I need to write out this tangent about the USA men's hockey team and THAT phone call.
Many years ago (pre-pandemic), I was a co-teacher to a class of junior (in high school) boys with a colleague who was a man who was also one of the football coaches. This was our third year being their teachers; it was an SEL class and we moved as a cohort. We KNEW these kids.
They were respectful, kind, appreciative, and fun to be around. One day one of the kids said something sexist. I cannot remember what he said; it wasn't directed at me, but I called him out for the sexism, and my co-teacher reminded him: "You can't say that around her. Remember, it's not just guys here."
And I went on one of my most beautiful tirades, grabbing the attention of the whole room: "No, you shouldn't say it at all. If you only don't say it because I'm around, you don't respect me, you just don't want consequences. That means your 'kindness,' your 'respect' is just a performance. You don't respect women if you would say it in locker rooms or with your boys. You put on a performance to trick me into thinking you're respectful and nice. I'm not sensitive, you know that, but if that's how you talk when I'm not around, I don't want to be around you, not because I feel unsafe because I don't, but because ultimately you don't respect me or other women."
The boys nodded, and we moved on.
After the boys left, my co-teacher looked at me and said, "I never thought of it like that."
There were only men in that locker room and on the phone. They didn't feel the need to perform allyship.
And to more tangent this as Heated Rivalry is more in the front of my mind. This is the same reason queer players haven't come out because players on pride nights have said nice, respectful things. Even Matthew Tkachuk has said, "A night like tonight, for me, is really about including everybody. In my opinion, it’s by far the greatest game in the world, and everyone’s invited in my locker room and our locker room as an organization." The thing about queer players though is that they are incognito in those locker rooms, and they hear what is said when they don't have to perform, and I can imagine how awful that gets.
I think about this quote from Dr Lilla Watson, a Gangulu woman, a lot in my own reflections on whether or not I'm being performative or not: "If you have come to help me, you are wasting your time. If you have come because your liberation is bound up with mine, then let us work together."
A lot of men see themselves as "helping" women and queer people, and that's the crux.