Based on what we’ve seen so far, I just wanted to get his out of my system regarding this character.
Please debate me if I said anything wrong or misunderstood anything. I’m trying hard to grasp his character, buts he’s like a soap bar to me, haha.
This is spoiler territory. Kindly beware if you read any further.
The hidden quest made me consider whether Orion is entirely evil with very little humanity. Especially with how he treats Kazim and leaves him alive as a form of torture, not mentioning that the Flesh Binding Curse already inflicts extreme repercussions (distortion of the mind and body).
And then, I’m torn with how much he loves his little sister. Especially how he saved her at the end, and his affinity tales explaining that he helps Peggy hide from her instructors.
But then I remembered when Gwyneth interrupted Orion’s scheme to “protect” the nobles, and she defeated the giant spider instead.
Orion wanted to send her to Ashvale county, where the war between Bantus and Savannah is currently underway. As Hendrik said, it was a death sentence.
Orion wanted to send a sixteen year old to Ashvale county because she came into the spotlight with Merlin and changed his plan…. While fully knowing that he was sending her to meet her death on the forefront.
One could argue that he did it based off fear, but you could see the look in his eyes when he said, “You… did well.” And Merlin did that little eyebrow raise in that cutscene.
He already branded her a problem. Masked it with friendliness. And his first option was that she needs to be out his way. Figuratively speaking, he presented a snake (her death) in the form of a gift (her promotion).
Orion seems to have learned a lot from Cyran. Since in the hidden quest, Cyran even said to him to just kill Kazim explaining it was the easiest solution to that problem. And it seems that he applied it here.
To add, it looks like to me that he also did that to try to break apart Gwyneth’s and Hendrik’s relationship so that she can have zero support and can get out of his way.
Isolate her from her father, then use her ambition as a weapon.
Then back to Peggy, did Orion ever try to defend his sister after she tried pulling out Excalibur?
All the rumors must’ve reached his ears but he turned a blind eye to save himself—to ensure the throne.
Orion may genuinely love Peggy. I don’t think that love is fake. But I’m not convinced that his love is stronger than his fear. He will protect Peggy when he can do so without destroying the image, position, and plans he’s built around himself.
The real test of his character is whether he'd be willing to sacrifice those things for her.
And for Kazim. Until Orion can come to terms with him and treat him right. Though… that would be the biggest feat since he’s done more than just harm him.
Until we see that, I don't think we can call him good—or completely evil.
He's somewhere in between: a person capable of genuine love who is also capable of sacrificing other people when fear (of abandonment, shame, etc.) convinces him that he has no other choice.
And he ran away in the midst of it all.
There is no excuse for him to do what he does.
He had a choice. And actions have consequences.
Orion is morally gray, but being morally gray doesn't mean his actions are morally equal.
No one on planet earth is black or white, but each person stands on a different shade of grey.