisabeth's desire to remain young stems from this societal pressure, where her job demands a youthful body to remain relevant. This societal ideal is reflected in Elisabeth’s transition into Sue, where she essentially sacrifices her identity to fit society's narrow standards of beauty. 

Male Gaze: The Substance is a critique of the male gaze, where women are reduced to objects of lust and admiration. Men, even those who don’t measure up socially, financially, or in terms of beauty, still hold power and dictate societal standards for women. Some examples are: Elisabeth's loss of identity in favor of Sue, the assistant being stripped of her name, and the candidates’ cruel comments when trying to find the next big Elisabeth star. The most noticeable of all is the scene where the video of Sue "twerking" is replayed and analyzed by the men, while other women in similar staff roles to those men are sidelined in the background because they too are helpless to this objectification by men. 

The Destruction of Self: Elisabeth's transformation into Sue reflects her attempt to reject her aged body. Substance depicts Elisabeth’s struggle with aging and how it leads to her feeling disconnected from herself, especially when she begins to see her own body as unworthy. Despite being beautiful even at that age, she can only see herself through what society deems beautiful. It's worse that she works in a job market which operates with extreme beauty standards. Her insecurity subtle but gradually grows as her body physically changes more. This is evident when she refrains from touching her own body in the shower, seeing it as less valuable because of its age.

Ageism and the Disposability of Women: The film underscores how older women are discarded once they no longer fit the youthful ideals of beauty by the entertainment industry. Women are treated based on their appearance, Elisabeth’s body, in her older age, is treated as a "hag" or "witch," quite literally appearing as one, with her hunched back and wrinkled colored skin. She is disrespected, yelled at and sidelined by the men of different ages - the motorcycle guy, the neighbor even her boss. Yet Sue is treated the opposite by these same men.

Sue's Role & Insecurities: Sue is a younger, idealized version of Elisabeth, embodying the body men desire—youthful, perky, and flawless. However, Sue's insecurities start to mirror Elisabeth’s once she internalizes society’s expectations. Sue's discomfort with aging becomes clear when she is shown removing a lump in her body, revealing a drumstick (metaphorically referencing how food shapes the body as mentioned by this YouTube creator). The sacrifice for beauty is the sacrifice of basic necessity, in this case food and Sue. We never see her physically eat, as not eating is her way of controlling her body, one she prides herself of, because that is what society has prized her for. Additionally, Sue’s bitterness toward Elisabeth is the same frustration and resentment Elisabeth felt deep inside—about the way society treats women, about aging, and about her diminishing beauty—seems to have taken root in Sue. Even though she embodies the youth and beauty that Elisabeth once had, she too is trapped in a system that will never truly allow her to be free

Jealousy Between Women: A major theme is the toxic relationship between Elisabeth and Sue, which reflects how women are often pitted against each other due to societal pressures. Sue who makes a remark about Elisabeth's show being jurassic, gained laughs at Elisabeth's expense. Sue’s hate for Elisabeth is not immediate. It happens slowly, influenced by the toxic standards around her. Remember, Sue at some stage did care, example is when she puts a rolled up towel under Elizabeth's head for comfort. Sue, being young and initially not having those fears and just saw Elizabeth as a person. Not ugly, but as a person. Slowly Sue, succumbs to the influence of society’s unrealistic beauty ideals. This shift is heartbreaking because it shows how Sue, at one point, might have seen Elisabeth’s aging as a part of the natural cycle but eventually reduces Elizabeth to the physical representation of ugliness in society's eyes. not as a person anymore but as something to fear and reject.